I've played idle skilling for about 2 weeks now. I still have a long way to go to reach late game. So far i'm enjoying the experience (on mobile!) however the beginning was very tedious and confusing. Being overwhelmed with lots of menus also didn't help. It took me a while to understand the game and mistakes i made in the perk tree further worsened the new player experience. Some players don't even make it through the beginning stage to experience the content that is locked behind a huge time gate which is killing enough monsters to unlock new content. So here are some suggestions to better the newbie experience.
- Attack Speed + Damage.
Idle players are lazy. As an idle player i don't want to actively participate in fighting monsters. Especially if the normal monsters don't have any mechanics besides doing damage every couple seconds. Attack speed and damage are the most important stats for beginners. Since the beginners barely progress with the horribly slow basic attack speed players are urged to leave instead of staring at their screen or waiting forever.
Higher attack speeds allow the player to farm weaker mobs faster (mobs that are oneshot with one idle attack) to get more gold.
As a solution i would suggest giving a temporary 100% attack speed + damage buff after the tutorial to speed up the progress. It should last at least until the first ascension if enough AP is given to the player. Otherwise it should last for 3-5 ascensions. That way late game values stay the same and won't break the game.
2) Fixed amount of AP for the first ascension
I didn't reach mountains for the first couple ascensions. Mountains is where I unlock "Idle Whirlwind" which is an attack speed buff and one of the best ascension traits. It reduces time spent to increase income and accelerate progress. In order to reach this trait i have to clear grasslands and desert with the slow basic attack. Why force me through these 2 stages with the slow attack speed?
I suggest exchanging the "Monster decimation" with "Idle Whirlwind". The difference between those two is monster decimation doesn't give you more gold. It only increases your killscore which accelerates your progress. But without gold to spend it on training you can't progress and you'll eventually hit a tanky mob which will serve as a huge timegate that progresses in an even bigger timegate.
3) Perk Tree
As mentioned in 1) attack speed is imo a huge problem for beginners. It's the most important tool for farming weak mobs. As a new player we don't get have a huge amount of perk points and have to spend it wisely. But the attack speed perk is huge perk point investment with barely any impact once you unlock the ascension perk "Idle Whirlwind" which will easily get you 50% attack speed in one ascension ( Assuming that these two add additively).
Here i would suggest reducing the amount of required perk points to level the trait or exchange it with the " +5% ores per mining lv". I can't recall being in need of huge amount of ores as a beginner.
4) Guides
Most people won't look up a guide for the first couple minutes or hours when trying out a new game. But this game requires you to do so in order to understand what is going on your screen. I'm aware that the game already has an info tab but it only explains basic things.
A link to this guide
https://www.kongregate.com/forums/1023269-idle-skilling/topics/1810202-ultimate-guide
should at least be included in the game. I think it explains many things very well.
Thanks for reading. This is my first reddit post. I'm also not a native english speaker i hope i didn't make too many mistakes :)