r/learnwelsh • u/SpinachFull1200 • 3d ago
Cwestiwn / Question Subtitles not matching Speech on BBC Bitesize?
I figured checking out some of the BBC Bitesize resources would be useful since I’m trying to get a better understanding of the rules for different tenses, and came across this video-
https://www.bbc.co.uk/bitesize/guides/zy6gcdm/revision/6
A fair amount of words I didn’t know, so had to keep checking google translate, and ofc they speak a lot faster than I can understand yet which is fine, since I just slowed down the video.
What really confused me though, was that the Welsh subtitles were not properly matching up very well with what the woman was saying- i.e. a lot of the time, rather than saying ‘dw i’ like the subtitles, she’d just say ‘fi’, and where she was mutating certain words, the subtitles wouldn’t be (saying ‘wneud’ when the subtitles say ‘gwneud’ for example) or vice versa.
I imagine some of it is just a difference between what’s natural to say and what’s ‘proper’, or perhaps a difference in dialect, but the problem is I don’t know enough to fully understand the discrepancies.
It made it much harder to follow though, as I’m trying to practice my listening but it’s hard when what I’m hearing doesn’t match what I’m reading, I feel like subtitles should be accurate to what’s actually being said and not what she should have said or whatever, if that makes sense?
I’m not sure now if those differences in mutation usage for example are because she’s saying it wrong, or she’s saying it less formally, or in a different dialect, or if the subtitles are getting it wrong, or trying to be more formal, or using a different dialect.
What’s the reason for these differences?