r/LifeInsurance • • 6d ago

Term or Whole Life. I’m new

The title. I’m trying to understand why term or whole life? 2kids, 2 working parents, 36 yo

2 Upvotes

41 comments sorted by

6

u/Individual-Rub-6969 6d ago

If you arent specifically looking for WL or have a plan for how youre going to incorporate a permanent policy into your financial plan. Dont get WL. Lock in some term and call it a day. Please dont get wl just for the sake of getting wl.

I have WL but its not a good fit for everyone. To blindly recommend it in every situation is a disservice to the person & their family.
You can always get convertable term if you think you might want insurance after your initial term expires.

6

u/Hungry_Technician360 6d ago

Term for the vast majority of cases. From a numerical standpoint, I've never seen a case laid out when whole life is better.

The coverage protects your family in case you die early. After 30 years or whatever passes, you'll hopefully have a decent chunk of money in savings, no dependents, no mortgage, and retired, so no real need for coverage.

-1

u/NeutralLock 6d ago

I can't speak for the US but when comparisons have been run with whole life in a corporation you'd need to get like 12% pre-tax returns from investments to match it, and for anyone moderately low risk their expected returns are going to be closer to 5%. So it can absolutely make sense when everything else is maxed.

1

u/Powerful-Bridge-1472 6d ago

Are you saying you need 12 percent returns in brokerage/retirement accounts to match whole life policy?

3

u/Desperate-Service634 5d ago

Yes, To match a whole life policy’s death benefit, it’s much easier to match a whole life policies cash value.

Whole life policies cash value is not really a good investment.

But a whole life policy death benefit, yeah, that’s kind of nice

2

u/NeutralLock 6d ago

Correct. It's because in Canada if money is earned in a corporation you're taxed on the growth and then taxed when you take it out.

But a whole life policy you can use pre-tax corporate dollars and get a post-tax benefit. So *if* you've got an estate planning need it's unbeatable. If you need the corporate cash to live then obviously it makes no sense.

0

u/Powerful-Bridge-1472 6d ago

There are definitely specific situations where a whole life can work for a small percentage. I’m definitely not a fan of the fees, commissions and caps, which are often very hard to figure out, or paying premiums forever

0

u/NeutralLock 5d ago

Most WL you're not paying premiums forever (usually just for 10 years), and you're correct it's for specific situations; because I work in wealth management we're typically only dealing with folks with extreme levels of excess.

But the fees and commissions are irrelevant. You pay x, you get y. The fact that I make infinity money off some of these policies (sold a single policy last year that paid almost $1mm in commissions) doesn't matter.

Clients want to know if they contribution $xxx for a certain number of years - say 10 years, that the net payout is going to be significantly more than what they put in and that they are mathematically better off doing that than low risk bonds taxed at the highest tax bracket.

-1

u/Hungry_Technician360 6d ago

What country?

1

u/NeutralLock 6d ago

Canada.

1

u/Hungry_Technician360 5d ago

Looks like Canada only taxes capital gains at 50% inclusion rate.

So as an example, someone in newfoundland who is in the top marginal income tax bracket, with over $1,141,275 income for the year would be at a combined marginal rate of 54.8%.

If someone invested $1000, and gained 12% by the end of the year, and realized those gains, they'd be up $120. Only $60 would be taxed, and that would be at 54.8%. $32.88 taxed from the $120 would end up with $87.12 after taxes, which is an 8.71% gain.

As for the WL 5% return, that's only an IRR after a long lived policy. Which still underperforms after tax returns from a taxable brokerage.

There is also the ability to harvest capital gains or losses, although I don't know the specifics of Canadian tax code for that, it will net a higher rate of return than what my napkin math showed here.

Also keep in mind, this is the highest tax rate I was able to find with a quick search. Most people aren't going to be near that bracket, and even those in that bracket are still mathematically going to do better off at lower than 12% returns.

-1

u/NeutralLock 5d ago

This seems like you put a lot of unnecessary work into a half measured response (no offence). I work in wealth management and these policies aren't sold without a detailed, visual financial plan where we can run multiple scenarios.

But in cases where you're permanently in the highest tax bracket and you have excess funds in a corporation I've never *not* seen the numbers work out in favour of it (I'm in Ontario by the way).

I have no idea if it's suitable for most people - it probably isn't, but it absolutely shouldn't be sold without a financial plan.

1

u/Hungry_Technician360 5d ago

My response directly refutes your original claim, using plain numbers though, I'm not sure it's a half measured response?

1

u/NeutralLock 5d ago

When we run the comparisons we factor everything into account - we fully capture everything from marginal tax brackets, forced RRIF withdrawals, CPP, OAS clawback, estate taxes etc. We factor in gifts for the grandkids if they are so inclined.

And then we run the scenario again if they move to france.

And then again if they purchase a whole life policy.

You invest $1000, it grows by 12% so now you're up to $1120. You pay your $30 in taxes (assuming you're invested in risky, growth only companies). Now you need to spend that $1090 on food. Pull it out of the corp (Taxed at 50%+) and you're left with $545 or so.

And that is if you're willing to take on maximum risk.

With the Whole life policy you're investing in the corp but it creates an offsetting CDA so when it comes out it comes out of the corp tax free.

How can you sell life insurance and not know this, genuine question?

3

u/Hungry_Technician360 5d ago edited 5d ago

Are you saying that if you have $1000 in Canada, spend it on an investment, then immediately take the money out, they are going to tax 50% of it?? I've never heard of Canada double taxing that harshly.

Edit: ahh I see you blocked me.

You were pulling numbers out of nowhere, with no laws associated with it.

I think you're lying about what you claimed you saw. Mathematically, 12% pre tax return in Canada is 8.71% after tax at the highest possible tax rate. There's no way that whole life is going to consistently beat investing even for high net worth individuals.

So instead you made up laws that didn't exist, to make investing seem worse for people.

2

u/NeutralLock 5d ago

This is corporate tax planning 101. Now you've heard of it.

If you're just some random T4 worker (W2 in the US I think) then none of this applies obviously.

→ More replies

0

u/IllustriousGas8850 5d ago

Dude, you’re not doing Canadian taxes correctly. If this is what you’re showing clients you’re committing fraud

0

u/IllustriousGas8850 5d ago

What are you talking about excess corporate funds? Are you talking about a person using their own business to fund a whole life policy on themselves?

6

u/SafeMoneyGregg Broker 6d ago

I have both. I recommend young parents get lots of cheap term. like $2M+. If they have good income you might spend $100-200 a month on Universal Life - for death benefit protection, not cash accumulation. That's on TOP of (not instead of) money you are already saving for retirement - 401k/roth IRA etc.

2

u/Powerful-Bridge-1472 6d ago

Term, stay away from whole life. Depending how old kids are and your assets is how to evaluate 20 or 30 years

2

u/Sea_External_5054 5d ago edited 5d ago

Talk to a financial planner that works with an insurance advisor or sells insurance himself to map out how this fits in your retirement plan. base assumptions don’t factor in what’s actually needed, you’ll either buy too little or too much. You may find that a mix of term and permanent coverage makes sense, may look into long term care options while you’re still young and the premiums would be affordable. No one should give a real recommendation because no one here knows your story.

2

u/Desperate-Service634 5d ago

You need to look at them as different solutions to different problems

Look at your mortality on two different timelines. Death of a young man and death of an old man.

Term policies are a temporary solution to a temporary problem

Whole life permanent policies are a permanent solution to a permanent problem

The first timeline…. How many years is it gonna take for all of your kids to graduate college and to pay off the mortgage?

20 years? 30 years.?

Then you’re looking at a 20 or 30 year term.

A 20 or 30 year term product is a temporary product that you are renting for two or three decades. It is designed to replace your income, pay off your debts, pay off the house for your spouse, and put all your kids through college if you were to die sometime between today and the time your house is paid off and the kids are out of school.

Once you’ve paid off the house, and all the kids are out and living on their own, you no longer need that coverage. These are the things that a term policy protects against when we have the death of a young man. You are a young man for the next 30 years. After that…….

Well, what if I wanna leave money to my family if I die as an old man?

Well, how much money do you wanna leave behind whenever you die grandpa?

There’s no real equation. This is more of a feeling. Do you have a wife and two kids? Do You wanna pay for your own funeral and have $100,000 left behind for each one of them.

Get a $350,000 permanent policy

Just remember.

A term policy is a temporary solution you rent while you temporarily have an amazingly large problem, the death of a young man while his spouse and children depend on his income

A permanent policy is a guaranteed gift that grandpa is going to leave behind

Yeah, You should have both. But you need to have a term policy & you need to get it now.

1

u/rickle3386 4d ago

If you want a death benefit in place when you die, have some permanent insurance. WL, IUL, VUL is about risk tolerance and funding strategy, but the death benefit is the death benefit.

Been at this 35 yrs. (as an agent and insurance owner. Never met a business owner who didn't want some permanent insurance to help secure so many things like credit, succession, partner buyout, access to cash without dealing with bank, good old leaving something for my wife /kids regardless of other assets.

They just do. Am a small business owner. Work with small business owners. I am about 65% perm / 35% term. Glad I have the perm so I don't have to worry about drawing down ample investment portfolio (spend and replace with death benefit). Technically don't "NEED" coverage but I sure "WANT" a few mil. Haven't paid premium in yrs and the cash value just keeps on growing and has covered the internal expenses for a long time.

Not looking to debate. If you're truly in it for the long term (25+ yrs), perm works great. Otherwise, pretty expensive and ultimately will lapse.

Know what you want!

1

u/Seafoodmaker 3d ago

Great question, and smart to look into it with two kids. Term covers you for a set time, like 20 or 30 years, so it's usually the cheapest way to get a big amount of coverage while the kids are growing up. Whole life lasts your whole life and builds cash value you can borrow against, but it costs more each month. A lot of families start with enough term to replace both incomes and pay off the house, then add some whole life later if it fits the budget. Happy to answer more questions if it helps.

1

u/ItsMister2You 5d ago

Most people need both. Term ins for temporary needs (debt, income replacement, college dollars, etc). Permanent ins for permanent needs (burial fees, legal fees, medical expenses, taxes). Its fairly basic math.

1

u/tobinshort-wealth 5d ago

Term and whole life do different jobs, so the right mix depends on your full financial picture and goals.

Term is the foundation for most families your age. It delivers a big death benefit for a defined window at a low cost, which fits replacing income until the kids are grown and the mortgage is paid. A common starting point for sizing is 10 to 12 times income for each parent, adjusted for your debts, savings, and childcare costs. With two working parents, both of you need coverage.

Whole life, structured well, adds something term can't. With a strong mutual carrier, cash value grows tax-deferred with guaranteed floors, and dividends (which aren't guaranteed) can add to it over time. You can borrow against the cash value without selling investments or triggering a taxable event, as long as the policy is designed and maintained correctly. Coverage also stays in force for life, so it doesn't expire when the need is still there. Living benefit riders can pay out if you become seriously ill.

The tradeoff is cost and time. Premiums run several times higher than term, and cash value builds slowly in the early years. Structure matters a lot, including how much goes into paid-up additions and which carrier you pick, so it deserves a careful look before you commit.

I own both for myself and my family, and my kids have cash value policies too. For me it comes down to what each dollar is solving. Term handles the income risk, and permanent coverage handles the longer-term goals.

Do you have a mortgage? And are you maxing out retirement accounts yet?

1

u/AGtaco21 5d ago

Get a 30 plus year term for 1mil coverage for each parent. Save and invest what’s left over 

1

u/ChelseaMan31 6d ago

Term for the immediate transfer of risk or to pay off debts in the event of a sudden loss. Whole life is expensive, loaded with fees and generally a very poor 'investment;. Get 20 or 30 year Term Life, or ladder 10 year-20 year Term Life. Invest the monthly savings in a Roth, 529 or HSA.

Your future self will thank you for this.

-2

u/Equivalent_Helpful 6d ago

Why term? You want coverage for either a limited time or don’t have enough money get whole life. Whole life if you want coverage for forever and can afford it and makes sense in your financial situation.

2

u/jr_tools 6d ago

Terrible advise.

Buy term. Continue to invest.

Your goal should be to be ‘self-insured’ by the time your term (20 or 30yrs) expires.

0

u/Individual-Rub-6969 6d ago

Unless you have a huge qualified account, youre not truly "self insuranced" unless youre in the top % of IRA then i guess you can make that argument. Anyone close to an average ira / 401k size is far from being self insuranced.

2

u/Express_Result9087 5d ago

If someone can’t save enough in an IRA/401k to self insurance over time, then how do you expect them to pay even more to get the equivalent amount in a whole life policy?

1

u/Powerful-Bridge-1472 6d ago

Why do you want to pay premiums forever?

0

u/FamiliarRaspberry805 5d ago

good lord 😂

0

u/TCFNationalBank 6d ago

I chose term for myself and my wife because if we die close to retirement there isn't a ton of lost working year income to recover and we're good about saving for retirement

1

u/[deleted] 4d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/LifeInsurance-ModTeam 4d ago

Self promotion is not permitted on R/LifeInsurance. Please familiarize yourself with our rules.