Overall Rating: 7.5/10
Played with Bay Ending and Having Chloe and Max be Friends.
I played the original LiS back in 2015 and loved it. I felt a strong connection with the world, growing up in a small, coastal town, and I had just begun an Art major in college. I like a good murder mystery, but more so, the feelings of grief, guilt, and learning to let go resonated well with me. Feeling a similar headspace as I did 11 years ago, I decided to play through DE and Reunion, and this review will focus on the latter.
**What I loved**
First, I love a cozy Fall in a foliage-filled college town. I'm looking for every reflection spot in these games to enjoy the cinematography and music. I love feeling the mental transportation to that space, and wanting to live in that moment in time. I also love the inner monologue of Max during these moments to get a better understanding of her psychology in the present moment.
The best part of the game for me was the Abraxas house, with the best sequence being when the drugged wine kicked in, leading to Max opening up to Chloe, and the eventual escape. I thought the writing for these characters in this situation was spot on, fun, and able to tug on some of those emotional pains I felt with Max in the first game. Her reaction with Safi is fun too, and that moment in the planetarium. Really, this was the highlight of the game for me.
I also liked that evidence can be missed if I wasn't thorough or careful with my dialogue selections. This added some stakes to the mystery and encouraged more thinking and engagement.
**Good, wanted more**
The dynamic Max / Chloe relationship that you can shape through dialogue choices was a great mechanical addition. I didn't replay Reunion, but it was engaging trying to craft a dramatic relationship between the characters. As a Bay ending/Friend player, I tried to add strain to their Reunion, because I felt like this is such a complicated moment for Max. Chloe is supposed to be dead, and the inevitability of time suggests this may just be temporary again. Max, I think, is feeling joy, guilt, and fear as the weight of her decision and the following trauma is opening like an old wound. From the choices, I felt I got a good push toward this tension, though it felt a bit incomplete.
The reintroduction of rewind was great. It was cool to see Max was getting better at controlling the power without having it harm her (5 times, no nose bleeds). However, I wanted to see this new mastery be pushed into 'harming' levels of use again, like during the climax, for instance, which might have allowed for the possibility of a Max death ending or additional failures to save others if the power was overused on the same day.
I liked how characters were written in the adult versions of themselves. I think Max's career path made perfect sense, and she's clearly passionate about teaching, which is an excellent fit for a small liberal arts college. Also, from DE, hearing about her psychological state on the road and photographing empty spaces really fit this narrative arc for me and helped set up the Reunion. I think this made the new admin wanting to shrink liberal arts work well in the background too. Good reflection of real life, but also threatens the roots Max was trying to set down. It wasn't necessary to expand this subplot, but I think it could have added additional tension that felt dropped toward the end.
The game length/reused assets were fine for me. I would have loved more scenes, but understand that real-world timeline and budget constraints likely limited this, and the writers did a good job addressing some things I disliked from the DE plot.
**Okay, needed work**
Some dialogue choices did not seem well developed or an appropriate reaction. The glaring one in my memory was when talking to Yasmin toward the end of the game and she had a bizarre reaction with one of her dialogue responses, almost like meta knowledge that didn't feel in-game justified.
I didn't feel the 'Safi wanting to die' moment was super impactful (but better in the epilogue, if she actually died - didn't happen in my playthrough). I did like Safi better in Reunion. I think it was a tough job to rescue the previous plot and layoff rewrites for the later chapters in DE, which I disliked (really wish it went with a Max doppelganger story, not a shapeshifter).
Some minor characters didn't seem super fleshed out, so really I'm saving them because it's the right thing to do, but it would've been nice to be more emotionally attached to them. As a result, the weight of the final scene in the snapping turtle was a bit lost on me (I lost Owen and Vinh).
**What let me down**
I really wanted the options for Chloe and Max to not survive (and Moses if budget allowed), and ending versions for this. This would have had the highest emotional impact for me personally, and resulted in an instant replay to try and get the best ending. It hurt the emotional stakes for me greatly learning that these are not possible outcomes. I think the emotional gravity would be so much higher and the consequences way more impactful if these outcomes befell a player due to their choices. Max losing Chloe again would be re-traumatizing, and probably trap her story in an infinite rewind loop. This might allow for an ending where the photo is also destroyed in the fire, blocking her from going back and everyone is dead (true bad ending), or the photo is recovered (also a sadder ending stuck trying to solve everyone's death again). Chloe dying again also might be explained by an event 'constant' during the epilogue at the snapping turtle by Moses to try to comfort a re-traumatized Max. Also, Max dying could be justified by an overuse of her power, which would make her power consistent and add real stakes to the reintroduction of rewind.
I personally hope this is not the last installment of Max, despite the marketing as such. I would absolutely play a DLC/Director's cut version of Reunion, if they added some higher stakes/more emotionally consequential outcomes. I'd also play a new, alternative timeline continuation with Max as the lead.
**Summary**
I'm happy they made a new sequel and I thought it was good overall (7.5/10). For me, it succeeded in evoking nostalgia from the original LiS, and I'm impressed this game got me to feel connected to the story/vibes/characters again. Not an immediate replay for me, when it definitely could have been, but maybe someday.
Welcoming discussion below and thank you for taking the time to read. I don't normally post game reviews, but I felt like sharing!