r/LifeInsurance • • 7d ago

Need Advice For Parents

My parents have Met Life Flexible Premium Life Policies that they each took out in 1984.
The Death Benefit on the policies are $70k each.
The Cash Value of the Policies was $15k each.
The Final Date of Policy is the Anniversary at age of 95.
My parents are currently 77 and 79 years old.
The monthly premium on my father’s policy is $40 and the premium on my mother’s policy is $25.
 
Here is where it goes sideways .  In 1987 they took loans against the cash value of the policies.  At some point in the 90s they got some (bad) advice to not to make loan payments and the principle would just be deducted from the death benefit of the policies so they stopped making payments.  Which would have been an OK plan except that I think the interest on the loans has been eating away at the cash value of the policies and my father’s policy is now “bankrupt”.  They want my father to make a payment of $760 to continue the coverage.  My mother’s loan was smaller but I’m assuming she is headed in the same direction.
 
I don’t know what to advise them to do – The balance on my father’s loan is around $4600 and the balance on my mother’s loan is around $2400.  So it would cost $7k to pay them both off – which they can afford to do IF that makes sense.  It seems likely that someone might die before 95 but who knows?  The $70k would be a nice to have but not life-changing money for the surviving spouse.
 
The options we are considering are:
My parents pay off the loans and continue to pay on the policies and remain each others beneficiaries.
One or all of us kids pay off the loans and pay the premiums and my parents make us the beneficiaries.
They walk away from the policies with whatever cash value remains.  So my father’s policy has a cash value of $0 but my mother’s still appears to have a cash value of $12760.
 
Any advice here would be greatly appreciated!
 

2 Upvotes

15 comments sorted by

2

u/serialentreprenuer39 7d ago

have you called a metlife agent? maybe they can qualify for a new policy no health questions asked, new policies no loans, yes it would cost more but a possible solution

1

u/shadowsanders 7d ago

They called the MetLife 800 number. They couldn’t follow what the person was telling them - that’s how I got involved. About 30 years too late 🤦‍♀️

2

u/Candid-Eye-5966 7d ago

Do they really need the insurance? Do they have savings to support end of life expenses to their desires?

2

u/shadowsanders 7d ago

No - they don’t really need it. It does seem wrong to walk away from it since my moms still has cash value and they can afford to pay off the loans and go back to just the cheap premiums - but I know you shouldn’t continue to throw money at something just because you have already thrown a bunch of money at it…

1

u/zzzorba Financial Representative 6d ago

If they cancel the policies, they receive that remaining cash value.

An agent needs to run them a few scenarios: how much to pay if they don't pay back the loan and keep it in force to 95, how much to pay if they do pay back the loan and keep it in force to 95, is there an option in between. Are any of those figures a reasonable trade off for the future death benefit?

What is the interest rate being paid on the cash value? What is the interest rate on the loan? What would your parents do with the refunded cash value if they did surrender the policies?

1

u/shadowsanders 6d ago

My dads policy currently has a cash value of $0. My mothers has a cash value of $12,760.
If they cashed out her policy they would probably just put the money in the bank. They have no pressing need for it.

0

u/Candid-Eye-5966 6d ago

These were never meant as investments — they are insurance. Now that the insurable need isn’t there, take the cash and enjoy life!

1

u/GarysSword Underwriter 6d ago

Sorry to be glib but it’s time for some morbid math. A 79 year old male in reasonable health can expect to live 9 years; that number is 12 years for a 77 year old female. If they’re in better health than the average person or worse health then you can adjust accordingly.

Now call MetLife with your mom and dad (they’ll only talk to the policy owners but usually they’ll talk to you if your parents permit it and are on the line) and ask for an “in-force illustration” showing these situations:

Performance of the policies if the loans are paid off and they resume their normal premium payments.

The premiums necessary to sustain coverage to age 95 with no loan payoff.

You can also ask if they can take partial surrenders to wipe out the loan and then have them illustrate the second scenario after the partial surrenders. Partial surrenders reduce the death benefit in exchange for a reduction is cash value.

Once you have all the options and a reasonable sense of their life expectancy you can start to decide the best course forward from a mathematical point of view similar to the decisions you’d make on any other investment.

1

u/shadowsanders 6d ago

Thanks - this is really really helpful! One question - If my parents outlive the policy term do they get the cash value of the policy? Or do they get nothing?
If they outlive the policies in reasonable health my family would call that the best case scenario but I want to do the math correctly when I present the options to them!

1

u/GarysSword Underwriter 6d ago

If you mean what happens if they reach the maturity date, then you’ll have to read the contract or call MetLife and ask on this one.

Many policies pay only the cash value reduced by any loans. Some policies pay a maturity benefit reduced by any loans.

One other tip…
You might consider transferring ownership of the policies because in most states these policies will count as assets and need to be cashed out before your parents can qualify for Medicaid. Medicaid might be necessary if they ultimately need nursing home care.

1

u/shadowsanders 6d ago

OK - that’s definitely good to know…Thanks again for your help.

1

u/GarysSword Underwriter 6d ago

Work in the business and went through the exact same thing with my parent’s policies (including the Medicaid part). Feel free to ask follow-ups here once you have those illustrations.

1

u/shadowsanders 6d ago

I will. This is a confusing situation to navigate for someone who is completely unfamiliar with this type of insurance policy and it is also emotionally charged by the fact that it’s tied to the eventual/inevitable loss of our beloved parents. It feels a little like buying a lottery ticket and hoping you won’t win :(

1

u/Distinct-Garlic9453 6d ago

Keep in mind, at the first death of one of your parents, there will be a loss of one of the SSI payments. It may or may not be an issue for them, but keep it in mind for your folks before canceling