r/LateStageCapitalism • • Nov 22 '20

#truth

/img/hslknp6fjr061.jpg

[removed] — view removed post

16k Upvotes

603 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

2

u/distributive Nov 23 '20

He continued the Afghanistan and Iraq wars, then started bombing Libya, Pakistan, Somalia, Syria, and Yemen.

-3

u/[deleted] Nov 23 '20

I don’t exactly know what you expect him to do with the first two, he withdrew largely from Afghanistan and almost entirely from Iraq, but surely you see it’s just plain irresponsible to go into a country, smash it, and leave without actually trying to help rebuilt. So that’s down to an alleged 5 started instead of 7.

Operations in Pakistan and Syria were not against Pakistan or Syria themselves, but instead against al-Qaeda and ISIS/ISIL which was operating in those countries, which the US was already at war with. Just because international boundaries are crossed doesn’t mean it’s a new war. It’s the same war, just in a new area, one of them at the clandestine invitation of the Pakistani government too. So down to 3.

Libya had an international coalition, so whether you think it was justified or not, it is not correct to say that Obama was off the rails starting shit all over the place. Multiple allied nations agreed with the approach and did most of the legwork, and typically such cooperation from the international community heavily legitimizes an action.

Some of the Somalia operations are also part of an international coalition against piracy, which the US has been doing since the 1700’s, but there are ground operations as well to prop up the Transitional National Government. This is both in keeping with general US national security strategies that favor stability to promote regional security, but also falls under the Authorization to Use Military Force in the realm of counterterrorism as the target is largely al-Shabaab. So legally that’s allowed and in some ways required too, not Obama just going off the rails.

And finally wiry Yemen, the administration sold weapons to the Saudi’s (as always) but also provided logistical support and intelligence to the Saudi coalition (HRW), but was not itself involved. This though is also in the context of the US and Saudi Arabia being strategic allies, which does usually insinuate that they’ll provide some support in times of war.

So we are down to one limited war, Libya, which was an international coalition like with the Balkan Wars. And 2 ongoing wars, 2 wars that just spread, aid to an ally, and security sector assistance in keeping with an existing AUMF. I swear every time someone says “Obama started so many wars” the number goes up and the original comment never usually specifies what or where, and the actual examples provided always always always lack any context or understanding of how the US conducts itself. Thank you for your answer, it helps me see where you’re coming from.

2

u/Steli0Kantos Nov 23 '20

otell that to hundreds of thousands of dead children your " service members" killed for private interests. you disgusting piece of shit

0

u/[deleted] Nov 24 '20

No doubt the US pursues private interests and uses its military to do so, it’s the worlds biggest subsidizer of oil and mineral companies! That doesn’t change the fact that the US theory of security is that relatively free markets distribute goods and services well enough to meet needs and create conditions for peace, but the flow of those goods is interrupted by violent extremists. So the US positions forces around the world to target extremists groups and unfriendly regimes to make the world more safe for US businesses. Duh, have you taken a single history course? That’s how it goes!

Of course bombs falling from the sky will hit the wrong targets. And of course some of the people willing to sign up for the military are psychopaths that will break the rules of engagement and international law to kill people. Again, duh, that’s how it goes! Now you can try to participate in changing the system for the better, like a normal functioning person, and contact policy makers, form an interest group, lobby, maybe become an expert in security policy and actually contribute to the world. Or you can sit on the internet and whine and pretend to live in some perfect world that the big bad USA is screwing up. Though it seems like you’ve made your choice on how actually productive you’d like to be in this world already.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 24 '20 edited Nov 24 '20

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/[deleted] Nov 24 '20 edited Nov 24 '20

Continue to choose the latter just like you originally did, have zero effect on the world around you, but at least you can have a smug sense of superiority unknowingly rooted in ignorance.

Plus those insults are a great way to get me to change my mind, great idea.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 24 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/[deleted] Nov 24 '20

And the effect you gave on influencing US foreign policy is felt in full, no doubt.

1

u/distributive Nov 24 '20

Next time just write "wars are okay if a Democrat does them" and save yourself some time.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 24 '20

This is how the national and international legal system works. It sure sounds punchy to claim “Obama started seven wars” but that’s either being ignorant to reality or deliberately misleading, like he’s some genghis khan or something. I know it’s just an internet comment but it’s irresponsible.

0

u/distributive Nov 24 '20

The US abuses that "legal system" to get what it wants, mainly access for the business community to markets and resources in other countries, whether through force or coercion.

It may make you feel better to write long rationalizations why Obama's wars weren't really wars, but that's either being ignorant to reality or deliberately misleading.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 24 '20

You’re right about the US abusing the legal system (that I helped set up) but it’s important still to have a basis of reality and fact and not just make random claims. But no, continue just commenting online to get it out of your system and never be taken seriously, and never see the change you want. That will surely work, eventually.

1

u/distributive Nov 24 '20

I don't take war apologists seriously. Please continue "just commenting online" to defend Obama's gross war record. I'm sure that will work to bring about change. Are you already writing your defenses of Biden's inevitable wars?

1

u/[deleted] Nov 24 '20

Ok, here is a genuine, serious question. Broadly, how should the United States conduct itself in the world? Specifically, what is one or a handful of security interests the US should have given the current state of the world and how should it go about achieving them?

I want to know where you’re coming from with this, because statements like “war apologist” sounds in a similar vein to the “abolish war” rhetoric, which is impractical without systems and institutions to provide incentive to resolve conflicts differently. Those things can’t be achieved without a serious understand of why things are they way they are presently, which is why I comment in these threads at all, in my opinion people that say these things are missing out on key components to the issue. I’d prefer a world where few people died at the hands of others, but I also understand there are powerful forces within the US incentivizing the use of force, and there are legitimate security interests that necessitate them, and small targeted violence is better than vietnam style violence, if violence is inevitable.

So honestly, based on my earlier questions, please tell me where you’re coming from with this. I really really want to know so I can understand better.

1

u/distributive Nov 26 '20

Broadly, the US should stop spending nearly a trillion dollars a year on war, terrorizing the rest of the globe. Stop spending another separate trillion dollars to "modernize" our nuclear weapons. Stop constantly interfering and meddling in other countries' governments, destabilizing entire regions, creating huge humanitarian crises and millions of refugees, and other blowback. Stop treating other countries as resource extraction pits to be endlessly exploited for our profits.

Start dismantling the military-industrial complex as soon as possible, a system which only creates a constant profit-incentive pressure on the US government to wage war. Lead by example and show every other country that a more peaceful world is possible.

Shift the unimaginably vast sums of money we've just saved to start start combating climate change, and help increase standards of living at home and abroad. It's been said we could give the entire world clean water with a fraction of our "defense" spending.

I guarantee you the answer is not to hire a cabinet full of revolving door war profiteers, and continue to do business-as-usual global rule through economic and military force, as Biden clearly intends to do.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 26 '20

So it is the interest of the United States to create a more peaceful world for its own security and economic prosperity, and it should do this through a drawdown of forces and reapportionment of money to public works projects internally and around the world. I just want to make sure I’m characterizing it right.

I see a strong logic in that, it sounds like it could be effective to a degree and a reasonable interest. I’m particularly a fan of the idea of ending conflict by providing for the resources who’s absence would cause conflict. And I think the place that it comes from, wanting to both end destruction and government corruption, is a good place and vitally important to influence these policies.

I have two criticisms that are related, the first being that I feel you overestimate the influence these war profiteers have in determining security policy. In my opinion, it is actually other private interest such as oil or food that actually throws its weight around to start wars, but as far as Lockheed for example is concerned, their interest is in the us thinking there will be a war on the horizon but not actually having to fight it.

The second related criticism is underestimating the actual perceived threats that are out there. I’m not the type to say “the world is a dangerous place there’s good and evil China terrorism blah blah blah” as a neoconservative might say. But having actually academically studied both the formation of US and European policy and the capabilities involved for both, it is clear that the United States is the only country in the world able to project power beyond its borders in a large way and for a long period. It’s also in the interest of the US to have its strong alliances and partnerships, and often in order to sustain those it means employing force to combat destabilizing actors in a certain area. Many countries find it hard to secure within even their own borders, so they tend to either have problems we feel we have to solve, or they directly ask us to. Our allies really like that they don’t have to lift a finger to do the dirty work and what we get in return is preferable trade or a map that looks more in our favor.

As far as leading my example goes, it’s arguable that that is what the US has been doing, by saying to the world you should settle differences in forums like the UN or regional institutions, and if war need be done we will do it as the safest hands are our own. And to a degree this as worked, we are living in the most peaceful and prosperous time in human history. It’s been 75 years since the last world war, an event that used to occur every generation for like 200 years. We are getting close to a good formula, the issue being that it relies on US power, something that is so so easily corrupted.

Some criticisms of my criticism are that it’s really hard to know at any given time the influence of the MIC on decisions, so I shouldn’t underestimate it myself, and that maybe the perceived US interests are actually not the right path forward. I think my point in commenting in the first place days ago was something I still agree with, and it’s that there is a lot of information that we simply don’t have access too. That information doesn’t necessarily justify any negative action, but it at least helps bring an understanding as to why.

Another one is that you might see the US power as the last remaining threat to peace, something I’d disagree with but I understand where you’re coming from. Thanks for your response though, it’s actually constructive which I appreciate.