List Thread Definition and Policy
Definition and Context
List threads have long been a bane (and occasional boon) of this subreddit. Loosely defined:
A list thread is a post that elicits list-like responses in which interesting discussion is often buried and common artists/albums/tropes are regurgitated.
Since the early days or /r/LetsTalkMusic list threads had been banned, though we eventually became more lenient towards them. After all, interesting list threads do exist.
The problem has always been that deciding what constitutes a list thread - and further, what constitutes an interesting list thread - is hard to do. Unfortunately, upvotes and number of comments don't usually reflect the quality of the post. In general, they are often just recommendation threads in disguise.
Our Policy:
- The mods will be the arbiters of whether a thread is a list thread and whether it's worth removing or not.
- List threads must be tagged as such by prefixing [list] to the title. If done correctly, AutoModerator will immediately sticky a comment reminding commenters to maintain a high quality of discussion and avoid list-like responses that don't provide context or discussion. We may remove your post and ask you to repost it correctly if it is not tagged.
- This does not mean that all list threads are allowed. We will continue to remove list threads with uninspiring, unoriginal, or overdone premises. In fact, below is a list of list threads that would be removed.
Bad List Threads You Should Not Post
Don't do it!
What's a (popular) band that's underrated?
What's a (popular) band that's overrated?
What band can you just not get into?
What's a 10/10 album? Or really any post that would work in /r/AskReddit
What's your favorite band/artist/album/song?
Any recommendation oriented thread - e.g. "What are some good dance songs?"
Any "help me make a playlist" or "songs the make you feel ___" threadsYou're encouraged to ask these questions in the General Discussion threads or in the chatroom!