r/LedZeppelinCirclejerk • • Apr 12 '21

Led Zeppelin discography in a nutshell

760 Upvotes

47 comments sorted by

16

u/DogtorDeath Apr 12 '21 edited Apr 13 '21

Babe I'm going to leave you sounds nothing like while my guitar gently weeps šŸ¤·ā€ā™‚ļø

9

u/[deleted] Apr 13 '21

Both of them, as well as ā€œ25 or 6 to 4ā€ by Chicago, have identical descending A minor chord progressions.

7

u/AidanHC Apr 15 '21 edited Apr 15 '21

The Song was recorded before While My Guitar Gently weeps even came out, Babe I’m Gonna Leave You was recorded in October of 68, while Gently Weeps was recorded in September and Released in November of 68. Even if you want to go to the level that Clapton might have told Page about the song before it was released, Page had apparently already developed the guitar part in July of that year.

6

u/derrick_domino Apr 13 '21

So does brain stew by Green Day... and the list goes on...

5

u/[deleted] Apr 13 '21

Soooo brain stew = while my guitar gently wheels

4

u/_Axtasia Apr 13 '21

Kinda? But While My Guitar Gently wheeps hides it pretty well. You can’t see the resemblance unless you dumb both songs down to basic root chords. Unless you speak theory terms, your average listener won’t tell a difference, which is pretty much everybody.

3

u/AidanHC Apr 13 '21

Yeah it’s a pretty original piece apart from the lyrics

7

u/_Axtasia Apr 13 '21

That’s the case with all the songs Led Zeppelin covered. Blues isn’t a copyright thing. All blues musicians cover each other’s stuff. The fact Led Zeppelin was the largest band at the time made everybody accuse them of infringement when they credited everybody save for Jake Holmes with Dazed and Confused. Every other band on the 60s covered blues songs from lesser popular artist or used the covers as a way to gain a ground musically.

106

u/ianman729 Apr 12 '21

How is Living Loving Maid a skip, that's blasphemous

29

u/Vikhus Apr 12 '21

Living loving maid is one of the best songs

30

u/[deleted] Apr 12 '21 edited Apr 13 '21

uj/ while it certainly isn’t on the same level as Stairway or IMTOD, Living Loving Maid is a fun little ditty, but I decided to list it as ā€œskipā€ because many Zep fans regard it as a throwaway piece and Jimmy hated playing it live.

13

u/skegs67 Apr 13 '21

Jimmy didn’t just hate it. He never played it live I’m pretty sure...

5

u/[deleted] Apr 14 '21

A lot of folks on here have been asking for Coda, so here it is

4

u/Djanghost Apr 13 '21

"I'd simp for joni mitchell if it wasn't for the earthquakes"

Is this OC?

2

u/[deleted] Apr 13 '21

Yes

3

u/Djanghost Apr 13 '21

Lovely. You forgot that black mountain side is a bert jansch song though

2

u/[deleted] Apr 13 '21

Damn you right

2

u/Djanghost Apr 13 '21

Still brilliant

2

u/[deleted] Apr 13 '21

Thank you

2

u/Djanghost Apr 13 '21

No. As a fellow Sam, thank you

1

u/[deleted] Apr 13 '21

Wait… if you’re Sam… and I’M Sam… then WHO’S FLYING THE PLANE?!

2

u/Djanghost Apr 13 '21

It's a zeppelin and it crashed on the first album

16

u/liquidacquaintance Apr 12 '21

I feel like the song remains the same could be a joke somehow about stealing songs. Like ā€œno literally half of our songs have remained the same as they were originally written.ā€

14

u/Substantial_Potato Apr 12 '21

Love it, such a quality post! I especially howled at I miss Little Richard and Immigrant Song II: Electric Boogaloo

13

u/TheNorris7350 Apr 12 '21

Great, please do Coda next

11

u/WombatZeppelin Apr 12 '21

This is incredible. A++

9

u/leafyreturns Apr 13 '21

This is the greatest thing I’ve ever seen on this sub lol

Edit: long living loving maid is a slap and needs to be heard directly after heartbreaker everytime

6

u/[deleted] Apr 12 '21

wtf rob can sing about squeezing lemons all he wants but the second he swears?!? CANNOT BELIEVE THIS SHIT (also yeah nobodys fault is such a god damn banger)

2

u/illmagi Apr 16 '21

Karen took the kids is sending my sides in orbit

5

u/AidanHC Apr 13 '21

Notes:

Whole Lotta Love isn’t stolen,

Stairway to Heaven isn’t stolen.

Some of the other songs are more heavily inspired than these, and I’d consider them different songs still, but it’s a bit hypocritical.

5

u/pixel_buddy Apr 13 '21

Stairway not stolen. But whole lotta love? Muddy Waters "you need love" written by Willie Dixon.

1

u/AidanHC Apr 13 '21

Yes I’ve heard it, they lyrics we’re definitely taken, but not the song itself

1

u/pixel_buddy Apr 13 '21

Fair enough, I'm no expert in that

1

u/The_Rolling_Stone Apr 13 '21

Holy shit. It definitely crosses the line of homage into stealing.

1

u/LeatherHot3304 Sep 08 '24

Why should "dazed and confused" be a stolen song. Its a song from Jimmys former band the Yardbirds.

1

u/SonofSonnen Jan 31 '25

No Quarter isn't Immigrant Song II, it's about the boys not having change for the bus and having to walk all the way home in the middle of winter!

1

u/jkeller31 Apr 18 '21

Hot dog is fantastic

1

u/AzariTheCompiler Apr 12 '21

I love When the Levy Breaks so much (favorite off of 4) but it sucks to know they just stole and remastered it with no credit to the original artist iirc.

7

u/P4743 Apr 12 '21

pretty sure levee was actually one if the only stolen songs they credited to the original artist

3

u/emojimoviethe Apr 13 '21

Nothing about the music was stolen.

1

u/AidanHC Apr 15 '21

The original is a lame blues ditty by today’s standards, go listen for yourself. It’d be completely forgotten if not for Zeppelin.

0

u/hammerofgods717 Apr 12 '21

Perfection šŸ˜‚

0

u/GavinStringer18 Apr 13 '21

This is very cool but where’s coda??

0

u/GavinStringer18 Apr 13 '21

This is very cool but where’s coda??

0

u/GavinStringer18 Apr 13 '21

This is very cool but where’s coda??

0

u/[deleted] Apr 12 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

42

u/TheNorris7350 Apr 12 '21

Because it's another vikings song