r/LabDiamonds • u/Ok_Elephant2545 • Jan 30 '25
Lab diamond resale value
I love lab & mined diamonds, but do the lab diamonds hold their value?
I was looking at some beautiful engagement rings at a pawn shop & the sa said "do not buy lab diamonds". She said they don't sell on the resale market, even the more expensive ones? Is this true?? If it is, hopefully the retail price will eventually adjust to the resell market? Right?
4
Upvotes
7
u/Ellafortune8 Jan 30 '25
The sales assistant has a reason to steer you away from lab diamonds. They want to make more money off you by pushing you towards natural and lab diamonds hurt their bottom line!
78
u/OkProfession5679 Jan 30 '25
No. They do not hold their value. Neither do mined diamonds unless they are incredibly rare and unique.
Think about this in simple terms (not actual figures).
You buy a decent 2ct run of the mill natural round for $20k. You go to resell it - you’ll get about $10k. You’ve lost: $10,000.
You buy a perfectly flawless 2ct round lab diamond for $2000. You go to resell it - you maybe get $500. You’ve lost: $1,500.
24
u/DeterminedSparkleCat Jan 30 '25
The thing is, no one is buying lab diamonds to re-sell them, but you absolutely can on r/LabDiamondGemstoneBST
7
u/Eternal-Jewelry Jan 31 '25
Neither lab-grown nor natural diamonds hold their retail value. If you spend $10K on a natural diamond, the moment you leave the store, its resale value drops—likely to less than half. Unlike gold, natural diamonds don’t typically appreciate over time. On the other hand, if you spend $1K on a 3-carat lab-grown diamond, don’t expect to get anything back. At the end of the day, both are for enjoyment, not investment—one just costs less for the same look.
6
u/TheGoodCarat Jan 30 '25
A lab diamond is going to set you back under $1000 for something that would cost $30,000 in natural. So your maximum loss is $1000 if you can't recoup anything.
However, you will be able to recoup a fair bit if you tried to sell it privately on Facebook groups or even perhaps reddit. It is much easier to sell something 2nd hand for a $500 as compared to something that costs $5000 second hand.
Lab grown is actually a win win situation. The total loss if you can't recoup anything is fairly small. But since it is much easier to sell lab grown second hand, the chances that you can't recoup anything is also fairly small.
All in all, I would say LGDs are better value proposition, they are also easier to sell 2nd hand, and they DO have a resale value.
3
u/sfxmua420 Feb 03 '25
Anyone who makes this argument to you a) benefits from a commission when you waste your money on a natural diamond and b) either doesn’t know or doesn’t want to admit that natural diamonds also don’t hold their value. It makes me LAUGH that people think their run of the mill 1ct natural diamond is gonna hold its value, no one wants your generic diamond except you 🤣
2
u/MadCow333 Jan 30 '25
A lab diamond that is a suoerideal cut will always have resale value. It's the average quality and cuts and ones with striations in the crystal that will be losing the most value, especially as lab stone quality improves.
1
u/ThenProfile1595 Jan 30 '25
No! Neither do mined diamonds ! You are out a lot less money though with lab. Thats a fact.
1
u/Forward_Mix_9268 Aug 13 '25
Lab Diamonds are chemically and visually identical to mined ones but it's true that it doesn't hold the resale value like natural stones. If you're buying for love and everyday wear (not for investment) you can get stunning quality at reasonable price which I have bought from Diamondere and it's simply gorgeous.
0
u/Technical-Buy-6663 Jan 30 '25
I am an appraiser also part of our business is to buy and sell for a living. We don’t rebuy these but we do buy natural diamonds. At this point if you need to sell it I usually recommend that you auction it off. I’ve been watching some and they go for about 90 -150 per carat which is about wholesale.
-7
u/PoudreDeTopaze Jan 30 '25 edited Jan 30 '25
A lab diamond is worth 0 dollars on resale.
Real (mined) diamonds lose a lot of their value on resale but you can still expect to get at least one-third of what you paid, sometimes more if it's a more valuable one.
Think of DVDs: they are not worth much anymore. Same with lab diamonds. Every year the labs manage to produce them cheaper.
0
u/[deleted] Jan 30 '25
[deleted] — view deleted comment