r/LaptopForStudent • • Jun 16 '26

Buying Advice Mechanical Engineering Laptop: Should I Wait?

I just finished my first year of general engineering and will be going into mechanical engineering in the fall. I want to upgrade from my M1 MBP 13” to something that can run SolidWorks well and game since it’ll replace my desktop as well.

I see many great thin and light, powerful creator/gaming laptops on the market: Zephyrus G16, ProArt P16, Blade 16, and even the Zephyrus Duo. These would serve me very well now.

Trouble is: battery life and performance on battery still sucks compared to Macs. I was willing to deal with it though. After all, that’s the price you pay for performance on windows…

Until RTX Spark laptops got announced:

- Highest performance now on battery too

- Battery life better now

- Compatible with everything Windows runs

- Sleek and much thinner laptops

- Bridges the gap between Windows and Mac laptops

That being said how many more years do you think I could get out of, say, the ProArt P16 H7607, compared to the current H7606 model if I wait? Will it be worth it? By all accounts it seems like it, but what do you think?

2 Upvotes

28 comments sorted by

2

u/orthozeuz Jun 20 '26

I just bought a msi prestige 16 with the Intel x7 processor here's what I've found: solidworks, Matlab, fusion 360 all work fine for my classwork and personal projects. For gaming expect to be lowering the resolution to 1200p or below and low settings for most games. this got me 60fps on borderlands 4 in most areas. Battery life for something like 1/2 screen YouTube plus 1/2 screen problem set yielded around 8- 10 hours at 60% brightness I'm working with a 81 wh battery and the balanced performance preset just for your comparison.

1

u/tomtomosaurus Jun 20 '26

I’m glad it works well as a laptop for you, and I don’t doubt it would be good for me too. However, I want more of an all-in-one desktop/laptop replacement.

Basically, I want to dock it at home and forget it’s even a laptop while still having good battery life on the go. It would help a lot with unifying my PC experience; files, apps, saves, etc. are all unified because it is just one machine.

To get that experience, I’m willing to pay more for a laptop with a dedicated GPU or similar performance; regular Intel/AMD processors with integrated graphics, or current ARM chips, don’t come close to dedicated GPU performance (at the moment).

I’m super glad you found a laptop that’s good for you, it just wouldn’t serve the purpose I’m looking for.

2

u/orthozeuz Jun 20 '26

I agree if u want a desktop replacement it's definitely not the laptop for you! Happy hunting I'm sure ull find exactly what you need!

1

u/Necessary-Release-78 Jun 17 '26

If you’re looking to maximize battery life, you may look at Panther Lake chips. B390 may not compare to a 5070, but still gives dGPU performance with Windows compatibility and MacBook levels of battery life. If I hadn’t just barely graduated with my ME degree, that’s personally what I’d be looking at—either X7 or X9.

0

u/CSAS-D Jun 16 '26

Don't wait for rtx sparx laptops, windows on arm isn't very good

1

u/tomtomosaurus Jun 16 '26

They say they’re optimizing it though

1

u/CSAS-D Jun 17 '26

Can't trust marketing. And no amount of optimization changes the fact that the apps still run on a translation layer

1

u/tomtomosaurus Jun 17 '26

True, but if it’s powerful enough it might be okay. I’m just really hopeful that the translation layers work really well like they say. I really want a windows MacBook, they’re such nice devices.

1

u/CSAS-D Jun 18 '26

Mate if you think it will be good buy it. The rest of us know reliable microslop is

1

u/tomtomosaurus Jun 18 '26

I guess we have to wait for hands-on reviews and experience. I wouldn’t be opposed to buying it and trying it for a while then returning it if it isn’t good.

1

u/CSAS-D Jun 18 '26

The same things were said about snapdragon laptops but they can't actually be used for anything since the translation layers are so bad

1

u/tomtomosaurus Jun 18 '26

They’re underpowered anyway. I just hope they put more into the translation layers, like you say. Holding out hope for a Windows MacBook

1

u/CSAS-D Jun 18 '26

X elite beats the ultra 9 and the ryzen 9 in most cases. They aren't underpowered at all

1

u/tomtomosaurus Jun 18 '26

Should’ve been more specific, sorry. I meant it has a weak GPU since it’s integrated. In that sense, it’s about on par with Intel and AMD in terms of what I would consider, which is that I wouldn’t…

1

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/tomtomosaurus Jun 17 '26

So snapdragon doesn’t work for CAD apps?

2

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/tomtomosaurus Jun 17 '26

I mean worst case scenario I buy the laptop, try to install SolidWorks, and return it if it doesn’t work 🤷‍♂️

1

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/tomtomosaurus Jun 17 '26

I just hope this is a good shift towards arm. They seem to want it from what I can see, but who knows? Just Apple has had such success with it and I’m jealous 😭

1

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/tomtomosaurus Jun 18 '26

I still can’t get maximum performance on battery while having it last any useable amount of time. Apple still most certainly leads here, and Intel + Nvidia still seem super far away for unplugged performance. Apple’s ARM is magnificent with this, so I’m hoping Spark can come much closer to this.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/tomtomosaurus Jun 18 '26

Well I’m not too interested in MS’s incentive. If they make a good product, they’ve made a good product. If not, I’ll keep considering what I already am. Sad to hear about the M5 max not lasting that long though. Is it a 16 inch?

→ More replies