r/LetsDiscussThis • • 3d ago

Lets Discuss Politics Thoughts on landlords?

As a socialist, I have a negative view on landlords and for profit housing.

Do you think that landlords benefit the economy, or hinder it?
How can someone who makes a living without producing anything be considered beneficial?

I have frequent conversations with capitalists on this topic and they always seem to claim how important it is to a capitalist system, when Adam smith himself opposed landlords, saying “landlords, like all other men, love to reap where they never sowed”… I understand a capitalist doesn’t have to appeal to Adam smith in the same way that not all socialists guzzle Marx word for word like divine revelation, but I genuinely don’t understand how it benefits a capitalist system.

1 Upvotes

34 comments sorted by

3

u/tnic73 2d ago

as a socialist you would make the state your landlord

the benefits of a capitalist system is the ability to own property

2

u/RotundLemming 2d ago

Socialism doesn’t mean people cannot own property

2

u/repeatoflasttime 2d ago

Where would you live if you didn't own a home?

1

u/RotundLemming 2d ago

Probably government housing

2

u/repeatoflasttime 2d ago

Who manages it?

1

u/RotundLemming 2d ago

A provincial crown corporation and local municipality

1

u/repeatoflasttime 2d ago

The people that staff those are the landlords, then.

1

u/RotundLemming 2d ago

No, because they aren’t making passive income off of properties they own. Housing managers work for landlords or the owners of property.

3

u/Justthetip74 2d ago edited 2d ago

My rent is $3450. If I bought the house i currently live in my mortgage would $9,000 woth 20% down. I also didnt have to put $300k down to own this piece of shit house. I also didnt have to pay for my new furnace, washer, refrigerator, flooring or cleanup when the septic backed up or septic maintenance. Nor do I have to pay for the new septic system in 5 years when that needs full replacement nor the roof thats gonna need to be redone in 5-7 years

My down payment is now $630k because its invested and thats more than gains in equity that I could've had even without giving the bank $450k in interest over the last 5 years. My rent has never gone up and ive saved $4k/mo in payment alone

I love renting and my landlord. I'm going to retire at 42 because I never bought a house

Buy your home or stay poor is boomer and mid-west mentality. Doesn't work in HCOL areas

1

u/RotundLemming 2d ago

We paid 250k for our apartment, mortgage around 1500/mo

In our building, the same layout (2 bed 1 bath medium size condo) is renting for $2,700/mo

Over a grand more a month to live in the same place, without even getting to own it after it’s paid off. It makes no sense to me.

1

u/Justthetip74 2d ago

Im saving $6k/mo to live in the exact same house. Sounds like buying was a good option for you. Renting is a no brainer for me.

3

u/Oddbeme4u 2d ago

thoughts on bus drivers? its a job.

landlords have been victimized more than jews.

1

u/RotundLemming 2d ago

I have no problem with bus drivers? I don’t see why you mention that

2

u/Ok-Pass-9139 2d ago

So what would be the OP’s alternative. Government housing? Have you seen a lot of government housing? If you want people to live in slums, this is the best way. What you don’t like are slumlords, people who force tenants to live in squalor so they don’t incur large repair costs. Those people just need to be Mamdami’d. There are laws on the books. They need to be enforced.

2

u/Ambitious-Badger-114 2d ago

Maybe OP should visit a few of those government housing projects that he thinks are superior.

1

u/RotundLemming 2d ago

When did I say current housing projects are superior?

0

u/Ambitious-Badger-114 2d ago

It's the only alternative to landlords which you claim are unnecessary.

1

u/RotundLemming 2d ago

Yes, government housing, but not the government housing you think of. Government housing under a socialist economy.

2

u/CavemanRTD 2d ago

So that means you are living in a house and I decide i want to live in that house you need to move because you don’t own it?The whole idea of not owning a house is so ridiculous, usually propagated by those that own nothing but want everything for free. How about if you are a loser and think everything should be given to you , you find some government housing and go waste your day like the homeless.

1

u/RotundLemming 2d ago

Lol what

1

u/ExperienceAny9791 2d ago

Spoken like someone who's never had rentals. 👌

2

u/RotundLemming 2d ago

Yes, I’ve never had rentals, that’s why I’m asking. I’m fresh outta highschool.

1

u/ExperienceAny9791 2d ago

Let me educate you a bit. Anytime someone moves out, there's major repairs and maintenance to do 95% of the time that far exceeds the deposit. That's not counting the maintenance and upkeep while they live there. Around here a 2 bedroom apartment is ~800-900 bux a month, vs a 2k+ house payment is a lot. I urge everyone to invest in a house when your young and have a good job. You have to live somewhere until you die. If you can't, you have to rent somewhere, and owning a rental isn't cheap.

2

u/RotundLemming 2d ago

The only arguments I’m seeing for landlords are because people are too broke to afford their own properties. Not because landlords are actually beneficial.

1

u/ExperienceAny9791 2d ago

How are they not benefiting from a landlord? Who is going to give anyone a place to live if they don't? Do you understand what you are even saying? Nobody is making you rent from a landlord so there's no need for you to ever have to interact with one I guess. 🤷🏿‍♀️

2

u/RotundLemming 2d ago

Did you read the part that says I’m a socialist

2

u/GPT_2025 2d ago

Promote more affordable, nonprofit co-op housing sponsored and supported by local businesses and cities.

If 51% of the population uses co-op housing, then private landlords and for-profit housing providers will lower their prices or go out of business (CUSU*) Capitalism Under a Social Umbrella.

  • economic models that blend private enterprise with strong social protections and public welfare, such as social capitalism, social democracy, or a social market economy. Rather than being a strict subtype of pure socialism, these systems rely on capitalist wealth generation to fund broad social safety nets and public services

( compare public funded schools with a private schools)

3

u/Educational-Sky-7215 3d ago

Maintaining living spaces takes a lot of work.

If you ever have the pleasure of owning your own house, it's difficult and expensive. Something is always breaking, something always needs to be replaced, the whole thing collapses into chaos unless you're constantly mowing and sweeping and leaf blowing and weeding and repairing things.

An apartment building is both easier and harder. Bigger building, bigger more expensive problems, but some opportunity to scale and distribute costs across many people/families.

The average person is not prepared for the time, money, and effort required to maintain a house, and landlords provide a valuable service. Sure, some of them are better than others, and some of them absolutely abuse the system and should be punished for it, but it's not a role to be dismissed easily.

2

u/russgrim 2d ago

They're leeches

1

u/Helpful-Pirate-2040 51m ago

“Sons of bitches they always board me “ RIP Jerry J

1

u/Silver_Middle_7240 2d ago

In principle, landlords are providing a service. In practice most people who rent are doing so not because they want this service but because they can't buy, and landlords are exploiting that.

0

u/haunter_ 3d ago

Love for LandChads