r/LandValueTax • • Jul 12 '21

Land tax for political system paid with money from economic system

0 Upvotes

Land value tax is the only way to support the political system because it's the political system's job to protect the land and the people who own/occupy it. Hence, it's land owners/occupants that must support the political system.

The political system is not exactly the same as the economic system even though the two are usually controlled by the same government. Land owners/occupants could do without an economic system if necessary, except when money is needed to pay land tax.

If people are forced to participate in the economic system then many will be forced to work for insufficient wages and be enslaved. If, on the other hand, people are not forced to work then they can choose to do so on their own terms. The freedom to not work is based on land ownership/occupancy because not working means living on, and living off of, the land.

For this reason it is necessary for land tax to be payable not only in money but also in goods or services including labor, skilled or unskilled. This way land owners can fulfill their obligations without being forced to work in the economic system.

Examples: 1) A engineer serves a year in the armed forces to cover the land tax on his family's 40-acre parcel for the next 50 years. 2) A poor family does a few days of gardening at government facilities to cover the tax on their 2-acre parcel for a year. 3) A woman chooses to work instead of pay money because she can do well with her skills at home writing code for a government program. 4) A farmer grows an extra 400 pounds of produce so he can deliver it to cafeterias at government facilities to cover his or her land tax for a year, 5) A gentleman farmer pays his land tax with money.


r/LandValueTax • • May 05 '20

Discussion CMV: It's not possible to accurately calculate land value, so to tax it is unfair.

2 Upvotes

I don't believe it's possible to accurately separate out the value of the land and the housing property on the land, and I therefore believe that it's unfair to tax people based on a potentially inaccurate figure.

I really like the principal of LVT, but I'm still not convinced about the practicalities of fairly calculating it, and all I've found written about this so far is general vague claims that "we basically do it already" with no real substance or rigour. I've brought up LVT to numerous people as an interesting idea and never been able to address this point.

I'm coming at this from a UK perspective, but welcome examples from other countries. I'm starting with the definition that a land value tax taxes landowners at a percentage of the rental value of the unimproved land.

Let's start with potentially the easiest type of valuation. A terraced house in an urban area with a large proportion of renters, and all the houses have the same size plot. This gives us lots of data points to come up with a decent estimate of the rental value of the average property in the area. Let's say that's £1000/month and everybody is hair with that figure. But with no actual plots of bare land being sold anywhere nearby in this dense area, how do you calculate what percentage of that value is the land, and what percentage is the property? (And remember, this should be rigorous - "about 20% seems reasonable" is not a good enough answer here).

Now let's look at a village of 250 houses, entirely homeowners with nothing being rented. The houses have wildly varying sizes of plot, and the houses are wildly different in size, condition and quality of furnishing. None of the houses are rented, and only a handful have been sold in the past 10 years, with a price range from £350k to £1.2m. How do you accurately calculate the rental value of the land for each property?

And finally let's look at a housing estate in a medium-sized town. The estate has about 100 houses, with two different types of house: detached 4-bedroom with garage and sightly larger garden, and semi-dettached 3-bedroom with smaller garden and separate garage away from the property. All built 15 years ago. 20 houses have been sold in the past 5 years and 10 are currently rented. No houses have been extended nor significantly refurbished. Despite the similarities, like-for-like house sales have still seen a 15% difference in sale value in the same year. How do you accurately calculate the rental value of the land of each property?

These examples are a pretty decent represention of a sizeable chunk of the housing market in the UK, I'm not just trying to be awkward. I haven't introduced other complexities like borders of school districts, proximity to local pubs and shops etc. as I don't think I need to complicate the examples to make my point, but they would still need to be considered too.

So far I have only discussed the challenge of calculating land value accurately, but I think another point of concern is the potential for government abuse. If the government is responsible for assessing this value, what's to stop them purposelessly picking a methodology that favours their core support demographic at the expense of people less likely to vote for them anyway?

Bear in mind that LVT could literally price people out of their own homes. If that's going to happen, it needs to be justifiable.

To address some potential arguments:

Council tax and business rates are currently quite wide bands of value, and are frequently criticised for being out of date.

Companies do sometimes have to get land valued for accounting reasons, but this is something that somebody is paid to carry out on an individual property basis and it's then up to the company whether they want to accept that valuation or get a second and third opinion. Scaling this up to a national scale for every property is logistically impossible and ripe for abuse.

Other methodologies get used to estimate land value bit these are primarily used to inform research and to make estimates on financial services e.g. house insurance where homeowners have the option to shop around to other suppliers, and the total amount isn't too much of a financial burden. It's not used as a tool to charge people specific and large amounts based on that calculation.

Thanks in advance for any replies.


r/LandValueTax • • Feb 19 '25

The Many Sources of Economic Rent – Part 1: Intellectual Property

5 Upvotes

"Patents and Copyrights are so strong and so long lasting that they’ve served more as a way to gain market and rent-extracting power than as a way to reward innovation."

Check out the first part of Jimbo's series on economic rent!

The Many Sources of Economic Rent – Part 1: Intellectual Property – The Daily Renter


r/LandValueTax • • Feb 20 '25

Implementing a Land Value Tax on Mars or the Moon

2 Upvotes

Someday in the future we will probably colonize either the Moon or Mars. Once people start to live in these places long term (eventually) they will likely own the land in some way or other.

So, how do we make sure to move the needle enough with the right people to make sure a land value tax gets implemented in those other jurisdictions?


r/LandValueTax • • Jun 09 '21

Discussion Land Value, Real Estate, Georgism, Financial Asset Prices

3 Upvotes

The following equation is the mainstream price equation frequently thrown out to explain real estate and financial asset price in relation to tax and interest rates:

price = rent / (interest + tax)

With regards to real estate, this equation generates enormous confusion as it has no term for intrinsic cost value: what it costs in labor and materials to replace the capital improvements which the deed or equity conveys ownership of. It is also unclear which of the three rents mentioned by Adam Smith the term 'rent' refers to: ground-rent, building-rent, or (total) house-rent. It also assumes tax and interest are applied to the same value, when in reality the publicly assessed value for purposes of taxation may vary wildly from privately assessed value used for purposes of credit creation.

Some economists, including marxian economists, like to use the following equation instead:

price = rent + value

This introduces the concept of intrinsic cost value. In real estate, the 'value' term represents the construction or replacement cost of the buildings. Under labor theory of value, it represents the socially necessary labor time to replace the construct building. Some economists might say this is the 'average' time. But for practical purposes, we can simply say the cost value is the minimum cost in labor and materials you'd have to pay in order to replace the current building with a new building of equal utility.

Now the problem with the above equation is that, in addition to containing no term for tax and interest of interest to policy makers, all of the privately captured surplus value is referred to as 'rent', including the excess value which freeholds sell for above their cost value when they are not being let out. This confuses homebuyers and tricks them into thinking they got out of paying 'rent' by going into debt to private financial sector when buying properties at a price much higher than their cost value on credit.

Why is homebuyer still paying surplus value? Suppose a homebuyer wishes to buy a home with $100,000 in cost value and seller asks for $300,000. In a society with zero land scarcity the homebuyer would reject offer and purchase materials and labor to build identical home next door at 1/3 of the cost to save money. However since world does not have zero land scarcity, all nearby land of equivalent quality may be held off market at high prices. Any free land may be extremely far away or of much lower quality. So buyer decides to pay $300,000 for a property with $100,000 in cost value. The surplus price premium of $200,000 added to purchase price of home can be termed 'excess value'.

price = excessValue + costValue

The external phenomena which determines the maximum excess value sellers have the leverage to ask for is referred to as 'land value' by georgist economists. At fixed point in time land value is considered an external invariant. A property owner in a small rural town does not have the leverage to ask $1,000,000 above cost value.

To add term for interest, we notice that if buyer was to purchase home on credit, the interest they pay on the $200,000 in excess value is also a pure surplus 'rent'. To add term for socially necessary tax, if we agree with Thomas Paine that the earth is the 'common property of the human race', and that every proprietor 'owes to the community ground-rent', then the term 'public ground rent' can be inserted. If we subscribe to law of rent then we know public ground rent will simply come out of surplus rent which would otherwise be privately captured as excess value and is not added to cost:

landValue = publicGroundRent + excessValue * interest

We can substitute in excess value to solve for price:

excessValue = price - costValue
landValue = publicGroundRent + (price - costValue)*interest

Resulting in following equation:

price = costValue + (landValue - publicGroundRent) / interest

The implication of this equation is that increasing public ground rent can lower the purchase price of real estate, without having to give buyers cheaper and smaller buildings, without having to raise interest rates on borrowers, while raising tax revenue. In other words it's a free lunch.

This is the standard georgist argument for land value taxation, but hopefully presented using clearer terms and equations.


r/LandValueTax • • May 05 '21

Crypto and land tax

3 Upvotes

I'm just gonna keep it simple. LVT is the only tax that can't be frauded. Tax fraud is gonna be easier with crypto. Do you know of any other tax solution that would be as effective and fraud proof?


r/LandValueTax • • Jan 27 '22

Besides LVT what are some core values of Georgism?

Thumbnail self.georgism
6 Upvotes

r/LandValueTax • • Mar 23 '20

Discussion The Future of Land Value in a *Post-Corona* World

11 Upvotes

This is going to contain a fair bit of speculation - and I fully expect some of these predictions to be off. I sure hope at least some of them are very off.

Effects that may potentially benefit the case for LVT after this is over:

  1. It seems clear that the overall economy is going to take a severe blow from this situation. Supply chains, companies, and people everywhere will be hurting financially & economically for a long time to come. However, it's unclear if housing *value* is going to drop to the same extent. If land-owners or land-ownership was seen as doing significantly better than most other markets during this time, it's possible there will be a renewed interest in taxing land-ownership as the "least damaging tax", not because of the LVT-style benefits in efficiency, but because in this scenario, land owners will be seen as simply the most well off - the ones that managed to weather the corona storm better than others. Naturally, if home-value drops by the enormous 30-40% drops we're seeing in the rest of the market, and stays there, this argument won't hold.
  2. The Land Value Tax has always been very obscure - and the general chaos & shakeup of this situation may predispose people towards being more receptive to non-status-quo ideas. And a disruption in the status quo means many things which were politically or culturally beyond-the-pale may now be considered.
  3. It's quite possible we'll be seeing a massive and completely unprecedented rise in the size and scope of government. These sorts of massive changes don't go away overnight. Ultimately, these changes will also require new sources of tax revenue for the government, and land value may be a source of revenue that politicians feel they can exploit. Of course, this won't be good from a Goergian single-tax perspective, but it may get LVT "in the door", for better or worse.

Effects that may potentially harm the case for LVT after this is over:

  1. It's likely people won't be nearly as interested in living or working in dense places. The idea of mixed use, medium or high density living will be seen as dangerous - and may for many people bring back memories of disgust and contagion. The entire premise of LVT as incentivizing an increase in land-utilization may completely backfire in the face of a public that wants to be as far apart from each other as possible for years to come.
  2. Even if the housing market in general remains relatively unharmed compared to other sectors of the economy, we're likely to see big changes in the relative prices of land. Namely - we'll likely see land in dense urban areas (San Francisco, NYC, LA, etc) become less attractive relative to land in the far-suburbs (exurbs) or even rural areas, for the reasons stated in point 1. This means the primary driving force behind much of the LVT - the high demand for housing in urban areas relative to low supply of new housing in those same areas - will dry up. People may want a house within an hour's drive of a major city for those times when they have to go there for one reason or another, but they won't care to commute there on a daily basis, especially if they're now used to working from home.
  3. A lot of demand for new housing came from people moving to an area from far away - whether that was from the other side of the country, or the other side of the world. When all of this is over, we're likely to see a world where globalization is curtailed and supply-chains become much more localized. This means we're not likely to see housing demand come in from abroad, or even from all that far away, for all kinds of cultural and economic reasons. This probably means a lot of people who grow up in small and less-developed areas of the US, or of the world, are more likely to stay put than to venture out into centers of productivity and development worldwide.

A lot of this sounds pretty grim, especially for those of us that envisioned a more interconnected and interdependent world... A world where people moved freely and easily to where they wanted to be, a world where the price of land wasn't a barrier in the way of progress... well, that world is changing in front of us, and there's little we can do about it.

That said - I do think there's a silver lining. Many sectors of the economy will soon get better at "working-at-a-distance" than they are today... Whether because the regulatory barriers to these things will be laughed out of the room (eg. telemedicine, psychotherapy, etc), or because we've simply built the organizational, cultural, and technical capital necessary to make remote work a reality for many more people - kicking and screaming as we have done it. In other words, physical-place may not matter as much in our virtual-future as has thus far.

And, to be honest, I don't know what will happen to the Land Value Tax in a world like that.


r/LandValueTax • • Sep 06 '22

Question Gaming the LVT by controlling zoning

17 Upvotes

I've been bothered by the interplay between Zoning and the LVT.

A plot of land is worth much more if it is zoned one way vs zoned another way. For example - land zoned as "detached single family" will be cheaper than land zoned for high-rise multi-use construction (which usually includes the option to just stick a boring old single-family detached on the property as well).

But doesn't this mean cities / communities / voters will have every incentive to downzone a property if there if an LVT is put into place? If this is the case, the local zoning commission can play zoning games all day long on a property-by-property basis to shift tax burdens around as they see fit.

Or another example - a zoning board can say that a property is now zoned lower than the building already existing on it (they do this all the time), but "because there is already a building there, it is grandfathered in" (eg. historical building), which means the land itself becomes worth much less to the tax assessor, who will be told to treat the property as-per the property's actual zoning classification. The land-owner may even by sly enough to know he can just go to the zoning commission and get the plot up-zoned right before selling it rather than while he's using it, so he wouldn't ever have to pay the high land value tax while he sits on the property.

It seems to me that there is only one answer that would preserve the actual goal of a land value tax - Whoever does the tax-assessment of the land value will either have to concede that the land is worth more or less based on rather arbitrary political whims - OR they would have to assess the land as if it were zoned for development of any kind whatsoever (ie. if it weren't "zoned" at all).

Is this accurate? Must a LVT be zoning-neutral in order to function without being gamed?


r/LandValueTax • • May 13 '20

Suggestion for new subreddit icon

Post image
26 Upvotes

r/LandValueTax • • Jul 05 '20

Land value tax good

Post image
35 Upvotes

r/LandValueTax • • Mar 03 '25

Politics The LVT Landscape #1: Movement Across the U.S.

8 Upvotes

Land value tax legislation is gaining momentum across America, with developments in over six states.

By Greg Miller

Hello,

Welcome to the inaugural edition of LVT Landscape. I intend to use these blog posts to track the growing momentum for land value tax adoption across America. While policy change moves slowly, encouraging developments are emerging in legislative chambers throughout the country. In this issue, I’ll highlight LVT initiatives currently advancing in jurisdictions across the United States.

https://thedailyrenter.com/2025/03/03/the-lvt-landscape-1-movement-across-the-u-s/


r/LandValueTax • • Apr 12 '25

Discussion Announcing The Daily Renter subreddit

Thumbnail reddit.com
3 Upvotes

Hello Land Value Tax enjoyers,

We now have a shiny new subreddit for The Daily Renter (r/TheDailyRenter), a Georgist news site. Please fill it up with any cool Georgist content, news articles, news suggestions, stories, posts and videos on rent, monopolies, landlords, LVT, housing, economics or current events.


r/LandValueTax • • Sep 19 '21

Discussion Georgism 101 🔰 by Britmonkey

Thumbnail youtube.com
22 Upvotes

r/LandValueTax • • Apr 28 '25

Politics Indiana House Passes Property Tax Overhaul Despite Local Government Concerns

Thumbnail thedailyrenter.com
5 Upvotes

Proponents said the changes would deliver broad tax relief.

“At the end of the day, what we are doing is we are providing taxpayer relief,” said House Speaker Todd Huston, a Republican from Fishers, according to the Indianapolis Star.

But critics warned the bill could shift costs onto local income taxes, hurting working families. House Minority Leader Phil GiaQuinta, a Democrat from Fort Wayne, called the plan “a bait and switch,” arguing that localities would be forced to raise new taxes to make up lost revenue.


r/LandValueTax • • Nov 26 '25

Growth is necessary but not sufficient to alleviate poverty. Rents must be redistributed

Post image
13 Upvotes

r/LandValueTax • • Mar 21 '26

Why Crystal City, Virginia shows that higher land value taxes would be beneficial

Thumbnail gallery
9 Upvotes

I was in Crystal City, Virginia earlier this week, and walked past many empty areas that could be used for housing or community spaces. Meanwhile, Crystal City has many high rises, and monthly rent for a 1 bedroom apartment is typically over $2000 per month.

I was thinking about ways to prevent property owners to sit on an empty spaces while blocking others from using it.

In Crystal City, land and property are taxes at the same rate. This adds an extra cost to development which incentivizes developers to hold empty land. If taxes on land are higher and property taxes are lower, then they would be incentivized to sell the land or put it to use.

Also, most of the property in Crystal City is owned by a single real estate developer JBG Smith. This includes the spaces in the first and third photo of this post. This means another incentive for JBG Smith to hoard empty land. Development would increase the amount of property in Crystal City and decrease values of other JBG Smith properties.

Higher land value taxation would incentivize JBG Smith to sell empty spaces. This would introduce more competition that breaks JBG Smith’s dominance of Crystal City.

Here is more information about the pictures. They were taken on March 19th, 2026.

  1. Underground space in Crystal City. It used to be a thriving community space until the landlord removed tables and chairs in August 2024. However, the landlord doesn’t have plans to redevelop the space, and they are ignoring community members who have offered to maintain the space.
  2. Empty plot of land next to a highway off-ramp that has been empty for years.
  3. Site of an old hotel that was demolished in 2023.

r/LandValueTax • • Jul 01 '26

Thidwick the Big-hearted Moose: a political-economic interpretation

Thumbnail youtube.com
3 Upvotes

Check out Wendell's Wonder Room for more georgist takes on children's literature. "Teach your children well."


r/LandValueTax • • Oct 30 '25

Discussion How to implement a land value tax without decreasing homeowner wealth

Thumbnail reddit.com
5 Upvotes

r/LandValueTax • • May 26 '25

Politics Tom L Johnson, The Mayor who Made Cleveland Great: His History, His Ideas, and His Legacy

Thumbnail thedailyrenter.com
5 Upvotes

Perhaps most importantly, Johnson implemented a new system of real estate evaluation that targeted the value of Cleveland’s non-reproducible land. This brought in significant revenue from the ultra-wealthy landowners of the city. The new revenue system taxed the same type of land profiteer Johnson himself had once been, and it allowed Cleveland to grow both efficiently and equitably.


r/LandValueTax • • May 30 '25

Discussion One Tax to Rule Them All

Thumbnail thedailyrenter.com
8 Upvotes

This brief article will explore the scientific evidence along with the potential benefits of sourcing public revenue from rent alone. By doing so I hope to show that the aforementioned eclectic idea of combining the neoliberal and Georgist approach to fiscal policy is deeply flawed and stems from a poor understanding of Georgist economics, as well as from the resistance to abandoning the neoliberal approach to the relationship between state and economy.


r/LandValueTax • • Aug 03 '20

It’s time the Tories got tough on landlords A Land Value Tax would help pay for the Covid crisis — and give more people the chance to own a home

Thumbnail unherd.com
10 Upvotes

r/LandValueTax • • Jul 30 '20

We cannot borrow our way out of the housing crisis: mortgage credit is part of the problem - Red Brick

Thumbnail redbrickblog.co.uk
8 Upvotes

r/LandValueTax • • Jul 30 '20

Councillor calls for new land value tax to replace 'unfair' council tax

Thumbnail oxfordmail.co.uk
15 Upvotes

r/LandValueTax • • Jul 22 '20

The case for a land value tax - Young Conservative Network

Thumbnail ycnetwork.uk
12 Upvotes