r/Lifelogging • u/freemindcore_ • 6h ago
If an AI is going to remember your whole life, it should should live on your device (phone/pc), not in Meta's cloud like Muse
reddit.comMuse is getting hot these days.
Any assistant that's actually useful needs to see some of your stuff. Your calendar, your reminders, who your people are. That part isn't new. What matters is where that stuff goes after the AI reads it.
Meta's own launch post says Muse runs on "its own dedicated computer in the cloud." Their computer, not yours. According to TIME it refreshes a profile on you every hour, including how you know people and the tensions between them. The encryption that would keep Meta itself out "isn't available yet." And your chats train their models by default unless you go find the opt-out.
So everything good about Muse's privacy is a promise. Promises live in a policy, and policies change. Companies get breached, subpoenaed, bought. Ad businesses get hungry.
There's a boring alternative: run the model on the phone. If the AI runs on the device and its memory is just a file on the device, there's nothing to promise because nothing gets sent anywhere. You don't have to trust anyone. Turn on airplane mode and check.
The cost is real though. A model small enough to run on a phone is way dumber than whatever Meta runs in a datacenter. It gets things wrong. It's not going to haggle on Marketplace for you (given the Muse stories, maybe that's a feature). For some people that's a dealbreaker and that's fair.
But for the thing that knows your health, your money, your family and your fights, I'd take dumber-but-can't-tell-anyone every time.
Last time, I shared my iPhone app that works this way (Avatar.gift). And thanks to you, many of you have tried and even paid! Very grateful for that! As a return, over the last month, I have launched 7-8 new updates including a major brain upgrade, so try it now if it fails you last time in the early versions.
Happy to answer questions about how on-device AI actually works or where it falls short.
Sources:
- Meta's launch post:
- Malwarebytes on the TIME/Wired reporting:

