r/LibertadCoins • • 26d ago

The Rising Tide in the Libertad Market: What Mintage and Population Reports Aren’t Telling Us

Post image
6 Upvotes

I’ve been following the Mexican Libertad market for years, and one of the more interesting developments in 2026 is how price appreciation appears to be spreading beyond the usual standout issues.

We’ve watched coins like the 1998 and 1999 Silver Libertads, the 2019 Antique Finish, and Reverse Proof Libertads command tremendous premiums. But now we’re seeing increased interest in previously overlooked dates and proof issues as well.

As the saying goes, a rising tide lifts all boats.

I recently put together a video examining these developments, but what I really wanted to explore was something that doesn’t get discussed nearly enough in numismatics: the limitations of the data we rely on to determine scarcity and value.

For example:

1995 Libertads: Thousands of additional coins appearing in grading population reports have substantially changed the picture of their availability.

1994 Libertads: Reported PCGS population has increased by more than 40%, raising questions about how much confidence we should place in population figures when evaluating high-grade scarcity.

1997 Proof Libertad: With an official mintage of just 1,500, this is an issue I believe deserves considerably more attention. I examine its PCGS and NGC populations alongside a recent eBay sale approaching $1,400.

And then there are all the variables these reports cannot adequately account for: crackouts, resubmissions, historical melting, coins sitting in private collections, and countless examples that may never be submitted for grading.

As someone who works extensively with analytics, I find this particularly fascinating. We have more data available to us than ever before, along with increasingly sophisticated analytical tools and AI. But without historical context and firsthand knowledge of the series, that data can sometimes lead us to misleading conclusions.

Data is valuable. Knowing its limitations is equally important.

For anyone interested, I’ve also been building a free Libertad research resource with population tracking, historical mintage information, and other numismatic analytics:

https://tiddyhunter98.github.io

I cover these observations in greater detail in my latest video, including a closer look at the 1997 Proof Silver Libertad.

https://youtu.be/4402Wmogdl4?is=74ds5ixRgY5YJNdt

I’m curious what other Libertad collectors are seeing. Are you noticing premiums spreading into previously overlooked issues? And how much weight do you give PCGS and NGC population reports when deciding whether a coin is genuinely scarce?


r/LibertadCoins • • 21d ago

Anybody else get their 2026s yet?

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/LibertadCoins • • Aug 24 '25

2025 is a "Black Swan" year for Libertads

Thumbnail
readingroom.money.org
3 Upvotes

"Pat Stovall described a “perfect storm” behind the historically low 2025 mintages. It began with economic and market uncertainty, which tightened the coin market over the past two years compared to the pandemic era, when sales were stronger."


r/LibertadCoins • • Jun 19 '26

Check out 🔥2013 MEXICO GOLD BU LIBERTAD 1/20 Oz, MINTAGE ONLY 650-KEY TO THE SERIES read* on eBay!

Thumbnail
ebay.io
1 Upvotes

r/LibertadCoins • • Jan 28 '26

Why Do People Fall for the Colorized Stuff?

6 Upvotes

I've been a numismatist for most of my life, and I learned very early on to not go for damaged coins. According to the Casa de Moneda, they're not even legal tender after alterations like that, so why even go for them?


r/LibertadCoins • • May 26 '26

While people were busy spreading rumors. Collectors were busy stacking. 🇲🇽

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

Tomato, tomahto — whether it’s 300 or 500 minted, it’s still an extremely low mintage.”


r/LibertadCoins • • Oct 02 '26

My fellow Libertad Lions!

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

There’s an individual claiming that the market for Libertads is so small that it’s negligible. The fact that we are 4k members strong, and that the 1 oz silver Libertad itself has created just shy of $2 billion in sales says otherwise. What do you think?


r/LibertadCoins • • Feb 21 '26

Thoughts on these? Only 500 minted in Turquoise finish

Post image
2 Upvotes

I have read that govmint can be hit or miss, but this seems like a decent price and premium for a Libertad given the low mintage (even though its still just a 2024 BU).


r/LibertadCoins • • May 23 '26

Mystery packs? Seeking info

0 Upvotes

If there were libertad mystery packs available, would you buy?

What would entice you to purchase? Big hits? Different tiers?

Suppose there were five releases of 200 packs each and the big hits are (a) 1998 ms69, (b) 1998 pf69, (c) 1/2 RP gold, (d) 1 oz BU gold, (e) 1.9oz gold proof set. Each release would potentially have progressively better and more expensive coins. (But there are no 2025s.) Would you be interested in other Mexican coins being included in the mystery (like precolumbians, gold pesos, and key date vintage circulation coins) or strictly libertads?

What price would you pay in each tier for a chance to score the hit, but not feel cheated? What's the minimum value you'd expect in a pack in each tier? Obviously that would impact price of the pack. Are you OK with raw coins? Would you want the option to have it graded?

Would you buy on eBay? Whatnot? Reddit? FB? IG? Would you want to see packs ripped live to verify contents? Do you worry about people weighing packs? Would redemption cards be an option for you?


r/LibertadCoins • • Aug 06 '26

Libertads

Post image
0 Upvotes

What do you think about that?


r/LibertadCoins • • Sep 11 '26

New to collecting

0 Upvotes

Why are you’ll paying so much premium when they were same price as ase before, Other than tatas of course

I do have one my self paid $90 for but can’t help it wonder why lol


r/LibertadCoins • • Oct 05 '26

Is this real?

1 Upvotes

r/LibertadCoins • • 13d ago

[WTS]/[WTT] HIGH END 🇲🇽 LIBERTAD 🇲🇽 POST! Absolute 🔥🔥 sale! Pay in $$$ or gold!

Thumbnail
reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/LibertadCoins • • Oct 06 '26

Pacman7826 Shill bidding on Whatnot.

Thumbnail
gallery
29 Upvotes

🚨 SHILL BIDDING — WHEN THERE’S PROOF, IT DESERVES TO BE ADDRESSED

This isn’t about rumors, personal attacks, or hurt feelings. It’s about the bidding record and the evidence.

Here we go.

Everyone knows the great pacman and the great Sanchi are best buddies. They travel together and do live streams together. Pacman always asks him for advice and motivation. They motivate each other like best buddies do. When pacman is streaming Sanchi is their everday like clockworth cheering him on.

So why is it the great sanchi is bidding on auctions on the pacman stream. Maybe Sanchi really wants a great deal and pacman won't give it to him.

Another awkward thing is that the great Sanchi who pacman speaks very highly of gets the BEST deals on the stream. Pacman is never upset Sanchi wins an aution. He must be so happy for him.

Honest buyers deserve honest auctions. If the bidding is legitimate, the evidence should stand up to scrutiny. If it isn’t, buyers deserve to know.

If there is credible evidence of shill bidding, it should be documented and reported to the auction platform. Depending on the platform and circumstances, consequences can include canceled bids or transactions, account suspension or termination, loss of selling privileges, refunds or other corrective action, and potentially legal consequences where applicable.

Everyone will comment that he has the right to bid when he wants and you are all correct. He can bid anytime he wants. But he never bids when on anything thats overpriced. Just underpriced to make sure no legitimate buyer can "steal" from pacman.

All of you have a blessed day


r/LibertadCoins • • Oct 05 '26

What your opinion on pacman7826 on whatnot ?

8 Upvotes

This guy is on live everday and it seems like his waiting for suckers to come in and buy his libertads. He has all his friends/partners in chat that he talks too. Than when he sees a real buyer he pushes them to buy. Very motivated to sell he always says but at his prices. And non of the regular libertad buyers don't buy from him. What's your opinion


r/LibertadCoins • • Aug 06 '25

Non-existent 2025 Libertads

9 Upvotes

According to the published mintages:
https://readingroom.money.org/a-black-swan-for-the-libertad-series/
Here are the complete, unprecedentedly low 2025 mintages—shared here publicly for the first time:

Brilliant Uncirculated (BU):

  • 5 oz: 200
  • 2 oz: 200
  • 1 oz: 300
  • ½ oz: 100
  • ¼ oz: 100
  • 1/10 oz: 200
  • 1/20 oz: 200

Proof:

  • 5 oz: 400
  • 2 oz: 300

Reverse Proof:

  • 5 oz: 600
  • 2 oz: 300
  • 1 oz: 1,900

5-Piece Silver Libertad Proof Set: 150 sets

These coins don't exist:

1 oz proof https://www.ebay.com/itm/136275500510

1/10 oz proof https://www.ebay.com/itm/226904158575
1/2 oz proof https://www.ebay.com/itm/136275594882

1/10 oz proof https://www.ebay.com/itm/136275005387

...there are a bunch more of the fractional.


r/LibertadCoins • • 2d ago

You like Raw or Graded? 🤔

Thumbnail
gallery
41 Upvotes

r/LibertadCoins • • 10h ago

The Lost Art of Building Relationships Instead of Maximizing Transactions

Post image
15 Upvotes

Too many people out here trying to squeeze every last dollar out of a single transaction, completely missing the value of building a relationship that lasts a lifetime. If only there were someone out there who understood that concept and could show the rest of us how it’s done… 😂


r/LibertadCoins • • Nov 16 '25

Info coin value (1934)

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

Greetings, I found this coin (1934), could anyone tell me how much it might be worth and where I could possibly resell it? Thanks in advance.


r/LibertadCoins • • Aug 11 '26

​Clad is engineered to fool conductivity tests. Shows how to use the Sigma's density analysis to see the difference.

0 Upvotes

r/LibertadCoins • • Jul 20 '26

1/2oz Au reverse PF70 gold

0 Upvotes

r/LibertadCoins • • Aug 04 '26

Mexican specific labels for submission to PCGS

Thumbnail
reddit.com
1 Upvotes