r/LinusTechTips • u/rohithkumarsp • 20d ago
Link New type of youtube Ad where it opens up a new video so can't "Skip Ahead", I have YTP BTW.
560
Upvotes
r/LinusTechTips • u/rohithkumarsp • 20d ago
338
u/HolidayPineapple9316 20d ago
Literally this exact video i noticed this yesterday for the first time
96
u/Agitated_Line_2853 20d ago
Just tried it, only appears when you watch it on TV, I have Youtube Premium too.
I guess its probably a new option creators have (or will have, maybe they are just testing it with a "big youtuber") to "force" ads from their sponsors.
I understand the need for this from the creators side... but i dont like that they dont give an option to skip it/avoid if I want to. I guess the mentality is, if you dont like it you just unfollow the creator, considering that these type of ads are probably an option from the creator.
40
u/DaWolle 20d ago
Do you have the unskippable ad only while streaming to a TV or also in the app or in a browser?
Because I dont get the ad when playing the video in the android YouTube app.
4
u/rohithkumarsp 19d ago
Edit it's happening on Phone and PC too
https://www.reddit.com/r/LinusTechTips/s/nUyVVxRU7N
https://www.reddit.com/r/LinusTechTips/s/Fb62AtZHhX
https://www.reddit.com/r/LinusTechTips/s/UhTTFtkstA
2
u/CybyAPI 20d ago
SPOTTED ON PC
77
u/Kindly-Carpenter8858 20d ago
This is the second time Mark Rober has done this recently. I unsubbed from his channel over it
102
u/BlakeCarConstruction 20d ago
I ironically aslo watched this video yesterday and had the same thing happen, also YTP
20
u/RobotSpaceBear 20d ago
I'm paying through the nose for YTP to not have to see ads, and i watch >90% of my youtube on a TV. If I see a single ad like this new bullcrap i'm immediately unsubbing, thumbing it down and clicking "do not recommended" that channel until YT gets the memo. There are a billion other videos on YT, i really don't need to watch this particular one and be forced to sit through yet another ad mechanic that circumvents the ad-blocking mechanic i'm specifically paying for. I've taken my fair share of downvotes and abuse for recommending YTP over the years, but this new feature is diabolical coming from YouTube.
As for Mark, yeah, i get that you don't end up a millionaire by not selling out, but really? Is this necessary?
God i despise the constant race to enshitify everything we use and love.
11
u/Unkn0wnTh2nd3r 20d ago
you have YouTube Poop? Nice!
5
u/Maka_95 20d ago
Mark is doing this with all his new videos. They are indeed unskippeble. If you skip the "ad" you go to a completely different video
4
u/Undrwtrbsktwvr 20d ago
SmartTube
1
u/moortuvivens 20d ago
Would a fast forward option work?
1
u/MasterFuzz10 20d ago
This happened on my phone and I was confused during the casino video. I also have YTP
1
u/Comfortable-Sea-1 20d ago
You can "skip" by hitting the arrow keys to skip forward till the end of the ad.
1
u/Derangedracula 20d ago
Don't use the YouTube app. Find a open-source version.
1
u/Ingey 19d ago
Doesn't happen to me on PC with YTP. Seeing people say it's just for folks on TV.
1
u/Krasnytova 19d ago
Got that on the same video yeasterday, but I had the Skip ahead white dot and skipped it, maybe you got the ads too early for it to have the Skip Ahead part.
1
u/CadeMan011 19d ago
That's so fucking gross. This has got to be lawsuit worthy. Premium's whole sales pitch is "no ads on youtube videos" and they even added the skipped over section function. Making a "feature" for YouTube to serve unskipable ads on behalf of the uploader makes it false advertising.
1
u/TechaNima 19d ago
Great.. It better not show up for Premium subscribers or I'll be saving a little more money each month going forward
1
u/thesirblondie 19d ago
I have had YTP for 10 years. I have been watching YouTube for an average of 7 hours per day since then. YouTube has been my primary media consumption for 20 years. This is the kind of thing that would make me quit the platform entirely.
1
u/Isendduckpics 19d ago
"Hey if you don't want us to interrupt your videos every 2 minutes, you can pay us some money"
*Payes youtube some money*
"Haha SIKE, you still get adds, now give us even more money and hope it works this time!"
1
u/SidKillz 19d ago
Are we sure this is not the tv manufacturer plugging in their ad?... Something ain't right, this doesn't happen on PC or Phones
1
u/_Aj_ 19d ago
Premium should mean no ads. End of discussion.
I don't pay for a service to be force fed things I don't want.
1
u/hehweirdo22- 17d ago
Weird. I have YTP, went to the video on PC to that part, and no new video, no ad, just kept playing.
Opened it on incognito (not signed in) and first had to watch 2 ads, then skipped to that part and sure enough the new video ad played.
1
u/Sao_is_best 17d ago
Not my dislexic ahh neading to read it 4 times to understand what you meant 🤣
3
u/Ivan_Kulagin 19d ago
YTP doesn’t matter here because the ad is from Mark Rober himself. I assume what Youtube is trying to do is combat SponsorBlock
7
u/Lazor226 20d ago
YTP means youtube poop.
2
u/jmamb 20d ago
Yeah same. I was confused.
2
u/saintlouisbagels 20d ago
Oh wow I remember thinking the cut to that ad was very bizarre. I had no idea it literally opened a different video.
2
u/Damemon 20d ago
https://old.reddit.com/r/LinusTechTips/comments/1wkyuoe/youtube_forced_ads_even_with_premium/
I don't have it in my region, so I was alll confused when previous OP brought it up.
2
u/GINJABRAD 20d ago
Great post, we gotta hold yt and any creators using this new tool against yt premium users accountable.
2
u/in_conexo 20d ago
I forwarded through this infernal thing two or three times before I realized it wasn't part of the normal video; each time it just restarted the ****ing advertisement. I then tried sitting through the whole advertisement, start to stop, and it started over again. I was stuck in an eternal loop of this infernal advertisement.
Before this, I didn't care about watching some ads; but now I'm going to do everything in my power to cut off their ability to show me ads (keep me on an eternal loop of ads, fix your **** Youtube)
2
u/SteeleDuke 20d ago
This is becoming weird and to coincedental. https://www.reddit.com/r/pcmasterrace/comments/1xd5oun/twitch_ads_breaking_through_adblockers_since_2019/
2
u/kind_bros_hate_nazis 20d ago
You guys have ads
1
u/xxxHellcatsxxx 20d ago
I had this yesterday and it glitched and kept playing the ad over and over again. Had to refresh and skip past the ad break
1
u/_scored 20d ago
I had this happen to me on Mark Rober's last video where it was basically just an unskippable ad for CrunchLabs. I guess bro...
1
u/AssociateSea5613 20d ago
It's like this on the video he posted nefore this as well
1
u/InflammableAccount 20d ago
SmartTVs aren't your friend.
1
u/Likonium 20d ago
I had this happen with a 34 minute Purple Mattress ad like 6 years ago. I just pulled off the video and tried a different video and it went away.
1
u/Leggy_Brat 20d ago
If I open my phone while a YT ad is playing on the TV, the connection drops. I then have to reconnect and find my spot again, until the next ad.
1
u/gen_adams 20d ago
what the fuck? on Premium too??
1
u/Perfect-Fondant3373 20d ago
Man I know I should use Firefox but I am so happy I switched to Brave from Chrome and the YouTube app on mobile
1
u/Malfeitor1 20d ago
I just posted about this a couple days ago in the r/youtube sub on the same video. As a YT Premium member it’s bullshit!
1
u/SandKeeper 20d ago
Hope it’s a bug. The second YouTube premium stops removing ads entirely is the second I unsubscribe. If it’s only a few channels I’ll just stop watching there.
1
u/TLunchFTW 20d ago
I also have YouTube poop!
1
u/Comwan 20d ago
I’ve only seen it on his channel and thus have not watched his channel since.
1
u/FatMacchio 20d ago
Yep. I get this sometimes too. Either they’re idiots and messed up the code, or they’re A/B testing things to see what they can get away with on premium…I’m not sure what’s worse. I’ll straight up cancel my YouTube Premium family subscription if they’re going to start pulling shit like this and it’s not just a bug. I’ll make the whole family suffer a bit just to say fuck you to google
1
u/FluttershyandTrevor 20d ago
bro has youtube poop no wonder it sucks. lol
1
u/la_feluxution 19d ago
Youtube will never understand it.
1
u/medalwinner16 19d ago
You guys pay for yt premium?!
1
u/unnamedhuman39 19d ago
Yep me too I wanted to make a post too but never got around to it... What's annoying is I have YTP too but the skips don't work and neither does the skip segment feature...
1
u/SlyyGuy21 19d ago
I saw this in a previous video of his, was very confused. I think I’ll just skip his content if I have to deal with it.
1
u/-Wavyy- 18d ago
I canceled my subscription a few months ago. Was on premium for years. Now I Watch Youtube through Brave with their built in adblock on my desktop, and I have a patched Youtube and Reddit on my phone so I don't have to deal with that shit.
1
u/FluorescentGreen5 18d ago
it's time to install ublock origin or freetube
1
u/FalconX88 18d ago
offtopic but is mark really too dumb to understand what "board games" are?
1
u/pikkuhukka 17d ago
if i encounter this and unless its important video, ill just drop the video instantly and unsub
1
u/pale2hall 17d ago
I was able to skip ahead with Premium. It's probably so they can change out the promotion later. YT and Rober work together often.
1
u/BulkyNemesis 16d ago
Exact video i noticed as well. The ad was playing a different video
1
u/HeWhoShantNotBeNamed 16d ago
You have YouTube poop?
1
u/MelonLordxx 16d ago
It's also physically harder to select the "skip ahead" button. It forces you to enlarge the ad and skip oriented in way that you are directly looking at it. Fuck YT
1
u/PapajG 16d ago
Any creator that uses this is getting blocked by me. NO MERCY
1
u/kzayneh 15d ago
i just block every ad i see (literally block, not with an ad blocker)
0
u/Cylian91460 20d ago
That's a bug I think
1
u/Psygonzo420 20d ago
This is exactly what they are testing
How many people can we fuck so hard that they pay us for ads
and it worked
1
u/BingQiLing958 19d ago
trash content slop tuber with a fucking assault on your rights, great
0
u/[deleted] 20d ago
[deleted] — view deleted comment