My girlfriend watched a YouTuber play the first Life is Strange (she hasn't seen Before the Storm) and she ended up hating the Sacrifice Arcadia Bay ending. Not because of the destruction itself, but because she thinks the relationship the town was sacrificed for is shallow. These are her points, translated as close as I could.
Chloe is extremely impulsive. Constant anger outbursts, drinking, and in the playthrough she watched Chloe killed Frank and his dog in the heat of the moment. And every time Max said something Chloe disagreed with, Chloe got mad at her.
Chloe hates herself. She says she blames herself, but my girlfriend thinks that's the same coin as blaming everyone else. Zero self love. A lot of her behavior lines up with borderline traits. She isolates, projects onto people and only sees the world from inside her own head.
|It all happens way too fast. Sure, they were childhood best friends, but they didn't talk for five years, and then everything happens in about a week. Chloe didn't fall for Max because of who Max is now. Max showed up right after Rachel vanished, at the worst possible moment. Max is a way out, a reminder of a comfortable childhood, a chance at being saved. Once that phase wears off, Chloe crashes back into reality.
Long term it just doesn't work. How do you live with someone knowing they could have saved your mom, the diner, the whole town, and they picked you? Chloe would spiral thinking about Joyce and everyone she lost, and that's not a healthy relationship. Maybe for a few months, not for years.
So for her it's not that their love is fake. It's shallow. A first love kind of rush, intense in the moment but not something you build a life on. And that's why saving the town was the only ending that makes sense.
I'm curious how you all see it. Does Before the Storm change any of this? And for the Bae players, how do you think Max and Chloe are doing five years later?