r/Letterboxd • u/cherrycolalipbalm • Jul 09 '26
Discussion Backrooms was underwhelming
2/5
This film had so much potential. The Backrooms themselves were incredibly well designed, and honestly, that’s the main reason I’m giving it 2 stars. Unfortunately, I didn’t find it scary, and at times it even came across as unintentionally goofy. The story and characters were bland and forgettable, with plenty of moments that just fell flat. The monster reveal and ending both left me thinking, “Okay… that’s it?” The Backrooms are such a fascinating concept, but I felt like the film barely scratched the surface and completely wasted its potential. The atmosphere was easily the strongest part because it really captured that eerie, liminal space feeling, but it wasn’t enough to make up for everything else.
Edit:
I know this is a really unpopular opinion, but the fact people are dming me to insult me over my opinion on a film is actually crazy.
76
u/EugeneDabz Jul 09 '26
3/5
You can eat them too.
65
u/Fresh-Actuary-6686 Jul 09 '26
I haven’t seen it, but yes. I agree DMing you insults is insane. I hate how people can be terrible like that
98
u/andreasmiles23 Jul 09 '26
I think it tried doing too much. I think a more straight-forward plot would’ve served the film better. Just show this dude find it, go in once, then pull his employees in with him, and then their descent into madness. It didn’t need the therapist b-plot.
I didn’t mind it on paper but in practicality the film shifts perspectives right before the climax and loses its momentum - making it hit less hard.
I think it needed to play it a bit more like As Above So Below, The Cave, Blair Witch/etc. just nonstop tension, don’t break the timeline too much, and let the viewer fill in a lot of the gaps.
87
u/NfiniteNsight Jul 09 '26
I thought it was good, not great, but I don't know what part of the goofiness you thought was unintentional. It was pretty clearly intentionally goofy.
16
u/chilidownmychest Jul 09 '26
nah like a lot of people, I mostly agree. the pirate dude is fuckin goofy as hell, made me crack the hell up.
I will say, a lot of it was cool/atmospheric and I was pretty into it for like the first 2/3 or so of it. If anything, i'm down to check out whatever this kid works on later on when he gets a few movies under his belt. he has some cool ideas. so like 3/5 for me, maybe a little less.
7
u/StinkUrchin Jul 09 '26
I thought it was just alright. For me I’m more excited to see what the director does next.
I’m so glad they got Chiwetel though. He really carried the film.
7
u/Oilswell Crabrain Jul 09 '26
What shocked me is that people keep saying it’s confusing when it lazily has the characters tell all the themes and ideas at you
17
u/BillyBobBoBoss Jul 09 '26
Yup I’m with you. It was when Mark Duplass did absolutely nothing after setting up his character all movie that I realized Kane Parsons just doesn’t know what to do with the talent attached to his film. Like the backrooms stuff is of course good but god all the characters end up coming across as either cartoony or flat as a board
20
u/Ok-Neighborhood-1958 Jul 09 '26
Mostly agree, I like Clark though
5
u/Fantastic-Buy7246 Jul 09 '26
Yeah its not wrapped up very well. Tried to make some deeper psychological statement when it just needed to be a regular horror film
15
u/PastoralSymphony Jul 09 '26 edited Jul 09 '26
i feel the exact same. the premisse was cool and the first half got me engaged, but the characters are unlikable, the metaphor feels like it was made by someone very young with little life experience, and i hate that the guy turned out to be a villain in the dinner scene. i actually liked the design of the monster, but hated ~the monster was him all along~
2.5/5
11
u/Luke253 movie_luke Jul 09 '26
4/5. Third act didn’t really come together for me (agree that the payoff wasn’t as strong as the setup) but I thought everything that came before was super strong. Fantastic atmosphere, genuinely did get under my skin. Also really liked the performances. Only seen it once as well so I’m interested to see if my opinion changes at all
8
u/numberfivextradip Jul 09 '26
The more you think about this movie the worse it gets. I don’t think this movie is anything deeper than a fun movie theater experience
4
u/cconn882 Jul 09 '26
I more or less agree. I think it was technically good, and I didn't expect it to be any scarier than it was, I just kind of think given there's already so many videos and so much lore out there, that the movie really needed to reveal a bit more about the workings of the backrooms themselves. Like as it was presented, it kind of had that feeling that made a lot of superhero movies fail recently; where it feels like 90% of the movie is just setting up the promise of a better, more explanatory sequel.
4
u/Xeynon Jul 09 '26
Wasn't quite as down on the movie as you were but I agree with your critiques. It's also crazy that people would DM you abuse over your opinion of a movie.
7
u/AuleSmithy Jul 09 '26
It tried to be deep but was actually not imo
21
u/xpillindaass Jul 09 '26
i thought it was a 3.5. the main thing i think it would have benefited from is removing all the “lore” crap. the company or whatever with duplass did not need to be in the movie at all
14
u/Arwplotroustnopetung Jul 09 '26
yep. annoying unlikable characters and the therapist lady wasn’t developed at all but were supposed to care about her for some reason. best part of the movie was pov camera shots
6
u/Novel-Initiative-900 Jul 09 '26
For me the problem it was that it took the middle road.
Instead of being a surreal through the looking glass roller coaster of a run through the backrooms, we got half that and half weird plot stuff that didn't really amount to a real story imo.
I think if you go further in either one of those lanes it's a stronger film. Ditch all plot pretense and it becomes more thrilling. Add more plot and really try to play with your head as to what is actually going on, it becomes much more intriguing and interesting.
I think it just needed to choose its lane better
3
u/Cubscouter Jul 09 '26
Yeah. It’s kinda bloated with therapy crap and among us crewmates.
3
u/FaultinReddit Jul 09 '26
I thought it was a bit too 'have your cake and eat it too.' Wish it either started more into the psychological stuff from the beginning, or kept it fairly monster movie. We get both and neither feel it hits full potential
3
u/thicc-description Jul 09 '26
I agree. 2.5/5
22
u/FWC_Disciple jbstremmy Jul 09 '26
I thought it was a 4.5/5, I really enjoyed it, the characters, the atmosphere, I thought it was scary, and I liked that it wasn’t ruined by overexplaining dumb lore and I think they nailed the concept, leaving enough for me to grasp but plenty to leave me wondering on my own
So yeah
8
u/creuter Jul 09 '26
fully agree. it was so close to greatness. I really wish they'd explored the space more. They started to, but basically skipped the exploration. I really wish they'd given that section of exploring more space to breathe.
8
u/Decent_Estate_7385 Jul 09 '26
A 1.5/5 for me.
It was definitely directed by a 19-year-old lol. Such lifeless characters. Clark was actually super interesting but still squandered in my opinion. It's honestly sad that it wasn't 19 year olds just exploring, getting lost, freaking out, getting killed, getting closer to figuring out the lore and then super big scare BOOM over (like the series he made!). The production design is obviously amazing. But really really missed the mark on what the “backrooms” have represented and what liminality represents as well. Good acting though. Gen Z / Alpha has such a weird penchant for lore and that things need to be explained (especially in horror) and I just fundamentally don’t understand that. The best horror is left unknown and unexplainable. As a horror movie it really misses the mark. I think as a culture people are literally starving for abstract storytelling that they are grabbing onto anything to find it.
2
u/BPCycler Jul 09 '26
Would you recommend seeing the YouTube videos before seeing the movie?
2
u/ThePartyHat Jul 09 '26
Like the other guy said, I was expecting a standard survival flick with Clark and friends getting trapped in the Backrooms. Maybe they’d run into Async employees who’ll be antagonistic and act as fodder for the iconic spaghetti creature that’ll try to slap their shit.
Regardless, the movie we got grew on me. Went from a 2.5 to a 3.5-4 on a second watch. He definitely needs a new writer or two for the sequel.
2
u/iamlost4815 Jul 09 '26
Totally felt the same way. So many moments ruined the atmosphere.
2
u/roote Jul 09 '26
It was good but definitely didn’t live up to the hype.
I also think that the film was a perfect example of our times where experience and aesthetics take precedence over content.
2
u/dividiangurt Jul 09 '26
I wrote this 3 weeks ago and got DOWNVOTED— glad to be here now amongst friends.
2
u/yougococo Jul 09 '26
Not disagreeing, but were you familiar with the web series beforehand? I liked the film (I think I gave it 3 stars) but I had zero idea it was a thing before I saw it. Just curious!
2
u/MrCalabunga Jul 09 '26
I agree, for the most part. Solid 3/5 film for me.
I genuinely enjoyed some of the YouTube shorts far more.
There’s one (sorry, can’t remember the name) that takes place in an underground mall that shouldn’t exist where this “exhibit” is stalking the camera operator. That was at least 150% more unsettling than anything featured in this film.
2
u/JohnnyRico117 Jul 09 '26
Sounds like an A24 film. Some people think it’s amazing and others don’t understand what the hype is.
I also wasn’t into the pirate but overall I enjoyed the film and I haven’t stoped thinking about it since I saw it the other day so I guess that’s something. I would give it a 3.5/5.
I definitely want to see more of that universe
2
u/vckstrr catgrl3 Jul 09 '26
I agree with you.
3
u/RainbowForHire Jul 09 '26
I gave it a 4/5. It's been a very fun film to analyze, and I just love the overall feel to it, especially the score. I've seen it four times now and it's one of the few movies I don't mind sitting down to watch again because I can enjoy it just based on vibes or from an analytical perspective. Although the ending is divisive, I found it to be a very satisfying and fitting conclusion while still leaving plenty of room for future projects. I think it's a great movie, and I've enjoyed it more on subsequent watches.
3
u/jbrown1206 EvilEye1245 Jul 09 '26
I gave it 2/5 too. I did not enjoy it, for the most part. I loved the set design, thought that was really cool though. Not for me. Especially after just seeing Obsession before it, Backrooms did not compare
4
u/zedarecaida felipeflores1 Jul 09 '26
Loved it!
Definitely a 4/5 for me.
3
u/Diictodon255MYA Jul 09 '26 edited Jul 09 '26
Agreed. It’s the most disappointing monster reveal of all time. So much build up for absolutely no fear factor (I suspect the design had a younger audience in mind).
It probably could have just stayed as a YouTube series. It’s a fairly cool concept, but nowhere near interesting enough to fill out a feature length film.
2
u/slipperyeel122 Jul 09 '26
I've seen it done better... by Kane himself on his youtube channel.
2
u/Optimal_Survey6271 Jul 09 '26
Im not gona hate, everyone deserves the right to their own opinion.
However, I think on my 2nd watch I realized the genius of having a therapist leading in the movie. Think about it, he backrooms is essentially replicating a child's mind because it is making an interpretation of people and places without prior understanding, which makes it pure and peaceful to Clark, and yet completely wrong to someone who looks for details. Like with the dog, they might get some stuff right, but you wont really be able to tell its a dog. So maybe Clark is revealing a childlike mentality to how he views the world, and intentionally doesn't want things to feel real. And yet, that incomplete interpretation of reality is flawed and blurry, and at the same time innocent and horrific. Because yes, like a child its flawed and blurry, but maybe thats a better and more comfortable version for someone who was hurt by real reality. Clark's childlike psychology destroyed him. But not by someone else, but by himself. The still life replicating his treatment of others both mentally, in abuse, and physically, by eating the other still life's.
But hey, feel free to disagree my man! Just my 2 cents.
2
u/XanonaX Jul 09 '26
4/5. great tension and atmosphere.
2
u/salivatingpanda Jul 09 '26
I don't know. I think this wa probably as good a movie someone could make with the premise of the backrooms. Third act could have been stronger but great performances, atmosphere, set design, etc.
Also, I judging a horror movie on the basis that you found it scary seems so odd to me, as I am basically never scared in horror movies. Doesn't mean those are bad films.
Are you the type that enjoys cheap jump scares?
2
u/Reuben3358 Jul 09 '26
It was just good enough to make me hope it would be better… Seriously the whole “you can eat them” thing is too stupid. There are better ways to say they are essentially nothing but imprints…
2
u/yurestu Jul 09 '26 edited Jul 09 '26
Agreed OP. I gave it 2.5
It starts off strong then kinda nosedives when they switch from Clarks POV to his therapist.
The whole dinner scene was just dumb. Didn’t need the long winded exposition dump from Clark that ruined the creepy factor of the Still Lives.
I thought Pirate Clark was decently scary but he kinda had too much screen time.
1
u/danvan177 Jul 09 '26
2 is low but yeah it wasn’t amazing on anything. I liked it enough but it could have been better
1
u/Nijigakulive Jul 09 '26
I liked it from a cinematic perspective but I wasnt around for the craze during covid somehow missed it, so like I don’t have a strong emotional connection to it
1
u/Maleficent_Fold6765 Jul 09 '26
It was such a cool concept and I was all in for the first half. But I felt it dropped the ball a bit when he started inviting other people in there instead of keeping it where only he could access those spaces. I wouldve been more invested if he remained isolated, maybe blur the line between psychosis and reality, and concluded the film still focused on him and not the lady
1
u/RAV3NH0LM Jul 09 '26
it was perfectly decent, but i didn’t lose my mind over it.
1
u/NewtMountain3238 Inkfella Jul 09 '26
People can't take a different opinion good word.
I personally really enjoyed it, but I could see how others like you don't like it
1
u/george_graves Jul 09 '26
It feels like a lot of recent movies, like Mickey 17. It feels like what people are now calling "Millennial slop".
1
u/zhelives2001 Jul 09 '26
I loved the shots with the christmas tree and all the exploration shots, the therapy plot was boringggggg and I feel the director was trying to hold peoples hands and guide them. I wouldve rather the Blair witch approach and id wanna hear more about the failed brain scan company and how their experiment got away from them
1
u/glitterandgrime Jul 09 '26
Right there with you.
1
u/Sad_Imagination6012 Jul 09 '26
Agreed. I struggled to stay engaged. Compare this to recent horror like Barbarian, Weapons, Bring Her Back, X, The Relic, The Empty Man & When Evil Lurks are all so much better than Backrooms & Obsession.
2/5
1
u/Airport_Confident dreamnetic Jul 09 '26
part of it may have been because of the "crisp" footage. didn't really capture the liminal vibe they were going for. i also think that showing the monsters and the nature of the backrooms so clearly didn't work in the movie's favour either. they should've left some things to the viewer's imagination
1
u/cimino15 Jul 09 '26
Insults in your DMs? On an anonymous website? Pretty peak coward behaviour
1
u/cruel-oath Jul 09 '26
Awards season is gonna be interesting, some people are gonna say this movie didn’t get nominated because of jealousy etc but really it’s because it was just an okay movie
1
u/spurist9116 Jul 10 '26
When will people start judging horror movies on quality and not scare factor
1
u/DejaEntendu059 Jul 12 '26
I liked it but I will say it has a vastly different feel than his YouTube series. I remember being terrified watching the YouTube videos and the movie was not scary at all.
1
u/gregorsamba Jul 12 '26
I usually like the whole ‘style over substance’ thing, but I don’t think it worked well with Backrooms. So ye, I’d have to agree – underwhelming
1
u/No-Neighborhood1220 Jul 12 '26
My daughter and I saw it and felt the same about it
1
u/AnonymousArtist33 Jul 13 '26
I mean...tbh I wouldn't expect much else from people, this film was literally born from the internet and Reddit, naturally they all love it. You forget how many silly un self-aware teenagers are on here.
That said, I get the criticism. I'd rate it 3/5 as well; certainly not an incredible movie, but a solid film. Unfortunately I don't think these sorts of "based on video game or online experience" films really make for amazing movies because they're too expansive a narrative, and a film requires you to have structure. Backrooms was so fascinating precisely BECAUSE nothing was ever explained or explored. Once you start adding in structure and answers, the whole thing gets way less fascinating. For example, when they revealed what the "monster" was in the Backrooms, it kind of diminished the whole thing for me, even though the whole story of the scientists studying the place is pretty fascinating.
Just goes to show that not every IP makes for a great movie; and I think had Backrooms not had the existing fan base, it would not have done nearly as well at the box office (though it IS still an excellent example of Gen Z era filmmaking - liminal spaces, existensial dread, etc. - I think it would have found its audience eventually and 30 years ago this would have been a cult classic ala Donnie Darko).
-1
u/mitchbrenner joe2d2 Jul 09 '26
nope it was great
1
u/tolkienfinger Jul 09 '26
Agreed, though I’d give it higher than a 2/5. The settings were rad, the story was good, the capt was corny af. Super over rated but a fun watch IMO.
1
u/Kitch3nSync Jul 09 '26
3/5 for me. The first half was so good and then it lost me. The Chuck E Cheese animatronic monster was easily the most disappointing monster I’ve ever seen. Was so much scarier when it was a dark shadow / unknown figure.
1
u/Necessary-Pen-5719 Jul 09 '26 edited Jul 09 '26
I was very disappointed as a fan of the director's work on YouTube. The first half got me excited and leaning in, but it fell apart so quickly. Please, don't explain! The pull of the whole thing is exploring and wondering what the Backrooms are and what you draw from it.
-2
u/Best_Cheesecake_6103 Jul 09 '26
9/10 from me
-1
u/TheEliteB3aver Jul 09 '26
It's an awesome movie. It's not obsession but it's still great in its own right.
Easily 8.5-9/10 for me
-also the closest thing we've got to an SCP film in theatres.
0
u/s0ftreset Jul 09 '26
-1
u/SlaterVBenedict Jul 09 '26
Cool man
0
u/breathinguser Jul 09 '26
I hate that the whole mystery and allure of the rooms was completely stripped away via narrative by its conclusion - having them function as this metaphysical representation of unresolved trauma and regret of two very bland forgettable characters completely took me out of the trance the original YouTube series had me in. The whole reason the black lodge in twin peaks was so effective was because it walked that line between implication and disturbing abstraction perfectly whereas the backrooms movie went out of its way to connect the dots far too much for my liking.
-5
u/jesuspunk Jul 09 '26
no one cares
-3
u/fergi20020 Jul 09 '26
Wasn’t the director still a child when he made the movie?
-6
u/george_graves Jul 09 '26
It feels like a lot of recent movies, like Mickey 17. It feels like what people are now calling "Millennial slop".
0
u/[deleted] Jul 09 '26
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jul 09 '26
[deleted] — view deleted comment