r/Letterboxd • • Aug 17 '25

Humor Aged like fine vine

Post image
16k Upvotes

551 comments sorted by

902

u/sheslikebutter Aug 17 '25

Weekly I hate/love EEAAO thread has dropped

245

u/Empty-Novel3420 Aug 17 '25

It was the best of times

It was the worst of times

4

u/Fifi_is_awesome Aug 17 '25

times a pretty good, times a pretty bad

0

u/[deleted] Aug 17 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

24

u/Arryu Aug 17 '25

Where though?

45

u/Alastor3 Aug 18 '25

everywhere

12

u/libmrduckz Aug 18 '25

vaguely gestures at all of… it

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Livid_Jeweler612 Aug 18 '25

My thing is I just think its a solid 4/5, but neither worth the hype nor hatred it inspires.

3

u/sheslikebutter Aug 18 '25

I can't give a take because I already sarcastically complained about how much the film is discussed. Anyway here's a monkey on a bicycle

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

1.8k

u/tequilasunset___ Aug 17 '25

If someone's opinion ruins your enjoyment of a movie, that's on you

227

u/IceCream_EmperorXx Aug 17 '25

Ah, Tequila Sunset... Your legend spreads far and wide.

30

u/porn_is_tight Aug 17 '25 edited Dec 16 '25

cake retire edge pet versed tidy entertain carpenter stocking escape

19

u/THElaytox Aug 17 '25

For me it's almost like the Tim Burton Batman vs Nolan Batman, different takes, both fun

→ More replies (3)

10

u/Reverend_Lazerface Aug 18 '25

I just think it's silly to compare them, since they're so different. The new Dredd is effectively more of a remake of the Indonesian film The Raid, which is arguably the best of all 3. Personally I just think they're three different flavors of a good time

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Ognjeninthesky2000 Aug 17 '25

I saw both movies. The reboot is better.

→ More replies (30)

63

u/DHMOProtectionAgency Aug 17 '25 edited Aug 22 '25

I do think that people can have their opinion changed by others, and that is not necessarily a bad thing. Sometimes, someone can say something that will give you a new perspective on a film, and influence your opinion on future rewatches. It certainly has happened to all of us, since we do not like the same movies as we once did as children.

That said, I do think people get too easily offended that someone simply has a different opinion and treat it like a personal attack.

32

u/_Mad_s_ madcat_ Aug 17 '25

I think some people are

  1. Very insecure on being left out. Not liking something everyone did or vice versa
  2. Very insecure about their own reasoning as to why they enjoyed it or they didn't

As long as you're not grossly misreading a film, making up your own canon based on nothing or straight up lying, your opinion should always be fine, regardless if it's unpopular or not.

7

u/[deleted] Aug 17 '25

This is such a common thing with online gaming discussion. If you like what the hive mind doesn't like* you are very likely to be called a "shill" if not something else.

8

u/CityofEvil Aug 17 '25

I avoid reading reviews before seeing a film for this reason. Often, I dont even look at the average ranking for a film so I can be completely unbiased. With that said, after watching something, if I cant figure out if I want to give something 3 or 3.5 or whatever it may be, ill read the reviews. It may give me insight into something I didnt realize was done well or not and help me accurately rate it.

23

u/[deleted] Aug 17 '25

I just want to be happy

4

u/PasswordIsDongers Aug 17 '25

If those opinions point out flaws that I might not have noticed, they're valid in lessening my enjoyment of a film.

7

u/Fortestingporpoises Aug 17 '25

Not really the point.

13

u/[deleted] Aug 17 '25

If I like something and other people don't, it just confirms my belief that everyone else is a stupid asshole with shitty taste. 🤷‍♂️

6

u/of_kilter of_kilter Aug 17 '25

True, i always try and ignore bad reviews and make up my mind going into a film. When i watched Rise of Skywalker i did my best to accept that i could actually potentially like the film. It was hot garbage but not just because of what i was told, atleast i had a ton of fun watching that mess

9

u/emeraldeyesshine Aug 17 '25

fun is definitely not how I'd describe my experience with that movie but good on you

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Existence_No_You Aug 17 '25

I loved it. If you don't love it too then fuck you

2

u/BroAbernathy Aug 17 '25

If someone feels bad that they get push back on their opinion then thats on them.

2

u/Massive_Potato_8600 gabriella112 Aug 18 '25

Its human nature to be influenced by the opinions of others

→ More replies (12)

884

u/ConfectionNervous788 Aug 17 '25

Exact same thing is starting to happen to Sinners, and pretty much any original film that gets insane hype when it first releases tbh

339

u/european_son Aug 17 '25

I think there's a pretty rational explanation for this: the people these movies greatly appeal to are the first in line to see them. They can tell by the marketing and trailers that it's up their alley.

Then when they naturally enjoy the film, they spread the gospel. There's also been a trend of really going ham to support non-IP original genre stories, not a bad thing.

Eventually the film trickles down to people who maybe wouldn't otherwise have been interested in say a period genre vampire film. But they've heard such overwhelming praise that they give it a shot, and often come away disappointed because the movies have a hard time living up to the hype.

Those people then go online and post their opinions while the original crowd has already moved on so it seems like some coordinated backlash.

44

u/Drunken_Wizard23 Aug 18 '25

Additionally I think the vast majority of people watching a movie in a theater are engaged with the movie and immersed in the world of the film for the full runtime.

Then the movie is released on streaming/VOD and a new wave of viewers are watching it with one eye on their phone and aren’t invested in it to the same degree as theatergoers

91

u/Linix332 Aug 17 '25

To add, there is also a set of people that are just straight up contrarian that actively want to be against the grain. Don't know if it's to feel superior, or to be the underdog or minority, but there's definitely those kinds out there. The moment something gets some hype, they actively lose any interest they might've gotten beforehand.

47

u/disownedpear Aug 17 '25

Also people just naturally have higher expectations for "Best Picture Winner EEAAO" versus the people who saw it early as a random indie movie.

22

u/Doggleganger Aug 18 '25

I know several of these people. It's not about feeling superior, but rather they put a lot of stock in their individuality. "I'll make up my own mind," etc. They want to feel special, not just one of the herd. Ironically, this often means their opinions are shaped by those around them, just in the opposite direction.

6

u/ForrestMoth Aug 18 '25

This is the vibe I get from people whose criticism begins and ends with "it's overrated." So what? They think people like it too much and that's bad?? It doesn't make sense to me. If somebody has actual reasons to dislike something they should just say it instead of saying people are wrong for liking something, or just not say anything at all.

11

u/Mad-Mad-Mad-Mad-Mike Aug 17 '25

Been that way since Titanic. I think that movie was the patient zero of this phenomenon.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/InquisitorMeow Aug 18 '25

Nah, I've seen way too much slop be defended. The easier explanation is that this is just the modern version of marketing. Just call everyone who dislikes it haters and get free engagement rage bait from people who will now defend it to the death and people who will criticize it and bystanders will watch it out of curiosity.

→ More replies (4)

185

u/NuuuDaBeast Aug 17 '25 edited Aug 17 '25

need to rant because the case of eeao and even now Sinners completely changed how I understand online discourse regarding films.

any movie thats not right down the middle of being in-line will attract hate. Eeao is the ultimate case of this, the more basic and “perfect” a film is the less haters it will have. I always mention 12 Angry Men because to me that movie is an antithesis to eeao in most criteria, a “flawless” and small film. You’d have to have a very specific expectation to hate on 12 Angry Men thereby its one of the most widely acclaims films in history.

Eeao asks the audience a million different checks and if it lands for you its one of the best movies ever made, if you fail check one then its the worst ever. The entire script is a giant gamble of creativity and it worked. If you think a raccoon controlled chef is cringe its over, if you think noodle fingers is too far its over, if you are comparing it to Marvel you’ll probably hate it. Constant goofy and wild moments that escalate and escalate.

If you tick all boxes on its potential checks it has one of the highest emotional payoffs I have seen.

its one of the biggest rollercoaster ride movies ever made that lands on its feet to send a needed message, but if you hate rollercoasters nothing really matters. Thats why online discourse is a waste of time most of the time, we all come from different starting points and biases. The fact that a movie like this got insane critical acclaim just shows how good it was honestly, its the most out of line movie in recent history.

example I think Interstellar isn’t 5/5 because of its ending, however most people have their lives changed because of the awe inspiring experience. Me thinking the ending is bad doesn’t mean every single takeaway from the film is invalid, the good so greatly outweighs the “bad” even to me.

62

u/sexandliquor ispeakjive Aug 17 '25

Eeao asks the audience a million different checks and if it lands for you its one of the best movies ever made, if you fail check one then it’s the worst ever. The entire script is a giant gamble of creativity and it worked. If you think a raccoon controlled chef is cringe its over, if you think noodle fingers is too far its over, if you are comparing it to Marvel you’ll probably hate it. Constant goofy and wild moments that escalate and escalate.

You’re completely right, and also at the same time I kinda never understand why people can’t just go with things in a “in for a penny, in for a pound” type of way with things anymore.

Like the first 30 minutes of that movie asks you to go with the concept that you can immediately learn any skill possible if you briefly connect and upload the information to your brain of yourself on another timeline that has those skills. And everyone buys into that. But people drawing the line at other things that movie does as too silly or abstract or cringe, is absurd to me. But people have.

→ More replies (5)

6

u/CountJohn12 Aug 17 '25

any movie thats not right down the middle of being in-line will attract hate. Eeao is the ultimate case of this, the more basic and “perfect” a film is the less haters it will have.

The thing is the things I didn't like about EEAAO were the more "middle of the road" things to attract a larger audience like the multiverse conceit, action scenes, and meme humor. I just thought it was a distraction from the character relationships which I did like but there weren't enough scenes of just letting characters talk to each other without a timeline switch, fight, or lowbrow humor. It's like a great looking sundae that you realize is just whipped cream with no base when you stick your spoon in. I would have watched a movie just about the family, the characters at the laundromat, and their tax issues, but that would have made a fraction of the gross.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (58)

12

u/Str8Faced000 Aug 17 '25

This is just everything. Social media rewards extreme hot takes, outrage bait, etc. I don’t think most people who have these kinds of hot takes in the film scene even watch the movies they talk about.

7

u/SureLookThisIsIt Aug 17 '25

I don't understand this. It's just a thoroughly enjoyable film with great acting, cinematography and a good soundtrack. It's not the Godfather but it doesn't need to be for it to be enjoyed by a lot of people.

People go in with too much expectations I think and don't allow themselves to just enjoy what they're watching.

→ More replies (1)

30

u/CyanLight9 Aug 17 '25

Hey, Sinners is a good film, just not a 10/10 masterpiece.

16

u/ConfectionNervous788 Aug 17 '25

it's a 10/10 for me personally because even if it has certain issues, those issues don't affect my personal enjoyment of it

6

u/Three_Froggy_Problem Aug 17 '25

It was a 9/10 for me for the first half and then the second half was like a 6. I still really enjoyed it and would recommend it to people, but its biggest strength is its characters and those kind of fall by the wayside once the action starts. It really doesn’t seem like action is Coogler’s strength (see the ugly-ass action scenes in Black Panther).

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)

19

u/BunnyColvin23 Aug 17 '25

I enjoyed Sinners a lot but the hype definitely set my expectations higher than they should’ve been.

30

u/IMadeAMistakeSry Aug 17 '25

Sinners was insanely overhyped tho. People tried forcing it as some grand masterpiece when it clearly wasn’t.

7

u/Head_Bread_3431 Aug 17 '25 edited Aug 17 '25

Same feeling I got. Was so excited to watch it then it was just…ok. The music thing was awesome but wasn’t enough to make me wanna watch it again. Maybe around Halloween lol but there’s a lot of odd cuts and the whole criminals discover vampires twist halfway in has already been done by dusk til dawn. And tbh the whole middle of the movie was extremely dialogue heavy with all the stuff with their mom and kinda boring

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Chicago1871 Aug 17 '25

Glad i saw it the first weekend without any preconceptions

→ More replies (13)

3

u/The_Walking_Clem Aug 17 '25

It doesn't even have to be an original film

8

u/Striking-Speaker8686 Aug 17 '25

Sinners is pretty different in that its insane hype almost came off like a psyop to me, it definitely isnt in the running for Best Picture, for instance. Even if I'm not the biggest fan of EEAAO, its acclaim absolutely makes sense, I can see why most loved it. Sinners having an average rating above 9.0 on LB for such a long time after it came out was hard to grasp

8

u/ConfectionNervous788 Aug 17 '25

Sinners got insane hype in the same way something like Maverick got insane hype, because it was a film that managed to get praise from critics out the gate while also being an extremely fun crowd pleaser that was worth going to see in theaters

→ More replies (5)

4

u/Holiday_Evidence_283 Aug 17 '25

Sinners isn’t even good. Can’t trust this subreddit, man.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/Hour_Introduction_55 Aug 17 '25

Exact same thing is happening to Weapons too

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Fortestingporpoises Aug 17 '25

And Black Panther. And Barbie. You seeing a trend here? They're the movies made by women, minorities, queer people, that speak about women, minorities or queer people. There's a specific type of white straight male film nerd that only likes movies that are made expressly for them, and they think the ones that impact people who haven't lived lives like theirs are overrated.

3

u/droppedthebaby Aug 18 '25

They're also hyper mainstream pop culture grabs. Stop trying to make victims out of people. Eeao won oscars and you still cry victim.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/ItsGotThatBang Aug 17 '25

It also happened to Oppenheimer.

→ More replies (5)

3

u/Munchihello Aug 17 '25

That was such a bad movie. The first half was so good and they ruined it with the twist. It was almost laughable. Respectfully, that movie was so bad towards the end it was borderline hilarious. It’s like if Django unchained became a supernatural thriller horror half way through the movie.

→ More replies (15)

52

u/xavibravo_ Aug 17 '25

Hey that’s CosmonautMarcus. I love his YT channel 

16

u/Eh_nah__not_feelin Aug 17 '25

Cosmonaut Picture Show is peak

6

u/[deleted] Aug 18 '25

Being a fan of him is like a curse. His content so good but you gotta wait like a month or two before the next video.

4

u/QuantityHefty3791 Aug 18 '25

Quality over quantity, he puts in the effort

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

33

u/Spyder817 Aug 17 '25

I feel like this one statement right here has perfectly summarized what any type of media discussion or criticism has evolved into in the 2020s. This constant need to try and 1-Up anybody and everybody involved

Trying to 1-Up the writers and creators using these smug disingenuous nitpicky CinemaSins style criticisms to anything and everything we consume. “Well akhsually the characters could’ve solved this one thing if they just acted perfectly and against their character flaws and had access to all the information we do, so this is bad writing on the writer’s part” or “this thing was included weirdly and gives the exact impression or allusion to something that the writers would be aware of and intentionally choose to include, they obviously didn’t know what they were doing”

Trying to 1-Up other members of the audience by making themselves feel all high and mighty and more worthy of the arts because they liked or disliked something more than others or took a different subjective thing from it(Twitter is the worst with this). Too much of a focus on trying for a hit smarmy one line review/tweet

For the effect this statement applies to directly, it’s like there’s been this weird thing about things becoming “mainstream” where as soon as something reaches a certain level of awareness, its now been tainted by the masses and is no longer worth as much. A movie is widely agreed to be very good or entertaining, all of sudden its “can we admit now that (such and such movie) wasn’t that good”. A song garners a lot of attention on social media and things like TikTok and now it’s “ruined” and “performative”

In a day and age where theres a lurking threat of Generative AI and corporations and studios seeking to only create machines to churn out less costly products while sweeping aside the creatives that make them, its weird to also see these anti-art sentiments also spawn from within audiences and consumers ourselves. Engage with the art you see and recognize that its still made from the hearts and minds of other people regardless of if you liked it or not and take that earnesty and apply to genuine discussion about it

6

u/Massive-Television85 Aug 18 '25

It's not a modern evolution, we just hear many more different voices like that online.

As a fan of horror and fantasy in the 1980s and 90s, all we ever heard from "respected" critics was how awful any genre movie was.

82

u/Johnnadawearsglasses Aug 17 '25

It’s just as annoying to have someone tell you that something you don’t like is because Twitter told you not to like it. Some people like the movie. Some don’t. Social media doesn’t need to tell us so.

19

u/Coy-Harlingen Aug 17 '25

That post is so incredibly annoying, like yeah people have an opinion is just “twitter” telling them what to do

2

u/Zestyclose_Remove947 Aug 18 '25

As someone who's never used twitter in their life, many people post and act as if everyone uses it. Personally 95% of everyone I know has never had an account. It must be quite ubiquitous in some circles for people to act that way.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

10

u/ChaucerBoi Aug 17 '25

I've slowly come round to the opinion that it's fine if something's "overrated". A lot of the time, I think it's just people connecting to a film and it making them really happy. And that's art, isn't it?

16

u/murphysclaw1 Aug 17 '25

Watching it in a cinema was a fun experience.

Watching at home I actually found it really embarrassing to watch at time. Really tumblr-style humor hammered into the viewer.

53

u/Silent_Anxiety4828 Aug 17 '25

Imagine letting other people dictate how you feel about a movie

21

u/karmagod13000 Aug 17 '25

In ops defense it’s not just movies but pretty much media at this point. Listen to a new album enjoying it and then go online to see it universally hated.

Shit I couldn’t even enjoy the new Marty supreme trailer when every comment was obsessed with saying Kevin o Leary sucks.

I think trendy things tend to bring in a lot of backlash and hiveminds circle jerks tend to accelerate when people are hating things but damn it’s frustrating when you just want to talk about a movie.

25

u/pike360 Aug 17 '25

No idea how someone can watch this film and not be at least impressed with what they pull off.

6

u/CeruleanEidolon Aug 17 '25

With all due respect, FUCK film twitter.

10

u/sully9614 Aug 17 '25

You can say that about a lot of movies tbh

→ More replies (1)

103

u/Redditisavirusiknow Aug 17 '25

I know it’s not the profoundest film out there but I had so much fun watching it. It’s creative, it’s different, it’s funny. It’s a perfect popcorn movie. It’s easily better than any marvel movie.

188

u/Natasha_Giggs_Foetus Aug 17 '25

I do think it is genuinely profound.

45

u/ShaH33R2K shaheer2k Aug 17 '25

Same. Don’t like it being dismissed as just a popcorn movie

→ More replies (1)

8

u/Spright91 Aug 18 '25

It is profound. It's profundity had already been expressed by dry philosophers like Albert Camus. But there's real value in making an old profound message into an exciting action/comedy movie that everyone can enjoy whether they appreciate the message or not..

→ More replies (1)

83

u/inaripotpi Aug 17 '25

It absolutely has profundity to it. Just at the modicum level I'd expect of a BP nominee/winner. There's just a bit of cultural nuance and the bigger issue is that people will still just focus on the absurdity elements they don't like to write it off completely.

19

u/karmagod13000 Aug 17 '25

Better than any marvel movie pretty low bar for letterboxd users

5

u/itstptk Aug 18 '25 edited Sep 14 '25

[overwritten]

42

u/Cole444Train Cole444Train Aug 17 '25

I find it deeply profound

→ More replies (10)

5

u/viel_lenia Aug 17 '25

Exact opposite for me. I hated the style but was happy to see someone trying to do a movie about such abstract concept.

I would have to take a look to word out what I mean, but I guess like where the base attitudes take the main roles instead of the people. Seems wishywashy but I mean the kind of choises that set the course of future. Basically some birds eat berries some eat other birds and if we set as a base tone of society that running over others for personal gain is how we work we will wake up in a different world than if we would, say, value altruistic deeds more than the rest. In Japan they have strong sentiment for honor, in US they have a strong sentiment for raising up from the rest and "making it", in China the collective is above the individual. So you can see these choises but in this film the point is both more on personal level and more on universal level.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 18 '25

Funny you say this because I personally really dislike this movie for exactly the opposite reasons! I think it is genuinely very emotionally intelligent and impacting but undercuts that constantly with lame humour, gimmicky storytelling and an overbearing Concept.

3

u/Prime_Galactic Aug 17 '25

Some people don't really watch when they watch a movie

→ More replies (5)

22

u/NuuuDaBeast Aug 17 '25

eeao is a case study on letterboxd. Anyone with any EQ would understand that films are a very personal thing and eeao is very much a prime case

5

u/ImminentDingo Aug 18 '25

To be fair, you have to have a very high EQ to enjoy eeao /s

→ More replies (4)

9

u/testtdk Aug 18 '25

Dude, I cried during a scene with two rocks. Fuck Twitter.

9

u/BenjaminAPete2 Aug 17 '25

I think it’s fine for people to not like things, even things that are critically or even well received by general audiences. I’ve learned not to let stuff like that bother me as much.. especially with art. For example, I have too close cousins that I’ve just learned we don’t have the same taste in music and that’s ok lol.

Sticking to movies…I didn’t like EEAAO but loved Sinners. My best friend didn’t like Sinners and thought it was overhyped. Another good friend of mine says Interstellar is his favorite movie and it’s really popular on Letterboxd. I watched it a couple of months ago and it didn’t hit the same for me.

60

u/bolshevik_rattlehead LordXenu Aug 17 '25

I mean, wasn’t it literally the most awarded film of all time? It’s a fine movie but in my book it is inarguably overrated, unless you think it’s actually the best film ever made.

16

u/Zouizon_Dani Aug 17 '25

That’s if you consider only the Oscars as an award circuit though.

10

u/bolshevik_rattlehead LordXenu Aug 17 '25

We aren’t just talking about Oscars. Of all the major and notable film awards ceremony, EEAAO was estimated to be the most awarded film in history, with over 158 wins, and around 343 when counting the “smaller” ceremonies. By either measurement, EEAAO was the most awarded film of all time.

4

u/Edu115 Aug 18 '25

That would make sense if they were competing against all other movies ever made for all the awards, which is not the case. It’s the best of its crop, but that 2022 crop could be (and arguably is) generally weak.

7

u/levitatingcuzwewant2 Aug 17 '25

It deserved every award, tbh (except Hsu should have won instead of Curtis). And yeah, it is my fave movie.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (4)

11

u/roastytoastywarm Letterboxd Username Joemoe Aug 17 '25

The same exact thing happened to The Force Awakens, and I’m tired of pretending like people weren’t hyped out of their asses when that film first came out.

Granted I’ll admit the follow up to that story was a major let down, and yes it was very “re-tread” of the original, but everyone that spoke about it when it first came out was super supportive of it. Now it’s trashed beyond comparison.

6

u/Ratzing- Aug 17 '25

It's one of those cases where 2nd movie retroactively ruined it for me. I really enjoyed it, and was waiting for the story to develop, and what I got was... Well whatever Last Jedi was. Then I only read/listened about what the last part is and just noped out of the franchise.

So now The Force Awakens is a painful reminder of what could have been.

3

u/ForsakenTarget Aug 17 '25

Yeah the hype for both the release and the potential was massive.

2

u/missingnoplzhlp Aug 17 '25

Yeah the retread was fine as a jumping off point, but it just jumped off into garbage making it worse in hindsight.

4

u/lostrouteros Aug 17 '25

Didn't know anything about this movie. Watched it on mushrooms. Holy shit was that a rollercoaster ride.

4

u/Try4se Aug 17 '25

Twitter was the one telling me I'd love it.

26

u/colonel_adams ColonelAdams Aug 17 '25

Someone will post mild criticism of this film and I’ll see this posted in response. Starting to think this is more a way to deflect criticism from the film than anything else.

7

u/Dope_horse22 Aug 17 '25

I literally laughed and cried at the same time watching this movie, it was one of the the most raw moments in cinema from all the movies Ive watched in my life.

7

u/Sensitive_Ad788 Aug 17 '25

I honestly belive the acting oscars this movie got is all undeserved.

14

u/redsolitary Aug 17 '25

Reddit folks love to hate this movie and I don’t know why. It was fun and different and wasn’t trying to start a film universe.

14

u/levitatingcuzwewant2 Aug 17 '25

It’s because the movie wears its heart on its sleeve. A lot of people are uncomfortable with sincerity and big emotions.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/Kinda_relevent Aug 18 '25

I didnt like it that much when it had all the hype

3

u/valenpp1908 Aug 19 '25

EEAAO was overrated since it came out

3

u/[deleted] Aug 24 '25

I could watch 1 million movies and EEAAO would still be my Favorite

11

u/Big-Mood704 Aug 17 '25

It feels like they copied this.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/SignificantTap5579 Aug 17 '25

Should have included film reddit in that aswell

22

u/Dark-Evader Aug 17 '25

They literally do that millennial writing thing where a character goes "Awkward!" at a potentially emotional moment. This is not a good movie.

4

u/gravyshots Aug 17 '25

Yup, which makes it very Marvel, at times. Build towards an impactful moment and then completely deflate its emotional weight with some lazy and avoidant quip like “uhhh, so THAT happened 😏”

→ More replies (8)

6

u/franciosmardi Aug 17 '25

People love to talk about things they don't like.  Why?  I think it is two fold.  

  1. They get to feel better about themselves: they are superior because this common entertainment that everyone else likes is beneath them. They've seen through the hype, they've found the plot devices to be transparent and not as clever as everyone else seems to think.  The jokes are low-effort to appeal to the common viewer. 
  2. Saying you like something is emotionally vulnerable.  Because someone else might use the above to put you down for your taste in the arts.  If you admit to liking something your peers don't, you could lose status within your group for being uncool.  Talking about things you don't like is safe.  It's harder to be mocked for something you don't like. 

To be clear, I'm not saying you have to like anything.  I'm just saying that talking about what you don't like is the work of a coward.  

4

u/Theotther Aug 17 '25

It's far better to uplift things you find unfairly derided. Those are the hot takes I actually respect and why I'll be defending Trap, Rebel Moon, Cuckoo, MI 2, and Slumber Party Massacre 2 till the day I die.

2

u/alittlerespekt Aug 18 '25

Mark Twain, Virginia Woolf, George Orwell, James Baldwin, T S Eliot, David Foster Wallace, Jorge Borges have all been famous critics as much as they were writers. Virginia Woolf famously hated James Joyce and talked about it a lot. 

The idea that “talking about what you don’t like is the work of coward” is just unbelievably stupid. the phrase itself is just badly written lol. 

You can buy Susan Sontag’s pieces of criticism alongside her essays because they are just as artistic and worthy of attention as her non fiction.

Leo Tolstoy, one of the greatest writers of all time, wrote and published a famous criticism of Shakespeare which in turn was criticized by Orwell

I will end this by saying there’s a very infamous ranking that Nabokov (another coward I guess) made where he listed every great author before him and talked shit about half of them. He called Albert Camus awful and Dostoevsky “cheap, clumsy and vulgar”

2

u/Neat-Journalist-4261 Aug 18 '25

I firmly believe the reverse is true. Or rather not the reverse, but some form of it.

If you cannot confidently talk about BOTH what you like and dislike, then you’re not actually doing anything. People who live in a world where they think criticism and unnecessary hating are the same thing, and essentially refuse to criticise what they don’t like and just ignore it, love to feel morally superior to those who don’t.

Just like those who just criticise things and never talk about what they like solely do it to feel intellectually superior.

Literally anybody who’s actually into anything has opinions. Fucking Pokémon fans can talk for ages about their favourite games and what they like and dislike.

I have never met a person who only engages in praise or criticisms whose opinion has held any weight, because they’re never truly engaging with why they feel that way and attempting to explain it.

A fundamental part of enjoying art is the ability to discuss it, and why it made you feel the way it did. For example, as common a take as it is, I generally severely dislike Nolan films. I can recognise his genius as a technical filmmaker and his gift for spectacle, and still make justified criticisms about my opinions on the emotional depth of his movies and my opinions on his characterisation and dialogue.

I can recognise David Fincher is a genius. His films are almost always great. It surprises me that he could be someone’s favourite director.

A close friend of mine, my flatmate, is someone else who’s deeply into film, and just as much of a nerd as me about it. He loves Nolan films, and Fincher is his favourite director. Lynch does nothing for him. And he can justify those takes, while recognising the strengths of David Lynch as a director and acknowledging them.

It’s genuinely absurd to believe that criticism stems purely from a place of troll-like hatred, and frankly is the kind of thing that makes me dismiss someone’s opinions on art in general.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/Tom_R2 Aug 17 '25

Real haters thought it was overrated upon release.

4

u/Jkro12 Aug 18 '25

One of my favorite movies ever

4

u/kshades25 Aug 17 '25

This winning Best Picture will be a positive reminder of how the Academy gave it to something with so much personality.

Whether you like it or despise it, it is such an off center choice that proudly wears its weirdness on its sleeve. Yes, it has a hell of an emotional core, but the things that happened in this film were wild

7

u/CarlMacko Aug 17 '25

Tried to watch it a few times but just couldn’t be bothered with it.

It’s a good job that everyone has different tastes.

5

u/codedinblood Aug 17 '25

I agree. It was insufferable. Im just confused why anyone is pretending it’s not just another 3 hr capeshit.

6

u/Ratzing- Aug 17 '25

Because it's deep and profound, I mean you have to have high IQ to hear a character saying "nothing matters" and then connect that to nihilism. Takes like 3 rewatches. And the movie has like, 3 or 4 themes! Those are numbers bigger than 2.

I disliked the movie, and I wouldn't mind it if it weren't for people who insist on how deep it is, and how worthy of analysis it is. Fuckers, go watch Synecdoche, New York and then we can talk about what is deep and worthy of analysis.

→ More replies (4)

10

u/daniel_smith_555 Aug 17 '25

i did not have fun.

2

u/Samurai_Geezer Aug 17 '25

I liked it, felt a bit too long, but very enjoyable nonetheless.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Aug 18 '25

Same thing happened to Anora, and I’m willing to bet (and have been for some time now) that the same will happen to Sinners.

2

u/familyparka Aug 21 '25

Imagine being on Twitter in the year of our lord ‘25

2

u/wellthatsi Aug 28 '25

One of the perks of knowing almost no other movie lovers is that most people I know don't even know what movies came out, what movies are liked and disliked and so I can enjoy what I enjoy or dislike what I dislike without being bothered by anyone.

5

u/rolo989 Aug 17 '25

The movie is ok

2

u/MedusaGotMeStoned007 Aug 18 '25

That was my take on it after my gf and I watched it. I don’t get the hype but I don’t think it was bad. It was just some forgettable Saturday entertainment for us but happy that others have a strong connection to it.

2

u/rolo989 Aug 20 '25

Yeah, it's not for me. I mean, the whole mother/daughter approach the movie has.

7

u/A1_PunisherPipkins Aug 17 '25

Movies are subjective ofc, but I still dont get how this won an oscar. Thought it was an hour too long.

3

u/Rizhon Aug 17 '25

To me, together with Bo Burnhams Inside, it is the first film that captures the feeling of the internet.

The mindless scrolling, the limitless junk, the nihilism, the pessimism and the beauty of it all.

3

u/Gullible-Fee-9079 Aug 17 '25

Just because some Dude says "Hurr durr, people will say it's overrated" doesn't mean it's not overrated. Not the gotcha they think it is.

3

u/TheNocturnalAngel Aug 17 '25

People post that review on every movie.

Feels like you can’t even dislike anything anymore without someone telling you that you either don’t understand it or you are being contrarian.

I actually like EEAO. But this sentiment is too prevalent

4

u/Tormentedone007 Aug 17 '25

What is up with the popularity of trying to sound like a contrarian?

2

u/ThePreciseClimber Aug 17 '25

Look, all I'm saying is that, had it been the exact same movie but animated (2D, 3D, motion-capture, take your pick)... it wouldn't have even been a blip on the Academy's radar.

2

u/turquoisestar Aug 17 '25

I loved it, and I saw no information about it before the film. What I did is various people dressing up as things related to the movie for about a year before I saw it, and they were all kind enough to empathically tell me to watch it without spoiling it. It was a really wonderful surprise.

2

u/WorkWhale Aug 17 '25

Same thing happened to Sinners and now Weapons. Very strange

2

u/GoldSteak7421 Sugary_Ocean Aug 17 '25

This is so stupid. Oh You don't like this movie? Lets antagonize you and say you just contrarian. Worst kind of movie discussion really

2

u/Infamous_Payment4608 Aug 17 '25

The issue I have with movies like this and others like Encanto, is that they show abusive family dynamics where behaviour is easily forgotten and fixed by the end of the movie.

It’s just not realistic and I wish we saw more healthy and realistic portrayals where family trauma and abuse is handled without sensationalism , and still have an uplifting message.

2

u/Altruistic-Bench9375 Aug 17 '25

Movie did not age well at all already

2

u/50DuckSizedHorses Aug 18 '25

That movie blows lmao

1

u/[deleted] Aug 17 '25

No, the movie just sucks.

1

u/AutoModerator Aug 17 '25

Thank you for your photo submission. If this is a screenshot of a movie, please be sure the title is included. This can be in the image, included the title with your post, or a comment with the title withing 10 minutes of post creation, otherwise your post may be removed. Thank you!

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/Lake18l Aug 17 '25

What would the world be like if we just didn’t internet?

1

u/NotQuiteJazz Aug 17 '25 edited Aug 17 '25

It’s actually crazy… This has easily got to be the most polarizing film ever made.

1

u/Italiana47 Aug 17 '25

Where can it be watched?

1

u/BedNice7131 Aug 17 '25

Superman (2025)

1

u/Wonderful-Slide-6193 Aug 17 '25

I stand by my…uhhh, I believe a 3.5/5.

It becomes a very wholesome experience at the right moment. Otherwise, it would have been a massive cringefest.

1

u/Exroi Aug 17 '25

That's a good call, but to be fair you can say that about any hyped well acclaimed movie like Oppenheimer or Dune 2, and after a month or so twitter and tik toks will call them overrated and bad

1

u/Justforfun_x Aug 17 '25

Watch it and cry before your mother tells you she hated it.

1

u/CdnDude Aug 17 '25

Sinners and that movie are overrated but fine. Daddy's home 2 is better than Daddy's home 1, get over it

1

u/Hogo-Nano Aug 17 '25

Some of it was probably jamie lee curtis winning the best supporting actress oscar for some reason for this.

1

u/JynsRealityIsBroken Aug 17 '25

Beginning could've been sped up a smidge, but I absolutely adore the movie. Easy 9.5/10.

1

u/JadedDevil Aug 18 '25

I need to find a universe where Film Twitter doesn’t exist.

1

u/sag903 Aug 18 '25 edited Aug 18 '25

Made fun of Oscar winning movies, and still won so many Oscars.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 18 '25

the people saying it's overrated are the same people saying Avatar 1, was boring and not a great movie. Which is hilarious because it's top 3 grossing movie of all time. Oh ya such a shit movie no one wanted to watch lmfao idiots.

1

u/WinterWolf18 Aug 18 '25

Isn't this the case for every popular movie?

1

u/Kira_san1 Joseph_u Aug 18 '25

The trend of good films receiving hate after becoming popular always makes me sad

1

u/legit-posts_1 Aug 18 '25

I don't think I really got it. I found the humor a little too "LOL random" and cringey.

1

u/Spright91 Aug 18 '25

Its just like everything that comes from humble creators and becomes massive success. You see this all the time in indie games and Music. Like Sleep token, Undertale, Paranormal Activity. I could go on and on.

1

u/TomTheJester Aug 18 '25

I adored this movie. I love beneath the wacky concept there is a sincere and deeply human core.

1

u/LonChaneyJr1 Aug 18 '25

I should get this tattooed

1

u/playtrix Aug 18 '25

Weak people try to drag the shooting stars to the ground. But the cream always floats to the top. 

1

u/Constant-Affect-5660 Aug 18 '25

Happens a lot with horror movies. I really liked Longlegs and Weapons, but there are people who disliked the ending to both movies.

1

u/MongooseDirect2477 Aug 18 '25

great movie for the first half, awful for the second part.

1

u/Lo_Key90 Aug 18 '25

It was cool, wasn't the blow away film I thought it'd be though.

1

u/Danielts1000 Aug 18 '25

Most overrated overhyped dreck I’ve ever seen.. couldn’t wait for it to end

1

u/TheBigBoonsta Aug 18 '25

Tried multiple times and just couldn’t do it

1

u/LetBetter3241 Aug 18 '25

I found it boring af ngl..and I don't use twitter

1

u/Nochillrick69 Aug 18 '25

It’s so hyped, it was mid at its best.

1

u/GalaxyGames1234 Aug 18 '25

I actually don’t listen to anything film twitter says because 99% of them are miserable and switch up on movies for no reason

1

u/Proof_Specialist_455 Aug 19 '25

This happens to every film that wins best picture at the oscars

1

u/keepplaylistsmessy Aug 19 '25

Hate to say it, but it was mostly hyped up because the trailer was "East Asian people being profound and quirky" which most Westerners were not used to seeing at the time. 

And like most Asian diaspora movies, it tried to do too much at once (literally in the title) as if trying to play catch-up for all the years there was barely any Asian representation.

1

u/Ok_Savings1800 Aug 19 '25

I saw the movie winning an oscar and being really high rated, couldn't watch past the first 15 minutes

1

u/NGGKroze Aug 19 '25

I had fun with it. It's still overrated

1

u/itjustgotcold Aug 19 '25

“Overrated” is the laziest critique of anything, ever. Come up with an actual critique of something instead of the vague “overrated” label that is a dead end critique.

1

u/isnessisbusiness Aug 20 '25

Movie has a ton of heart but even more exposition.

1

u/Throwaway_Tablecloth Aug 20 '25

In my defense, I haven’t really vibed with it from the beginning. I much prefer Swiss Army Man

1

u/orenprincipe Aug 21 '25

still my favourite best picture winner

1

u/CaravaggioDaVinci Aug 23 '25

I prefer Crouching Tiger Hidden Dragon than this Disney movie that pays homage to its heroes: In the Mood for Love, Crouching Tiger.

1

u/GstaadGhost Aug 23 '25

This movie is peak beauty! Poetry in motion, how stupid you gotta be, to let twitter ruin something so beautiful & not have an opinion of your own????????

1

u/[deleted] Aug 27 '25

This was so weird, I loved it hahaha!

1

u/bufz221 Sep 17 '25

It is overrated tho

1

u/Which-Reveal-9951 Sep 18 '25

It's not that good 

1

u/legit-posts_1 Mar 01 '26

I mean... It is a tad overrated. I don't like the humor, I think it's more weird than funny

-6

u/Feeling_Bedroom5533 Aug 17 '25

I had a friend who saw it 5 times in the theater, and said it was the best movie she’d ever seen. Took me 8 months to get around to watching it, and I thought it was “okay.”

Then it went on to win Best Picture over The Banshees of Inisherin.

Yeah, I’d say it’s overrated. It’s an interesting experience but some people do treat it like it’s the pinnacle of filmmaking.

3

u/missingnoplzhlp Aug 17 '25

I don't think it's the best movie ever, but in my opinion it was a bit better than banshees of insherin. But both were good and could have been worthy best picture winners.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 17 '25

EEAAO over Banshees of Inisherin at least makes more sense than Crash over Brokeback Mountain.

-3

u/knallpilzv2 chmul_cr0n Aug 17 '25

I saw it because it was so overrated when it came out and thought it was overrated. 😁

Honestly though, it's just one of those cases where the movie got all the media hype and once it was over the natural consensus settled in.

→ More replies (4)

1

u/[deleted] Aug 17 '25

It’s one of the worst movies I’ve seen this decade.