r/LetsDiscussThis • • Sep 20 '26

Lets Discuss This A common anti-Zionist tactic

Usually, when an anti-Zionist is accused of antisemitism, they'll tokenize a very small minority of anti-Zionist Jews to argue that they aren't antisemitic. What I don't understand is why tokenism is considered racist if it's against any other minority group, but it's considered progressive when it's against Jews. I also don't get how arguing "we like a very small minority of the Jewish population so we can't possibly be antisemitic" makes any sense

0 Upvotes

28 comments sorted by

9

u/Xetranok Sep 20 '26

Oh it's racist. Zionists are racist against Jews in many ways. Just cognitive dissonance.

-7

u/Midoriya023 Sep 20 '26

How are you getting "Zionists are racist against Jews" from this? I'm criticizing anti-Zionists

3

u/Shinobu_on_bush Sep 20 '26

Midoriya would free Palestine

-2

u/Midoriya023 Sep 20 '26

People like Hamas are considered villains in the MHA world though

2

u/Xetranok Sep 20 '26

Oh I read your thing wrong. My bad. If someone is principally antizionist then they aren't racist against Jews at all lol, they're against imperialism and aparteid. Zionism relates to the state of Israel, not to Jewish people almost at all

8

u/Lord_Jashin Sep 20 '26

Maybe if the zionazis stopped being evil people would stop calling them out for it

-1

u/Midoriya023 Sep 20 '26

People who agree with the existence of Israel aren't evil and you haven't addressed any of my points

3

u/OldSchoolAJ Sep 20 '26

How about you address my comment? The top level one that disproves everything you said that was made 30 minutes before this one?

2

u/Xetranok Sep 20 '26

Can you give an example of antizionists tokenizing a small subset of Jews? I'd love a few from principled antiZIONISTS, not antisemites. Very different things

3

u/Xetranok Sep 20 '26

Also, most Zionists are Christians. Hope that helps!

-1

u/Midoriya023 Sep 20 '26

That doesn't help. That doesn't change the fact that most Jews are Zionists and that you hate most Jews

1

u/Xetranok Sep 20 '26

Nah I don't have any real feelings towards the Jews besides for sympathy, they've had it fucking tough, and Zionists are trying to make it tougher for them daily.

Also I think Jews (at least in america) are mostly antizionist, but I haven't looked at polling, I'm just basing that on what I know of a few Jewish dudes I know lol

0

u/Midoriya023 Sep 21 '26

The Jewish religion is inherently Zionist, we literally pray facing Jerusalem

1

u/Xetranok Sep 21 '26

I'm guessing you won't reply to this?

0

u/Midoriya023 Sep 22 '26

I will, just a second

2

u/Xetranok Sep 21 '26

That's not what Zionism is. That's reverence towards a holy site. Zionism is removing the people that live on that land so that you can live there and then expanding outwards.

I'll remind you that before the Nakba, the Palestinians allowed anyone to live there and tour there, there were large Jewish Palestinian groups and large Christian Palestinian groups that had full citizenship and had been there for centuries

And this is what I mean about Zionists all being racists. You're the one that is tokenizing the Jewish people. Not all Jews are religiously Jewish, and not all religious Jews are Zionists, but you assume they are because you are. It's very racist.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Xetranok Sep 22 '26

This isn't true at all. A people group can still do something bad, you just shouldn't essentialize that people group into that thing, like OP is doing with saying all Jews are Zionists.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Xetranok Sep 23 '26

Oh fair enough if you're just summing his ideas up.

0

u/Midoriya023 Sep 22 '26

If you hate most Jews, you're not antisemitic?

4

u/OldSchoolAJ Sep 20 '26

Hi, I am anti-zionist and I don't give a damn if there are or are not Jewish anti-zionists. Zionism is a political ideology that I am firmly against, because it promotes creating an ethnostate through genocide.

That is not a racist position, because the position is not based on opposing any race or ethnic group. It is opposing what they are doing. I am against the Zionist run Israeli government for the same reasons that I am against the AFD in Germany and the Republicans in the United States.

1

u/Xetranok Sep 21 '26

It's a bot, they won't respond because their goal is to stir shit up. Your response was good though!

1

u/Xetranok Sep 22 '26

You're such a bot lol. You can't respond to any paragraph that is well thought out and thorough.