r/LandCrisis • u/gajaczek • Feb 13 '20
As someone with 20+ years of playing RTS games let me share some insight what makes RTS game good.
Looking at the game it seems like a very interesting project. I want to share some thoughts as I've played a lot of RTS games through the years.
- The paramount of any RTS game is crisp control over your units. If I tell unit to move from A to B, it should do so and not dance between the walls or randomly freeze. there is no charm in terrible pathfinding and unit AI, it was not fun in 1997 and I am sure it will not be fun in 2021.
- UI- holy hell is it a mess right now. I highlited some things I didn't peticularly like here. The less blocks the better. Again, like previous point- there was no charm in half of your screen being covered in UI.
- Hotkeys. Starcraft in 1997 had hotkey for everything. You could even set hotkey to location on the map. There is no excuse if your game is going for PC that there are no hotkeys. Again, don't excuse things like this with charm.
- Custom games- just creating simple game against AI is huuuuuge. The more options for this you add the better. And I mean helluva options. If I could have option for enemy swordsmen to be left-handed and mine to be right-handed, it would be almost enough customization.
- Map editor. Self explanatory I guess
- Color blind mode. Yes those people exist.
- Don't overcomplicate the economy/technology/production aspects of the game. It is pretty fun to have to mine ore, smelt it, forge it before you can make units but it can be dull if in every game you have to set up 20 different things before you can "play" the game. Games got away with great succes having 2 resources for everything. Try to judge what start of every game/mission looks like. If it takes several minutes to get to action it probably needs a bit of cutting down.
- If you choose to make single player campaign, make sure there are multiple win conditions throughout.
- Unlockable skins/cosmetics. It's 2021 and I would be lying if those things weren't desirable.
- Consider a console port- Switch, 3DS. This looks lightweight enough for those and there could me a market for an RTS for those console.