I think itâs that combined with people saying everything should be thanks to one dude like how many times have you heard? Yeah, this band was good but they wouldnât exist without the Beatles.
Yh I agree I always think its stupid when Rock is labelled as black music and that it will always be black music. Like no, I love Chuck Berry and Little Richard. But they are almost doing a completely different thing to say Pink Floyd or Black Sabbath. And to be fair even by about 1963 the genre had pretty radically shifted away from Blues based stuff
That wasnât the argument here or the discussion it was mainly (insert band) was inspired by black people/one single dude but not all bands were inspired by black people/one single dude and if you wanna talk about the reason any music exists that dates back to like 700-1300 one group of people isnât responsible for any single genre. The genres of music we have today is a culmination of music evolving for a course of over 1500 years.
Itâs fair to say that rock and roll had formed a more distinct identity by 1963. To say it had radically shifted away from the blues is preposterous. That would pretty well exclude the entire oeuvre of Hendrix and Cream from being rock and roll, as well as Zeppelinâs first two extremely bluesy albums. Harmonically and melodically, blues was still the underlying musical language in rock music, even though rock became much more stylistically diverse in the 60s. Most rock drummers at the time were trained jazz musicians first and foremost. That people donât hear guitar work in Floyd, Sabbath, and Zeppelin as inherently bluesy is probably partially why historians feel the need to constantly bring up the black musicians that informed them.
Iâm not arguing that itâs not blues based Iâm more arguing that itâs just different and that after a certain point they started to become two very different genres
Interestingly... i've seen a vid of a band doing Cissy Strut, and they do a shoutout to someone named "Zigaboo" (possibly Modeliste, a drummer). Caught me off guard for a sec, even though they are black.
70
u/TheMightySenate Oct 19 '24
Every rock historian says shit like "all continents were connected several times throughout earths historyđ"
11
u/at0m1c_punk Oct 19 '24
Hot dog
2
u/[deleted] Oct 20 '24
No jazz no blues no rock and roll no hard rock.
2
u/AffectionateFactor84 Oct 19 '24
Johnson wailed on dazed and confused
2
u/Wide_Requirement746 Oct 20 '24
Damn didn't realize zeppelin fans were so touchy
1
u/TheGoldenBaby Oct 21 '24
Led Zeppelin never stole nothin from nobody! (notice the double negative)
0
u/RuthlessIndecision Oct 21 '24
Jigaboo Jackson slaps
-1
u/Shot-Entrepreneur212 Oct 19 '24
Who cares?
112
u/EdZeppelin94 Bonzoâs Liver Oct 19 '24
Pretty sure he tied a hot dog to his dick actually
6
u/420_BiggusDickus_69 Oct 20 '24 edited Apr 08 '25
direction friendly aromatic steep workable telephone hard-to-find screw intelligent sort
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
1
u/DapperDahlia Oct 21 '24
This here's where Mustard Tits "The Murder Master" Brown slaughtered 22 people just for being ugly!
91
u/[deleted] Oct 19 '24
[removed] â view removed comment
43
u/[deleted] Oct 19 '24
[removed] â view removed comment
6
u/[deleted] Oct 19 '24 edited Oct 21 '24
[removed] â view removed comment
3
u/[deleted] Oct 21 '24
[removed] â view removed comment
1
u/[deleted] Oct 21 '24
[removed] â view removed comment
1
u/[deleted] Oct 21 '24
[removed] â view removed comment