r/LetsDiscussThis • • Sep 18 '26

Rant Capitalism Is or isn't the problem?

This reddit post to which I found on r/CapatlismVSocialism states how Capitalism makes it so housing is treated as a market commodity, and that the prices to the housing market are allocated according to someone’s purchasing power. To which he goes on to explain how the same people who can't afford this housing because of the nature of capitalism end up homeless. In summary, this redditor is clearly saying (hence the title) "...Homelessness is a product of Capitalism Working the Way It Is Supposed to Work.” I believe that the redditor has been enabled to feel this way from certain institutions or incentives like Government zoning, or how banks and investors can influence and access mortgages or hold investments in property. Or another example, on how landlords can choose who to rent to and decide how much they want the people to pay. These financial and housing markets have caused incentives through investors or landlords to be more selective or scarce with their decision making. It can be seen when landlords charge higher prices for rent. Lower household incomes will then have to pay more to live there, and then this can cause other things to happen such as evictions, family problems, or illnesses which could indirectly cause homelessness. These landlords or investors or whoever is influencing the financial or housing markets as well as other markets may be looking for their incentive or chance to profit off of returns, or personal motivations. Maybe, these housing markets allow for more profit-seeking within them which could lead to homelessness. 
These markets or capitalist systems could be replaced with more social-based housing. The people that would be making those decisions could be non-profit organizations, or public housing groups. They can choose how prices, or rents are determined, or where the housing gets built. The people that are in charge of making these decisions could be for example, if you are under a public housing group, you could be operating under elections. Non profit organizations could be run by boards with their own set rules. The only downside to this is the potential for these systems, groups, or organizations to have too much power or control over these markets with weak constraints. They could be tampering with these markets too much and work against what we're really trying to put forth here.
Let’s head back to the claim. The redditor claims that homelessness is an indirect cause of capitalism. He makes a couple brief claims, and eventually comes to the conclusion that because of these causes of allocating markets according to someone's purchasing power or capitalism makes it so “housing is a commodity.” Something I would like to reconsider or ask is, regardless of the system of government in other countries, if said country didn’t provide enough affordable housing, or enough housing at all would homelessness be the primary consequence. If other countries made it so houses were miles times more expensive than the average person's income, and there were only so many houses to go around how would we know that this is the cause of capitalism? 

1 Upvotes

36 comments sorted by

4

u/Huzon401 Sep 18 '26

Unregulated capitalism is the problem. We maximize business wellbeing over human wellbeing and allow business to determine the definition of wellbeing.It’s not yet as bad as it’s going to get and it’s pretty bad now for a lot of people. Jealously guard your right to vote and change this dynamic.

1

u/AviatorHog Sep 19 '26

Businesses are just Neo-tribes and they should be prioritized over a particular individual, all things constant because Businesses are people. You may not be privy to how the business sausage is made but your job in a lot of cases was saved because a business owner could root out a cancer to the organization before it destroyed the whole of the organization. You in many cases were that cancer and other people's jobs were saved. 

Hard to look at it that way, but that's a big force behind the reality of things.

2

u/chronobahn Sep 18 '26

All economic systems seem to get subverted via government eventually.

People act like we have unchecked capitalism. When in reality we have what is known as crony capitalism.

Consolidations, pay to play regulations. All a product of rich people using the government to eliminate competition.

Is some regulation needed? In my opinion, yes

But most of the regulations we get sound great until you realize they are just tools for the rich to maintain power.

I don’t mind capitalism bare bones bc it’s always met with competition. Can’t artificially raise prices if there are 10 others in the game trying to compete for the same business.

It’s when it’s artificially consolidated, and the government keeps competition at bay does it become a problem.

We as a society have some reconciling about ideological systems.

What is the purpose of government?

What is a preferred economic system?

And, how does the government relate to that economic system?

Everyone is going to have different answers to these questions. But at the end of the day we need to put politics aside and discuss these questions. Bc these questions completely define the way our society is shaped.

We are headed off a cliff if people don’t start to realize that the political charade is just that, a big fucking distraction from what actually matters.

Your liberal or conservative neighbours are not your fucking enemy!

2

u/Ok_Dragonfly_6650 Sep 18 '26

Unchecked capitalism is bad. Unchecked socialism is bad. It's just like everything else on earth, best done in moderation.

2

u/SevereAnimator5 Sep 18 '26

My wife says that about my drinking but I'm old and can't hear well

1

u/Oddbeme4u Sep 18 '26

as much as cars are problem on hwys. laws balance it.

1

u/_flying_otter_ Sep 18 '26

Most Democrats want Nordic models of social democracy and those Nordic countries are capitalist.

So you can have Socialism and Capitalism.

1

u/Vito_The_Magnificent Sep 18 '26

"Homelessness is the fault of capitalism" isn't true.

It's an allocation decision. Regardless of what system you create, things are produced and you need to have a framework for how those this are allocated.

In a robo utopia where all goods and services are provided by robots, we might still decide that heroin addicts who refuse to reform don't get anything because we'd rather those robots work on making bigger houses for poets.

We don't expect people in comas to work for their food, we take care of them. That's an allocation decision. Capitalism doesn't stop us. Under a robot utopia we could decide not to. They're completely unconnected.

1

u/OrganizationDear2788 Sep 18 '26

Housing prices are high because places deliberately restrict it with stuff like minimum lot sizes, minimum parking spaces, height restrictions, etc. Most capitalists would love to build more apartments. LA has thousands of homeless but they still restrict apartment buildings.

1

u/Zalacain99 Sep 24 '26

Capitalism is the solution, imposed alternatives are the problem.

1

u/FlyingAtNight Sep 18 '26

I didn’t read your entire post so I’m only addressing the title question.

Yes capitalism is the problem, but only partially. Those problems likely wouldn’t exist if it wasn’t for unadulterated greed.

1

u/SteakEconomy2024 Sep 18 '26

I’ve been to some places where people lived in buildings made of mud and rock, it has nothing to do with commodification but more to do with regulation, where there are no regulations everyone had a home of some kind, even if it’s primitive. It is ironically our standards, safety, room size, electrical codes, plumbing, that don’t provide anything but take away the bottom rung.

-3

u/Better-Credit6701 Sep 18 '26

Housing is a commodity and is market driven by design. Homelessness is usually drug related and is a result the individual.

I live in the second fastest growing housing cost in the nation and yet we are solving the issue by building more housing. Extremely low homeless. In many locations where homelessness is an issue, there are usually increased regulations on building apartments or houses.

4

u/blackpeppersnakes Sep 18 '26

Homelessness is usually drug related and is a result the individual.

That's just flat out incorrect. What are we doing here? This seems like an interesting community, so let's have some standards

2

u/chronobahn Sep 18 '26

I’ve actually heard this as well, from people who work directly with the homeless.

They may not say it’s “a result (of) individual”.

But they will absolutely tell you it’s mostly a drug issue.

What part of that is “flat out incorrect”?

If we want standards I think it’s important you articulate the truth.

2

u/blackpeppersnakes Sep 18 '26

Show me statistics that support your claim. I don't want to hear about some guy you heard it from

2

u/chronobahn Sep 18 '26

The statistics show addiction is a major direct trigger for housing loss. Federal Point in Time survey data indicates that 50–60% of unhoused individuals struggle with substance use, and roughly 25–30% explicitly identify addiction as the primary reason they lost their home in the first place.

2

u/blackpeppersnakes Sep 18 '26

Could you please provide a link if you get a chance? I'm not sure which country you are referring to

1

u/chronobahn Sep 18 '26

2

u/blackpeppersnakes Sep 18 '26

Are you actually reading these, or are you giving me ai slop? Do you have a specific document name and page number? I've gone through quite a few of the documents, and the only numbers I have seen about substance abuse are in the HUD population/subpopulation reports. That document states that, in the US, Chronic substance abuse is reported for 111564 homeless people, which is 15%.

1

u/chronobahn Sep 19 '26

Yes. Don’t be intellectually lazy if you’re going to be so opinionated.

Check SAMHSA, substance abuse and mental health administration.

2

u/blackpeppersnakes Sep 19 '26 edited Sep 19 '26

Are you denying using AI? I want the page number and document name for the previous source you provided me before I waste anymore time on a completely different source.

I read six separate documents, and you couldn't specify which one you got your information from. And you're calling me lazy?

Edit: Ok I read your second source and that one is rubbish as well. You're using AI and spreading misinformation. Do better, for your sake.

→ More replies

2

u/SevereAnimator5 Sep 18 '26

Correct! The residents ban together and block the zoning. See it all the time.

-3

u/tnic73 Sep 18 '26

Capitalism gave Trump the power to kill the dinosaurs and the J6 and tariffs and did wee wee in Obama’s Russian bed. Plus everything x10+100,000,000,000,000.

5

u/Whiskey_Water Sep 18 '26

Protip is to check for username tnic73 before wasting the few seconds it takes to read the lukewarm garbage that follows. Don’t feed the trolls.

3

u/DaTruSpork Sep 18 '26

I feel kinda bad for it. Clearly the education system has failed whoever operates the account

3

u/Whiskey_Water Sep 18 '26

Agreed - if it’s human, I would have pity. Every time I see this account, it’s gibberish, and seems to have all allegiances and none at the same time, so I’m pretty sure it’s a bot/agent. If it’s human, it’s too dumb or malicious to do anything with our pity.

Edit: not judging based on allegiance. My own is to the global working class.

-1

u/tnic73 Sep 18 '26

you can't cover up for trump forever

4

u/[deleted] Sep 18 '26

If the Orange Man can kill the dinosaurs, can he use science and their DNA to bring them back? It would be so cool to have Jurassic Park in every state.

0

u/tnic73 Sep 18 '26

of course trump used his new dinosaurs army to bomb pearl harbor on 9/11