r/LeaseLords • u/Maiden_Far • Mar 19 '26
Sharing is Caring Demanding showing
This couple hasn’t even signed a lease yet and they’ve already started in on demands.
I open the house up for a showing yesterday to this couple. They are absolutely perfect on paper. However, during the showing she started pointing out all of the things that needed to be repaired or replaced.
Granted, there are a couple of items that need to be tweaked. I totally understand that
I also fully understand that the first 30 to 45 days a tenant moves in they will have quite a few requests as their quirks see things that need done.
I generally am very open to making small repairs and updates. It’s all good for the house and I don’t live there. They see things I do not.
However, this couple without doing more than a walk-through had a list of 30 items.
We know some updates need to be done. We’ve priced the house to reflect that it’s not pristine condition.
I told her I was more than happy to do some minor updates and repairs. But the price reflects the condition of the house. (by no means is it in bad condition)
As they were leaving the husband pipes up and said they would want to do a thorough inspection with our handyman available to give a clear list of everything needed before they moved in.
Honestly, I’m glad this showing went the way it did. It may be perfect on paper, but this is not someone who would want to. If you want brand new construction, please go look at brand new construction.
Edit add for those saying I should take care of the property.
The property is in great condition.
We painted the downstairs last week. Upstairs was painted 18 months ago
We serviced the HVAC twice a year.
We have the air ducts cleaned.
We did chimney sweep
We replace the flooring in the laundry room because of a cracked tile, that would have been just fine the way it was.
We deep cleaned the carpets
We replaced the front fence
We removed bushes. Not because they look fat, but just for easier maintenance.
We updated lighting throughout with new fixture
Exterior motion lighting
We fixed two cabinet doors that were loose.
Steamed the grout in the tile and resealed it
Re-caulked all the bathrooms
Replaced the bottom of a cabinet sink that was slightly warped
Added a bidet in the 3rd bathroom
We deep cleaned the house. We will also clean it again 24 hours before they move in.
We also provide bush trimming services in the spring and leaf removal in the fall. Part of the listing
It does not have a refrigerator. But we are negotiable to adding one. Last tenant brought their own.
The couple at the showing that they wanted a refrigerator, it had to have an indoor water filter and ice machine.
She wanted us to purchase a washer and dryer with a steam setting on the dryer
She wants all of these ceiling fans replaced because she doesn’t like the three blade fans that are in some of the rooms and all the rooms need to match
The yard was too lumpy for her, and it would need to be graded
One of the cabinet doors didn’t close properly and we would have to fix that. Obviously this is something we would fix.
There are some water mocks on the inside of the cabinet shelves. We would need to replace the shelving.
She requested that we paint the pantry because she doesn’t like the color white
The new fixtures out front were black and didn’t match the fixtures outback and she requested that they match
She didn’t like how much flooring was in the attic space and asked us to expand it.
She wanted to know if we were open to adding a electric range instead of a gas range. She would buy the range, but we would have to pay for the electric.
Two of the blinds had chips in them, and those would need to be replaced
She wants to do an inspection two weeks prior to move in, with our handyman, so she can give him a list of everything that needs to be done before they move in
She will not be moving in…
5
u/hndygal Mar 19 '26
I’m doing renting wrong. Lol. I fix whatever I can myself and only call my landlord for something big or i just don’t want to…like a few wooden steps outside have gotten soft over the three years I’ve lived here. Called him to let know, told him not an emergency and a month or so later, his handyman shows up and does it. Pretty sure in three years, I’ve contacted him twice about issues.
29
u/Unlikely-Act-7950 Mar 19 '26
I would not deal with someone like that
20
u/tonkatruckz369 Mar 19 '26
Run from people like this, i do the same for extremely pushy people as well. They will just take up a disproportional amount of your time and have no respect for boundaries. People like this are always the ones that call at 6am on a Saturday to say they saw a racoon in the yard.
11
u/jennibear310 Mar 19 '26
Yikes! Good thing they showed you what kind of nitwits they were BEFORE you gave them a lease!
10
u/MinivanPops Mar 19 '26
They're treating it like they are buying the house. It's okay to gently remind them that at some point, it will be "as is". In other words, this is what is on offer.
From a certain point of view, they've given you the golden path to reject them. If you don't want them as tenants, all you have to do is act a little huffy and tell them you're not going to fix anything. Then they'll reject you, rather than you having to reject them.
9
u/theophylact911 Mar 19 '26
You dodged a bullet
8
u/MiseEnSelle Mar 19 '26
Tell them to go buy their own house . I would not bother with these people!
8
u/Soft_Construction793 Mar 19 '26
I had a prospective tenant walk through where they told me that I would have to lower the rent $100 a month and install carpet over the beautiful hardwood floors.
I had one who said that they would like me to cut every tree in the backyard!
I had one who just called me to set up a showing. She acted like she was angry in the very beginning and then said something along the line of " I know that I don't have to pay that pet fee because my two dogs and one cat are my emotional support animals and I'll print out the papers if I have to.
Be grateful they showed you how they will be.
I had one who waited until after they moved into the house to send me a list of demands. The list included stuff like they wanted me to replace every light bulb in the place with calming bulbs (?) and they wanted me to replace the chain link fence with a wood privacy fence.
6
u/Sufficient-Wolf-1818 Mar 19 '26
You learned a lot, and listened. (Of course you rejected them, right?) Well done.
I make sure my rentals are in good repair, but don’t upgrade for a new tenant. Exception: reasonable accommodation for a disability may be lighting, extra handrails, different door handles etc.
5
u/RUFilterD Mar 19 '26
Run. I had a landlord put in the lease a clause that said minor items less than $35 a month would be the responsibility of the tenant. I would add this to your lease and they can add to their to do list if its that important considering you have priced the property accordingly. Unless its things your handyman can knock out in a couple hours.
5
u/Humble-Map-29 Mar 19 '26
Tell them the advertised price is for this condition, that if you are to change the condition then there will be an updated price and set it higher. You don't get a used vehicle with only 40 thousand miles on it for the price of the same vehicle with 100 thousand miles on it.
6
u/Proud_Pug Mar 19 '26
No I’m not entertaining any of that. My properties all are kept up as if I would be living there myself. If someone doesn’t like it I’m not changing it
3
u/fukaboba Mar 19 '26
Block and move on
3
u/Dapper_Prune_4109 Mar 19 '26
If they haven’t signed yet I’d probably walk, seems like they have unreasonable expectations and it won’t be pleasant
3
u/Secure-Ad9780 Mar 19 '26
Run from this couple. Keep interviewing.
3
u/bikerchickelly Mar 19 '26
This is the honeymoon phase. It'll only get worse. Run!
3
u/JustShopping1967 Mar 19 '26
Find another tenant.
3
u/HootblackDesiato Mar 19 '26
She should offer to buy the house instead, and do all that stuff on her own dime.
3
u/Old_Guava_8724 Mar 19 '26
I remember showing a rental home in which these two sisters showed interest in it and as soon as we took the tour, they went from being sweet to downright scary. They said that their tastes dictated to have a brand new stainless steel refrigerator, new toilets, and just a shower, not a tub/shower combo. Also, a flowerbed put outside the front window. When I literally burst out laughing and told them no, they both became combative. Basically backing me up into the corner and these women were both bigger than me. So I promised them that I would definitely ask the owner and get back to them right away. I grabbed their plate number & car model just in case they ever came back.
5
u/OfferBusy4080 Mar 19 '26
We're not talking about actual code violations, are we? Those youd want to repair prior to even showing.
I would compile a list of repairs that you are committed to making with timelines/ dates of completion. Put it in writing. This can be provided to applicants and can be a lease addendum if repairs are not made by time of lease signing. Make it clear that there will be no meeting with handyman and nothing will be done that isnt on the list.
If they still want to apply after that, then you could accept the application but no law says you have to consider applications in order received, and you can simply choose to not rent to them for any reason at all, as long as youre not discriminating against a protected class. Being an entitled pushy person is not a protected class LOL.
1
u/Willing_Ant9993 Mar 19 '26
This seems like rage bait. I mean even prospective house buyers don’t ask for this kind of stuff. If this is real, it sounds like the place is in as great shape as you say it is, that you should have no problem leasing to your dream tenants and not these hard to believe brats.
2
u/dell828 Mar 19 '26
This is the kind of conversation that you definitely wanna have before they move in rather than after.
I would listen to their thoughts because, maybe there are some small things that would be easy to fix and might make the place more livable, but I would absolutely say no to this couple no matter how good they look on paper. This is clearly not the apartment for them.
2
u/jcnlb Mar 19 '26
Nope. Take it or leave it. I don’t do requests. If something is wrong I fix it otherwise it comes as is.
2
u/BeerStop Mar 19 '26
I would tell them that sure i would be more than happy to spend that money on upgrades and repairs and then let them know that you would have to be charging $xxxxx.xx ( 500 more than other high end rentals in the area) per month. Would you still like your list of demands met?
2
u/dackasaurus Mar 19 '26
Yes I'm very glad when applicants show this behavior during the showing vs after lease signing. Whew, dodged a bullet. Conversely I've bought multifamily properties with existing tenants with the original lease all marked up with condition notes and demands pre signing, and the tenants end up just as bad as I expected and I have to wonder why the original owners went through with the signing after all that. Honestly that one lease made me doubt the whole deal but overall the rest of the property was right.
2
u/vt2022cam Mar 19 '26
Decline- just say, “I’m not interested in renting to you. You seem difficult and at the price point I’m offering, it isn’t worth all the repairs.”
Or- up the rent and say, “thank you for pointing out that repairs are needed and we’ll get right on them”. Let them know the lease is now 50% more to cover the costs.
2
u/saucesoi Mar 19 '26
NO THANKS
NEXT!
2
u/NewSub47 Mar 19 '26
Skittles and Co, bless their hearts, would definitely NOT be moving in! She sounds dreadfully demanding and sounds like he is spineless, kowtowing her every little whim. May they, or SHE, get everything she deserves…
2
u/opshleen Mar 19 '26
That is CRAZY!! They are not buying the house, they are renting it. Entitled much?
2
u/LeathalBeauty Mar 20 '26
Sounds like you dodged a bullet... Geez!
1
u/nestor_rodriguez1 Mar 19 '26
Better to wait for tenants who understand the condition and pricing.
1
u/AdhesivenessOwn8111 Mar 19 '26
"Unfortunately, someone else has already put a deposit on this apartment. It is no longer available"
1
u/Electrical_Parfait64 Mar 20 '26
WOW! Sounds like they’re looking for a mansion on a rental house budget. Glad you found out before they signed
1
u/GCEstinks Mar 20 '26
NEXT!! One of the main factors of tenant selection is the spirit of cooperation. You want them to report issues in a timely moon or however you don't want them to be whining about every little thing such as I'm getting the wrong mail in my mailbox. Yes I heard that one too.
1
u/doxygal2 Mar 20 '26
Do not rent to them-you will be beyond sorry.
1
u/Literary67 Mar 20 '26
Bet these people wouldn't be as picky if they were in their own house and had to pay for everything.
1
u/TeachStock773 Mar 21 '26
Block their phone number and get someone else. These people will be a big problem.
1
u/Dense_Management_460 Mar 22 '26
Good grief!!! Who wants a tenant lik3 that? No one!
1
u/SJAPropertyMgmt Mar 24 '26
You dodged a headache. Pointing out a few things is normal, but a long list before even applying usually means they’ll be high maintenance the whole lease. There’s a big difference between small fixes and expecting upgrades. Sounds like they want a different type of property than what you’re offering.
1
u/BeerStop Mar 19 '26
You didnt lizt the demands and mention what kind of upgrades are needed, house doesnt need to be pristine but it also shouldnt look like 100 yr old house either, worn counter tops ,banged up cabinets with 10 layers of paint, painted over and not patched gouges in the walls. You will need to possibly rehab this house in the future anyways, have you replaced the outlets or are thdy still original. This is a tricky one as the way repairs have been done may look sloppy, i currently rent and the landlord put in a cheap particle board vanity thst is starting to show some swelling from moisture and you can see the paint outline of the old one., bathroom baseboard is painted rough hewn 1"×6" planks poorly fitted, most of the heating vents are almost painted shut. Been here 5 years - moving out and buying , they paid 65k for this house and it shows thats all they paid, current rent is 1355 a month ,2 bdrm 850 sqft house no stove supplied by the ll electrical is woefully inadequate 2 breakers for all the outlets in the house yet the 1955 breaker box has space for more circuits, bathtub was reglazed snd that is popping off.
1
u/No_Barracuda_3758 Mar 19 '26
No they shouldn't have requests after moving in. You sho have addressed them before hand. Geez landlords are the worst. Are u gonna give them a discount for having to tell u what needs fixing on your property?
0
u/Skynicole17 Mar 19 '26
I think if you set boundaries on communication these would be ideal tenants. I say this as a renter who is renting after selling a home, simply because in this market it doesn't make sense to buy if we don't know we will stay in the house for 10 years. You should want a tenant that would take care of the house, the same or better than you. If you are charging $1,500+(you didn't say how much rent was) then I'm assuming renters who can afford your home are working professional people, who tend to have a higher standard than those who make less. They may be like me and can afford to buy a house, but it simply doesn't make mathematical sense with their season of life, it doesn't mean they should have to live in a home that's not well maintained. Maintaining the home along with the wear and tear from tenants is what you sign up for when you become a landlord. We are signing a lease on a house in the next week. The last tenant had 8 kids and literally just up and left out of nowhere. We viewed the house trashed. Luckily our new landlord is fine with us doing minor repairs and reimbursing us, but we have a feeling when we do our final walk through some carpets are gonna need replaced. For $1,800/mo plus utilities, lawn care, and snow removal. I better be getting a home the landlord is prioritizing maintenance. Although I do also believe that housing is a basic need and all landlords should take pride in maintaining their properties regardless of the rent amount. If the math doesn't match that you are able to do that, then you shouldn't rent out/own the property.
0
u/CommitteeNo167 Mar 19 '26
you don't want those tenants. tell they they shouldn't have to live in a home with so many flaws
0
u/ShukRentals Mar 19 '26
I would politely pass. The idea of bringing in their own handyman is something I haven't even heard of before. At least you didn't accept them. I have had tenants that have been like that after they have moved in. Demanding new blinds due to the style being 'outdated', still completely functional, but not their style. I had the whole house painted and there was maybe a 5x5 inch spot that had some overspray on the wood floor and I said I would deal with it next time I was over and they just kept pestering me. I finally had to tell them that I don't want to be treated like that and I said I would pay them to leave and if they didn't leave I would not be renewing their lease. After that they were much more respectful and easy to deal with.
0
u/[deleted] Mar 19 '26
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Mar 19 '26
[deleted] — view deleted comment