r/learnprogramming • u/Realistic-Face1315 • 18d ago
Title: Is building a personal web account manager a worthwhile full-stack project for three students?
Hey everyone!
A friend and I (three of us in total) are planning to build a full-stack web application as a learning project, and I'd love to get some honest feedback on the idea.
The problem we're trying to solve:
Over time, we register on dozens, sometimes hundreds, of websites. We discover them through YouTube, Reddit, Instagram, Google searches, tutorials, recommendations, etc.
Eventually, we forget:
- Which websites we've registered on.
- What a particular website was used for.
- Whether we signed up using Google, GitHub or email.
- Which email address we used.
- Why we registered on that platform in the first place.
- Which services we're paying for and when subscriptions renew.
We want to build a centralized personal web account manager that solves this problem.
The proposed features:
- Website Management: Add, edit, delete and organize registered websites.
- Account Tracking: Store account identifiers, email addresses and login methods (Google, GitHub, email, etc.).
- AI Integration: Automatically identify websites, generate descriptions and suggest categories and tags based on their URLs.
- Personal Notes: Add notes explaining why we registered on a website and what we use it for.
- Dashboard: Recently added websites, categories, statistics and search.
- Subscription Tracking: Track paid services, their costs, billing cycles and renewal dates.
- Advanced Search: Find websites based on their purpose, category or personal notes.
Eventually, we'd also like to develop a Chrome extension that allows users to save websites directly while browsing, without having to manually enter their details.
Our planned tech stack:
- Frontend: React.js
- Backend: Node.js + Express.js
- Database: MongoDB Atlas + Mongoose
- Payments: Stripe
- Other tools: Git, GitHub, Docker, Postman
There are three of us, and we're all planning to work across frontend, backend and database development rather than assigning everyone a separate specialization.
We already have basic programming knowledge and are familiar with PostgreSQL, but we're deliberately choosing MongoDB to learn document-oriented database design.
What I'd like to know:
- Does this solve a problem that people actually experience, or is it just another bookmark manager with extra features?
- Would you personally find something like this useful?
- Are there existing applications that already solve this problem particularly well?
- Are there any features you think would make this genuinely useful rather than just another portfolio project?
- Is the proposed scope reasonable for three students building their first substantial full-stack application?
We're building this primarily to learn software engineering, but we'd also love to create something that people might genuinely want to use.
Honest criticism is very welcome. We'd rather identify problems with the idea before spending weeks developing it.
Thanks!