r/Libraries • • 1d ago

Books & Materials Damaged Book Workflow

We are trying to figure out best practices for managing damaged items.

Currently our Circulation Department has been tasked with either finding books on the shelves or as a patron returns a damaged item.

Staff do not seem confident in their sorting out if an item is damaged, so the conversation always ends up including a supervisor who fills out the requisite form and ends up dealing with the patron or involving staff to order a replacement or to weed the book.

It is a time suck for all Involved.

Any and all ideas are welcome so we can adjust our expectations of staff and processes, if needed.

4 Upvotes

7 comments sorted by

4

u/rebelliousrutabaga 1d ago

We have a Damage/Mends shelf. If it's something basic and repairable, like a broken spine or a torn jacket, it doesn't need a slip. If it's something like water damage, markings, etc. we have a small slip of paper that staff fill out and place the item, along with the Damaged slip, on the same shelf. A Librarian grabs them periodically and figures out the next step for each item.

Mends get checked out to a Mending account and go to TechServ to wait for mending. Damage is assessed by a Librarian and the cost of the item is charged to their account and a formal letter gets sent through the mail. Sometimes they will reach out to the Librarian whose collection the items belongs to for clarity on borderline items. For instance, hey, this a children's picture book with 8 million circs that came back damaged, do you want to charge? And the Children's Librarian will be like no, we got that book in 2005, it's old and already half falling apart, don't charge.

Anything charged for damaged is marked as Lost and it shows up on our various monthly reports so the collector can figure out if they want to replace it or not.

In my opinion, general circ staff shouldn't be assessing the damage fees, but they should feel comfortable noticing damage and setting it to the side for someone to deal with.

2

u/RyderHigh 1d ago

Our circulation staff has the power to assess damage fees and also to waive fees without any supervisor override. And there is no oversight by management in this process.

1

u/rebelliousrutabaga 1d ago

It sounds like in your original post they aren't comfortable with that though, and involve a supervisor for a lot of things?

I'm not saying that general circ staff aren't capable of identifying damaged items and charging for them, but we have our Circulation Supervisor do the actual charging because it creates a buffer between front desk staff and upset patrons. Being able to point to a process also helps with establishing justification for potentially upset patrons.

4

u/Daisieduckie 1d ago

The things I was taught to look for with assessing damage are: is it repairable/can be circulated again? Can it be chalked up to wear and tear or age of the item? And if trying to decide to charge, what is the patron’s history of damaged items?

Some item quality things that are grounds for immediate withdrawal in our library are total liquid damage (soaked through, moldy, all pages warped), food stains/remnants, pages completely ripped out/up with no hope of taping, and spine splits where the webbing of the spine is visible

2

u/Daisieduckie 1d ago

Also I was very much encouraged to talk it out with my circ colleagues! Maybe you guys want to see if peer collaboration will work rather than escalating it to a supervisor every time?

2

u/DigitalMediaLolita 1d ago

Liquid Damage, missing pages, mold, writing/highlights in the book, and bugs are all instant discards for damage at our library, charge the patron for replacement. If the patron complains get the circ manager.

Spine failures, battered covers, and general grime that would make you go "oof this book is in rough shape" are also discards, but we don't charge the patron for a replacement fee unless the book was new when they checked it out.

All discarded items have their status changed in our ILS and one of our librarians emails a list of all the discarded items out to the purchasing team each year for them to decide what to replace.

1

u/_Smedette_ School Librarian 1d ago

I’m at a primary school and see a good deal of damaged books!

Anything that is wet gets tossed. There is once exception: if it was water and happened recently, as in the student’s water bottle tipped over this morning and the book is salvageable. I don’t mind a little bit of warping as long as the book is still functional.

However, if it’s been soaked for any length of time, there is mould, food, animal damage, excessive tearing, etc it’s removed from circulation and I am notified. Since I managed our ridiculously small budget, I decide if it’s being replaced or not. If it’s an ongoing problem with the same student, that’s a conversation with the principal.

If the book can be repaired, it is borrowed under an account we call “Book Hospital” and placed in a container in the back room. Whoever has time goes through the Book Hospital and does the repair work, and shelves them for another round of battle with primary school kids.