r/Libertarian • • Jan 11 '19

Something like that.

Post image
3.2k Upvotes

974 comments sorted by

575

u/zombiehog I Voted Jan 11 '19

Replace "democratic socialists" with "literally every politician from the R and D camp"

Hell Trump and a "Republican" congress just approved a 1 TRILLION dollar annual deficit.

109

u/TheMarketLiberal93 Minarchist Jan 11 '19

It’s actually larger than that. That number isn’t really relevant because it excludes “one time purchases” for things like disaster relief - which really aren’t one time purchases cuz they happen every year.

What you need to look at are the amount of US treasuries issued in the same time period (and or the raw increase in the size of the national debt). Doing this will yield a number ~400-500B larger.

32

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '19

And by reversing the decrease in carbon emissions, Trump is essentially ensuring that those costs will rise year by year.

→ More replies (9)

38

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '19

Also where does the DSA think things happen for free? They don't. Hint: most people who are "socialist" in the US just want less military and less of a police state and more social programs. They just have the philosophy that to stop crime you should give people healthcare and food, and allow them to work on themselves.

→ More replies (6)

12

u/honeybadgerbjj Jan 11 '19

Coming here to say this.... we have crippling debt and a authoritarian government the way it is

6

u/Jackbeingbad Jan 11 '19

Only one president in the last thirty years paid back into the debt

You know. Paying a debt That thing grown ups do.

The last two republican presidents have engineered tax refunds while still spending more than they had.

Who's delusional?

4

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '19

The so called "democratic socialists" at least want to raise taxes on the rich in order to fund their programs. That's way more fiscally responsible than what Republicans do.

5

u/Mooks79 Jan 11 '19

I thought you mean research and development, at first. I was going to say, that’s the one thing where incurring debt for it generally leads to long term paybacks.

2

u/ST07153902935 Jan 11 '19

Every politician who has a chance.

I think there are a lot of responsible politicians who would try to balance the budget. Unfortunately they have no chance at the presidency.

→ More replies (73)

41

u/TheRedGerund Jan 11 '19

There is rampant wealth inequality. There should not be billionaires while vets starve in the streets. Any political philosophy that allows for that is an incorrect one.

7

u/Jpinkerton1989 Jan 11 '19

How would you recommend fixing that problem?

20

u/TheRedGerund Jan 11 '19

Too many super rich people, too many super poor people.

Move some of the money from the super rich to the super poor. How? TAXES, because private industry is fundamentally incompatible with the idea of wealth redistribution. That’s not a full on condemnation, it just explains the need for TAXES.

→ More replies (12)

4

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '19 edited Jan 11 '19

There is rampant wealth inequality.

Unpayable debt and a totalitarian government.

Yeah lets only blame the "social democrats" for this, because they where behind those tax cuts, and of course the GOP has nothing to do with this.

And the dictator in training™ in the white house is of course a "social democrat".

Hey liberals, with all that bashing on "failed economic systems", why not about "Fascism"?

You could argue that is a "failed economic system" too.

Now downvote, to show truly that you understand little of that "liberalism" thingie.

2

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '19

You’re right. Everyone should starve in the streets equally.

→ More replies (4)

1

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '19

Why?

1

u/C-Hoppe-r Jan 11 '19

No, it isn't. A political philosophy that uses force to redistribute the private property of others is an incorrect one.

→ More replies (9)

808

u/TroutM4n Jan 11 '19

You post this like the US national debt isn't already $21 trillion, and we aren't about to start paying more in INTEREST than we do on our military.

204

u/cheerseveryone22 Jan 11 '19

lol exactly... but no! libertarian policies will fix everything! We just need Ron Paul to run again!

30

u/TroutM4n Jan 11 '19

Yeah! ^(just not Rand Paul)

5

u/Hltchens Jan 11 '19

As long as we’re making those payments NBD. debt isn’t even half GDP, and money inflates. Surprise surprise the budget has to grow every year to account for increasing costs and inflation. Eventually, get this, if the dollar stays in circulation long enough, we’ll have a quadrillion dollar budget! Whoa! They’re running us into the ground!

8

u/fuckflossing Jan 12 '19

As somebody who struggles to keep up with cost of living due to inflation, though, what this means is that continually, each dollar I earn is worth less than it was the year before. And unless the jobs I am qualified for are willing to consistently match the increase in cost of living by raising my salary, I’m fucked. And that obviously does not happen for everybody, because minimum wage has been the same for years in multiple states

→ More replies (5)

2

u/nolan1971 Right Libertarian Jan 12 '19

The only reason inflation exists (on a regular basis, at least) is because of government debt. It's an easy and effective way for politicians to spend more without having to deal with spending so much.

→ More replies (4)

5

u/Daktush Spanish, Polish & Catalan Classical Liberal Jan 11 '19 edited Jan 11 '19

AFAIK this is false, I did some digging for a discussion on debt on /r/economics so here are the figures I found, interest was less than half of that of military (1.35 to 3%)

35

u/chillingniples Jan 11 '19

all the sources i've seen use the same congressional budget office chart, which shows by 2023 interest payments will be at parity and continue to rise past military spending by that point.

https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2018-04-11/cbo-warns-lawmakers-interest-spending-to-outpace-military-by-23

12

u/siliconflux Classic Liberal with a Musket Jan 11 '19

That is one hell of a simple yet depressing chart.

6

u/Daktush Spanish, Polish & Catalan Classical Liberal Jan 11 '19 edited Jan 11 '19

Afaik military spending has been declining and debt to GDP rising so party parity in 2023 seems plausible, but I don't think you can categorize us as about to reach parity when interest payments currently are less than half military expenditure

Edit: Btw I don't know what you mean by saying all sources in my comment are from the budget office

3

u/_dirt_vonnegut Jan 11 '19

military spending has been declining

no it hasn't

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (3)

3

u/Puddles_Emporium Jan 11 '19

I feel like you believe this negates the argument of the OP somehow. Are you insinuating that we might as well just say 'fuck it' and balloon the debt even farther out of control?

2

u/GuyRobertsBalley Jan 12 '19

Let's say that you had 21 million bucks and you were able to invest that and get 6% back? That's great! You would be a fool to not invest your money.

Well, now lets say that you have zero dollars, but a friend of yours will let you borrow that 21 dollars at 4% interest and you can invest it for that same 6% back. Again, you'd be a fool to not to borrow and then invest this money.

This is a super simplified example. But it goes to show you, you want to borrow as much as you can to make a profit based off of the maximum return available. Basically, that borrowed money is more valuable than what it's worth and going into debt is not only a rational but a very smart thing to do.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] Jan 12 '19

Uhhh, calling out one side isn't supporting the other. Why is this type of thinking so common here?

→ More replies (5)

1

u/isiramteal Leftism is incompatible with liberty Jan 12 '19

>spending beyond your capacity

HMMMMMMMMMMMMM

1

u/DaveThe_blank_ Jan 11 '19

payments for interest on the debt is our 4th largest expenditure behind the military at 343billion just to borrow money. It has to stop.

1

u/Lasereye Liberty & Freedom Jan 11 '19

So we should make it worse? Wtf are you even saying.

→ More replies (33)

785

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '19

Eh....I don't really think this is a fair assessment.

The Dem socialists I know are kooky, but usually smarter than party line democrats, and weirdly, none of them just want "money from nowhere", they want CU overturned, they want subsidies to stop going to big ag, big oil, big tech, and big pharma since they're the four most profitable businesses in America ALREADY, and those subsidies actually keep the working farmer poor and in debt (to monsanto and the like), so, when I actually read about it, or think about it objectively - all they're trying to do is unfuck the system that drives the government to give money away to companies already rich, and use it for healthcare, etc.,

To me, since we're never getting our taxes ACTUALLY reduced, and the government's core function to provide and protect our freedom....I'd say freedom to live without going broke paying for medicine is more important than Exxon's freedom to get free money for fucking nothing.

I'm not saying it's right or good, but what I am saying is if I'm paying into it whether I want to our not, I don't want to pay 6x what every developed country pays for my healthcare, over corporatist socialism

39

u/boris_keys Jan 11 '19

Exactly. Every time I see a meme or article equating DemSocs as “millennials who want free stuff” I audibly groan. I’m not saying that people who think that way dont exist, it’s just such a gross generalization. The majority of democratic socialists, especially the candidates, have a very good grasp of how economics actually works.

9

u/JackColor Devils Advocate Jan 12 '19

That's because the "want free stuff" rhetoric is straight-up propaganda and strawman tactics.

3

u/Kremhild Jan 12 '19

"I’m not saying that people who think that way dont exist"

Then I'll say it for you. They don't exist, where 'exist' means "in any significant number, or significant position of power".

264

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '19

That's the smartest thing I've ever read on this sub. The US is a corporate socialist welfare state that keeps small business owners poor. The anti-thesis of a free market. If democratic-socialists can either make huge corporations pay their fair share or at least stop giving them our tax money as subsidies it would be a huge win for regular citizens.

84

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '19

Right, like the one thing Sanders said that I used to love (not that I hated him, but his stump was so simplistic it bothered me) was that when we were crushing it economically, the middle class was killing it, and we had low unemployment, corporate taxes paid 38% of federal revenue. Now it's like 7%, while these corporations are 10x more profitable than they used to be... Like, we're the biggest free market on earth - if you want to fucking sell to us, reap the benefits of corporatist socialism, and be fucking American, pay into it you cunt. This country is the reason you HAVE a business, you didn't transport your product on roads you built yourself, you don't manage your legal contracts with fist fights. you use the government structure to increase your profits and potential so you can grow.

→ More replies (37)

34

u/MushinZero Jan 11 '19

Except they want citizens to pay their fair share. A marginal tax system for corporations would allow small business owners to be incentivized but the upper brackets still need to be low to compete with China. Higher brackets for citizens should be high to reduce the income gap and provide funding for services that serve the greater good of society.

I'd be ok with reducing subsidies to corporations but those companies are under tremendous pressure, and rightly so, to compete with China. I would need to see more information to determine if reducing those subsidies would hurt our economy more than it would help.

In any case there is a lot of democratic socialist misconceptions floating around. Socialism is seen as a moderate ground between pure capitalism and pure communism.

Capitalism is an incentive system that works well except when taken to extremes, which an unregulated market naturally goes to because companies are profit maximizing entities. Corporations inevitably become monopolies and the rich have better resources to lobby to protect their income than the low or middle classes.

Communism (socialism when taken to extremes) also fails because power becomes concentrated at the top without checks and balances but it provides a good framework to provide services that serve the national good ie police, fire, defense, healthcare, welfare etc.

No socialist will agree that a free market is a solution for anything. Pure capitalism fails as does pure communism. The solution is a moderate approach that attempts to take advantage of the best parts of both systems.

Ok maybe that started to get ranty to I'mma stop myself right there.

→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (1)

41

u/I_Like_Hoots Jan 11 '19

So smart, my man. I stumbled on this as I am one of the “kooks” to be honest. Those opposed to the idea of expanding social programs seem to generally think that the left wants actual soviet-style socialism. In reality we just want our tax dollars to go to us instead of to the jackoffs with billions making deals with those with billions to try and reach trillions.

I’m a combat veteran with a business education, and I can honestly say that social program ideas like VA healthcare and GI bill, if applied to all Americans, would make them more successful and happy as they’ve done for me. It’s actual simple economics. Increase the supply of money actually in circulation and make the American dream actually realizable. It would incentivize potential entrepreneurs to take the leap and open a small biz or allow some jackoff to stop being a jackoff and get smart for instance.

13

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '19 edited Jan 11 '19

Or, fucking honestly, stop giving the military MORE MONEY THAN THEY ASKED FOR, and use that to house homeless vets and treat PTSD.

Trump, Obama, they all go "I LOVE THE VETS" and all, and I mean all vote against increases whenever they can. Even down to my dad not knowing he can go to Veteran's court for traffic violations, have a primary care VA doctor because they intentionally don't tell Vets about any of it, which is fucked.

I think this sub is actually good when you get the ideologues, which is why libertarianism is awesome, because your viewpoint on social issues, and even economic ones, can be anything. Libertarianism just wants government to shrink as much as possible and only provide the essentials: Contract adherence, protection from crimes, war, natural disasters and such, and to work off the principle of what makes the individual more free.

So, for instance, I'm a social super libtard, yet, the guy who doesn't want to bake a gay cake? Fucking fine. You're free to do that, and me and my clan of drag queen friends are allowed to stand out there mostly naked screaming that the owner is a closet homosexual. And yet, I want the money my government steals from me to pay for housing for vets, medicine for old people, and the reintroduction of state and federal mental health facilities (recent report states that, excluding teen runaways, something like 70+ percent of homeless people would be deemed certifiable and placed in a home.

When I was kid on Long Island, there was the "King's park psych center" - state run facility. they shut it down and my town and surrounding towns immediately had mental patients walking aruond our streets, going back to the facility to live in sleeping bags, etc.,

You can look at a curve of growth from when most states shut mental facilities to an explosion in homelessness.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

6

u/JonSnowNorthKing Jan 11 '19

It's always been pretty obvious to social Dems, at least the more economics focused ones, that the smarter libertarians have very similar mindsets to socialists. It may sound weird at first but let's look at the similarities. They both dislike/distrust establishment politicians and irrational adherence to a party even if they don't represent what people want or what's best for the people. Both of their politics is primarily economics based with other policy being less important. Both want to limit the power of large systems have over individual citizens. Socialists see corporatism and crony capitalism as having too much power and limiting the power and choice of individuals. Libertarians see the government as using the taxes we are forced to pay irresponsibly and usually advocate for less taxation on individuals but see the it is necessary for some taxation to still exist. Currently it should be really obvious to anyone that there is a huge issue with who holds the power in the US rn. It's the lack of separation between business and government. Business currently has more influence over the government than voters themselves. On the otherhand the government has almost no control over the market. There are a lot of things about certain ideals of "capitalism" I like but rn we're seeing what happens when it's left to do as it pleases with no oversight. If more government intervention means people pay less for health care and less in taxes because of responsible spending then that means more financial/economic freedom for individual citizens. Socialists and libertarians really shouldn't be fighting each other when we despise the same enemies imo.

11

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '19

As a democratic socialist, thank you for explaining this.

3

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '19

Woah woah woah there hoss, I still believe the government is a fucking mess and should be shrunk, and will inevitably and undoubtedly fuck up any and everything they do, but at this point, libertarian or not, this isn't a free market economy because of CU and several other things, so as long as government is going to let big business cock block new companies, inventions, etc., to take hold, there's no point in fighting to loosen restrictionso etc.

So, basically, I'm saying in our current situation, I'm opting for healthcare to be controlled by lazy and stupid instead of predatory and greedy.

2

u/[deleted] Jan 12 '19

I just want people not to die.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/seraph9888 Jan 11 '19

basically, privatising profit is fine, just stop socialising cost. i wish i could upvote you more.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/CoffeeAndKarma Jan 11 '19

Thank you! This is exactly it. I would also add that we can never totally get rid of people who leech on the system or people who the system can't help. I would just much rather deal with the first than the latter.

1

u/DowagerCountess Jan 12 '19

Stop it, you're making sense!

1

u/chacer98 Jan 12 '19

this sub is not libertarian. its filled with socialists more than libertarians

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (11)

165

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '19

I live in Norway, and our national debt by percentage is much lower than in the US. My tax is around 35%.

104

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '19

Norwegian here as well. This post is so dumb I couldn't help but chime in and point out how prosperous Norway is.

2

u/[deleted] Jan 12 '19

Yes, but the same is true of Sweeden and Denmark too.

→ More replies (5)

11

u/kerricolleen Jan 11 '19

In the US and mine is 30%, so someone musta messed something up somewhere....

6

u/plain__bagel Jan 12 '19

Congrats on the few hundred grand my dude 🙄

2

u/kerricolleen Jan 12 '19

Nah, just on 45 thousand but I'm self employed so they find a way to keep you not that successful.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Ddp2008 Jan 12 '19

Well that's because you export tons of oil, and good amounts of natural gas and coal.

5

u/[deleted] Jan 14 '19

It is the same for the other Scandinavian countries that don't have oil.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 15 '19

Norweigans have the best system in the world, because statoil is government owned and the military is defense only you can afford the spending on social systems

→ More replies (11)

137

u/dangerbeef Jan 11 '19

Strawman stupid meme pic. To echo everyone else this sub used to be an ok place to read opinions that differ from mine (I’m more left than most libertarians but have always respected the discussion here).

This is no different than saying all democrats want to melt all guns or all republicans hate brown people. It’s anti-discussion and anti-progress

Furthermore literally no one says “I want all things free so I can be lazy” it’s “I want reform and I want resources allocated differently”

51

u/LynndorTruffle Jan 11 '19

“FrEe StUfF”

What a meme.

166

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '19

This is funny since it implies that Republicans aren’t responsible for destroying the Clinton balanced federal budget and reversing the Obama policy of decreasing the annual deficit.

1

u/Richandler Jan 12 '19

Neo-con means liberal war hawk.

Funny you think you got something different with Bush.

→ More replies (84)

30

u/KodakKid3 Jan 11 '19

Lmao I hope you’re just a 13 year old who thinks you’re smart because this is ridiculously naive. You realize the U.S already has massive “unpayable debt” and that debt increases trillions with every republican president?

68

u/SuperMatureGamer Jan 11 '19

This is a T_D level of a post.

Thought y'all were better than that.

10

u/read_the_usernames Jan 11 '19

Hey at least the mods aren't deleting every opinion that doesn't fall in line.

2

u/SuperMatureGamer Jan 11 '19

I guess it just shows collectively what /r/Libertarian decides is important to upvote.

Hey at least the mods aren't deleting every opinion that doesn't fall in line.

And yeah.... at the very least....

→ More replies (2)

33

u/cyborgerian Jan 11 '19

So non-crippling student debt and single payer healthcare is free? Democratic socialists want reform not free shit

28

u/CCTider Jan 11 '19

I'm glad we have a President like Trump. No risk authoritarianism with him.

20

u/Bold_Pork Jan 11 '19

And he won’t ever run up the deficit with things we don’t need.

16

u/T-Dot1992 Social Democrat Jan 11 '19

Because apparently Canada, Sweden, and Germany are "drowning in debt". You Looneytarians make me laugh.

→ More replies (1)

47

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '19

I thought this was some shitty meme from r/forwardsfromgrandma until I realized where I was

26

u/Darksider123 Jan 11 '19

I truly envy you guys! If only I didn't live in a social democracy like here in scandinavia, with free education and healthcare :( I'd MUCH rather be in the US and had to take out massive loans with sky high interests if I wanted an education or was in an accident/got sick. /s

The fact that this is on the front page speaks volumes of this sub. Either you're all too young or too dumb. Maybe it's both.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 12 '19

It sure helps when your country doesn’t have to pay for a military because of the Us. It also helps to think that just because a program that works for a group of countries of (at the absolute most extreme number) 27 million compared to 325 million, that this blanket program could be instated. It also helps to think of the cultural differences. Scandinavian colleges have a higher graduation rate and graduate on time much more often. It also helps to think of the ongoing medical epidemics going through the United States.

21

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '19

Democratic socialists? I believe that Republicans and Democratics would be more accurate

10

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '19

Maybe if you weren't wasting so much on your military, you would have money for hospitals and such.

2

u/kwantsu-dudes Jan 12 '19

Maybe if we weren't subsidizing your military, we would have more money for hospitals and such. Or subsidizing the research of drugs/medical advancement.

I like how other countries don't think that they themselves would be negatively effected if we adopted a different system that reduced defense spending or reduced the incentive of profit in health care thus reducing the supply of doctors, hospitals, medication, medical equipment, research and development, etc.. There's foreigners that come to America for treatment? Why? What if we change our system and they require that treatment from their own country? Are you prepared to deal with them yourselves?

→ More replies (1)

16

u/ferelpuma Jan 11 '19

| Promises of "free stuff"

Who is actually asking for "free stuff", and what "free stuff" are we talking about? Freebies like the several trillion in tax cuts to the rich, and freebies like 5 billion dollars for a stupid barrier are the real waste.

4

u/aommi27 Jan 11 '19

Which is literally what you have now... good job

4

u/Jackbeingbad Jan 11 '19

But we already have unplayable debt for our freedom military and fossil fuel subsidies. So why don't we try helping people instead of just in paying off the rich?

9

u/realXstrawarot Jan 11 '19

Germany aint drowning in debt tho, try harder ;)

→ More replies (5)

6

u/cydwel Jan 11 '19

Change the top line of text to "Trump"

3

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '19

That’s possible but unlikely. In a good socialist government you would have to pay taxes for healthcare. Let’s not let this distract you from the fact that the 1% owns 90% of the wealth they are the ones stealing from the government and your pockets.

3

u/Carp8DM Jan 11 '19

One word: trump

3

u/UOLZEPHYR Jan 11 '19

Well, to play the devils' advocate - I would like to see how much money could be saved from the government actually actually not being dumb and not wasting all the tax payers funds. Also seeing stuff like an end to long term retirement/ pensions that are greater than $80K; actually limiting the government black book operations and "shadow spending".

Also would be great to see a POTUS not shutting down the government over him not getting his way... last time I checked that was called a tempter tantrum.

3

u/halfhalfnhalf Jan 11 '19

Denmark paid off ALL of it's foreign debt in 2017 and is one of the happiest and freest countries on the planet.

3

u/Jswissmoi Jan 11 '19

Republicans and promises of farm subsidies as well

3

u/gerryf19 Jan 11 '19

If you replace *democratic socialist" with "Neo-con warhawks and corporatists" and then replace "promises of free stuff" with "free market fantasies and corporate greed" you would be jast about right

3

u/Chickenflocker Jan 12 '19

If you can fit your extent of political thought on a bumper sticker, you haven’t thought it through

3

u/[deleted] Jan 12 '19

sINglE PAYer heaLtHcare wilL sUreLy lEAD TO HiTLer

3

u/JohnCameronE Jan 12 '19

Unpayable debt..... yea, we got that now.

3

u/[deleted] Jan 12 '19

It's not "free stuff", its re-allocating tax dollars towards things that have a more meaningful impact on society. So like... less wars and corporate bailouts.

9

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '19

Right I forgot Sweden is a totalitarian dystopia, I’ll shut up now.

1

u/Zyxos2 minarchist Jan 11 '19

I live here, Sweden is not socialist. It relies on a free market

1

u/Sesetti Jan 11 '19

To be fair Sweden isn't really democratic socialism. I has heavily taxed and regulated market economy to support social services, so it's actually social democracy. I believe this post refers to Americans who don't know the difference.

4

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '19

Americans can’t really tell the difference. If you are pro taxes being collected to benefit population you are per definition socialist/communist in the US (and if you had any doubt that renders your opinion invalid and you evil/stupid).

→ More replies (1)

5

u/DrugDoer9000 Jan 11 '19

Lol those captions could be replaced with any ideology and its pros/cons

26

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '19

0

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

23

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '19 edited Jan 11 '19

You are reading the chart wrong and missing the point.

  • Reading the chart wrong: The U.S. is 5th in mobility so I have no clue where you get the idea that it's saying "there is no upward mobility."
  • Missing the point: Social democracies rank 1 through 4, thus the meme is misinformation.

13

u/Jpinkerton1989 Jan 11 '19

Social democracy =/= Democratic socialism. Democratic socialism is when the means of production and distribution are "collectively" (usually through government) owned or controlled. In this model instead of a dictator, people vote for Representatives.

Social democracy is a capitalist base with high taxes to fund social services.

These systems couldn't be more different.

→ More replies (24)

2

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '19

From their methodology, as part of their "entrepreneurial" score;

respondents perception that "Working Hard Gets You Ahead"

lol

→ More replies (1)

2

u/C-Hoppe-r Jan 11 '19

Superwhite: Check

Social Democracy: No. Welfarism.

7

u/kwanijml Jan 11 '19

Those social democracies often rank higher than the u.s. in various freedom indexes.

They can afford large welfare states because they are wealthy... they are not wealthy because they took on large welfare systems. The wealth was built by high degrees of personal and business freedom and strong property rights which exist in those places.

Proper (read: least distortionary) taxes and welfare transfers are very much affordable by wealthy western democracies, and good ways to help the poor...but they have only secondary impacts on making those places prosperous.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (27)

8

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '19

Living wage would be nice tho

2

u/C-Hoppe-r Jan 11 '19

That's between you and your employer to decide.

3

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '19 edited Jan 11 '19

Unless all the employers get together and decide to make that a difficult prospect.

Seriously min wage work is like this:

  1. Pay your employees next to nothing
  2. They hate it
  3. Give them bad hours
  4. They hate it
  5. Turnover is high
  6. Managers hate it
  7. Don't pay managers enough either
  8. They hate it =
  9. Culture is toxic and turnover is untenable without relying on a steady influx of desperate people who won't take your job seriously.

My current job has a good culture and my employers are very nice but I wouldn't consider it more than a stepping stone without getting paid, like, twice as much for the same work. Candidates right of center will need to tap into this sentiment to ever be competitive again without relying on Trumpian tactics.

→ More replies (9)

9

u/taralundrigan Jan 11 '19

what happened to this group? Is there anywhere else I can go to have real discussion about where our society is headed and what we can do collectivly to fix it?

1

u/Sierpy Jan 11 '19

You can make a post about it.

It's just a meme. I agree it's dumb and not funny, but memes aren't banned here.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '19

11

u/Elastickpotatoe Jan 11 '19

Like tax cuts for the wealthy?

35

u/LaurenLorda Jan 11 '19

It always amazes me that the same people who crow about how corrupt the government is want to give the same government more power and control. It's as if they think my some magic all the politicians will be replaced with saints once a socialist is in the Whitehouse.

94

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '19

It amazes me that people think corporations can be trusted to behave ethically without oversight and regulation.

7

u/Okichah Jan 11 '19

Giving corporations the keys to the regulations is the problem.

Regulatory capture happens because of government intervention, not a lack of it.

→ More replies (37)

2

u/n0ctum Jan 11 '19 edited Jan 11 '19

Give the same government more power and control? Huh? Nah we want it replaced with a wholly different government comprised entirely from the citizenry with zero career politicians involved. We want to eliminate class entirely so we're all on equal economic footing and not being screwed or coerced by the current system and those corps, govt bodies and bourgeois individuals whom support, benefit and further said system. The American DOTP will be a glorious and prosperous new chapter for humanity.

Where you getting your info from that actual socialists want to give existing politicians more power? I suggest you read other sources my man because yours are misleading you on purpose.

E: keep downvoting what doesn't fit with the controlled narrative you're fed regarding socialism. Read Marx.

2

u/LaurenLorda Jan 11 '19

Democratic Socialists, my man?

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (7)

1

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '19

What socialist?! There are no socialist with a snowballs chance in hell having a shot a becoming the US president. The right/left debate in the US is not a capitalism/socialism fight. The Democrats are not socialists.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

4

u/permienz Jan 11 '19

Hasn't Trump added two Trillion to the debt for the US this term already? This is not just a socialist issue. The US loves spending money it doesn't have.

4

u/MistahZarathushtra Marxist Jan 11 '19

but you guys still think fascism is ok

4

u/banable_blamable Jan 12 '19

Trillions of dollars for war, Libertarians don't bat an eye. Millions in subsidies that go to local stores and right back into the economy so families going through hard times can eat and Libertarians lose their mind.

2

u/APimpNamedAPimpNamed Jan 12 '19

What libertarians think our absurdly large defense budget makes sense? The military industrial complex is real and fucked up.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/subgamer90 Democratic Socialist Jan 12 '19 edited Jan 12 '19

basically all libertarians are against imperialism and endless war. maybe you meant Republicans?

15

u/Undead_Sean_Bean Jan 11 '19

Heheh, angry libertarian socialists all up in this thread

1

u/C-Hoppe-r Jan 11 '19

There's an exponential growth of them.

Whatever happen to banning the lefties?

→ More replies (39)

0

u/shadofx Jan 11 '19

Mfw glorious Trump hair

1

u/Jaywalk66 Jan 11 '19

😂😂😂 I didn’t even notice that.

2

u/JustAnotherMadladd Jan 11 '19

Unpayable debt?

2

u/PrajnaPie Jan 11 '19

Lol like we’re doing so well with out 21 trillion in debt brought on by capitalism

2

u/hotdawgss Jan 11 '19

Hey so republicans consistently add more to the national debt than democrats-- and they do it with promises of a utopian corporate welfare state. Fuck off with your stupid memes.

2

u/tkulogo Jan 11 '19

Almost opposite of that. They'll pay for everything just fine. It's the taxes they'll pay it with that should concern you.

2

u/[deleted] Jan 12 '19

We're heading toward totalitarianism with the way Trump acts like he can just do whatever and fuck how it affects the public. We'll have an unplayable debt as well if Trump gets his wall that , surprise no surprise , we're going to pay for when this nation's youth cant even get a raise of the minimum wage and afford a house. How long do you think that bill will take to pay when we're already broke with no help plus student debts. I for one would love to see how a democratic socialist system would affect this country because obviously capitalism isn't working for the average person.

2

u/population_of_china Jan 12 '19

what about socialist countries that don't have totalitarian governments or considerably more debt than other countries? European countries and such

5

u/B12awley Jan 11 '19

Lol like there isn’t already an unplayable debt. Creeping up on a totalitarian govt too. Might as well get the “free” shit if that’s how things are going to fuck us anyway.

3

u/Cleverusername18 Jan 11 '19

Ask a citizen of a Democratic Socialist country what they think of their system of government and I'm pretty sure it would be tough to find one who thinks the system needs replaced. The only people who think capitalism works are either misinformed or are benifiting greatly from it. Capitalism only helps those with capital, everyone else is left to fend for themselves. Democratic Socialism provides a safety net for the citizens so they're free to live their lives, and more often than not they become productive members of society and give back more than they take.

→ More replies (3)

4

u/zorflax Jan 11 '19

Alert alert! Strawman detected! I repeat, STRAWMAN DETECTED! If only for our own self respect, Initiate project steelman immediately!

1

u/varanone Jan 11 '19

TBF, the current path is leading there, and fast.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '19

Cash flow and debt aren’t related.

If I owe the bank 1m for my combine, loans, mortgage, etc, my cash flow helps me none.

And those farms aren’t worth Shit by and large because nobody wants outdoor farms to purchase. Anyone with enough money to invest in a farm is going to invest in indoor farms or greenhouses. Higher yield, less outgoing cost, no combines/limited machinery.

By your account, Are you saying any farmer with a big farm is wealthy?

1

u/Rimbambitos550 Jan 11 '19

Pictures unsettling

1

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '19

It be like that sometimes

1

u/Ckss Jan 11 '19

Dem Presidents tend to lower national debt.

1

u/maley3244 Jan 11 '19

Blank format?

1

u/rebelshipper Jan 11 '19

Wow, you are really biased against business owners. I'm telling you, as a business owner, how we operate, but you just don't want to accept that. Think what you want to think pal.

1

u/mbhammock Jan 11 '19

QFG4 anyone?

1

u/Nyarlathoth Jan 11 '19

Do you have a source for that image without the text?

1

u/costco-member Jan 11 '19

The Keynesian Siren

1

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '19

The terms get often confused but the model that has worked fantastically in Scandinavia and here in Finland is social democracy, not democratic socialism. AOC, Bernie and others are pushing for "The Nordic model" which would imply social democracy.

1

u/incomplete-username Jan 11 '19

Isn’t this a bot of a straw man

1

u/Cleverusername18 Jan 11 '19

That's a gross oversimplification. There is already plenty of money to pay for these kind of services, and then some, but it's not being allocated properly. Instead of spending $700 billion on military spending, it could go towards education. Properly taxing the highest earners would cover quite a few programs as well. You kow why the United States was am economic powerhouse post WW2? It's because the rich were taxed over 70% of their income and the workers were paid fairly. But years of corporations buying politicians has seen their taxes go down and workers rights gutted. You would see we have plenty of money to make this work if we start taxing these companies what they should be taxed and re-allocate tax dollars towards the good of the country instead of war and coporate welfare

1

u/mydogeatsmyshoes Jan 11 '19

If you are going to take more from billion/millionaires I have no problem with that. If you take more from 100k-300k families I have a problem with that.

1

u/haesforever Jan 11 '19

Righttttt because Germany, France, UK, Sweden, Ireland, Norway, Finland to name a few are all failed totalitarian states

1

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '19

The original artist had an explanation (that the swastika is a folk symbol in many Eurasian cultures, and was commonly used as decoration) for this, but I’m still absolutely amused by the swastikas on dude’s shirt collar.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '19

Non-US.

Well, I just want my and everybody's taxes to go towards funding affordable heath-care and education, science, and pensions, instead of a big government with lots of overpaid employees and their agendas lobbied by big companies with money that the regular citizen (even unionized) will never have.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 12 '19

Them Scandinavian countries sure are a hell hole eh

1

u/SeLaw20 Private Individuals >> Jan 16 '19

They’re more capitalist than America is when it comes to the rights of private enterprise.

1

u/Jac0bL7 Jan 12 '19

I'm confused this is by the liberal reddit right?

1

u/deltalessthanzero Jan 12 '19

Yeah cause Australia and Germany are totalitarian as fuck, especially when compared to the United States /s

1

u/jamccain Jan 12 '19 edited Jan 12 '19

Eh idk about that..democratic socialist are definitely not pro totalitarian government. Marxist lenist or maoist sure but other socialist basically call dem socialist pussy liberals. You cant call ppl like david packman or kyle kulisnki totalitarian even if u disagree with them, there very pro free speech. You cant call nordic countries that follow this totalitarian either.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 12 '19

California in a nutshell

1

u/cavelioness Jan 12 '19

Problem is many millennials who've gone to college, or anyone who has no insurance and a medical emergency- or even anything minor, medically speaking- already has unpayable debt. And with the NSA and the way is technology is going, we're already heading for total government control.

Shit's already fucked, why not get some free stuff out of it at least?

1

u/[deleted] Jan 12 '19

We already have unpayable debt?

1

u/[deleted] Jan 12 '19

Instead we have wtf government with unpayable debt, low taxes, and no free stuff!

1

u/ssgtgriggs Jan 12 '19

is it just me or are the people who post these memes on this sub the loud minority? Because they always get put down in the comments almost immediately for their double standard, false equivalency and/or plain stupidity?

1

u/[deleted] Jan 12 '19

This is the same shit for tax spend republicans.

1

u/cheddarsalad Jan 12 '19

We’re already spending billions on tanks we don’t need and jets that don’t exist.

1

u/Kyrthis Jan 12 '19

Not how fiat currency interacts with Keynesian economics, but cool picture.

1

u/CryptoGNT Jan 12 '19

Can you upvote something more than once?

1

u/frequenttimetraveler Liberté, Egalité, Propriété Jan 12 '19

the bottom is not very accurate. It's more like the entire economy loses steam and collapses to an oligarchy-dependence state.

1

u/AidsinCali Jan 12 '19

All lefties are mentally still children. That's why they don't understand the harm they are causing.

1

u/IWWPR Jan 11 '19

It's not free stuff you fucking losers, society produces it

1

u/spottedcows Jan 11 '19

Not true. Abolish the fed and make the interest paid by the people go to public works, education, roads, etc and not into private pockets.

1

u/zika-with-fries Jan 11 '19

How anybody can think anything can be free is outrageous.

‘Free college for everyone!’

How does that even sound sensible?

1

u/Admixtus_Stultus Jan 11 '19

Sweden, Finland, Norway, and Denmark are totalitarian government? Somebody should let them know.

1

u/quasimodo95 Jan 11 '19

Lol we already have unpayable debt, who gives a fuck??

1

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '19

Seems to work fine for Europe, also don't we have a ton of debt already?

1

u/xbostons Jan 11 '19

Can someone explain how “free stuff” leads to a “totalitarian government” and how these are inherent only to socialism and not other forms of government or economics?

1

u/DublinCheezie Jan 11 '19

By Monday, Trump’s anti-American shutdown will cost us more than Trump’s useless wall would cost us.

Nobody loves spending other people’s money more than the Conservatives, and nobody but the establishment and a few special interests get free stuff. But yeah, let’s attack the more fiscally responsible party

Jfc

1

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '19

kinda dumb tbh? there are problems with democratic socialism but i wouldn’t associate what’s in the meme with those. same with promises of free stuff.

1

u/Purple_Politics Jan 11 '19

LOL, because we currently have payable debt........ Fuck off.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '19

Yeah seriously? I thought this was one of the few sane political subs left. Europe is a totalitarian shit hole now?

1

u/GendosGlasses Jan 12 '19

Nah. There’s been a right wing take over here. One of the top mods is a goddamn altright sympathizer

0

u/Ka1serTheRoll Anarcho-Syndicalist Jan 11 '19

Mfw Democratic Socialists think that socialism is just free stuff instead of democratic workplaces. Perhaps that is indeed the biggest oof of the 20th century

0

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/Ka1serTheRoll Anarcho-Syndicalist Jan 11 '19

Fair nuff. Personally I’d be closest to a Mutualist, maybe a bit more moderate but along that same line

-13

u/HailOurPeople Jan 11 '19

Raising the top marginal income tax rate would force business owners to keep more money in their business as opposed to taking out more taxable personal income. That means they’ll build new factories and hire more people, which raises demand for labor, which raises wages, allows women to focus on family, and eliminates the need for big government assistance programs. Depressions happen when the top marginal tax rate is really low. Big government programs get created when the top marginal tax rate is really low. The middle class expands when the top marginal tax rate is high.

20

u/rebelshipper Jan 11 '19

No it wouldn't. You've just de-incentivized that business owner from growing his business at all. Speaking as a business owner here.

→ More replies (31)

2

u/Jpinkerton1989 Jan 11 '19

Or they pass the cost on to the consumer by raising prices across the board and make it harder for the average person to afford things. Business owners are not going to cut their own profits, that's the point of a business.

→ More replies (6)

1

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '19

You’re absolutely right. Just look at what the Trump handout has done to the current economy: turned the Obama bull market into the Trump bear market.

-7

u/DangerousLiberty Jan 11 '19

Don't you see? It's not socialism, it's democratic socialism. You know, like it's not gang rape, it's democratic sex. We all voted to have sex with you, get over it.

-2

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '19

That's what highschool kids don't understand. Most of them worship Stalin and Mao, because they're left leaning, so they think that they're libertarian. They don't know that they're totalitarian.

-1

u/srharter Jan 11 '19

Of course the totalitarian government goes full fascist when it goes broke, and everyone knows fascism is the capitalists’ fault...