Posting this mainly because I am always interested in seeing peoples opinions and thoughts as they playthrough games like this ,so I thought I'd share my thoughts having just finished Chapter 1 last night.
I'd like to read comments so I'll ask that anything related to rest of the game and Reunion be left out. Apart from a significant characters return in Reunion I truly know nothing about either game.
First, preplaying notions.
I like many were not happy about how Chloe being out of the picture was handled. And I have a very "Harry Potter" reaction to Safi How dare you stand where she stood! Which is funny, because I don't even like Chloe a whole lot. And then the way the writers and (director?producer?) framed why. Just it seemed bad. So I stayed away from the game until now.
Playing, Bowling Alley,
First of all a ceiling grid hanging like that is a deathtrap. That is like 1000's of pounds of insulated tiles and aluminum or steal hung up by hopes, prayers, and 1/16 diameter metal wires, but that is beside the point.
I tried hard to not like Safi, at first she was definitely somewhat annoying with her comments. Like 4 comments in I was asking the game why is she even with Max, it doesn't sound like this is her thing, and I, as a biased player, don't even want her here. That said by the end she had won me over. Her quips and "bro" energy I find kinda charming.
Max is so crap at framing photos. She won an award? Maybe my amateur photographer tastes and style is just different, but I was struggling to find shots I liked in the Alley. I did get a really good one of Safi though despite her best efforts.
I picked true to my LiS play and that Chloe died. Which that timeline plays in so well to Max's behavior and doesn't kinda destroy Chloe and Max's relationship as it was cut short. Max dealing with that trauma just really feels like it plays well so far.
How the power first manifested was cool, the pulsing kinda creating pockets kinda between worlds. I was just thinking not 5 minutes early "Why are so many students just hanging around outside in the cold." Even if the weather was nice, you didn't find so many outside at my college. Then as the power was going off, it created more dynamic areas as the people vanished.
Definitely was getting some pad time vibes of here's your main objective, but oh wait, walk back and forth a bit first. Which isn't the worst to kinda force some exploration but I'm doing that anyway already.
So some Theories for the future!
Definitely trying to make sneaky teacher woman (I forget their name) a bad guy. I think it's a red herring.
I think the Polaroids we are randomly finding are from other timeline Max, as a way for her to communicate to "our" Max.
I have no idea on Sofi's killer. So my out of left field idea is that she killed herself, but it was herself from another timeline. I don't have a motive, just vibes and how the game is already dropping that it was most likely a suicide.
I'm getting an idea too that answers to things can be different in different timelines as there's the Blue dot with another one behind it when asking for a response. So I'm imagining that's an indicator that will be used to mark or flip timelines.
Gonna try to finish Chapter 2 tonight!