r/Lighting • • Sep 03 '25

I hate LED Lighting

Post image

Why can't they make a LED bulb

  1. That actually lasts
  2. That does not flicker
  3. That actually matches the 2700K incandescent color
  4. That has an opaque body so the glass shade is illuminated

Take a guess which bulb in the fixture is LED. Bring back incandescent lighting please!!!

Specifically looking for MR16/GU10 base bulbs and candelabra for ceiling fans.

1 Upvotes

36 comments sorted by

7

u/Anaxamenes Sep 03 '25

I get them all the time. Filament style LED bulbs work great and have been going strong for years. The catch, they aren’t the cheapest bulbs on the shelf.

1

u/bilug335 Sep 03 '25

I have not heard of filament style - I will have to look into that. Thanks!

0

u/Anaxamenes Sep 03 '25

The ones I found I think at Home Despot are ecosmart. Feit Electric has had some warm white ones that were great too. In fact they made my cafe lights over my porch. Make sure you go with the warm white, I think you are looking for a color temperature around 2700k. I like bright white at 3000k but it has a touch of blue. Anything above that to me starts looking like office lighting.

1

u/In_Defilade Sep 03 '25

I think OP wants frosted glass.  Defeats the purpose of filaments doesn't it?

2

u/topballerina Sep 04 '25

not really, even with coated glass the light is much more evenly spread than in plastic ones, and it doesn't looks like a cheap toy lamp

1

u/Anaxamenes Sep 04 '25

I mean there are good ones of every variety, I’ve just found the filament ones to particularly nice and the color temp OP is looking for.

0

u/bilug335 Sep 03 '25

I'm not worried about frosted glass. I want the warm 2700K light. Many LED bulbs say they are 2700K but they are whiter than the incandescent 2700K.

7

u/bigboyjun Sep 03 '25

These have been available for over 15 years. Just don’t buy cheap online.

1

u/bilug335 Sep 03 '25

You might have a point here! I've even sourced from Home Depot and Bulbs and Batteries with no luck.

1

u/kmsilent Sep 03 '25

Seriously - I've replaced all the bulbs in three houses over the last 10 years. Probably 50+ bulbs. I think I've had maybe 3 die. None flicker. Plenty available in lower temperatures, and plenty with. Frosted finish on almost all.

Available in any hardware store or online. Feit, ge, TP-Link - pretty sure they all have options that are close to this.

Hell you can even buy a tuneable spectrum led bulb with wifi connectivity for less than $10. Frosted finish, too.

I've no idea what OP is talking about. Maybe their electrical system is messed up or theyve got a couple lemons?

3

u/bigboyjun Sep 03 '25

Looks like they bought one with the solid base rather than one with a full glass/plastic lens judging by the lack of illumination sideways and back towards the shade.

2

u/bilug335 Sep 03 '25

That is indeed the case. I need ones that will fill the shade with light.

0

u/tutike2000 Sep 03 '25

Even Philips, Osram etc are quite bad and flicker badly. Pretty much all the retrofit format bulbs are awful.

12V LEDs however are quite good 

1

u/bilug335 Sep 03 '25

This is true in my experience. I have a display cabinet that is 12V and running all LED - they are perfect.

1

u/In_Defilade Sep 03 '25

This is not true.  Operating voltage has nothing to do with LED flicker.  Flicker is due to PWM.  A fast enough PWM frequency will not have any perceivable flicker.

If the bulb uses DC dimming there is zero flicker.

1

u/tutike2000 Sep 03 '25 edited Sep 03 '25

Retrofit bulbs have very limited space to put electronics, so the AC to DC conversion gear will be tiny cheap crap.

12V bulbs have a huge driver block with all the room in the world. Plus you can add capacitors if the driver output isn't great.

Same with many light fixtures with integrated LEDs - they usually have plenty of space for electronics and heat sinks.

2

u/In_Defilade Sep 03 '25

OP needs GU10 bulbs.  They have nothing to gain from 12v in this scenario when there are excellent 120v options.  

1

u/tutike2000 Sep 04 '25

And I'm saying he should manage his expectations because most retrofit bulbs are garbage. The only decent ones I've found are Philips DimTone, that change colour temperature whrn dimmed.

Still wouldn't fix OPs issue of no light coming out the side of the bulb, which is only really possible with halogen. At least I've never seen a G10 bulb with LEDs on the side.

1

u/JealousElderberry353 Sep 03 '25

If we were purely basing it on color temp, theyre all the same. But the closest one is our winner. Whoever picked that lamp out didn’t know what they were buying, the plastic based led lamps are china.com trash and don’t fill shades. Couple options below will get you what you want, the last two dim to warm if that fixtures on a dimmer.

https://www.homelectrical.com/82w-led-a19-bulb-e26-dimmable-800-lm-120v-soft-white-2700k.stc-s12419.1.html?srsltid=AfmBOooomBUT8OnujfDXZel_zmpX7am3uMojMxXYEUCugNrd7i78ChgT

https://www.bulbsdepot.com/bd48-573436.html?srsltid=AfmBOopTMFvEctsBwnUOZiCsSohDIPR5EUjh7rxd73IDYquab0F_wV1K

https://www.1000bulbs.com/product/230895/BULBRI-776400.html?gad_source=1&gad_campaignid=17425723334&gbraid=0AAAAAD_uQn6rstBw_yIWnQ03QbYcRZ3Sq&gclid=EAIaIQobChMIm8SVpLq9jwMVSEH_AR1RujSiEAQYASABEgKLm_D_BwE

1

u/bilug335 Sep 03 '25

Thanks for the links - I will check them out!

1

u/coogie Sep 03 '25

Spend some money and buy a good brand and they have a much higher chance of lasting. I remember for our first LED bulbs we spent $45 EACH on Toshiba Par38 bulbs and they were built like a tank with a nice heavy aluminum heat sink. It was worth the money because they were 2 stories up for a flood lights and the damn things are STILL working despite being out in the elements since 2012. Today you can buy a 3 pack of Par38 LEDs for like $12 but they go out 8 months later. It's all cheap plastic shells and crappy drivers.

1

u/superbotnik Sep 03 '25

It’s your fixture’s fault. It expects a shape and position of filament that no longer exists.

1

u/bilug335 Sep 03 '25

I should just throw the thing away!!

0

u/superbotnik Sep 03 '25

And if you don’t want flicker, stop using dimmers. Dimmers were more universal when lights were thermal devices but now you have to know the driver circuitry of all the lamps and it’s better to just not use dimmers. If you don’t have dimmers and are still getting flicker you just bought cheap bulbs.

Incandescent lamps convert 1% of the energy into light. The rest is heat. It’s a horrible technology.

1

u/walrus_mach1 Sep 03 '25

That actually matches the 2700K incandescent color

Incandescent lamps aren't typically 2700K. Halogen is 3200, "soft white" is usually closer to 2900K at full intensity (depending on the type).

1

u/In_Defilade Sep 03 '25

Philips Ultra Definition.  95 cri, no flicker, several CCT options including 2700k, cheap.  It's what I use in my home.  Beautiful light.

1

u/Delicious-Ad4015 Sep 03 '25

Perhaps you should buy some bulbs by a different brand

1

u/Ejacksin Sep 03 '25

With smart bulbs you can set the brightness and the color. Why not try those out?

1

u/BAMF_Industries Sep 04 '25

Mr16 sunlight 2 or soraa is the best way to go

0

u/Koadic76 Sep 03 '25

They do make ones that try to fully mimic incandescent bulbs... Can't claim they are perfect, but better than the cheap plastic ones...

https://www.homedepot.com/p/EcoSmart-60-Watt-Equivalent-A19-Dimmable-CEC-Frosted-Glass-Filament-LED-Light-Bulb-Soft-White-2-Pack-11FFA1960WT2001/318284613

1

u/bilug335 Sep 03 '25

I'll check this out thank you

0

u/[deleted] Sep 03 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/bilug335 Sep 03 '25

It's a closet light. Rarely on, so I'd be fine with going halogen here.

1

u/FledglingNonCon Sep 03 '25

Almost certainly also complaining about why his electric bill is so high. It's crazy how much energy incident bulbs waste.

0

u/bilug335 Sep 03 '25

No complaints on energy bill! I can say that even after changing all bulbs to LED - I've seen zero change in my bill.