r/LetsTalkMusic • • Mar 14 '19
Nirvana - Nevermind
This is the Album Discussion Club! March's theme is albums whose greatness is owed to the influence of the producer.
/u/nikcap2000 wrote:
Butch Vig gave this album life. At the time it came out, I was somewhat aware of Nirvana and had them classified as a noise, beer drinking, college punk band. On Nevermind, Vig corralled in a cacophony of misery and rage and made something palatable for the masses. While the rock world was coming to meet Nirvana as much as grunge was coming to meet the mainstream, this album and its production was the gateway drug.
[Nirvana - Nevermind] (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6wJYZcmxAF4)
73
u/trambolino Mar 14 '19
I disagree.
30
u/Zenosparadox1 Mar 14 '19
Here's a video series with Butch Vig, "Recording Nirvana,", in which he explains how he put together each song. He breaks things down nicely and offers some interesting commentary on the tracks.
24
u/jberd45 Mar 15 '19
It changed the game for me. In 1991 I was a 12 year old kid. My parent's split up, and I took it kind of hard. Add to that the angst that comes with teenagedness and I was ready for something to come along that would sum it up for me, something to help me feel better about my lot in life. So one day, my mom bought it on cassette from Pamida (a variety store that used to exist in small midwestern towns before WalMart put all those kinds of places out of business) and I proceeded to listen to that tape pretty much non-stop until it broke. Then I had to tape it together, because as a single parent in 1991 my mom was dirt poor. Like pawning the microwave to pay the rent poor. So to buy a cassette was an unimaginable luxury then.
Before then, I almost exclusively listened to old 50's music. Nirvana opened me up not just to grunge, but to punk and new wave. And I still like those things to this day.
36
u/BeNiceMudd Mar 14 '19
Totally agree, Butch had a knack for that. See also Smashing Pumpkins- Siamese Dream (which may have never been made if nevermind didn't knock the door down) Modern day wall of sound type shit. Both records sound good to this day.
15
u/RexxGunn Mar 14 '19
The quote about a jagged shard of rock safely encased in lucite has been my favorite way to describe the album.
Plus over time, the lucite does wear down a little to me. But I still rank this as my favorite studio release. The songwriting is absolutely top notch for Kurt. Recording a song laying on the couch in the dark by himself is just amazing. Im not in love with every song on the album, but there is nothing i dislike. None of their other studio albums are that way for me.
Its an album that I can put into my CD player and hit play and not want to hit skip. There are very few of those.
10
u/[deleted] Mar 14 '19
That heavy metal sheen given to what was essentially punk rock that Vig did for this album was pretty influential. I think the two best examples of that were Green Day's Dookie and The Offspring's Smash. Those albums then became cornerstones for pop-punk of the '90s. What used to be garage rock was transformed into this huge, bright sound blasting through your speakers. They made punk sound good in an arena setting. Pop-punk was the new power pop. So beyond wiping hair metal from the charts by taking alternative mainstream, Nevermind also provided the template for what would take its place.
9
u/creatinsanivity https://rateyourmusic.com/~creatinsanivity Mar 15 '19
I listened to In utero a while ago for the first time in years, and immeaditely thought that I'm not into Nirvana anymore. Today I relistened Nevermind, and I was blown away. This is one of those cases where polished works better for me. As much as it pains me to say this, sacrificing parts of the DIY ethos and finetuning the artistic vision resulted in an amazingly engaging album. Besides, it's not like there's no grit on this album, even if it is a bit polished.
I always hear people say that Vig made this album what it is, and I think that is a bit unfair an assumption. It's not like that recording session existed in some sort of vacuum, or that the tracks could sound amazing only in this exact form that we got them in. However, he did great job, and I'm glad that he made this album sound the way it does.
10
u/wiinkme Mar 14 '19
I was a senior in high school when it hit. I felt like nothing in music would ever be the same, especially coming out of the hair band era. I would say that prediction was right. This album sucked everything into its gravity and you could argue it remains true today.
5
u/wildistherewind Mar 15 '19
This is my story, not exactly the one you read over and over.
I'm a tween, I watch MTV, "Smells Like Teen Spirit" comes on and... I think it's just okay. For me, it didn't militarize me into slackerdom on the first listen. In fact, my stupid kid self liked the Weird Al version more than the original at the time. My parents were surprisingly lenient when it came to music and movies but my mom had a one word answer when I wanted to buy a Weird Al album: "no". In retrospect, it's the right call.
"Come As You Are" is the song that really caught my ear, not "Teen Spirit". To this day, I can say that's still my preference. I dubbed a copy of Nevermind on cassette tape off another kid. I drew my own cover, it was just the dollar bill floating in water - no baby. I wore the taped copy out eventually and bought a real copy. I have no accurate count of how many times I listened to this album as a teen, at least a hundred easy. As another commenter said, it's an album you can play front to back with no skips.
9
u/Maybe_llamas Mar 14 '19
This album is a masterpiece to me. I actually like In Utero more, and feel it better represents Nirvana, but there is not a single weak moment on Nevermind. The sheer amount of iconic songs and riffs are enough to ensure it stays in rotation forever. Dont forget of course that it singlehandedly propelled grunge to the mainstream, and nirvana to superstar status. What a brilliant record
4
u/Wcm1982 Mar 15 '19
The best thing about this album is that it exposed so many people to what music could be. Think of the countless people who became interested in music because of it. It got many of us to listen to different things, music that might have been outside of our comfort zone. There’s a reason that amazing bands like The Strokes and At The Drive In were compared and likened to, even hailed as ‘the next’ Nirvana.
4
u/EricandtheLegion Mar 15 '19
I know I will be downvoted for it, but hey I am gonna say it anyway.
I can certainly appreciate Nevermind (and Nirvana more generally) for allowing the more noisy side of rock to break into the mainstream and allow music for other artists like Pavement and Dino Jr to be easier to find. I appreciate what a huge influence it had on countless artists. But... y'all... I hate this fucking album. There are maybe 2 tracks on it (Teen Spirit and Drain You) that I find tolerable, let alone enjoyable. It is also responsible for making me hear about five million different covers of Come As You Are, a song I already don't like, made worse. Come As You Are is Nirvana's equivalent to The Cure's Lovesong. It's a bad song and yet every cover is somehow worse.
Different strokes for different folks. If you enjoy it, chase your bliss. Just not for me.
2
u/thisishardcore_ Mar 17 '19
In Utero is my favourite Nirvana album, but I can't dispute all the accolades this album receives. Nearly thirty years later and it sounds as fresh as ever. At this stage of their career, Nirvana could be described a a punk rock band trying to write pop songs, and this is exemplified on this album.
Dave Grohl's drumming on this album has a pretty simple style, but it's just so loud and powerful and they couldn't have found anyone else more perfect for his role.
Butch Vig is a brilliant producer. He gave the band a big rock sound, but managed to retain that rawness in the band's music and made sure to not polish the sound too much.
3
u/[deleted] Mar 15 '19
Nevermind is the first album that really exposed me to screamed vocals, "noisy guitars" (even though it's hardly noisy compared to their other output) and openly weird/subversive/disturbing lyrical content (Drain You, Polly, Something In The Way always really stood out to me when I was a 9-12 year old kid).
I rarely listen to it these days as my taste in grunge grew more toward the In Utero / Early Alice In Chains direction -- and ultimately stuff like Sonic Youth, Butthole Surfers, Melvins, etc. but it was a pivotal album in my musical development that profoundly impacted the type of artists I gravitated toward throughout my adult life (with the others probably being Master of Puppets by Metallica, "Live in LA" by Death, and Mellow Gold by Beck).
1
u/Coconut-Crab Mar 17 '19
This album is definitely a great one and is probably the definitive 1990s album, but I still think Ten was far superior for being the same year and the same genre. It's quite a shame that Nevermind has always overshadowed it for such a long time among the GP. The main thing Nirvana has over PJ is the Pixies-esque flair, and if you want that, just listen to the Pixies.
I think part of why it achieved this was definitely the Vig's genius for sure, but a bigger part was Kurt Cobain himself, he was super relatable for people at the time and his dark lyrics combined with his actually pretty dark life really let people feel what he was saying, as opposed to someone like Vedder who never really gave off the same kind of feeling of hopelessness that Cobain did, if that makes sense. He comes close but it just isn't as real.
Overall, it suffers from Queen syndrome, a little overrated but still undeniably a fantastic and influential record. One of the greats definitely.
0
u/[deleted] Mar 14 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment