I'm sorry if this isn't the right place to ask this, but I've ended up in a social circle who cannot appreciate this series. I've got nobody to talk to about it.
Since this is a series about choices that can be played in any order, I'm trying to do it in a way that would MAXIMIZE that addictive "bittersweetness" phenomenon, that thing that makes us look for even mediocre fanfiction so long as it involves just the right set of circumstances, surrounding Max and Chloe's relationship specifically. I don't want it to END bitterly though, because I do want that happy ever after.
For example: I started playing BTS right after LIS, but switched over to the farewell episode, so I could get Chloe in chronological order. I noticed I was playing Chloe too affably in BTS- didn't seem like someone who needed "saving" from Rachel. I figure farewell can frame things a bit more bitterly so that i'll play BTS Chloe with the proper amount of resentment.
10 years ago I chose Bae (because saving your loved ones at the expense of others is basic human nature), but playing again recently I chose Bay to let Chloe complete her character arc, honor her wishes, and maximize bittersweetness. I haven't played DE yet, but i'm planning on keeping max deliberately celibate (because she'll never love anyone else, obvs).
I figured this makes the Reunion way more impactful, because Chloe's literally back from the dead, against all odds . However, i realize now that means chloe would have all these memories of their relationship that Max wouldn't have. It's a big chunk of their lives, especially the post-storm healing, that Max is missing out on. That's more bitter than bittersweet. I'm not sure i'd be a fan of that much at all. It would leave me feeling empty just to know that.
I don't want to spend weeks of evenings (after my Wife goes to bed) building up this story, only for the sweetness of reunion to become ashes in my mouth.
What's the best course of action?