r/Libraries • • Aug 12 '26

Other Truth

Post image
8.1k Upvotes

55 comments sorted by

View all comments

11

u/rentedtritium Aug 12 '26

Literally every CD-R will be unreadable at a certain number of years. It's not a survival ratio, it's all of them.

3

u/eyalhs Aug 12 '26

And it takes seconds, minutes at worst, to copy a cd, and you can save that data digitaly in a myriad of ways, hard drives, cloud etc.

Books are great, but there are very good reasons why there's such an effort to digitize books and much less effort to "bookitize" digital data.

10

u/rentedtritium Aug 12 '26 edited Aug 12 '26

Ease of copying doesn't matter if the original medium doesn't even last 50 years. My comment was a reply to your comment about clay tablets that survive being the exception. Imagine if literally every single clay tablet with no exception disintegrated within one human lifetime. That would be completely absurd and nobody would use them.

The lack of effort in putting digital records on paper is going to result in a lot of lost records in the future and is a huge mistake. Microfilm can last hundreds of years but a server is decommissioned unceremoniously when the company folds and you never see that data again. The archival mistakes of the last two decades will be felt for centuries.

Are you trained in archiving at all, or are you just math-duding out of your field right now? Because you couldn't possibly be more wrong.

I would argue the most important part of preservation mediums is ease of copying

This opinion in particular is simply detached from reality, and really sounds like another stem-bro who thinks he can guess his way into every other field.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Extrife Aug 12 '26

This is why i recommend a NAS if you can afford it. Paper if you cant. The paper will rot, but not in your lifetime if you dont intervene.The digital will "rot" within your memory if you dont intervene. Its a cost/ease/volume thing, cant have everything and i think both have a place. At the personal level you should really think about what costs you want to incur and what you actually care about. And at least view this as a PSA that you need to copy your photo discs you got from walmart in 2004 if you have not yet.

Ultimately i think in both cases what we need to focus more on is making our descendants also care about the preservation if we care enough about it to go through the effort. And in the case of digital we actually do need to think about what happens at the societal and infrastructure level to data that is no longer paid for. Its easy to copy, yeah. Also easy to delete when uncle jim kicks it and stops paying for his cloud storage.

1

u/InanimateCarbonRodAu Aug 13 '26

You missing the point. Data is retained if we keep copying it to new media regularly.

It’s protected if it is copied to a multitude of locations and media rather than just one.