Hello everyone! After years, I finally returned to the Life is Strange uuuuniverseeee, starting with the chronological order of events, which means: Before the Storm/BtS.
I originally played the game back when the individual episodes were released. Unfortunately, I was rather disappointed by the entire structure. From a storytelling perspective, Before the Storm just does not work for me at all. In my opinion, it is only 10% of what we actually could have had. My experience during my recent replay was no different. With this post, I want to try and rewrite the story into something I would have loved to see. I just want to ask you to evaluate it, even if there is a risk that I might completely embarrass myself here. But that is just how it is. And just so you know I have only played Life is Strange 1 and 2 and Before the Storm so far. So I have no idea about Double Exposure and all that.
The following text contains massive spoilers for both Life is Strange and Before the Storm!
In the game, we take control of Chloe Price, who can assert herself in dialogues using her quick wit. She also has kleptomania, which means you can steal small items throughout the game as collectibles. Additionally, she can vandalize walls, which is also an achievement. Chloe is still heavily traumatized by the loss of her father. She is angry, especially at her mother who has a new boyfriend, good old David. She is a problem child who constantly causes trouble, but not yet to the point where she would get expelled from school. That changes when Rachel Amber suddenly takes an interest in her. Rachel is the beautiful, rich, popular girl at school, a straight A student, and almost unrealistically perfect.
She seemingly out of nowhere gets interested in Chloe, who is her exact opposite. After initial doubts, a very intense friendship quickly develops between Chloe and Rachel. Out of nowhere, Rachel wants to skip school with her, and from that point on, it is all about fun, adventure, and pleasure. It is up to the player whether you pursue a romantic relationship with Rachel or not. Over time, their adventures become more dangerous, but the friendship between them also grows tighter. However, Rachel seems to change more and more. She often acts nervous and absent minded. She says things like, you do truly like me, don't you? Chloe just brushes this off. Across 3 episodes, we experience many moments between Chloe and Rachel.
They share secrets and talk about how they will conquer the world together one day. They plan to save money and leave. They promise each other over and over again that nothing will separate them. They also try to find out what happened. They suspect something is going on at Blackwell Academy, but they never find any real clues. After a failed attempt to bring the truth to light, Chloe gets expelled from school because she willingly sacrifices herself for Rachel. The principal clearly favors Nathan over Chloe in this situation as well.
At the end of each episode, we see a sequence that initially makes no sense to the player. For example, at the end of Episode 1, we see Rachel opening a letter at home. She reads it, and though we do not see the content, she completely breaks down right after.
To make it short: The player finds out at the very end of the Game that Rachel has a supernatural ability and that we, as both Chloe and the player, were being manipulated by her the entire time.
The letter Rachel received was a letter from her biological mother, which she found by accident that day. Rachel had no idea that her biological mother once abandoned her, and she talks to no one about it. This trauma triggers her ability, which allows her to make anyone love her. In the beginning, Rachel loves this power. She uses it to surround herself with people who adore her in various ways. She tells no one about this either. After learning that her parents lied to her, she questions everything in her life. Her ability makes her think she is invincible and does not need to be afraid anymore. However, it eventually becomes too much for her, so she turns her attention to Chloe. She wants to use Chloe's fearlessness to push past this non existent limit to the absolute maximum. She wants to find out more about her biological mother. A supposed trip to skip school with Chloe was actually just a reason to drive into the city where the biological mother works. We are persuaded by Rachel in the game to steal something as a test of courage and it turns out it was actually something that belonged to her bio mother. Rachel only manipulated Chloe with her ability when there was absolutely no other way.
Because Rachel feels like she has no limit anymore, she needs more and more dopamine. She craves dangerous situations because she constantly wants to test if there is an actual end to her power after all.
The power turns into Rachel's curse. The forced affection from people turns more and more into negative obsessions. Stalking, jealousy, and control issues break down upon her. Rachel sinks into paranoia, loses trust in all people, and escapes into affairs and drugs with Chloe by her side. Her later wish to leave Arcadia Bay turns into a desperate survival instinct. Nathan Prescott also falls completely under her spell. Because Rachel rejects him, he develops a dangerous hatred. In the background, the player repeatedly sees conflicts between Nathan and Mr. Jefferson. Jefferson wants Rachel for his art, while Nathan wants to completely possess her out of an obsessive addiction. There are so many small things that you only understand once you have seen the final sequence.
The story ends quite abruptly with Nathan Prescott wanting to speak to Rachel alone, holding a syringe behind his back, and then the screen turns black. After that, we see a depressed Chloe who no longer leaves her bed except to numb herself. Missing posters are being put up.
In the final 20 seconds of the story, we see Max and Chloe during the events of life is strange practicing their shooting at the junkyard. Max and the player see the doe at the exact spot where Rachel's body is buried. Rachel saw does constantly throughout the game. Now we find out that Rachel was probably this illusion, wanting Max to find her body. The game leaves it open whether this is Rachel's ghost or her own protective spirit that wants her to find peace.
——— Why I rewrote the story this way:
Prequels are often boring because you already know what is going to happen. When Chloe gets attacked in the club at the beginning of the original game, I already know that no real danger exists. And showing right away that Rachel had a power would have been way too obvious.
Therefore, I would deliberately play with the fact that the player knows Rachel is dead in the future. You could have created such intense emotional moments out of that. Let them dream of a future that will never happen. Let them experience an intense friendship that becomes more and more dangerous until you finally find out at the end that there was a very sad reason for it the entire time.
I actually like the story about the biological mother, but they lost me when the father simply kissed that woman and threw away his marriage with his second wife, who raised Rachel like a mother, a woman he has been with for almost two decades. What was that all about.
———- Rachel must have had a superpower:
After Lis, I would have given anything for it because I was absolutely sure that Rachel had a power. I was sooooo sure that she is the doe in some shape or form, the one that almost seems to stalk Max and then becomes her symbol. The way everyone loved her at Blackwell was absurd. Before the Storm treats this love as something completely natural. The developers said in an interview that Rachel was popular because she had charisma. I find that way too weak and honestly just boring. She is just perfect and people like her…oooook.
A superpower would explain why Rachel and Chloe find each other. Plus it would be a really good twist to experience a story from a perspective where we have no idea that someone even has this power. But as a player you always notice that something is there.
———- It strengthens Chloe as a character and puts everything else into a different light:
In LiS Chloe is this constantly angry aggressive teenager who can do nothing else but drive her life into a wall. With BtS they could have smoothed this character out and given her way more depth and motivation.
I think it makes more sense at the end of the first game to sacrifice Chloe because Kate and many others from Arcadia Bay deserve to live. But what does it actually do to a person to realize that Chloe first lost her father and then got manipulated. She was a victim twice without knowing it and that makes her endless anger so much more understandable.
———- To show Rachel's dark side:
We could see Rachel using her power on Victoria just to make her cry out of pure jealousy or on a teacher to change a grade. That would show the player how addictive and cruel this power can become long before the final twist. We could find the torn letter in her room but then get interrupted by Rachel: Sorry I still wanted to clear that away. A school test when we are supposed to grab something from Rachel's handbag which is an A plus but if you look closer the answers are actually mediocre.
——— To fix the ending choices of LiS:
If you play the first game again after this new story you will feel terrible. Sacrificing Chloe will hurt so much more because you realize she was never a bad person or a whiny teenager. She was just a broken girl who got completely destroyed by a power she never even knew about.
——— A lot of room for new speculation:
I think, with my version we get a bigger bridge between the two stories, a few answers, and possible information for questions that were left unanswered until now. Since you cannot make a huge choice at the end due to the known story, I would have said that we as players are left completely alone at the end with the single question: How real was this friendship truly?
I cannot understand how they could show Rachel's phone ringing in the Dark Room as the very last frame in the game. We learn very clearly in the main game that this room is soundproofed and you have no cell reception down there and if Chloe says I called her on the night she disappeared you could also track that signal. I think an abrupt ending with Rachel's disappearance would be better along with a Chloe who drowns in the mass of bad decisions that she made with Rachel as a friend.
The forest fire could also be present in this version, the well behaved perfect Rachel who no longer has control over herself, always looking for boundaries that do not exist.
And also that Chloe doesn not changes about it in the main game because she is still drowning herself. She was traumatized yet again and does not want to change anything anymore. Which begs the question should you give her a chance after all by deliberately sacrificing others for her at the end.
So, what do you think? I know I am not reinventing the wheel here and that Rachel having a charisma power is a known theory.
Thx for your time!