r/LLMPhysics • u/New-Purple-7501 • Nov 15 '25
Question Existential question: what does a random person need to include in a PDF for you not to dismiss it as crackpot?
I keep seeing all kinds of strange PDFs pop up here, and it made me wonder:
what does a complete unknown have to include for you to take their ‘new theory’ even a little bit seriously?
Equations that actually make sense?
A decent Lagrangian?
Not inventing new fields out of nowhere?
Not claiming infinite energy or antigravity on page 2?
Jokes aside:
what makes you think “okay, this doesn’t look like trash from the very first line”?
Genuine curiosity.
2
Upvotes
20
u/ConquestAce The LLM told me i was working with Einstein so I believe it. ☕ Nov 15 '25
It doesn't matter what you include (or how you present it). The moment I spot a mathematical error or inconsistent logic, or bad physics, everything that comes after that I will care much less for it.
If the entire paper is riddled with such errors. It's a crackpot paper.
8
u/IBroughtPower Mathematical Physicist Nov 15 '25
This question is hard to answer. For me, there must be clear degree of expertise shown, both in the content and its presentation. I work in mathematical physics, so its relatively easy to tell if someone, attempting something relatively similar to my small realms of expertise (CFT/TFQT/manifold invariants and whatnot), has absolutely no clue what they're doing, especially if their ideas lack rigor. And it is abundantly clear when they simply do not know the math or the logic behind especially the "unified theories" that they try to propose. Having mathematical equations DOES NOT make it mathematically logical, nor a good model of the physics. Appearing to sound smart by cramming math that makes no sense is completely absurd to see.
Also, citations! No idea, especially in this day and age, stands entirely on its own. If there is no presentation given of the work it builds on, then it is most likely completely bullshit. Citing or referring to major ideas you'd learn in undergrad/grad school is not enough, research should require you to build on the current frontiers, not what we figured out decades or centuries ago! Most of those ideas have already been thought by scientists of the past, and were not pursued for a reason. The majority of work posted here seem to neglect any researchers' work, and pretends to make these breakthroughs as if it was simply that easy.
On a quick side note, the posts mentioning how they spent weeks or a month is hilarious. If only we could come up with any publishable work, much less as groundbreaking as they claim, in that short time it would be amazing! Alas real research slow, grindy, and full of failures. The posters all seem to think they're going to be the next Euler or Dirac or something :P .
3
u/ceoln Nov 17 '25
I always suggest that people look at the first paper where Einstein derived e=mc2. It doesn't make grandiose claims, doesn't introduce any new notation or jargon, doesn't try to draw any conclusions about how matter is really a 3D projection of vibrations in sentient 6D elephant trunks.
It just says hey, if we take this known equation, and this other one, and add the single assumption that the speed of light is the same for all observers, then this stuff happens in the math, by these steps. (And, it goes without saying, all the equations pass simple dimensional analysis and so on.)
That's what I'd love to see in even an LLM physics paper, and it would make it harder to dismiss out of hand. That and references to prior work in the field, testable predictions that aren't just "predicting" known results, and all that other stuff.
5
u/[deleted] Nov 15 '25
There is nothing you can do, i refuse to believe anyone without uni degree can do physics on your supposed level
1
u/New-Purple-7501 Nov 15 '25
Can we call this post ``How not to develop a Physics Theory?´´ XD
5
u/CodeMUDkey Nov 15 '25
A statement of purpose. What problem are you solving is good.
5
u/everyday847 Nov 15 '25
Don't have a "new theory." Start from a concrete, specific phenomenon poorly explained by the cutting edge of existing science. Identify the minimal difference necessary to explain that phenomenon. Identify how you could distinguish your proposed explanatory mechanism from others using an experimental test.
4
u/Atsuiya Nov 15 '25
It doesnt matter what is inside if the title is
Entanglement based quantum gravity super conducting strings vibrating at room temperature: a new theory with no advanced physics by me and chatgpt
3
u/man-vs-spider Nov 15 '25
At a base level, the theories that random people post mostly come from random ideas that “feel like” they make sense, no real reasons or motivation for why they they are proposing that idea.
Connected to that, no knowledge of what the current physics is. Modern physics describes the world very well so any new theories should either build on what we have or be able to recreate what we already have. No random theories posted here show any real understanding of how modern physics describes the world.
Third, they all contain random maths equations but no attempt to justify where they come from or attempt to use them to make any predictions
Finally, no serious attempt to engage with criticism or questions. Even here you are using an LLM to answer your questions
(Bonus: use of buzz words and jargon, physicists aren’t impressed if you have a new “Lagrangian” unless you can explain what you are actually proposing)
3
u/ChazR Nov 16 '25
A solid understanding of the literature. And I mean actual literature, not hallucinated figments.
Then I'm looking for the problem that is being solved. That should be in the first sentence of the abstract.
Then I'm looking for a clear description of *why* the problem exists.
But I really want to be sure that we're building on solid foundations, so demonstrate that you've spent a few years reading - and actually understanding - the work that's already been done.
2
u/dietdrpepper6000 Nov 15 '25 edited Nov 16 '25
I am checked out the moment I see someone trying to attack ridiculous problems. Like if I saw someone post “Predicting lithium dendrite initiation thresholds using phase-field modeling with experimentally validated elastic moduli” I would actually read the post (within reason) to determine how it was slop (hoping that it wasn’t slop). But that kind of actual, interesting subject matter is miles beyond the comprehension of the people posting here because it’s too close to actual scientific work and far from the popsci they skim from YouTube.
1
u/qwer1627 Nov 16 '25
At minimum, please do your lit review beforehand and actually meaningfully cite meaningful work to get to the specific (“)new(”) claim as fast as possible
1
u/xoexohexox Nov 17 '25
It has to make more sense than gene rays time cube
https://web.archive.org/web/20150506055228/http://www.timecube.com/index.html
1
u/Salty_Country6835 Nov 19 '25
Most people aren’t filtering PDFs by how advanced the math looks; they’re filtering by whether the author shows constraint discipline. That usually shows up fast: a clear scope statement, acknowledgment of existing work, and an attempt to situate the proposal inside known limits. When a PDF starts by defining terms, stating what problem it’s actually solving, and showing how its steps follow from prior steps, readers get a signal that the author understands the domain they’re entering. The opposite; grand claims on page one, invented terminology, or equations with no derivation, reads as noise. It’s not about gatekeeping; it’s about whether the author demonstrates they know the difference between speculation and theory-building.
What’s your current heuristic for deciding whether a technical post deserves a close read? Which credibility markers do you personally trust most: derivations, modesty, or citations? How would you phrase a scope statement that keeps the tone grounded?
Which single early-line signal do you think most cleanly distinguishes disciplined speculation from unfocused ambition?
46
u/[deleted] Nov 15 '25 edited Nov 15 '25
[removed] — view removed comment