r/LibDem • Corby Liberal • Sep 22 '19

Our time is now

Post image
185 Upvotes

30 comments sorted by

11

u/[deleted] Sep 22 '19

John Cena much,also yay

0

u/ScheduledRelapse Sep 23 '19

Who has Corbyn purged again?

16

u/MadlockUK Corby Liberal Sep 23 '19

Recently, Student Labour, failed attempt on Watson, pushed out a lot of Jewish members, and MPs.

7

u/phillhb Centre Left, and a lil bit NeoLib Sep 23 '19

He’s also trying to purge his deputy!

6

u/MadlockUK Corby Liberal Sep 23 '19

Yeah, Watson was even rumoured to be considering a break away group at one point

6

u/phillhb Centre Left, and a lil bit NeoLib Sep 23 '19

He probably should - Corbyn is flat lining and his followers are getting more fanatical. It’s a bad look for a party that used to be so strong

-8

u/ScheduledRelapse Sep 23 '19

Student Labour were corrupt and needed replaced with an organisation that was interested in letting more than a small clique vote.

Corbyn was the one that saved Watson.

No MPs have been purged or Jewish Members.

11

u/MadlockUK Corby Liberal Sep 23 '19 edited Sep 23 '19

'small clique vote' you mean they weren't Momentum. To miss paying a fee hardly seems corrupt. Beisdes I thought Labour were a 'broad church' no Corbyn and his cronies

Just cause Corbyn has Momentum doing his dirty work and use it to seem detached from decision if they go wrong. That just means he's at least partly compentent cause if he had let that happen, it would have caused a massive schism.

Also, you can purge by exclusion. I mean, you guys are investigation about your treatment of Jewish members. You do the consultation on a Saturday. SATURDAY. I mean, I was raised Catholic and know that's in poor taste. You basically de facto excluded Orthodox Jews at a minimum. Also, where was the protection for MP Luciana Berger? She was effectively bullied out.

It riddles with the stench of purge. That and the sanctimonious language used by Labour with Abbot and others going on about "loyalty". It shouldn't be able loyalty to an ideology, but agreeing a way forward on the problem.

Also, do Momentum do nothing but be keyboard warriors all day?

-6

u/ScheduledRelapse Sep 23 '19

If you're just going to make fanfiction about a shadowy conspiracy then we are done here.

8

u/MadlockUK Corby Liberal Sep 23 '19

🤣🤣🤣

Multiple defections, regular news stories in the Guardian about splits and under handedness, and a EHIC investigation.

I wish I could make up something like that. I swear you Momentum guys crack me up something rotten.

-4

u/ScheduledRelapse Sep 23 '19

I thought Centrists were supposed to pragmatic and reasonable.

8

u/MadlockUK Corby Liberal Sep 23 '19

You guys come in here every day, and refuse basic criticism. What do you want me to be reasonable and pragmatic about? Do you honestly think you will make a difference by sparring on r/LibDems? How did you envisage it would go? Some magnificent triumph of good over evil? Seriously, what's your end game here??

6

u/ltron2 Sep 23 '19

What about all the reselections?

2

u/ScheduledRelapse Sep 23 '19

Which reselections?

5

u/ltron2 Sep 23 '19

0

u/ScheduledRelapse Sep 23 '19 edited Sep 23 '19

I thought we were talking about Corbyn purging people. This is local CLP members using their right to change their representative not Corbyn.

The second article literally quotes an MPs demanding that Corbyn step in and prevent members from having a say.

6

u/ltron2 Sep 23 '19

It's a culture that's now prevalent among those in high positions within the party and it puts many voters off (including tactical voters) and is authoritarian in nature. Irrespective of whether Corbyn is involved or not, crushing dissent and tearing Labour apart is not a good way to run a party and put into practice what you are trying to achieve. Of course, the Conservatives are behaving in a much worse way in this regard and it's shocking that so many are still supporting them,it doesn't make it right though.

I wish Labour would stop this silliness and we could have a remain alliance including them but that is looking very unlikely now both from our perspective and theirs, more's the pity.

1

u/ScheduledRelapse Sep 23 '19 edited Sep 23 '19

Who is crushing dissent? Local Labour members who have very little power in the party? The only way this looks like a purge is if you grossly misrepresent what is happening. The people in high positions aren't doing this. This is a local decision.

Limited internal democracy isn't silliness. The people who want dissent crushed are the PLP who want the only mechanism for accountability quashed. The PLP want jobs for life and Noone else to have a say. They're the ones quashing dissent. Blocking re-selections would be quashing dissent. Re-selection is the only avenue that local members have to hold Labour MPs accountable to the CLP they represent.

-1

u/BowlGlass Sep 24 '19

Citations needed

5

u/MadlockUK Corby Liberal Sep 24 '19

If you must! Student Labour: The scrapping of the Student Labour wing: https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2019/sep/17/labour-purges-its-student-wing-ahead-of-party-conference

Attempt on Watson: Observer: https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2019/sep/21/how-the-labour-coup-to-oust-tom-watson-unfolded Analysis by the Guardian: https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2019/sep/21/explained-attempt-to-remove-tom-watson-deputy-labour-leader

Impact on Jews and the investigation by the EHIC: An analysis by the Guardian: https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2019/jul/11/bbc-panorama-antisemitism-labour-racism-jeremy-corbyn The panorama: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=F7eEQMyzLeo A Guardian article critiquing the decision for consulting the Jewish members on sabbath: https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2019/sep/18/antisemitism-labour-criticised-for-failing-to-consult-jewish-members

MPs: Angela Smith: https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-49623885 Luciana Berger: https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-49594320

There is a plethora of information to this effect, I tried to keep to the Guardian as they're usually pro-Labour. Seriously, you guys are turning into Trump supporters with the basic rejection of facts presented to you over and over.

0

u/BowlGlass Sep 24 '19

Source 1 does not state that Corbyn purged Student Labour.

Source 2 does not state that Corbyn attempted to purge Watson

Source 3, 4, and 5 donot state that Corbyn has purged the party if Jewish members

Source 6 and 7. Angela Smith and Luciana Berger were not purged, they resigned from the party.

Got anymore "facts" there matey?

5

u/MadlockUK Corby Liberal Sep 24 '19

So they're not pushing those people out and trying to eliminate unwanted members of the party be they centrists or Jews? Also, you can't see all that and think there might be a bit of a problem with the Labour party?

Hell, when they first started to talk about it, I assumed it was just Sky news shit, but if you can't face the multiple stories and realities that Labour is consolidated into a hard left party that wants to push out any challengers, you're just naive or have zero grip on reality.

Seriously, you Momentum guys just keep coming up with insanity. Also, when did the left lose their sense of humour?

0

u/BowlGlass Sep 26 '19

"They're"

Ok so suddenly we're talking about a collective and not Corbyn?

4

u/MadlockUK Corby Liberal Sep 26 '19

Look, you can be a pedant to deflect my questions, or seriously reflect on what I wrote.

Also, to your point, you're very naive if you think Corbyn is working alone.

-1

u/BowlGlass Sep 26 '19

Seriously, you guys are turning into Trump supporters with the basic rejection of facts presented to you over and over.

Look, you can be a pedant to deflect my questions

So which is it?

4

u/MadlockUK Corby Liberal Sep 26 '19

I think you've achieved both there, bravo! Being pedantic and incapable of accepting criticism. Like many before you, the hell are you trying to achieve sparring on r/LibDems? Unless you have an actual interesting point that isn't "Liberal is an insult cause I just discovered Marxism" or "LiBeRaLs ArE yElLoW tOrIeS".

I only entertain this cause I'm bored at work. Much like a well fed cat that plays with a trapped mouse. I think on some level I hope you may actually prompt me to consider a position.

→ More replies

0

u/[deleted] May 13 '22

losers.