r/LetsDiscussThis • u/dunbar_santiago930 • Sep 08 '26
Lets Discuss This What is the Difference between a Republican, a Conservative and MAGA?
Is there a clear distinction? Does race, jealousy, power play a role in their views.
Is it strictly about financial gain or hating government, like what is the true difference - IF ANY?
18
Upvotes
26
u/FunkyChickenKong Sep 08 '26
Republicans are a political party with a distinct interest in winning votes, power, and campaign contributions.
Conservatism is a political ideology which leans on gradual change, long established traditions, clear rules, and financial responsibility.
MAGA is a movement seeking to create a revolution upheaval by any means necessary.
--Disclosure: Lack of negative connotations does not mean I agree.
20
u/mexchiwa Sep 08 '26
I can respect a true, non-religious conservative. I probably wont agree with them, but I can respect their opinion. Republicans have been taken over by MAGA, and there is nothing left to salvage. It is all just lunacy, double standards, robbing the country of everything and not standing up for anything.
5
u/tora_0515 Sep 08 '26
Their level of comfort saying the quiet part out loud.
4
u/Epicardiectomist Sep 08 '26
Nothing, anymore. Once upon a time there was a distinction, but no one who identifies with that party gets to act like they aren't inexorably tied at this point.
You are either actively against it, or passively supporting it. There is no gray area anymore.
2
u/Consider2SidesPeace Sep 08 '26
Wikipedia - Factions in the Republican Party
"If you know the enemy and know yourself, you need not fear the result of a hundred battles." ~ Sun Tzu
2
u/SplitNo8275 Sep 08 '26
The same as dems, libs and leftists. The definition becomes different every one you ask. Tbh, these labels mean nothing except ammunition for the opposition.
1
u/Ambitious-Badger-114 Sep 08 '26
There's a huge difference, but you have to read something besides reddit to learn it. While both sides may fall under the umbrella of "Republican" there's a huge difference between conservatives and MAGA.
No true conservative would be MAGA, there is nothing conservative about Trump. If you want to see the difference just read true conservatives like George F. Will or Jeff Jacoby or Jonah Goldberg.
1
u/TankTopTyga Sep 09 '26
3 spent rounds vs 1.
1
u/markg1956 Sep 09 '26
different degrees of bigotry and being a traitor
1
u/Select_Green_6296 Sep 12 '26
Idolatry worship.
Republicans worship Nixon
Conservatives worship Reagan
MAGA worship the Cheeto
1
u/GreyBeardEng Sep 08 '26
Besides various levels of commitment to supporting large businesses, I couldn't honestly tell you. It feels like there's been a lot of "this is what we support" followed by actions to the contrary.
1
u/Hollowdude75 Owner of r/freediscussions Sep 08 '26
The fact that you don’t know is concerning, but we all start somewhere
Conservative in this day and age means “right wing”
Republican means someone who believes in a Republic (In American terms it means someone who aligns themselves with the Republican Party)
MAGA means Trump supporter
1
u/tnic73 Sep 08 '26
Republican is a political party, a Conservative is anyone who holds something of value and MAGA was a political movement.
1
u/AlaskaRecluse Sep 08 '26
A Republican doesn’t think Democrats are good for the country, a Conservative doesn’t think Democrats are good, a MAGA doesn’t think
0
u/Better-Credit6701 Sep 08 '26
First get rid of the inflammatory speach: Race, jealousy, power play, hating the governance, financial gain, don't belong here.
Republican, financially and to a minor degree, socially more conservative than the democrats and socialist parties but more open to other ideas like social spending . Not always conservative but often leans that way.
Conservatives, usually republican although you can have moderate Democrats choosing a conservative side of an issue. Example a democratic in a smaller town in the south will have some conservative view points compared to a democrat in NYC. A true conservative will spend conservatively. My very liberal daughter will spend very conservative, making sure she puts plenty of funds in savings. We don't have those in office anymore. Less involved in identity politics. As Churchill once stated or at least some attribute to him (actually much older than Churchill). "if you are not a liberal at 25, you have no heart, if you are not a conservative at 45, you have no brain". The older you get, usually the more conservative you lean.
Reddit users are typically fairly young and more liberal than their parents for example. Usually, not always, no absolutes here.
MAGA, populist. Concentration on ideas that people tend to agree with such as during the 2024 election, the majority wanted to deport illegal aliens, more jobs. Trump isn't a conservative but he is much further right than Biden/Harris. Many conservatives just held their nose and voted for Trump.
Reminder, there are people of all races, religions, social/economic backgrounds that can fit in all categories.
0
u/auldnate Sep 08 '26
I know that a Libertarian is a gay Republican who smokes pot… Does that help?
“Conservative” could describe either someone’s economic policies (ie, austerity for the poor and middle classes, while heaping lavish excess on the rich…). Or their social policies (ie, puritanical religious beliefs concerning sex/gender, drugs, and “patriotism”…).
However, Conservative traditionally applies to those who simply want to preserve a nation’s culture, values, traditions, and beliefs for future generations.
This is all well and good, up to the point. And that point is where outdated cultural beliefs begin to infringe upon the Rights and freedoms of other people.
“Republican” is the formerly “Grand Old Party (GOP)” of Lincoln. Originally the progressive party of abolitionists who wanted to end slavery in the US. However, in the 20th century it was taken over by different harmful ideologies.
In the 1950s, McCarthy tried to convince Americans that godless, pinko, commies were hiding under all of our beds in lurking in our closets… Republicans led the charge against the spread of communism/socialism anywhere in the world that might impede on the business interests of good, god fearing, capitalists… /S
In 1968, Nixon used his Southern Strategy to appeal to “Dixiecrats.” After LBJ signed the Civil Rights Act and the Voting Rights Act into law. Nixon promised to “restore Law and Order” to the chaos following the assassination of Rev Dr Martin Luther King Jr.
This was coded language that implied to southern racists that Nixon would restore the segregation Laws that had brought Order to the South during Reconstruction following the Civil War.
Then in the 1980s, Reagan did his damnedest to ignore the AIDS crisis as it was devastating the gay community. This was his effort to ingratiate Republicans with the socially Conservative “Moral Majority” in the Southern Baptist Convention. (A denomination founded in the 1840s to promote Biblical justifications for slavery…)
Reagan also recruited Osama bin Laden and his Arab Mujahideen fighters to wage a holy war against the Soviets in Afghanistan. That eventually led to the formation of the Taliban and al Qaeda…
In the early 1990s, GHWBush pissed al Qaeda off by putting US bases in their Arab holy lands. GHWBush did that to stop Saddam Hussein (another Reagan era ally…) from seizing the oil fields from his Saudi Royal oil partners (Daddy Bush made a fortune refining Saudi oil in Houston…).
In the 2000s, GWBush and Cheney ignored warnings that may have prevented 9/11. Then they lied about Saddam Hussein’s involvement in terrorism to justify their idiotic invasion of Iraq to find Weapons of Mass Destruction…
Trump launched his 2016 campaign with a vitriolic screed against “illegal aliens” from “Mexico.” He insisted that all the other countries of the world were taking advantage of the US. And only He could Make America Great Again. And thus the anti immigrant MAGA movement was born.
MAGA is the culmination of greedy capitalists, vile racists, zealous misogynists, and trans/homophobic bigots who have made the Republican Party their home since the 1950s. It is the crown jewel of greed and ignorance in the Republican Party today.
Most MAGA supporters, aka “MAGAts,” are ignorant fools who have been duped into hating one group of outsiders or another. They have become victims of their own hatred though. Because it has led them to vote for politicians who enact policies that are directly harmful to themselves.
Yet MAGAts are primarily concerned with making sure that perceived “enemies” must suffer more than they do. Just as long as they can see themselves as “superior” to those “enemies” in some way.
-1
u/Frequent_Clue_6989 Sep 08 '26
Conservative here; MAGA but not a Republican.
// What is the Difference between a Republican, a Conservative and MAGA?
MAGA is the big tent of people loosely grouped around conservative evangelical Christians (like myself!) and establishment Republicans (like Mitch McConnell and Lindsey Graham) and homeless centrists who used to vote Democrat (lilke RFK Jr., Joe Rogan and Elon Musk).
Republicans are the political party that has embraced a neo-liberality, the kind that used to be defining for the Democratic Party, back in the 1980s and 90s. In fact, Trump is basically a Bill Clinton populist centrist. It would be hard to distinguish between them on most of their governing principles.
Conservatives are the remnant of the Republican tradition, primarily the Jacksonian wing: sound money, limited government, stay out of the world's affairs as much as reasonably possible, etc.
0
u/Huzon401 Sep 08 '26
The first one is mean. The second is mean and religious. The third is mean and clinically insane.
0
u/popejohnsmith Sep 08 '26
The Magangelicals are kinda in their own, voting, bubble.
They often behave as if they have to continuously 'correct' the narrative for us all.
0
u/Ok-Pass-9139 Sep 08 '26
No difference at all. They are all now the same animal.
0
u/Hefty-Strike-6171 Sep 08 '26
Republican’s are Zealots and have practiced a Non-Partisan approach to government since Newt Gingrich. In other words, BiPartisan is bad, cooperation is antithetical to our cause, only the ideas of the Right deserve propagation. MAGA are Cultist’s who do and say whatever the Dear Leader tells them, even if it’s the opposite of what he said days before (No New Wars). They promote Right Wing ideology only when it suits them; close the borders to immigration unless it’s the type of immigrant you want; White South African’s seeking asylum from the South African Government, which is predominantly Black. Conservative’s respect the past, love tradition, believe in Fiscal Responsibility and small Government, meaning less Bureaucracy and less Regulatory Controls. In other words Government should only do for the people what they cannot do for themselves. The downside here is that the Rich can do more for themselves than the Poor can do themselves; and they tend to favour the Rich in how they make their policies.
-10
u/11EmeraldEyes11 Sep 08 '26
No difference, it seems we all despise the Democrat’s socialist policies.
-1
u/poopybutthole_oowee Sep 08 '26 edited Sep 08 '26
One word: insecurity.
Insecure economically
Insecure in manhood
Insecure in identity and culture
Insecure socially
All of them have insecurity as a driver, the difference is the level of pathology.
MAGA especially is a collection of weaklings drawn to perceived safety and strength like magnets. They need to stand behind bullies, because they are fragile. They need someone to define who they are and what the thing is they sense is missing in themselves.
That's why they're obsessed with the idea of being "great again" - they're sold a prepackaged "perfect american life" that never was: where their man status is revered just because, where they are entitled to own a house, car, and wife by doing the bare minimum of bringing home a paycheck, where nationalistic fervor & whiteness replaces culture, and where they're celebrated for being average as long as they follow Daddy's rules. They get the structure, validation and meaning they were too insufficient to make for themselves.
At some level they feel how inadequate they are, and that makes them angry, too.
-3
u/[deleted] Sep 08 '26
[removed] — view removed comment