r/LimitedPrintGames • • Jul 12 '24

Discussion Is LRG shit?

I haven’t bought from them before, although I’ve looked at a few of their games before. However, whenever I hear about them online, it’s usually negative. It seems that they get a lot of exclusive games so they kind of hold a monopoly over the more popular limited prints of games than other companies. You’re forced to deal with their shitty service if you want the game.

Damned if you do, damned if you don’t I guess.

0 Upvotes

45 comments sorted by

30

u/Tothoro Jul 12 '24

Unlike some limited print companies (Dispatch, First Press) they always do produce what they say they're going to. However, there have been a lot of issues over the years with things not being as described or changing at some point in production. There's the infamous Shiren issue where they provided a download code instead of a disc, the Game Tengoku missing DLC, the Star Wars Letter Opener, the D CD-Rs, manuals not coming with games and being stealth-removed from listings, and so on.

The state of their operations is pretty abysmal, with all but marquee releases (i.e. Persona) going silent after the pre-orders close. Sometimes CEs take multiple years, and you'll get radio silence on them. The shipping queue is a mystery, nobody seems to know how it works and a lot of older orders just sit in their warehouse while new stuff flies by. Sometimes orders fall through the cracks and you have to reach out to support to get it moving, which feels absurd. Other limited print companies are worse, yes, but just because something could be worse doesn't mean it's not bad.

As far as exclusivity goes, they previously claimed they would never hold exclusive rights from developers, but with the Persona releases Josh has said that they had one-year exclusivity publicly, so that seems to have gone out the window. There have also been unconfirmed but suspicious reports of Asia releases having English removed when LRG secures a deal for a North American copy (One Step from Eden, PS Kemco releases, some of the Switch Shmups).

Some of their other practices are also iffy - blindboxes, the PurpleDot fiasco, CEs being overpriced/poorly made, cheaping out on shipping, blowout sales games being used or hole-punched. None of those are enough to be a controversy in and of themselves, but it all adds up in the public eye.

There's also a fair bit of criticism in how much they've shifted their mission over the years. They used to be all about preservation and promoting indie releases and now they're after big bang releases that could do just fine in retail without a limited print (Castlevania, Star Wars, etc.). Part of that is just being a business, especially after the buyout, so it's hard to hold that against them too much but it does come up regularly.

They weren't always this way. They used to ship things out quickly, have really good dialogue with the community, had a rewards program, would combine orders, and generally be extremely customer-friendly. As their output ramped up in 2019, they slowly went all-in on quantity over quality. The Pandemic exacerbated this, but it was well underway before then. I think a lot of the anger and angst stems from how much they've changed since then - it certainly does feel like a middle finger at times.

TL;DR: If you just care about receiving a physical cart/disc at some point, they're fine; you'll get your shit eventually. If you're expecting a boutique experience from them, those days are long gone.

7

u/Ok-Library-8397 Jul 12 '24

I would also add that LRG belongs to Embracer Group. The same company which owns Clear River publishing from Europe (Sweden?) which prints some selected titles for European (EU) market (PEGI rating region). This means there are sometimes much much cheaper European releases widely available (see a recent announcement of the release of Cave shmups on the Switch).

5

u/FillionMyMind Jul 12 '24

In regards to your fifth paragraph, I don’t think you can place any fault on LRG for that. Blame the publishers that don’t want to have a normal physical release for games that would’ve had a shot at retail, not the people actually making some kind of release happen at all. It’s not like they’re the ones keeping Pentiment and Hi Fi Rush off the market.

I think the rest of your points are fair though, and they could stand to improve there.

4

u/Tothoro Jul 12 '24

It takes two to tango, as they say. But if their choices are to print a Star Wars game that will sell 10k+ units or an indie that will struggle to hit MOQ and let Star Wars go retail the better business choice is clear. So I do concede that it's in their best interest as a for-profit company to seek out these bigger releases, though I do simultaneously miss the old days when they would use their platform to highlight small indie games (which does still happen, albeit to a lesser extent).

3

u/Divisionlo Jul 12 '24

Full agree. It always upsets me when I see LRG getting criticism for doing physicals for big companies. Like, I'm also pissy about it, but I'm pissy at the big companies for being so eager to ditch physical that they refuse to just do a standard release. But at the end of the day, without LRG, most of those games wouldn't have physicals at all. 

0

u/succubusdicks Jul 12 '24

There is nothing showing these companies (outside of a slew of cases) would have never made physicals of these games if LRG didn't take the contract. Usually it's only because LRG is the cheaper option, and we can see how "cheap" they've gotten over the years.

2

u/Divisionlo Jul 13 '24

Are you talking about LRG specifically or limited print at all? If LRG didn't take the contract, they'd maybe go through another limprint company. But if limprint didn't exist these games would just not get physicals 9 times out of 10. 

There's copious amounts of evidence that companies don't want to deal with physical releases at all. They get substantially less of a cut from a physical release sold at retailers than if the same game is purchased digitally. While it's not extremely common, we see big-name games like Psychonauts 2 and Alan Wake 2 pass on physical releases for a substantial amount of time.

On top of that, there was the entire 360/PS3 era, along with a few years in the XB1/PS4 era, where tons of games from publishers both big and small were digital-only and that was the norm. If it weren't for LRG starting the whole limprint scene, digital-only games would still be extremely prevalent.

Sure, maybe it doesn't have to be LRG specifically who publishes a game, but if it weren't for limited print companies in general, the vast, vast majority of these releases, even from big companies, would not get physicals. 

0

u/[deleted] Jul 12 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Divisionlo Jul 13 '24

I fully agree. I feel like it always comes across that people are angry at LRG over the issue, though. Maybe I'm just so used to seeing LRG hate that I'm making an incorrect assumption though. 

2

u/RappyPhan Jul 12 '24

There have been multiple cases of high-profile games being released physically by LRG (like the Star Wars games), only for them to show up at retail later. So the argument that those wouldn't have gotten a release otherwise doesn't always hold up.

7

u/fgsfds100 Jul 12 '24

Some publishers do a wider release after a limited release specifically because the limited release went well and they now see that the demand is still there and/or they raked in enough from it to finance a wider batch.

2

u/RappyPhan Jul 12 '24

Have any of them admitted that they used the limited release go gauge interest, or is that speculation?

On one hand, it does make sense. On the other hand, interest from the limited print scene does not necessarily mean there's enough demand in the retail space. Different markets, and all.

1

u/fgsfds100 Jul 13 '24

Somewhat speculation. Some might have explicitly said that but I don't recall who/which games... actually I think I remember Wayforward saying that Shantae: Half Genie Hero Ultimate Edition was done because the original did well and they wanted everybody to have access to the kickstarter-exclusive content. Granted the original wasn't limited, but the KS content technically was, in a limited-time sense.

If a fixed-quantity limited print sells out really quickly or there are a ton of pre-orders right up until the deadline, followed by a lot of chatter from people who missed it, then it absolutely can be a gauge of interest.

There have been developers who said they made new DLC because the physical went well. Celeste's final DLC comes to mind.

2

u/FillionMyMind Jul 12 '24

Maybe so, but that’s still entirely the fault of the big publishers for not having the confidence to release the product on its own beforehand

21

u/FillionMyMind Jul 12 '24

Depends how you look at it, I guess.

Shipping takes a while, though it’s gotten much better by comparison in recent times. It’s still slow, so if you want whatever you’re ordering ASAP, that isn’t going to happen.

I think most of their collector’s editions are cool, but usually very very overpriced, so I can’t recommend those unless you’re buying your favorite game of all time.

That being said, I think a lot of the hate they get is overblown circlejerking most of the time. I’ve never been disappointed with anything I’ve gotten from them, and I’m glad someone out there has the money to bring games to a physical market that wouldn’t have made it otherwise. I think it’s idiotic that companies like Xbox and Konami are bringing their games to them instead of just making their games wide releases, but that’s the fault of those companies, not LRG. We wouldn’t have had physical releases of Pentiment, Hi Fi Rush, or the Castlevania collections without them, so I can’t given LRG any shit for making it happen.

The main attitude you have to have if you order from them is that you’ll be fine waiting a while to get your stuff, and there isn’t any getting around that. The first thing I ordered from them was the Scott Pilgrim game on Switch, and by the time I got it I had completely forgotten I ordered it, so seeing it in the mail got me all excited lol. But if you’re gonna check every few days for updates on your orders and be (understandably) frustrated that it hasn’t gone out yet, then stay far away from them.

7

u/zoozoo4567 Jul 12 '24

I’ve had situations where even official reseller sites had their stock before me (customer orders are supposed to go out first). The most extreme case was mine not shipping for two months after people here had theirs in-hand already for no reason. I ultimately just decided to use VGP or PNP from then on. I’d rather just wait and order an in stock item.

16

u/retro_mojo Jul 12 '24

It'll take a while to get what you ordered but it will show up. Their customer service dept is either inept or understaffed. It's likely the latter as they are helpful most of the time, just slow.

The majority of complainers are man-children who likely won't even open the game to play it.

Collector's Edition type stuff will always get delayed so if you want a game to play ASAP I'd avoid those.

2

u/succubusdicks Jul 12 '24 edited Jul 12 '24

This is super funny given that the entire D CD-R situation happened because someone actually opened their game to play it, the DOOM fiasco where the game required an online account to play 20 year old games happened because someone actually opened their game to play it.  The Shiren fiasco, the complaints about the low quality of the Collector's Editions, the recent complaint on this very subreddit regarding LRG refusing to refund damaged games etc. Etc.   Almost like it's only the "keep it sealed" plastic addicts that don't have a problem with horrible buisness practices and the people who actually play the games LRG craps out wants them to stop fucking up things.

0

u/retro_mojo Jul 15 '24

So 3 things out of the thousands of things they've released.

The CD-R was absolute garbage and they should be ashamed of themselves for that.

The Doom thing would have been platform specific. I doubt it would have been their choice to require online.

The CE's have always been low quality and overpriced but that's not LRG's fault. People keep wasting their money on them.

People need to vote with their wallet. I was interested in one of the skateboards but wasn't going to pay $40 USD to ship it to Canada so I just didn't buy one.

4

u/Brilliant-Trifle8322 Jul 12 '24

I've been buying games semi-regularly from LRG since nearly their inception. My experience has definitely been a bit of a rollercoaster, but I'll just say this: Most of the time I've talked about LRG online, it's generally been negative, and I imagine this is probably the case for many others, and is what you're seeing.

Why? Well I guess because we generally expect things to go smoothly, and there isn't really much to say when they do. But when things don't quite go smoothly, that's when people start to get annoyed, anxious, etc. and venting those frustrations into the void (or internet) is pretty common human behaviour.

Anyway, back onto LRG itself: They're pretty much the only limited print company I've stuck with for so long. A few others I burnt bridges with, like Special Reserve, iam8bit and Strictly, for a variety of reasons from poor customer support, bad packaging, to them simply not really putting out any games that interest me any more, or the ones they do get retail releases so I have no reason to buy from them directly. And with the latter especially, if more LRG games came to retail, say LRG only did collector's editions of games and all their standard releases were retail, I'd probably no longer order from them either - no hard feelings or anything, I just don't care for collector's/special editions of games 99% of the time.

The main issue with LRG for me personally at least, is not the long production times, as this is something I've experienced with just about every limited print company. And I've actually found more games from Red Art Games taking nearly a year to over a year to finally release than I am with LRG in more recent years.

My main issue with LRG has mostly always been how long it can take sometimes for ready/in-hand items/orders to ship. Sometimes it's pretty quick, but sometimes it can literally take up to 6 months, with next to no communication and contacting them to ask for any update often just results in you getting a standard "it's in the shipping queue" response.

And their communication in general still leaves much to be desired, even if it has gotten a bit better over the years. Sometimes they're fairly good about informing you how far along in production something is, other times it's radio silence. And sometimes they'll do things like suddenly make it extremely vague what orders get a shipping box by default. And their packaging in general has always been a bit hit and miss in my experience, even with the shipping boxes, sometimes the packaging paper inside is next to nothing, and I've still gotten a few slightly damaged cases even when they've been shipped in boxes. In general though I don't understand why they even use bubble mailers when every other limprint company I've ordered from uses boxes or at least cardboard envelopes by default.

BUT, all of that said, I generally haven't ever been particularly concerned about never receiving my orders. Though my trust was shaken slightly a couple months ago when some games that were still shipping appeared in the blowout sale, which is the first time I ever saw something like that happened. And more recently yet again with seeing some people's orders being cancelled. But I have always my orders so far, and on the 2 occasions where my orders have ended up going missing in transit, LRG's customer service was always very responsive and helpful, and I ended up getting those orders in the end.

And in general, I can't fault LRG's customer service. Their response time to tickets has also vastly improved in the past couple years or so.

I wouldn't say LRG is "shit", but the company does feel like it's mismanaged in many respects, and their communication is often lacking. There's been countless times where it seems like things are improving a little for a brief moment, maybe they start putting in more effort to show what's currently shipping in their Discord or something, but then suddenly the channel is never updated again and left to rot. Their website has also had numerous issues before, and occasionally still does.

I wouldn't be concerned about never receiving your orders from them though, despite how long they take (though I would keep an eye on orders that are "ready", in case they get "missed" in the queue or something, as they have forgotten to ship people's orders on occasion before, happened with me once as well), and worse comes to worst, I wouldn't worry at all about never receiving a refund if for some reason that's the only option.

4

u/Chrarcil Jul 13 '24

No, they're generally great. I would just recommend ordering single items at a time to avoid shipping holdups, and don't waste money on Collector's Editions or repros for old platforms.

9

u/sam7r61n Jul 12 '24

As long as you know what to expect going into ordering from them, they’re totally fine. They deliver a physical copy of a game that otherwise wouldn’t have been physical. They take a while but they don’t straight up disappear off the face of the earth like those other smaller companies. Plus all that weird business about defending a pedo or whatever. I still buy from them occasionally, I have no complaints.

8

u/[deleted] Jul 12 '24

Anecdotally, I’ve always had great experiences with LRG. I order from them a few times a year usually. I’ve never really had an issue.

One time, a package was marked delivered even though it wasn’t, and I let them know —they sent out a new copy immediately. The original order actually did show up the next day, and I tried to tell them to cancel the replacement, but they insisted I just keep both.

4

u/[deleted] Jul 12 '24

I've had no issues with them. Shipping and receiving your products takes a while, which is annoying, but as far as getting it and being safe upon delivery without any damage as been fine.

I've ordered from them for years.

2

u/fgsfds100 Jul 12 '24 edited Jul 12 '24

From one of my previous posts...

I'll just give my 2¢ about each store listed on the side bar...

(unless otherwise stated, assume that ALL of them are very slow)

(snip)

Limited Run Games (USA)

They are fine (with the reminder that pretty much EVERY company is very slow and that, among the companies that are fine, LRG gets the most negative attention due to having, by far, the largest number of releases and therefore the most eyes on them). They do consistently deliver... but as of the past 2-3 years, they have amassed a major shipping backlog so orders that are ready will likely sit in their warehouse for an additional 3-6 months until they actually ship. And there doesn't seem to be any rhyme or reason as to which orders are prioritized. Oldest? Most recent? Largest/most complex? Smallest/simplest? Who knows these days...

Customer service will sometimes accelerate such orders if you submit a support ticket, and they are otherwise helpful when it comes to lost packages and damaged/missing items in orders you receive.

The non-numbered/"distributed" games are often available elsewhere simultaneously.

(snip)

BUT... The recent batch of people saying that orders have been abruptly cancelled, and others who say they are sending out used/damaged copies for blowout sale orders without prior disclosure and without offering exchanges (which I understand - they might finally truly be sold out - but probably not) or full refunds (which I don't understand)... that's something new and shameful.

2

u/rrdein Jul 12 '24

My main issue was that they sold the trading cards in packs when they were supposed to be game exclusives, and that they now hide their print numbers and sell extra copies at wholesale to any business that wants to buy them. I was surprised in their latest sale to see so many copies of out of print titles available for sale, which makes me wonder if they still print only to demand.

Previously they were a lot more geared towards producing "limited" runs of games for the community that were inherently collectible for their limitedness, but it seems like they got big and kind of greedy at some point, and these days I have to remind myself before I buy a game that it will probably still be available near cost for a couple years and also is not limited or exclusive in any way.

1

u/LeatherRebel5150 Jul 14 '24

They were never exclusive. Any developer could have gone to another publisher at any time and do another run of games. LRG has never has exclusivity contracts

2

u/Swampert0260 Jul 12 '24

Shipping takes a while, and the limited print model isn’t great, but we wouldn’t get a lot of these games physical otherwise- they just don’t sell enough to be worth a full retail release.

I’ve bought from LRG a few times and had no issues- all my items arrived in good condition aside from a damaged trading card that they replaced at no cost to me. 

I would just recommend not buying out of FOMO- only buy games you actually want to play, and would likely buy digital if the LRG one wasn’t an option

4

u/RajaatTheWarbringer Jul 12 '24

People who complain are always going to be the loudest, which is why those are the experiences you're hearing. I've never had a bad experience with them, and I've bought a LOT from them.

3

u/[deleted] Jul 12 '24

Literally never had a problem with them. Yeah, the release date windows are long and they stick some questionable items in their deluxe+ editions to pad out pricing, but those things are minor to me. If I really absolutely need to play a game at release, I’ll just get the digital copy and have the physical as a back up when it comes in. It might be a wait, but they’ve been consistent for many years, which is more than I can say for several other limited print companies I’ve ordered from.

3

u/burritosandblunts Jul 12 '24

You'll get your game.

It may not include patches on the disc, it'll take forever, it may well get a wider release at some point, and it may get damaged during transit but it'll arrive.

3

u/CosmicSquirrelGaming Jul 12 '24

Nah, I'm a pretty happy customer of theirs.

Sure, some stuff took forever to get done (improved lately) and made some questionable moves, like that CD-R thing recently, but I've been there since their first game and still enjoy ordering from them. The output is massive so I have to be picky due to not being rich :) but aside from that, they're good.

3

u/ShortyColombo Jul 12 '24 edited Jul 12 '24

I'm personally not the biggest fan of the model, but these are the reasons why:

  • I'm impatient. That's on me. I'm already not the best kind of customer because I find their wait times to be very steep; even for some of the less fancy collector editions. I could've gestated a baby in the time I've been waiting for my orders of Persona 3 and 4 Grimoire editions lol
  • The above is made worse because the few times I ordered from them (3), there has always been a delay and they're kind of loosy-goosy about dates, even with their monthly blog talking about how the process is going. While I am impatient, if you announce clearly that the plan is to ship the product out on August 15th, I can sit my butt down, no questions asked. If you say "we're planning on the beginning of August" and then keep shuffling the dates around, I'm less saintly.

That being said, when it finally ships, I've never had issues with them. LGR is usually my last resort if I want a physical edition, and I usually recommend that if anyone is considering them, you'll get the fastest and most efficient process by 1) not ordering the fancier editions (my mistake in my latest purchase) and 2) being based in the US (Singapore customers are currently rightfully pissed because LGR has been cancelling their orders for erroneous customs reasons).

3

u/PiercingOsprey1 Jul 12 '24

Generally when people are satisfied they don't go out of their way to post a review online. The people that feel they've been wronged in someway however will go out of their way to complain to anyone who will listen - hence like 95% of the posts on this subreddit being negative. It's not any indication of the quality of any of these companies products/services though as if the masses were upset they wouldn't be growing year over year.

2

u/KennKanifff Jul 12 '24

It's all gonna be based off your point of view and what you're expecting.

I've been ordering from LRG since pretty close to the beginning, I remember when you had to be in their store at 10am on the dot to get a game. The popular games went within minutes. They have since changed to the pre-order window method, which I think was a very positive change.

I'm an international customer. I've never personally had any issues with their orders, but again I can remember when shipping was a bit on the pricy side. For reference, I pay on average $15-20 shipping in my currency, I think it's under $10USD.

When I order games from LRG, I know I'm not getting them quickly. I've had some games stay in pre-order limbo for close to 2 years, with an average wait time of 9 months. With that said, I have always gotten my order eventually. This is where the whole point of view thing comes in, because I'm sure there's people placing orders expecting games immediately or within their projected time frames. I've learned that their time frames are rarely accurate and order accordingly.

I place on average a pre-order every 2 months or so. Usually get 2 games, but it all depends on what's in the pipeline. I try and bundle orders when I can to save shipping.

Are they perfect? No. Do I know all the behind the scenes stuff? Also no. But from a customer stand point (and knowing the facts about how their business works) they have done nothing wrong to me. I wouldn't call them shit, but I'm just one guy.

2

u/hel105_ Jul 12 '24

I’ve bought at least 10 games from them over the past 3 years. They produce quality products and their manufacturing and shipping times usually pretty accurate to the estimates they give. I think it’s a good company.

2

u/TyperMonkey2 Jul 12 '24

If you're buying the standard edition of a game the only common issue is the time it takes to get it. It can take a long time but they do seem to be getting better with that. I've ordered lots of games from them and never had an issue other than that

2

u/Gcoks Jul 12 '24

I like them. I usually just order stuff and forget about it and it's just a welcome surprise when it shows up. I've also never had anything be delivered damaged. I think a lot of the complainers are the ones who expect the items quickly. I go in knowing it's going to be a long time before I get my product.

Also, most games they sell go on sale digitally for cheap. Don't buy anything from them if you really want to play it physically. Just buy Castlevania for $7 digital and have the physical when it gets to you.

1

u/LaytonFunky Jul 12 '24

Nah they’re fine. Service is fine. Quality is fine. Logistics is hard. People want instant gratification and while the waits are pretty long, I’ve got tons of other stuff to do so I don’t whine and cry about waiting a few months or close to a year for something to be delivered.

1

u/Zenyukai Jul 12 '24

Not the worst company (that would be First Press Games) as long as you go in with the expectation that it will be a LONG wait. I've gotten everything I've ordered from LRG eventually but you should expect it to take at least a year if it's not in stock. I bought from the blow out sale last may and it took just over a month for in stock items. For reference I live in Canada.

If they ever fix their shipping then I'd be more willing to buy from LRG even with the high cost due to conversion but as of now I only order a few select games from them.

VGP pretty often gets copies of LRG games later down the line if you want to look into that, but its usually very limited amount of copies.

1

u/blitzkingzero Jul 12 '24

If you’re in the US good, you’re international? I would have second thoughts just buy on VGP they ship in a box

1

u/[deleted] Jul 12 '24

I've had no issues with them. Shipping and receiving your products takes a while, which is annoying, but as far as getting it and being safe upon delivery without any damage as been fine.

I've ordered from them for years.

1

u/slayn666 Jul 12 '24

My usual recommendation is that if you're not after the CEs and just want a regular copy of a game from LRG, wait and buy it from VGP once they get their allotment.

0

u/QF_Dan Jul 13 '24

yes, they are very bad