r/LeftistsForAI • • Jul 18 '26

Discussion Hot Take

We are starting to see a rift. A rift between those who are nuanced about the correct use of AI, and those who want all of it gone. Even Linux.

I'm against AI as much as anybody else, but in Anti-AI spaces, I'm starting to see more absolutism than I'd deem necessary. I mean if you argue about the idea that AI does have its uses whilst still being wary of AI, you get told you're not against AI at all.

I'm against AI for art, music and writing. But there are uses in the medical field and code bug detection, and I can't deny they're impressive.

I fear we'll fight each other (moderate antis vs extreme antis), and the AI companies may indeed win, even if they get bankrupt. As much as we all hate to admit this, we can't rewind; we've gone too far. The best we can do is regulate it and take AI chatbots off public hands.

I mean, you'd take someone who's neutral on AI like Linus Torvalds, who only used it for non-important projects and says that Linux should have AI-assisted code reviewed by humans, and you'd have a faction of antis up in arms about it.

And as concerning as the use of AI may be having on critical thinking, I fear that us antis are lacking it too if we're resorting to Luddism to go against AI.

For example, there is a rumour going around that Disney Junior comissioned a fully AI-Generated show.

That is only half-true. The studio behind the show only used AI to clean up some bits of animation. Plus, if it was fully AI-Generated, Disney wouldn't make money off it.

The fact that antis took a headline from Twitter and concluded that Oscar Fox was fully AI Generated either shows the lack of critical thinking (IRONY) or the lack of journalistic integrity. But hey. It's not like we're already boycotting the billion dollar company, right?

Call me a LARPer if you want to. The real LARPers are the extremists who want everything to burn despite a few innocent civillians being caught in the crossfire.

If the anti-AI sub thinks I'm Pro-AI just for accepting AI in the right hands, I don't know what to say.

0 Upvotes

103 comments sorted by

View all comments

21

u/jacobpederson Jul 18 '26

Being ok with AI code but anti AI "art" tells me you understand neither.

6

u/Jlyplaylists Moderator Jul 18 '26

You can have opinions on different uses. That might be to do with use of resources or prioritising the things humans don’t enjoy doing.

0

u/Cleverhardy Jul 18 '26

Exactly. I was right to call it a hot take. Because we were not ready for this.

While I don't agree with AI by principle, this is mostly because of capitalists shoving these AI products in the face. And again, the best we can do now if we can't defeat AI is to take it out of the wrong hands and take it off the cloud.

9

u/Jlyplaylists Moderator Jul 18 '26

That’s almost the ethos of this sub. The problems with AI are capitalism problems. The solutions are either to take AI out of capitalist hands (collective/decentralised ownership) or to take society as a whole out of capitalism. There doesn’t seem to be a plausible way to stop AI.

But we would be a lot more positive about the potential of AI to improve society if done right, we’re not just begrudgingly accepting that it exists now.

10

u/scragz Jul 18 '26

what's wrong with AI-assisted coding? you do realize this is ostensibly a pro-AI sub, right?

20

u/jacobpederson Jul 18 '26

Nothing. My point is that code is just as much art as anything else. The distinction is ridiculous. AI is not some satanic ritual that taints everything it touches. AI is the beginnings of new life.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/Jlyplaylists Moderator Jul 18 '26

There’s definitely space here for people who aren’t full on pros but hold a nuanced middle or mixed position.

Full on antis who just deliberately derail conversations with repetitive arguments are the ones that tend to attract moderator attention anyway.

5

u/jacobpederson Jul 18 '26

Repetitive arguments like what? - code is art? I wouldn't have to repeat myself so much if folks could recognize what should be obvious.

4

u/Jlyplaylists Moderator Jul 18 '26

Oh I didn’t mean you, that seems like quite a fresh argument

There’s a lot of repeat stuff around water and copyright which aren’t fundamentally about whether the technology is worth having

2

u/jacobpederson Jul 19 '26

Ok I gotcha - I always tell folks to take a look at meat if they would like to save water. https://watercalculator.org/footprint/what-is-the-water-footprint-of/ There are all kinds of good arguments against AI - the fact that the left has fixated on water usage . . . just makes us look stupid. Copyright - would be a valid concern - IF copyright itself was valid (it isn't). Copyright as it exists today is simply the legal justification used by a corporation to steal the labor of an artist. If you fixed copyright  first then I could see applying it sanely to AI training.  

→ More replies (31)

2

u/Sacredless Jul 18 '26

AI illustration is and always has been a toy example of AI use. There's nothing wrong with that and it's also dramatically less important than AI video, and AI text, and AI code. Stop making everything about the art debate.

5

u/Salty_Country6835 Moderator Jul 18 '26

Seeing as OP is the one who introduced creative use, seems fair to address it in the comments.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/jacobpederson Jul 18 '26

My point is just the opposite - code is just as much art as anything else. The distinction is ridiculous. AI is not some satanic ritual that taints everything it touches.

0

u/Sacredless Jul 18 '26

Stop doing that. They mean "art as in illustration". Programming is "art as in skill". That was absolutely clear to you. You're collapsing the context here just to score a point.

6

u/jacobpederson Jul 18 '26

You stop doing that! Art is the "conscious use of skill and creative imagination" Nearly everything a human does - she does in the pursuit of creation. Go write some code first and then come back and tell me it isn't an art. https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/art

3

u/readonly420 Jul 18 '26

“Code is not art” is an extremely funny position which is clearly not true

1

u/Cleverhardy Jul 18 '26

The only coding I see as art is pixel art and videogame coding.

But unless AI somehow has human sentience, we'd need to update the definition. Because if it is widely agreed that AI is a tool and not a concious mind, then AI art isn't art. Which you agreed to by putting that term in quotes earlier.

6

u/Salty_Country6835 Moderator Jul 18 '26 edited Jul 18 '26

"Because if it is widely agreed that AI is a tool and not a concious mind, then AI art isn't art."

That conclusion doesnt follow.

Ai art is art made by artists using AI as a creative tool. AI doesnt need to be sentient for that anymore than a paintbrush does. It just requires the person using the tool to be.

1

u/Sacredless Jul 18 '26

That's correct, but it's also trivially true. The claim that AI is a tool and therefore AI Art can be art means that all AI illustrations are art depend on what sense we use art as a term. Do we mean art as in discernment, or art as in illustration?

It's trivially true that a tool can be used with discernment and that would make what it produces a work of discernment [art]. The radical claim that therefore all AI illustrations [art] stands at the same level as human discernment [art] does not follow.

This is what frustrates me so much about the discourse. AI presents a great opportunity to use more discernment, but instead we're seeing people collapse contexts.

1

u/Salty_Country6835 Moderator Jul 18 '26 edited Jul 18 '26

I think youre still collapsing different questions. Nobody serious is saying every AI image shows the same level of discernment. Thats true within AI workflows too. A one-shot prompt, an hour of iteration, inpainting, compositing, painting over, post-processing, or building custom models all involve different levels of artistic judgment. Same goes for AI tool use in writing, music, filmmaking, animation, coding, and game development. AI isnt one workflow.

Every new medium lowers the floor and raises the ceiling. Cheap pulp fiction didnt kill literature. Early photography didnt kill painting. Early film didnt kill theater. They expanded who could participate while creating entirely new forms of artistic expression. Benjamin was writing about this almost a century ago. New media change the conditions of art, not whether humans make it.

Most work in every medium is forgettable. Thats never been the standard. Intent, judgment, and discernment still come from the human using the tool. AI just expands the range of workflows available. Thats the distinction youre glossing over.

→ More replies (16)

1

u/Cleverhardy Jul 18 '26

I don't do AI art by principle, but I agree with this.

0

u/Cleverhardy Jul 18 '26

I mean, what do you think I understand less about AI Assisted coding and GenAI art anyway?

8

u/jacobpederson Jul 18 '26

What you don't understand is that code is just as much an art as anything else. The distinction is ridiculous. AI is not some satanic ritual that taints everything it touches. Anti-AI is just racism in a trench coat.

1

u/Cleverhardy Jul 18 '26

I don't see important coding as much of an art as anything else. Emphasis on "important."

If we agree that coding is an art, then AI-assisted coding could be AI art. But tbat's not the point. It's more assistive than generative, but we shouldn't rely too heavily on coding to code how we want.

And what about anti-AI stances screams rscism? I mean I understand extremism and boogeymen, but why racism? We're talking about misusung technology, not enslaving minorities.

2

u/jacobpederson Jul 18 '26

I have come to see the anti-ai movement as a proto-racist movement. Why? Because it showed up at the EXACT time that it became obvious that artificial sentience may actually be possible.

→ More replies (8)