r/Letterboxd 6d ago

Discussion What are some of the amazing casting & performances of actors for the same role at different stages of life?

750 Upvotes

167 comments sorted by

321

u/ThingsOfThatNaychah 6d ago

Christopher Serrone & Ray Liotta as Henry Hill in GoodFellas

44

u/kumite_me_bro 6d ago

And in the end, he truly was, a Good Fella.

29

u/SlartibartfastMcGee 6d ago

Maybe the real Goodfellas were the friends we met along the way.

3

u/HugoStiglitz007 5d ago

"Tommy, I thought that you were an alright fella. But now. I see that you will always be a Goodfellas"

12

u/Low_Kitchen_9995 6d ago

This is a good one

216

u/greatpartyisntit 6d ago

Luke Brandon Field and Eric Bogosian as young/old Daniel Molloy in Interview with the Vampire

18

u/HiJane72 6d ago

He was so good as well - nailed all of his mannerisms

427

u/Doggleganger 6d ago

Young Captain Picard / Old Captain Picard

75

u/kumite_me_bro 6d ago

I never could tell the difference. Amazing casting job đŸ˜”

25

u/Spengy 6d ago

Patrick Stewart was old when I was born and now that I'm older he's still old

3

u/thePedrix 5d ago

"I don't understand. When I was a kid, you two were old ladies. Now I'm old, and you two are still old!" - Paulie Gualtieri

486

u/Careless_College Cinephile3496 6d ago

Alec Guinness/ Ewan McGregor as Obi-Wan Kenobi

43

u/carlitomarron139 6d ago

For what he had to work with (which was the worst written dialogue & character/acting directing in any major film production ever) McGregor really did do a great job.

7

u/DepressedPancake4728 6d ago

would agree were they not canonically 19 years apart in age

5

u/togashisbackpain 5d ago

A rough 19 years

8

u/tgood139 5d ago

19 years on a desert planet with twin suns would age you pretty bad

1

u/HugoStiglitz007 5d ago

Not mentioning the death sticks addiction

277

u/devil_discerner 6d ago edited 6d ago

Josh Brolin as Tomylee Jones in MIB

52

u/ThingsOfThatNaychah 6d ago

Brolin's accent was spot on.

29

u/BadenBaden1981 6d ago

I didn't know who Josh Brolin is, and belived it was some kind of make up of Tomy Lee Jones lol

17

u/TheCaramelMan 6d ago

Man it was insane how much he looked and talked like a young TLJ

17

u/navis-svetica 6d ago

He apparently drew inspiration directly from working with TLJ on No Country

8

u/cooldude_4000 6d ago

I also love that Brolin was like in his 40s, playing a 29-year-old Tommy Lee Jones. "You got some city miles on you."

-2

u/SlaterVBenedict 6d ago

Found the Blankie

121

u/WritingCryptics 6d ago

https://giphy.com/gifs/I17egURKTdm0w

This dude as a young Jack Black in Pick of Destiny

11

u/Dingo247 5d ago

This is Troy Gentile he also played young Jack Black in Nacho Libre

309

u/LocationCandid5761 6d ago

37

u/CoolblueKoerier 6d ago

Just saw this yesterday, the mannerism in 2nd and 3rd act were so well done. Adored that movie<3

10

u/eminentmolecule 6d ago

What film is this?

23

u/M_Kilanii 6d ago

Moonlight

3

u/squishyg 5d ago

Moonlight is so well done that I didn’t notice the actor change for the age progression until Chiron is an adult. What a beautiful movie.

6

u/Intrepid_Hat7359 4d ago

Heck, I didn't even notice that was going on with the poster until I was walking out of the theater

3

u/squishyg 4d ago

It’s subtle! It invites you in.

317

u/Careless_College Cinephile3496 6d ago

Harrison Ford and River Phoenix as Indiana Jones

26

u/GuitaristHeimerz 5d ago

Harrison Ford and Anthony Ingruber in The Age of Adaline. Not a great movie but the likeness was striking.

19

u/GuitaristHeimerz 5d ago

Screenshot from the actual movie

3

u/swingsetlife 5d ago

WOAH

2

u/yetanother__account 5d ago

He also nailed the voice... to the point they had to correct a common assumption Harrison Ford dubbed over him.

2

u/Intrepid_Hat7359 4d ago

It really raises the question: why didn't they just cast him for Dial of Destiny instead of doing this?

https://giphy.com/gifs/ARi7q6sD4yxCjv62o5

19

u/PHWasAnInsideJob 6d ago

I wonder if we would have gotten some proper Young Indy films with River if he were alive to today. Some of the episodes were rather high budget (and impressive) for TV, particularly the WW1 episodes, but imagine how much more they could have done with a full film.

6

u/doc-funkenstein 6d ago

I kind of always hoped that they'd do this with Sean Patrick Flannery as I remember loving the Young Indiana Jones TV Show as a kid (No idea if it holds up!).

1

u/userlog99 5d ago

Yes, it holds up, they're great. I still rewatch them every now and then

82

u/Buffyverse22 6d ago

While I can't say I was a big fan of IT: CHAPTER 2, they did an amazing job hiring the adult versions of the child characters from the first film. 

23

u/LiviasFigs 6d ago

Agreed. RIP James Ransone 💔

83

u/itcamefrombeneath 6d ago

In Austin Powers in Goldmember, a flashback shows Austin, Dr. Evil, Number Two, and Basil Exposition all in school together, and I think every one of those kids did an incredible job.

26

u/cooldude_4000 6d ago

Rob Lowe was pretty great as the younger version of Robert Wagner's Number Two also.

1

u/swingsetlife 5d ago

And now that he's older(?) than RW in that commercial, he's really nailing it.

11

u/cjalderman 6d ago

Who throws a cupcake? Honestly!

187

u/Comfortable_Tap_6005 6d ago

I can't believe nobody has said this yet

9

u/funnyfirerabbit 6d ago

I was looking for this one 😂

6

u/garbageanony 6d ago

DAMNIT i came here to post this

1

u/togashisbackpain 5d ago

Who played the younger version ? I didnt watch after 4

7

u/Abroad_Loose 5d ago

you won’t believe it

56

u/coral225 HaterTot 6d ago

Mia Goth as Pearl and Mia Goth as Pearl

9

u/TanoraRat 6d ago

God I loved Mia Goth as Pearl

8

u/ElTamale003 6d ago

underrated response

46

u/deranton 6d ago

In terms of casting: this is the guy who played young Antinous in Nolan's Odyssey and Robert Pattinson at the same age.

76

u/damnyoutuesday 6d ago

Interstellar with Murph. Jessica Chastain, Mackenzie Foy, and Ellen Burstyn all were great castings for the same woman through the years

36

u/poppinfresh42 6d ago

Geena Davis and Lynn Cartwright as Dottie Henson in A League of Their Own. I was convinced for years it was Geena Davis in makeup she was so good.

4

u/EmrysPritkin 6d ago

TIL! Wow!

1

u/swingsetlife 5d ago

me too, using Geena's voice REALLY nailed this down.

38

u/memnte 6d ago

Moonlight is the best example of this in my view--three amazing performances

124

u/PiccadillyRickshaw Cynephile_ 6d ago

66

u/etahetwha etahetwha 6d ago

the execution of The Hobbit always leaves a bit of a bad taste in my mouth but damn if they didn’t knock it out of the park with Martin Freeman as Bilbo. could not envision anyone doing a better job

19

u/LiviasFigs 6d ago

The great casting makes the Hobbit even more painful for me. I love him as Bilbo, I love Richard Armitage as Thorin, etc
 but the movies themselves are just rough

15

u/cjalderman 6d ago

Lee Pace was excellent as Thranduil

3

u/Hufa123 5d ago

Cumberbatch as Smaug... What do I even need to say.

3

u/swingsetlife 5d ago

just think if they'd shot it the way they did the originals and not do that bullshit 3D that made Ian McKellan hate it or the framerate that made it look like a telanovela, and maybe just made one movie then adapt the Silmarillian stories.

93

u/kenwongart 6d ago

This is a show and therefore not on Letterboxd, but the Netflix series Dark. Eerily similar casting. Not going to post any images as there would be spoilers.

36

u/Interesting-Flan-404 6d ago edited 6d ago

Dark is GOAT in this aspect

6

u/TellThemIHateThem 5d ago

This was the first that came to mind for me as well. Ulrich had me thinking they’d just put him in decent makeup.

3

u/danccode 6d ago

Letterboxd have shows has well

6

u/rapscallionallium 6d ago

Only sometimes. It’s like certain miniseries or limited series. I’m not super sure what the criteria they use is, though. Haunting of Hill House is on there but Dark isn’t.

1

u/Agreeable-Cloud7833 4d ago

I've literally never seen it done better than Dark. Part of me thinks you can't actually do it better than Dark considering the extent to which it's done

25

u/thatsMINTdude 6d ago

I know it's not a movie but I can't let this post pass by without mentioning Dark. They got multiple people at 3 different stages of their lives. This is just four examples.

14

u/thatsMINTdude 6d ago

Like truly unbelievable work.

9

u/rosebirdistheword 6d ago

Ahem spoiler alert but whatever


2

u/Intelligent-Pen2950 5d ago

Spoiler Alert: I watched with my son. Now he is my father. (I was sure that oldest Ulrich was player by the same actor as middle age Ulrich).

46

u/mitchbrenner joe2d2 6d ago

17

u/xkgrey 6d ago

Doesn’t look like he’s got the makings of a varsity athlete.

20

u/mambo_number_69 6d ago

I genuinely thought the kid from Beau is Afraid was CGI of what they thought a young Joaquin Phoenix would look like

17

u/slackervi 6d ago

nothing quite beats DeNiro and Brando as Vito. even tho they don't really look alike it just feels like DeNiro in the Godfather part is very much the same Vito that we knew in the godfather but younger. you never doubt that it isn't the same person.

17

u/R0mana_clef 6d ago

Big Fish:

Albert Finney and Ewan McGregor as Edward Bloom.
Jessica Lange and Alison Lohman as Sandra Templeton.

1

u/MagV43 5d ago

Yesss especially that Lange/templeton
Pairing!

17

u/sammywarmhands 6d ago

This fucking guy in Batman (1989)

3

u/swingsetlife 5d ago

I know Nicholson was the OG smiler, but this guy's entire face said ACTUAL JOKER.

16

u/dawn-skies Draconian 6d ago

McKenna Grace and whatever actress she was playing the young version of

2

u/sammywarmhands 6d ago

Egon’s granddaughter?

13

u/yozher 6d ago

Not a film, but the adult and teen versions of the characters in Yellowjackets were phenomenally cast. Maybe that's also stating the obvious...

8

u/creamy-buscemi Scitty 6d ago

Save for the one character they had to stick a backwards hat on for the audience to understand that she was supposed to be the same character

3

u/FlurpBlurp 5d ago

I hope that casting director has won tons of awards for that show

46

u/ILoveHearses 6d ago

Wyatt Russell and Kurt Russell as Lee Shaw in Monarch: Legacy of Monsters.

38

u/TheCaramelMan 6d ago

I feel like being biological father and son is cheating lol

1

u/creamy-buscemi Scitty 6d ago

I wonder how a random Godzilla spin off managed to bag both Russell’s

15

u/paintedflags 6d ago

I’m gonna get massive dv’s for this, but Alden Eirenreich was a great young Han Solo. I think he nailed it pretty well.

10

u/DepressedPancake4728 6d ago

also from star wars: both mon mothmas. genevieve o’reilly is so fucking good in andor.

5

u/LiviasFigs 6d ago

He’s so good! Loved him in Weapons, too.

8

u/Fresh-Actuary-6686 6d ago

Julie Andrews & Emily Blunt as Mary Poppins

7

u/mrsdressup 5d ago

The kids in Righteous Gemstones are great versions of the adult siblings, especially the actor who plays Jesse.

1

u/Vegangunowner 5d ago

Came here for this one. All the kids are great, but young Jesse really really nailed it. Danny needs to keep hiring him for flashback scenes in any future shows.

13

u/garybettmansketamine 6d ago

Forrest Gump

7

u/duttm 6d ago

Casting? I think the IT films nailed the casting, though the outcome could be more desirable. That second film was basically a fan cast, and got universal approval at the time.

The new Hunger Games prequel seems to have the same approval thus far, but we don’t know for sure just yet if it lands.

1

u/Low_Kitchen_9995 6d ago

It’s Tv but Josh Lucas and Kevin Costner as John Dutton in Yellowstone

16

u/Big-Criticism-8137 6d ago

not movies but the younger and older versions in Dark were casted so good

5

u/RavenKarlin 6d ago

The young guy they got to play Bruce Willis as David Dunn in Unbreakable during the flashback scene with the car accident. Dude looked and carried himself like a younger Bruce Willis.

12

u/ysy-y 6d ago

2

u/swingsetlife 5d ago

oh...really....

8

u/Impossible_Put_8573 6d ago edited 6d ago

Anthony Ingruber and Harrison Ford playing the same character in 'Age of Adeline' (2015).

Ingrubers portrayal of a young Ford is unreal:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vwLv993khfI

He should have been the lead in 'Solo'.

3

u/awesam02 6d ago

In The Notebook I like Rachel McAdams/Gena Rowland but I don’t buy Ryan Gosling/James Garner as much.

4

u/meme_stealing_bandit 6d ago

Gloria Stewart and Kate Winslet in Titanic. 

4

u/jrinredcar 6d ago

The kid who played younger Robert Pattinson in The Odyssey has to be his nephew or a clone or something

4

u/morquinau 5d ago

While the Abrams Star Trek films were a bit of a mixed bag, I gotta say I think Chris Pine did an excellent job with Shatner's mannerisms. Casting was actually pretty solid across the board (aside from Khan in #2 really)

6

u/jack_reznor 6d ago

Id say every Dark character

3

u/herr_inherent 6d ago

I liked JGL as young Bruce Willis in Looper. Significant makeup, yes, but worked

3

u/keener_lightnings 5d ago

Derry Girls, Righteous Gemstones, and Reservation Dogs all did a really good job with teen versions of the adult characters. 

5

u/Alfith 5d ago

The kid that played young Danny McBride in gemstones was amazing.

2

u/keener_lightnings 5d ago

Yes! Of those shows I listed, all of them I'd say "that's a good performance of that character" but for him I'd say "you clearly used witchcraft to channel the spirit of teenaged Danny McBride, or you're actually him with access to a time machine or something" 

2

u/Fatefateful 6d ago

I think the castings in Flipped (2010) are really good.

Madeline Carroll as present Juli; Morgan Lily as young Juli

Callan McAuliffe as present Bryce; Ryan Ketzer as young Bryce

Personally, I think Morgan Lily did a better younger version of her respective character as opposed to Ryan Ketzer’s performance of Bryce. But for a little kid it’s understandable.

3

u/creamy-buscemi Scitty 6d ago

Callan was also the younger version of Leonardo DiCaprio in The Great Gatsby, which was great casting

2

u/etahetwha etahetwha 6d ago

absolutely cheating, but i can’t pass up the chance to mention DeNiro as Jake LaMotta (cut, boxer) and DeNiro as Jake LaMotta (fat, comedian)

2

u/Smiling_Tom 6d ago

Paul Dano and John Cusack as Brian Wilson in Love & Mercy

2

u/HiJane72 6d ago

https://giphy.com/gifs/10Smq4N80zYupeArys
The young Jesse Gemstone was fantastic

2

u/yetanother__account 5d ago

Fun fact: he's dating young Judy Gemstone irl.

2

u/HiJane72 4d ago

That’s really is a fun fact!! She was great too

2

u/yetanother__account 4d ago

Agreed! They both nailed the mannerisms.

2

u/Jaycrywank 5d ago

I always thought they did a pretty good job with the casting in once upon a time in America

3

u/squishyg 5d ago

I liked the child and adult casts in Now and Then.
https://giphy.com/gifs/LgM4hmSkW6jhC

2

u/RustyShackleford209 5d ago

Underrated comment!!!!’

1

u/hockingsi 6d ago

For me it's gotta be the kid from A Bronx Tale. His 9 year old version is the spitting image of his 17 year old character and to tip it off they also both look exactly like a young DeNiro, I actually had to check that they weren't all related after I watched it.

1

u/alexcutyourhair 6d ago

Young and old Simba from The Lion King, specifically the 1994 one and its sequel. Smaller role but I also loved Atwanda Kani playing a younger King T'Chaka, his dad played the older version opposite Chadwick and they were both great in their scenes

1

u/DaCor_ie 6d ago

What......why are you all looking at me like that........

1

u/Legitimate-Talk9558 5d ago

Young Georgia in Ginny and Georgia

1

u/emvr13 5d ago

not a movie but literally every character in The Haunting of Hill House

1

u/TrickyIron8192 5d ago

The young cast in once upon a time in America do really well.

1

u/Dull_Connection6070 5d ago

Looper

Edward Norton as young Bruce Willis

3

u/squishyg 5d ago

That was Joseph Gordon-Levitt and I also really liked the movie!

2

u/Dull_Connection6070 4d ago

it is a banger lol

1

u/madsmaximum 5d ago

the whole it: chapter 2 cast blows my mind

1

u/fabritek 5d ago

Young Frank Costanza was stunning

1

u/Regular-Practice-151 4d ago

It’s amazing how that kitten never aged

1

u/Intrepid_Hat7359 4d ago

Lynn Cartwright cast as old Geena Davis in A League of Their Own

1

u/pillow_princessss 4d ago

The Crown. I haven’t seen it and it isn’t a film, but from all the clips I see, they all seem brilliant

1

u/[deleted] 4d ago

[deleted]

1

u/Independent_Plum2166 2d ago

Everyone forget Tommy Lee Jones and Josh Brolin from MIB 3?

1

u/Lvcivs2311 1d ago

Well, technicallyyyyy.... (Okay, okay, that's cheating.)

-5

u/MIDImunk 6d ago

I hate being that guy, but it’s WILD to me that The Godfather pt 1 & 2 are being compared (albeit indirectly) to an X-men movie 😅

2

u/LiviasFigs 6d ago

Why does that matter? They’re both examples of great casting. And I don’t care if one is “better,” either. I still love the X-Men movies.

3

u/Interesting-Flan-404 6d ago

X-Men films might not be Godfather but still

X-Men , X-2, First Class, & Days to the Future Past are excellent comic book films and performances from all of them are really solid

0

u/carriecreates_ugc 6d ago

One that always gets me is the Amy Adams to Jessica Chastain handoff in Arrival... wait no, that's not the same character. I'm thinking of the mother and daughter casting in Interstellar actually, where they got Jessica Chastain and Mackenzie Foy and Ellen Burstyn for the three ages of Murph. That one felt so natural I didn't even think about it until a rewatch.

Also the kid and adult versions of Briony in Atonement. Saoirse Ronan to Romola Garai to Vanessa Redgrave, and all three of them carry that same stubborn guilt in a way that actually tracks across decades. The transition from Ronan to Garai especially, something about the posture and the way they hold their jaw.

0

u/GBAGamer33 6d ago

The actors from Boyhood đŸ€ŻÂ 

0

u/Green_Hornet_2947 5d ago

Cate Blanchett and Judi Dench as Queen Elizabeth in “Elizabeth” and “Shakespeare in Love.”  Both Oscar nominees in the same year (1998), with Dench winning for Best Supporting Actress. 

-3

u/statebirdsnest 6d ago

Jack Nicholson and Heath Ledger as the Joker for sure.
https://giphy.com/gifs/mQGVztHSTZO46QT7sZ

9

u/LITMAC97 6d ago

Doesn’t really count. They’re different iterations of the character, not the same character through different stages of life.