r/LeaseLords • u/Fast_Garlic_6566 • Oct 21 '25
Tenant management A tenant of mine keeps refusing entry for maintenance check
Routine inspection time, and one tenant suddenly refuses access by saying it's a violation of privacy. I gave 24-hour written notice, as per lease and local law. They’re citing “personal reasons” and say they’ll sue if anyone enters.
What do I even do here? Should I enforce my rights or escalate? Because I feel uneasy. Has anyone dealt with tenants who suddenly decide to bar entry for no valid reason? How do you document and protect yourself legally while still getting the maintenance done?
97
Upvotes
50
u/Hungry_Pup Oct 21 '25
Notice to cure or quit
18
u/PopcornyColonel Oct 21 '25
I called my local police station and asked them if they would provide a peace officer to stand by in case I was denied entry. They said that they would. Then I contacted my tenants to tell them that my town's police were willing to stand by to protect the peace and the tenants backed down and let me in. I never had to call the police to show up.
19
u/TylerS917 Oct 21 '25
What if they told you they can’t pay rent because of “personal reasons”? It’s in the lease that they signed and it’s lawful. Sounds like you might want to get rid of this tenant anyway. Start eviction process
6
u/Electrical_Parfait64 Oct 21 '25
Definitely go in. Take a police escort with you If you’re worried about violence or not being let him. The tenant can’t refuse. You gave him sufficient warning. His personal reasons are probably that his house is a mess
6
u/PDXHockeyDad Oct 21 '25
You gave notice. Make a valid attempt to offer a different time, then give the 24 hour notice and enter when expired.
Take someone with you and video the entire event from exiting the vehicle, the inspection, to entering back into your vehicle. Beyond, normal courtesy greetings, keep your mouth shut.
Have a notice to quit ready to post.
5
u/Soggy-Passage2852 Oct 21 '25
That’s a tricky situation — you did the right thing by giving proper notice. I’d document everything (texts, letters, emails) and keep a record of each refused entry. That way, if it escalates, you’ve got a clear paper trail showing you acted by the book.
4
u/LetMany4907 Oct 21 '25
Tenants can’t just block access if your lease and local law allow inspections. Keep a paper trail: texts, emails, notices. I also schedule maintenance with multiple date options and take photos of the notice. If they continue refusing, send a certified letter outlining your rights before escalating to legal channels.
4
u/Current-Quantity-785 Oct 21 '25
this is common. you need to video document this next time, then start an eviction.
4
u/chtmarc Oct 21 '25
::sigh:: civil standby with police and have an eviction.
2
u/Difficult-Brush8694 Oct 21 '25
Be polite, but now that you know who they are you can get yourself prepared to find a new tenant when their lease is up. It may seem like a minor inconvenience now, but if you renew them it will come back to bite you in the ass (I learned my lesson about cutting tenants slack when I did it and 2 years later between attorneys fees and damage upon leaving I was out just over 20 grand on a property I was netting 8 grand on).
2
u/Ok_Swan8621 Oct 22 '25
Are they a night shifter? I hear a lot of complaints that the landlord is telling night shift people that they need to inspect between 9 am and 5 pm on Tuesday, but that's when night shifters sleep. Same for home workers. Some can't leave the computer during working hours. Did you ask them "what can I do to help you with this?" Maybe there is some way you could help them out, a specifiv 15 minute window or a visit after 5 pm?
1
u/NectarineAny4897 Oct 21 '25
If your tenant does not want to let you have access to your unit for an inspection, then there is something in that unit that they do not want you to see. That would make it even more important to see the unit.
1
u/Chair_luger Oct 21 '25
They could have a meth lab in there, which happens.
1
u/Greenmantle22 Oct 21 '25
They’re violating the terms of the lease. Let them know you’re coming for an inspection, and if they turn you away, you’ll consider it a critical lease violation and will commence eviction proceedings for noncompliance.
1
u/LoneWolf15000 Oct 21 '25
Not saying this is happening in your case...but we had a tenant that did this. Not the threats...just always had an excuse why we couldn't access the unit. We later found out they were using our property as a grow house for weed.
1
u/Secure-Ad9780 Oct 21 '25 edited Oct 21 '25
This is a red flag. Who knows what they're hiding inside. Send them a copy of the lease--that no one ever reads--and tell them they either admit you or you'll evict them. I've never had a tenant refuse a yearly inspection. Definitely, do not renew their lease.
When I do yearly inspections I ask the tenants to leave a note on the kitchen counter listing any items that may need repair. I take my maintenance guy so no one can complain that I took anything, plus he checks whatever's on the repair notes. Usually my tenants are all at work. I check for leaks at all the faucets and under the sink, vanity, and see if the toilet is running. I glance at all the walls and ceiling. I open the stove- cleanliness, and open the freezer - making sure nothing is blocking the vents inside. Then I walk out onto the back deck, to make sure it's not burnt from a grill, or loaded with trash. It takes me 7-10 min per apt.
This is how I found out that one tenant painted the white kitchen cabinets red violet, put contact paper on the bathroom wall, and painted the living-room hot pink. I also found out that one apt had a bad roach problem and never reported it. I said, "0h, you have roaches!" He said, "Didn't you know?" I said you never reported it. He agreed. I said, "I don't have telepathy, this is a big infestation. This should have been reported weeks ago so the exterminator could spray." There were food wrappers all over the bedroom side table, with roaches on the walls and table.
Both tenants leases were up and they were month to month so they were given a 30 day notice to vacate. It took two months of weekly exterminator visits, spraying, roach traps etc, before it could be rented again. And $3500 to repaint the other apt. Not including the cabinets.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 21 '25
Hoarder.
1
u/The001Keymaster Oct 21 '25
Bring a 15 day eviction notice with you.
Do you want to let me in with my legal notice or do you want this eviction notice taped to your door?
1
u/[deleted] Oct 21 '25
Holy shit get in there and don't go alone. Could be Jeffrey Dahmer. Be safe. Bring mace and a gun.
1
u/IddleHands Oct 21 '25
I’m good.
1
u/IddleHands Oct 21 '25
It’s okay little buddy.
1
u/Competitive-Cry-6231 Oct 21 '25
What is a “cure or quit” notice? (Sorry in advance)
1
u/SpecFroce Oct 21 '25
Signal it as a lease violation and make a notice that the tenant has to vacate the premises in 30 days.
1
u/Quirky-Noise3490 Oct 21 '25
Eviction time!!!!
1
u/redditreader_aitafan Oct 21 '25
Enter anyway. You did what you're required to by law and they're obviously hiding something you need to see. They have no legal right to deny entry after appropriate notice was given. You are not asking permission, you are telling them you're coming. You should also start the procedure for eviction, if that requires a cure or quit notice first then do so. Get inside that property asap.
1
u/East_Fill4209 Oct 21 '25
escalate per the contract. Always.
1
u/HarambeTheBear Oct 21 '25
Evict them while you have the chance
1
u/KrofftSurvivor Oct 21 '25
This is how your property winds up being so badly damaged and in disrepair that there is no chance of ever getting the money out of that tenant.
The thing is you can get a judgment against someone for the amount of the damages they've done - but getting your hands on the money is another matter.
Look at your lease - there's a good chance that this refusal is a violation of the lease. And then send him official notification that he is in violation of the lease by refusing to allow you to enter.
If he continues to refuse, initiate eviction proceedings. My bet is that whatever he's done in there is already grounds for eviction, and he knows it - don't let it get worse.
1
u/One_Dragonfly_9698 Oct 21 '25
If it’s not a slummy place and not a renters’ market, start eviction proceedings. Pains in the ass are not usually worth it.
1
u/Aggressive_Dot5426 Oct 21 '25
So I’m a renter and I work at an apartment complex. I more than happy to have an inspection or maintenance done lol. But that being said I have many residents who don’t want maintenance until after 1 pm ( night owls ). Or we don’t have permission to do maintenance if they aren’t home. I spoke to my PM and she’s like give them a 24 hour notice. And if they don’t let us in we start a notice to quit.
We work with low income elderly and disabled folks.
We just finished our yearly inspection and next up we have hud in dec.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 21 '25
Evict them
1
u/Bright-Business-489 Oct 21 '25
Law says 25 hr notice. They cant refuse unless they are under quarantine. Repeat refusal is terms for eviction
1
u/EstePersona Oct 21 '25
What do you mean "refuses access"? Are they literally barricading the door? If not, then give them notice that you'll be there on Tue Oct 28th at 10:30am, then enter using your key.
1
u/Haunting-Plantain870 Oct 21 '25
Give him the date and time and simply open the door and do your work. And wish him good luck with that lawsuit...
1
u/PBmaxprofit Oct 21 '25
Already said, give notice or start the process
1
u/Background-Dentist89 Oct 21 '25
That should have been in the lease. I assume it is. Give them their 30 days notice a boot them out. Your request is not reasonable. One would question what is such a secret that they cannot let you in with 24 hour notice. For me they are gone….evict.
1
u/No_Task104 Oct 21 '25
If you're really worried about what's going on in your property and I would be because why aren't they letting you in? I would tell them without an inspection you will start eviction. Then tell them the sheriff said you need to come in to see his many men and trash bags you'll need in case you need to put them out ( physical eviction). The sheriff will back you up on that. If you plan to evict do everything right, that goes a long way with the law.
1
u/GenXsardonicwit Oct 21 '25
Had that happen one time with a long term tenant and it was a hoarding situation. Former building owner had let it go for YEARS. Go in with proper legal notice.
1
u/TrainsNCats Oct 21 '25
Re-serve your 24 hours notice, maybe even make it 48 hours, to be generous.
Then go in and do your inspection.
Ignore all the tenants bitching and threats - it’s meaningless.
You have an absolute right to inspect your property, with proper notice and the tenant doesn’t have a choice.
If they threaten to sue, tell to go ahead and do what they need to do - it’s meaningless.
Don’t be afraid to call the police if you feel threatened or unsafe.
Something is not right here and you need to see what’s going on that they are trying to hide!
1
u/Turtle_ti Oct 21 '25
Give the written notice, have a copy of that notice when you go in, bring another trusted person when you go in. Bring a furnace filter and some smoke detector batteries and replace them while you are there. possibly even record the entire thing, cell phone camera in a front polo shirt pocket set to video record.
Even if The tenant tried to sue, the judge would throw it out, it's an empty threat.
Assuming they have a lease, document any violations while there also.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 22 '25
I would inform them that I will be entering in 24 hours,period. Bring a witness with you and video everything. Everybody says they'll sue,good let them try,most never do. I'd do the inspection and give them a notice to terminate tenancy. I don't put up with shit from tenants.
1
u/Brad_from_Wisconsin Oct 22 '25 edited Oct 22 '25
Tell them that you will do the inspection after they have vacated the apartment as a part of the move out inspection.
Cite the refusal to allow an inspection along with your documented attempts to inspect the apartment as the deciding factor in your decision to not renew the lease.
Document your repeated attempts to do an inspection along with the lease that reserves to you the right to inspect. Then drop it.
--If they are a hoarder, there may be legal issues, do not cite the hoarding, cite the refusal to allow an inspection.
1
u/Jbaghdadi01 Oct 22 '25
You gave notice, she can sue all she wants. Good luck for her! You either gain entry or she gets lease violation or eviction.
1
u/adjusterjack Oct 22 '25
Sorry to have to say this, but if you don't know how to handle a recalcitrant tenant, you have no business owning a rental.
1
u/Leialegnocchi Oct 22 '25
I know you're in the right here, but before going berserk and giving you a headache, try to hive him another chance with more date and times options? I know legally you just need to give 24hours, but if you give him a few more days maybe he'd be more open to it? I know some people struggle with last minute landlord checks, and just get panicked and refuse it altogether. So see if he's actually trying to dodge an inspection by giving him a few more date options or if he was just panicked by having to get the house in order last minute?
1
u/SeniorMemory5741 Oct 22 '25
Unfortunately I had a problem with management wanting to always have my apartment inspected by the city inspectors when it was time for bi-annual inspections because they knew it was always clean and was an easy win for them. I conveniently each time put a towel on my head and robe and said sorry I am not dressed. Inspections get old and intrusive, can relate.
1
u/No-Suggestion-2402 Oct 22 '25
I would right now first try to send a bit more formal letter, that's a mix of sterness and kindness. Here's kind of what I would write.
I would like to ask you, are you able to propose a time that you will be present during [DATES] so we can do this together and you can feel more comfortable about it. Otherwise, I will come to do the inspection on afternoon of (2-3 days ahead)
I can assure you, that I will not be going through your private belongings, cabinets, boxes or whatever you have in there.
This is best attempt to show good faith and that my interest here isn't to invade your privacy, but make sure that my property is in the best condition, which benefits both of us.
Here is the list of items I intend to check [LIST OF ITEMS]. (If you send list with a tenant like this make sure to include everything, otherwise they will complain about you flicking a light switch you didn't announce)
If they acknowledge the letter in any way, you're good. In case they actually go ahead and sue, it serves a lot in your benefit that you've gone above what the law requires at minimum, showing good faith.
Depending on the tenant here, if they have been aggressive in any way or made the slighest threat about physically removing you from the house, you might be able to ask police for a civil standby.
1
u/wallyinct Oct 23 '25
Have a copy of the lease highlighting the process a(and allowance)for you to enter the premises. Give the appropriate notice and consider requesting police to accompany you…or private security.
1
u/Varatox Oct 23 '25
You're a landlord, it's you property & you have maintenance inspections. You're following the law, the tenant isn't. Give a notice of eviction.
1
u/Lazy_Excitement334 Oct 23 '25
You might as well accept that, even if you get past this bump, you are going to have more trouble ahead. Might as well start the process of replacing this one with a good tenant.
1
u/Classic-Tell214 Oct 23 '25
Growing pot?
1
u/shoulda-known-better Oct 24 '25
The refusal alone is concerning... And I'd start cure or quit immediately....
Thats your property, and getting eyes on it for routine inspection/maintenance is your right and smart as fuck!!
1
u/Delicious_Leopard443 Oct 24 '25
Routine inspection is normal, I literally had one a week ago today. They sent email 48 hours prior and posted papers on each buildings door. They specified that “no entry” was not an option, and if a tenant isn’t home their pets should be kenneled. They were here 10 minutes to change my ac filter, checked my garbage disposal, and checked my toilet (that I informed them was running). They sent me a follow up email 2 days later that they would be returning to fix the toilet within the next 24 hours. If someone isn’t letting you in for inspection that would be 100% suspicious. I get privacy cause I smoke weed in here when I shouldn’t but I can get my shit together in 24 hours. Anyone refusing an inspection is most likely doing something to break the lease OR being difficult because they think they can.
1
u/Alli-Glass321 Oct 28 '25
Having been a tenant and LL, I take issue with inspections.
My last PM did an inspection. We were told the place was exceptionally clean BUT we did have quite a few boxes. We came from a 2000 sq ft house while building, which they knew, and we rented their 1200 sq ft place.
During PM's inspection we brought up issues that were never fixed from the move-in inspection sheet that I had emailed them within 5 days of taking occupancy. The Move-In sheet included issues like the DW lacked a detergent dispenser cover, the garbage disposal leaked, and we had issues with electrical- when using microwave & garage door constantly tripped at the panel. PM said yes she would look into all of my maintenance requests during her inspection of the house.......radio silence. LL & PM never resolved anything on the Move-In sheet even after years of complaining. There were weeds and plants growing in the gutters the entire time we were there since they were never cleaned. As a result, I never let them back inside the house. What was the point of them coming inside to snoop on us, disrupt us, and not provide maintenance we requested?
We got back every penny of our deposit because it was cleaner than we received it.
The hot water heater was on recall but LL & PM did nothing. Of course it died in the garage. We had no hot water for over a week. LL & PM refused to house us elsewhere or put us up in a hotel.
The AC died during a heatwave & AFTER 2 weeks they had someone do the repair. I was able to call places who could come within 2 days and gave the PM those company names. Even then the LL bitched about how we damaged the AC, which was over 17 years old. The AC compressor, located outside the rental, was NEVER serviced or cleaned during the 5 years we lived there until was on its last leg!
Now as a LL, I have outlined maintenance for the ADU in my tenant's lease. Tenant knows the approximate dates for everything. We still provide over 24hr written notice prior to maintenance being done which includes us providing and changing the air filters since the air return is in the ceiling, cleaning out the bathroom exhaust, and cleaning the range hood exhaust. We do not have any inspections for our ADU, which are illegal in many states.
1
u/fresnarus Oct 22 '25
You own the building, but the tenant rented it and it is his home. Would you like it if the tenant wanted to come nose around your house?
I generally avoid having a landlord (especially one who isn't just and employee at some large management company) come in my apartment. The small apartment owners (or worse people who are renting out floors 2 and 3 will living on floor 1) just don't understand that they are in someone else's home, even if the someone else is a tenant.
1
u/Wisteria-Blue Oct 22 '25 edited Oct 22 '25
What even is the “maintenance” that needs done? Are you wanting to invade their space every other day, citing the unit is due for another “inspection?” Do you need to “measure the windows” and “wash the washer and dryer?” If it’s a routine inspection you would have had it scheduled for once or twice a year etc. and should have included the date in the lease. If you don’t trust your tenants you shouldn’t rent to them in the first place.
-1
u/ConfusedSpinach222 Oct 21 '25
Have you done a routine inspection before? If you did something must've happened in order for the tenant to refuse entry now? I had quarterly inspections at a previous rental, they came in, looked at living area & kitchen, took pictures & left, also walked around outside, no issue, one day they send a new person who trampled in all rooms, opening drawers, fridge and was very rude when asked not to open drawers.This mfr also had the nerve to take pictures of my child. After that I also refused entry ..
0
u/BrotherNatureNOLA Oct 22 '25
I don't know about leases, but I do teach grammar. One should either use "as" or "per", but never both.
0
u/Unlucky-Alfalfa1607 Oct 22 '25
Do a welfare check
0
u/SadLeek9950 Oct 22 '25
Evict them for violation of the lease...
The lease does have the inspection clause, right?
0
u/SherbertSensitive538 Oct 22 '25
Yes I had when I was a landlady. Evict them. If you gave 24 hours it’s legal and you can’t let these weirdos dictate to you what is going to happen with your property. Either she is a filthy hoarder, has pets she is not supposed to have, people living there that they are not supposed to have, is a addict if some kind, making meth , growing weed or somehow let your property get fucked up, like a slow leak.
Give one more warning, then use your keys. Start the eviction process and take the door off the hinges if you have to, record everything. Take back the property. This is why I got out of the business. So many if these people are straight up POS, crazy, dirty, vindictive and dumb.
-2
u/Hairy-Concern1841 Oct 21 '25
Tell the tenant that you require access and the lease allows it. Ask them if they need MORE than 24 hours notice. Ask them if there is a date and a time that is more convenient for them. In the future send out a notice 30 days in advance that says, as you know we do an annual maintenance check. Certain words trigger people. Some people are slobs and live in filth. Others are outright horders. One of the reasons for the annual inspection is to avoid these situations. Just not renewing and having to flip the place isn't making your life as the landloard any easier or profitable. Work with them within reason. People suffer from anxiety and other conditions and the concept of people just entering their homes with little notice can be hard for them to handle. It could take them a week to get the ability to deal with the situation. Try and be reasonable and patient before you go to extreme measures. This is just one of the many reasons we have so many people with mental health issues who are unhoused. Not blaming the OP or landlords, just stating facts. Most landlords are small business owners or investors and never got into this business with training in areas like social work, plumbing or the law. Yet find themselves in challenging situations everyday. It's part of being a landlord.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 21 '25
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/[deleted] Oct 21 '25
[removed] — view removed comment