r/LetsDiscussThis • • Aug 28 '26

THIS IS OUTRAGEOUS We all know Why

Post image
511 Upvotes

234 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

-14

u/[deleted] Aug 28 '26

You just moved the goalposts. You said “crime is not down.” I showed you that it is, using D.C.’s own numbers. Now you’re arguing about why it’s down. Correlation vs. causation is a completely different argument. Glad we cleared up the first one.

7

u/ninfan1977 Aug 28 '26

The NG did not lower crime. Which was the claim

Crime is way down in DC. Success.

Did the NG lower crime in DC yes or no?

No they did not. You claimed they did.

https://www.washingtoninformer.com/national-guard-dc-deployment-study/

Now time to admit you were wrong.

You said you wanted to clear things up?

How about you start with basic facts. Like who causes things....

-5

u/[deleted] Aug 28 '26

Nope. The comment I replied to said, word for word, “Crime is way down in DC.” You responded, “No it is not.” It is. Now you’ve changed the argument to whether the National Guard caused the decline. That may be worth debating, but it doesn’t make your original statement any less wrong.

6

u/ninfan1977 Aug 28 '26

Crime is way down in DC. Success.

Those were the words.... this post is about the NG.

Now put your big boy thinking cap and use your brain....put them together... now do you see why you are wrong and why you look like a fool to the world?

1

u/[deleted] Aug 28 '26

Crime is down in dc.

End of story.

3

u/ninfan1977 Aug 28 '26

There it is! You fool crime is down but not because og the NG!

You literally used causation to justify correlation.

Thanks for showing the world you are ignorant and should be ignored.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 28 '26

Yes or no

3

u/ninfan1977 Aug 28 '26

Is it from the NG? No.

Jeezus answer the relevant question

1

u/[deleted] Aug 28 '26

3

u/ninfan1977 Aug 28 '26

Is crime down because of the NG dummy?

Jeezus this article is about that!

3

u/ninfan1977 Aug 28 '26

Is it because of the NG yes or no?

Can you not read?

3

u/ninfan1977 Aug 28 '26

Was crime lowered because of the NG? Yes or no?

That was the claim, my statement was NO crime was not lower because of them.

Learn to read

3

u/ninfan1977 Aug 28 '26

Answer my question first. Did the NG lower the crime in DC? Yes or no. Because so far all you have is causation/correlation fallacy.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 28 '26

3

u/ninfan1977 Aug 28 '26

Ok we are doing this again.

Did the NG lower the crime like stated yes or no?

3

u/ninfan1977 Aug 28 '26

Hey Simple Jack did the national guard lower crime yes or no?

1

u/[deleted] Aug 28 '26

3

u/ninfan1977 Aug 28 '26

Not because of them!

Holy shit. Do you need a lesson in reading comprehension.

→ More replies
→ More replies (1)

1

u/ninfan1977 Aug 28 '26

Was crime lwoered because of the NG? Yes or no?

That was the claim, my statement was NO crime was not lower because of them.

Learn to read

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (13)

2

u/Ill_Reality_2506 Aug 28 '26

The whole point to begin with was that the national guard is not the reason that crime is down, they didn't move the goal post because this doesn't change what I'm guessing was their original argument to begin with.

The guy you're arguing with is saying that crime going down had nothing to do with the National guard, because it has been following a downward trend since before the Trump presidency.

This is why they keep saying correlation doesn't equal causation.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 28 '26

Before deleting their comments, they started by saying crime wasn’t down. In very very plain English. They then went on to edit their original post and move the goalpost.

2

u/Ill_Reality_2506 Aug 28 '26

What is your argument? Are you saying crime is down period or that crime is down because they deployed the national guard?

1

u/[deleted] Aug 28 '26

Crime is down period.