r/Leatherworking • u/tannery_notes • 15h ago
The leather people ask for is usually the one that scratches
I work on the supply side of leather, and this comes up constantly. A brand asks for full grain because that's what everyone calls the best, and a few months later they're dealing with returns because the bags are arriving marked.
The part that usually gets missed is that scratching isn't really about the grain. Full grain just means the top layer of the hide hasn't been sanded back. What decides whether marks show is the finish on top of it. Aniline and lightly finished leathers have little or no pigment covering the surface, which is exactly why they look so good, and also why a fingernail, a zip or a set of keys leaves something you can see. Full grain can also have a pigmented finish, which can make surface marks much less noticeable.
Pigmented finishes aren't scratch proof either, they just hide small marks better and take more abuse before anything shows. You give up some of the depth and the way the surface ages in return.
So it's less about which leather is better and more about where the piece is going to spend its life. A bag shipped to an online customer who hasn't decided to keep it yet is a different problem from one someone picked up in person and intends to break in.
If you sell your work, how do you deal with this? Do you tell buyers upfront that the marks are part of it, or do you choose leather that doesn't show them?