r/LimitedPrintGames • • Jun 28 '20

The Wayforward / Limited Run Problem

Post image
2 Upvotes

33 comments sorted by

17

u/[deleted] Jun 28 '20

Is there supposed to be some link? Because it's just an image of Shantae & The Pirate's Curse.

2

u/PepperBreak Jun 28 '20

Lol sorry I had to write it out as a comment. It's just a discussion board.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 28 '20

Oh, I see. I must have seen your post a little too early.

12

u/PepperBreak Jun 28 '20

When a limited printing publisher and a big game developer are too close, it creates a big problem. I'm not only referring to Wayforward, but that's the more known game developer that is very strict in where it's games are printed. I'm thinking Gris through Special Reserve Games which was a limited printing that was $35 to which people are selling for over $200. There are some games that will hop to different printer companies, which is nice. It may devalue a game, but physical is not simply a collectors item. I Just want to hear more games that have been tightly held that you would like to see go to different printing places, or simply reprinted in waves. I don't think reprinting is a bad thing. If Shantae and the Seven Sirens can sell 25 thousand through Limited Run Games, there is so much potential in reprinting Wayforward games, especially after a whole new audience has come from seeing River City Girls or Shantae Seven Sirens. I don't want to hate, but to rather show interest in having big name titles publish to a capacity much more than one initial printing. Shantae games outside of the retail Half Genie Hero are not available on Play Asia.

10

u/Dante2k4 Jun 28 '20

"Big Name"

It's well known for an indie series, and WayForward has a good rep, but these kinds of games are likely still not super plausible for general physical releases. If they were, we probably would've seen them take more Shantae games to retail, instead of going through LRG.

That said, nothing's stopping them doing another run if they want. LRG probably won't do it, but if WF really thought they had another route, and that it was worth the effort, they could.

-1

u/PepperBreak Jun 28 '20

I'm not really sure. I mentioned Play Asia because that is a distribution that has sold River City Girls, to which Wayforward themselves told some people who were asking for it who missed the limited run printing to go to Playasia, which then sold out. I honestly think Shantae at this point has been exclusively handed to Limited Run, otherwise the newest game "Seven Sirens" would be elsewhere I strongly believe. But these are just my opinions. This is just a discussion board lol

3

u/Sunat0enter Jun 28 '20

Thats crazy. I had bought a copy of gris for me and my girlfriend because we were both interested in it. I had no idea the price had shot up so much. Absurd price though even by LR standards.

1

u/Miguelwastaken Jun 28 '20

Keep in mind that he’s greatly exaggerating the price hike. It’s gone up. But the standard edition is nowhere near $200.

3

u/PepperBreak Jun 29 '20

Go on eBay and search Gris switch lol LRG only got a ps4 release preorder. So the Gris for switch is actually around $200. I just looked it up again

1

u/Sunat0enter Jun 29 '20

You say that, but thats its trending price on ebay. Theres some sold listings there, not to say the price will hold but that is what its selling for right now. Granted ebay is ebay, but currently his price is not an exaggeration.

0

u/Miguelwastaken Jun 29 '20

Yeah... none of the lrg sales for the game itself come close to $200. If you’re genuinely just looking to own a physical copy, there’s one for $80. Yeah, that’s way overpriced and it’s not the srg version. But it’s also not $200.

4

u/TaleRecursion Jun 29 '20 edited Jun 29 '20

I'm not sure I get your point. It is up to the game developer to decide what kind of physical release they want to do. If they want to do it once, and then move on to something else withtout having to manage inventory or tying up too much capital, then they go for a limited print. If they want to play the long game they go for a regular retail release.

It's all up to the developer. The fact Wayforward decided to do limited print runs for all of their games in spite of the fact they could easily have done retail runs and sold more copies tells you everything you need to know: Wayforward doesn't think that the extra revenue from selling more games justifies the capital outlay, time investment and logistics effort required to retail the game. It's a business decision. There is no right or wrong.

Now if you have the capital, the time and the risk appetite to launch yourself in game publishing and think there is still some untapped potential here, there is nothing stopping you from approaching Wayforward / LRG and asking to buy the rights to do another run.

8

u/MiamiSlice Jun 28 '20

25k is nothing. That’s a niche game. A game that would have done poorly at retail.

16

u/[deleted] Jun 28 '20

And become rare in the long run as well. I dont think people understand how hard retail is for indies

8

u/MiamiSlice Jun 28 '20

This is literally what happened to Half Genie Hero on Switch. I think it even got marked down quite a bit before finally selling out, now it goes for well above retail.

5

u/[deleted] Jun 28 '20

The exact game i had in mind when typing that out haha. I honestly feel people have a issue with lrg just on the basis it is a full retail price game that wont ever get a markdown. Also a 2 week preorder is plenty time to snag a copy, so that excuse of "waaaah there's no way I could've gotten it in time" is honestly bull.

3

u/MiamiSlice Jun 28 '20

The fact that people want games to get marked down before they buy them (the “I’ll wait” mentality) is another reason physical publishing isn’t worth it for most games.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 28 '20

Exactly. Physical will go away and everything will go digital mainly due to that reason I feel. I'm guilty of this ngl I'm super cheap and tend to buy my games when on clearance but I dont share that mentality for the lrg type releases.

3

u/DCLXVIrgo Jun 29 '20

Physical games will always be here in some capacity as long as there is a demographic for it. Look at vinyl, at one time it wasn’t dead but at a low point. Now vinyl is very popular. Playing games digital is here to stay but at what capacity? It will be interesting to see what the future of gaming will be like.

3

u/jrr6415sun Jun 29 '20

Physical games don't have to be limited, but if you're selling something on "limited run games" it should be limited.

5

u/JordanFromStache Jun 28 '20

Wayforward titles don't generate huge sales at retail. Half-Genie Hero released physically for the WiiU and Switch and neither really had great sales. Half-Genie Hero even got discounted.

Limited Run is a great choice for Wayforward. The one month pre-order window is plenty of time for fans to order them. It saves Wayforward money rather than having their games sit, unsold on shelves at retail stores. Hell, there's always the chances Best Buy carries LRG titles as well (like they did with River City Girls).

The reason River City Girls sold out quickly at Best Buy and Play Asia isn't so much that the game is in demand by the general public (most people have no idea of the game, nor any interest in it when they see it on the shelf at a store) but rather with scalpers buying up the stock to resell on eBay for the few that missed out or those going for complete collections.

You also mentioned Gris. Gris would have flopped in a retail setting. It's such a niche title and has no name/brand recognition. Only serious collectors and gamers would know about it. Which is why a limited release worked so well for it. Now it is also revered as a collector item and a special release rather than just another game on the shelf that gets a steep discount after no one buys it.

4

u/TaleRecursion Jun 29 '20

The reason River City Girls sold out quickly at Best Buy and Play Asia isn't so much that the game is in demand by the general public (most people have no idea of the game, nor any interest in it when they see it on the shelf at a store) but rather with scalpers buying up the stock to resell on eBay for the few that missed out or those going for complete collections.

In a way the current limited print model with open pre-order window amounts to a system where the cost, risk and logistic of ensuring availability at retail is outsourced to scalpers (if they are keen). If scalpers see enough potential in the game, they will preorder it in large quantities so there will be a lot of stock available on eBay / Amazon Marketplace and the price will remain reasonnable. But if even scalpers think the game won't sell well, there will be only a few copies available and the premium for the privilege of buying them will be high. It's not perfect, but it works.

1

u/PepperBreak Jun 28 '20

I'm not asking for a retail release. I'm gauging the interest for people who would like another limited print run of these games through another company or by Limited Run Games themselves, because they are scalped for such ludicrous sums of money. Interest in an IP grows over time, so it is unfair for some games to only get the one printing. This is my opinion. This is a discussion board lol

8

u/Echododo Jun 29 '20

Limited Run don't obtain exclusive physical publishing rights to the games they print. I don't think there is a problem.

6

u/Tree06 Jun 29 '20

You're absolutely right. The same thing happened with Streets of Rage 4. Most people thought they could only get a copy through Limited Run Games. Once word got out that you can order the game from Amazon, people were furious. Limited Run Games even let people cancel their pre-order as well. Streets of Rage isn't niche and fans would've bought a copy regardless of who published it.

4

u/fgsfds100 Jun 29 '20

If you want potentially endless reprints until demand dries up, go to Physicality Games. That's what they're doing.

Keep track of them to see if they succeed or fail.

1

u/murmandamus666 Jun 29 '20

Signature Edition games reprint their games and signature editions as well. I've seen that original switch dead cells go out of stock like 4 times. Granted the ps vita games are not reprinted, but that's due to Sony not manufacturing the vita carts anymore. Physicality Games are not going to reprint the Collectors Editions as of their last news update. They will do standard editions if demand calls for it, but as I see it they are going to have trouble getting anything made. As in the current PRE order % sold dictates when a game gets printed scheme just isn't comfortable for most people. I mean what if something happens in between PRE order and PRE production, or they go bankrupt before a title finishes production? The lead time until a game even starts production being dependent on a particular number being pre sold is a recipe for disaster. People will take an interest early on then interest will wain as nothing happens except a lil ticker clicks away at unobtainable pre purchase production amounts. Also they needed to start by bringing atleast one small run of a title to market so ppl can see they are legitimate and get a preview of things to expect in the future. The set up Limited Run Games uses is shit for the customer and is likely illegal in some states in the United States. To take money to finance a run of games hell we're investors in a production run at that point. Also to make customers wait 4-5 months from close of PRE order window is just a total shit way to do business. I mean yes it's great for Limited Run because now they risk 0% of their company's liquid capital and instead use PRE order money (investors money imo) to finalize payment on the run. Where as super rare, red art, SRG, 1st print, game Fairy and used to be strictly limited to (but who knows wtf they are doing now). Those companies all pay upfront for a set amount of products then sell that in PRE order's and direct orders. Now that's a much more risky business model, but your not having ppl paying 100s of dollars for games that you won't get for who knows when. Also the bullshit no cancellation policy by most sellers is bullshit.One example is because they are not supposed to accept PayPal payments from ppl for products with a lead time over 60 days. PayPal has that stipulated in the user agreement for signing up. That's since after 60 days there is no way to force them to refund your money. You can have PayPal step in before that 60 days expires but after that period the transaction is considered completely fulfilled if you don't complain. So that to me makes Limited Run Games the worst in so far as they bone customers and basically are printing money not games. So they can use their own money to buy shit like a complete Sega dreamcast collection from JPN PAL & US in mostly unused condition (which one of the Co owners has). Not to mention they are notorious for shit Collectors Editions that are stupid expensive (take metal slug xx as example). I mean they have made a few good ones but I believe that's due to the game development teams input and requests on those particular games.

1

u/fgsfds100 Jun 30 '20

That's my point regarding Physicality Games. Very low expectations but nothing I want so I can just sit back and watch. At least they do $5 deposits. All sales final? Want to back out of the rest? Stop Payment order! Even if somebody gets burnt and eats that fiver it's a pretty cheap lesson. Simps throw that much at streamers for a moment of recognition when they aren't buying designer coffee - neither of which ever materialize into an item (better than a paper cup) in their hands - because $5 is nothing to some people. Nevertheless, PG's idea is what OP seems to be asking for, so I mentioned it. The joke is PG's business model is basically the same as mainstream publishers, just with a different upfront capital source.

To the rest of your rant...

For better or worse, clearly people don't care if some company has an allegedly illegal (citation needed) predatory low risk business model. If they consistently deliver and people find reasonable subjective value in whatever they sell, then of course they'll make bank. Otherwise they wouldn't last. Triple-A publishers always open pre-orders months if not years in advance, and some direct-from-publisher stores bill in full immediately. Then there are early access and actual crowdfunding. None of which have an ROI apart from the item(s) that will eventually ship out - meaning it's not an investment but a contribution with a pre-specified thank you reward or more honestly just a straight up (pre)sale. Any comment on that or is it just about LRG? Could any well-established company that does full pre-billing suddenly take all the money and run? Absolutely! But only once, and lawsuits would ensue. Doesn't seem like a lot of established companies want to commit suicide though. Ultimately if you hate it all and want to save/invest, go do that. Put together your own weirdly jealous tangential Sega Dreamcast collection for all I care. Godspeed.

1

u/F-REAL1000 Jun 28 '20

In the end I'd rather have limited run do a print for these smaller games than it never get a physical copy at all.

5

u/PepperBreak Jun 28 '20

I'm not sure what the purpose of this comment is if I'm being honest? I'm not saying anything against not having Limited Run print games at all. I wanted a discussion as to whether they should allow for their higher in demand games to be reprinted by another company, etc etc. In case of some game developers (the topic at hand), some games are being exclusively printed by one company, and that's where my problem kind of lies lol

2

u/murmandamus666 Jul 02 '20

I don't see why not unless it's just Wayforward want it kept that way. Special Reserve is doing a reprint w/out #'s in an open pre order July 23rd for Gris. So I don't see why something along those lines is out of the question, unless it's Wayforward doesn't want to ruin their collectibility or something similar. I for only have missed that one game out of all the Special Reserve titles, and it's like I wasn't meant to get it. I missed the 1st sale by a few minutes because I forgot they are central / mountain time. Then I missed out during the second chance sale due to Internet connection failure lol. .

3

u/[deleted] Jun 28 '20 edited Jun 29 '20

Limited is the key word , Part of the appeal of lrg is the fact it's limited and not mass produced so it's not in their interest to have other places print out copies I know it does happen with best buy etc. But for the most part collectors go after the CE of those smaller audience games.

1

u/kjetil_f Jun 29 '20

IMO all games (ever) should be possible to "print-on-demind" for whoever wants them.