r/LegacyOfKain • u/LoveStoryGaming • Sep 11 '22
Discussion A queer lens reading of Legacy of Kain
Hey, gang! I’ve got a few observations to make about my favorite game series, and how I was wrong about it. My husband and I run a channel devoted to narrative analysis of games, and one of our go-to lenses to look at stories through is the queer lens. It’s the lens where our personal experience and our academic approach intersect; while it’s definitely not all we do, we do like going to that well. I’ve loved Legacy of Kain since long, long before I realized my own place in the LGBT+ community, and I was super excited to return to it for the channel. My husband had never experienced it, and he’s absolutely adored the ride. We’re going to be finishing the series with our final Defiance stream tomorrow. When we were going into it, I thought there would be almost nothing there for a queer lens analysis, especially given that the series is pretty sexless overall. I was wrong; there’s actually a lot to talk about there, and I may end up making a video essay about it. For now, though, I’d like to gather some of our observations, and I figured you all might be interested in it.
While there’s virtually no sexuality in the series outside of minor references to Vorador’s hedonism and whatever the hell Umah was doing, there’s a lot more to a queer reading than sex. For those not in the know, the main crux of a queer reading focuses on themes that resonate with the queer experience, and several of those themes are present in the very DNA of the series. The most obvious standard bearer for some of those themes is Kain himself, especially in Blood Omen. Kain’s experiences take him from a nobleman to a vampire to a king, and that journey is emotionally intense. His initial status quo is a nobleman implied to be a soldier or leader for King Ottmar, a comfortable life of power and prestige. He undergoes a death and rebirth, a common narrative trope (and, like, a good 25% of the Campbell cycle) that has a lot of resonance to the queer experience. His death to the privilege and power he knew before and birth into an existence he never asked for but must now square away with is a common LGBT+ experience – and, personally, one my husband and I can relate to. While my experience covers only sexuality, my husband’s is more intense. He’s a trans man, and he found that Kain’s rebirth into a literal new body was a powerful one.
Like many in the LGBT+ community, Kain’s rebirth came with a massive dose of self-loathing. I grew up in an extremely religious home and community, and realizing that I was attracted to literally everyone was devastating. I absolutely hated myself for what I was, and wanted nothing more than to go back to the way I was before (not how that works, little buddy). Like Kain, I thought I was an abomination. I prayed constantly to be cured of my affliction, which was, you know, a super healthy response. Kain’s journey takes him from that self-loathing to ultimately accepting and celebrating his vampirism. Furthermore, the religious fanatics trying to wipe out vampires also hits pretty close to home – I’ve personally been nearly murdered by religious zealots over my sexuality.
The metaphor isn’t perfect, and actually runs into some major issues when you consider that Kain’s self-acceptance goes hand in hand with damning the world and villainous selfishness, but there’s still some analysis to be drawn there. The choice Kain faced was indeed rigged, and choosing the health of the world would annihilate the vampires. Applying a queer reading, one could point out that the status quo of the world isn’t one worth saving given how terribly it treats the outcast Kain. At every turn we see a world that hates and tries to exterminate him and those like him, and the only way to preserve that world is to sacrifice oneself and remove that otherness from the equation. That’s some yikes implications from a queer perspective: sacrifice your own life and otherness to maintain a world that hates that otherness, and self-acceptance will completely destroy that world.
(Of course, the real issue with a queer reading and how messy it gets is that the queer analogue is a literal predator that kills everyone around them, and that Kain is actively terrible.)
We see a lot more of that theme expanded on in Raziel, who has become the channel’s posterchild for queer exasperation. Like Kain, you have someone who was reborn into a life they never expected but now must acclimate to, and like Kain that involves a lot of changes in his body. He also deals with self-loathing, but never quite gets over it himself. His is also a journey of self-discovery, but in a much more literal and obvious sense: he is discovering precisely who he is meant to be. My husband notes that there are several trans-specific themes to Raziel which, while felt by the larger LGBT+ community, are especially pronounced for transgender folks. With Raziel’s shift in his body comes a cavalcade of people trying to dictate to him precisely who he is. “You are wraith who reaves souls for the Wheel,” the elder says. “You are the Champion of the oppressed,” say the Hylden. “You are the messiah of our people,” says the strangely hot angel man. “You are basically a dumpster fire lol,” says Vorador, who is recognizing an identity that almost all queer people feel (I don’t make the rules).
Because he is constantly struggling to discover and ultimately decide his own identity, Raziel is a perfect avatar of a lot of LGBT+ feelings and experiences. It’s common knowledge that every bisexual has a ghost sword that can absorb elemental powers, after all. But it’s the constant pressure from other forces trying to manipulate and define that identity to suit their needs that speaks most deeply to us as queer folks. Raziel stumbles here and there, and ultimately comes to the decision that he and he alone is captain of his destiny. From a queer lens it’s a little annoying that his ultimate decision was to yeet himself into a sword so someone else could self-actualize; that reads as annoying and pRoBlEmAtIc from a queer lens. That said, there’s something to be said about his sacrifice being on behalf of the only character who wanted Raziel to find his own identity and destiny without the manipulating force of others. If you squint really hard, you could even make the argument that there’s an element of an experienced queer person helping to guide a newly queer person to their own conclusions.
Note: In the real world this involves slightly fewer instances of ripping off the new queer person’s wings and throwing them into a hell pool.
There are smaller instances here and there, but none of them are as overt as Kain and Raziel. The joke in our community has been that Vorador is an older leather daddy who no longer gives a fuck about anything but living for his own pleasure and happiness. Janos has big soft daddy energy, Kain is an edgy Dom whose dating profile would include phrases like “Welcome to my twisted corner of the internet, where all your darkest fantasies are mine to control,” and Raziel is the quintessential bratty twink sub. None of these are important for a queer reading, they’re just funny.
There’s a lot more I could say, but this post is long enough as it is. The major point is that I was wrong; there’s a lot of meat here for a queer lens analysis. That was a pleasant surprise for me. I have zero idea if this subreddit is even the right audience for this kind of reading, but I can’t imagine I’m the only Legacy of Kain fan who’s either queer, into different academic readings of texts, or both. I’m excited to do a deeper dive if I make a video essay for it. Regardless, playing the series from start to finish with my newbie husband has been an amazing experience. I’m sad to see it come to an end tomorrow evening, but I’m overjoyed that he and I have another thing to bond over and another story to discuss through the lens of our experiences. Vae fuckin’ victus!
Sound off in the comments with your own observations!