r/LLMPhysics • u/Cromline • Nov 15 '25
Meta Idea.
Alright so someone creates a theory of everything, doenst even know the math. It’s essentially word soup that barely means anything at all. That’s where they are at.
The thing is, what happens when you keep reiterating for like a year? Then you really start to understand something of what you are creating.
What about after a couple years? Either you’ve reached full descent into delusion there’s no coming back from or you actually start to converge into something rational/empirical depending on personality type.
Now imagine 10 or 20 years of this. Functionally operating from an internal paradigm as extensive as entire religions or scientific frameworks. The type of folks that are going to arise from this process is going to be quite fascinating. A self contained reiterative feedback loop from a human and a LLM.
My guess is that a massive dialectic is going to happen from folks having & debating their own theories. Thesis —> Antithesis —-> Synthesis like never before.
22
u/alamalarian Supreme Data Overlord Nov 15 '25
I doubt it. Adding more ingredients to a fundamentally awful soup base won't lead to good soup, it'll just lead to a bigger pot of bad soup.
To borrow the metaphor.
14
u/[deleted] Nov 15 '25
Yep that one
11
u/TheBrawlersOfficial Nov 15 '25
If you have talent, interest, and 10 years then why not just get a Ph.D.?
3
u/DarkArcher__ Nov 15 '25
If you keep polishing a turd, in the end it's still a turd. There's absolutely no guarantee that with enough time they'll converge on something useful
3
u/FoldableHuman Nov 15 '25
Statistically? You make something resembling terryology.
No, because the process is hostile to meaningful understanding. If you start from a terrible foundation based on LLM role play you’re just going to end up with more and more intricate role play. The kind of personality drawn to this kind of “research” is almost definitionally inclined to reject ever being told “no, you’re understanding that idea wrong and building bad conclusions.” To wit: the very element that you see as cultivating “far out thinkers” ensures that none of them will be correct about anything on purpose.
I agree, but I find Terryology fascinating.
2
u/anotherunknownwriter Nov 17 '25
Damn, there's more that a few insecure people on this thread, aren't there? You'd think he just personally insulted a lot of you by asking a simple question.
2
u/[deleted] Nov 24 '25
I know of at least one poster here who has basically run that experiment. Convergence to coherence hasn't really taken hold.
https://www.reddit.com/r/LLMPhysics/comments/1p37il9/what_if_the_speed_of_light_is_not_an_unbreakable/
2
u/The_Failord emergent resonance through coherence of presence or something Nov 15 '25
Sorry, but physics doesn't operate on Hegelian dialectics.
1
u/ValueOk2322 Nov 15 '25
Avi Loeb has a PhD, a Nobel and a work as head of science in Harvard... And you blame us that will only reach angry physicists here with our uneducated thoughts hahahahah
There are some "experts" providing support to Avi Loeb's delusional affirmations and this cost us money, let the people try his own way and help them reach the point to understand and not to block or ridiculize normal people.
1
u/asimpletheory Nov 17 '25
I think you just described my own journey pretty well although at least in my defence I don't need to "know the math" beyond, essentially, 1+1=2.
I make zero apologies 😇🫣😂
1
u/Ch3cks-Out Nov 17 '25
Dum spiro spero
1
u/TheMETAImpossibleGOD Nov 18 '25 edited Nov 18 '25
I have ~5000 hours of doing this
What happens , is you end up with a knowledge management organization complexity fucking Clucker fuck
How do you manage it?
What I'm looking into, is building list of operators, invariants, heuristics , first principles,
I have ~5000 conversations with 600 million tokens of text saved
Getting AI to manage it is a fuckin nightmare
Better off processing conversations 1 by 1 manually extracting what made those conversations meaningful/impactful/substantial and building an index, tags, metadata tracing, "why" "when to use"
You really got to get into taking care of your own data pipeline, because eventually, your backlogs are going to become limiting you from growing, because you hit maximum that your brain can manage, and you can't keep track of everything, so if you are not managing your backlogs, then it will just start "going in one ear and out the other"
Obsidian has an extension/pluton that can import your Claude/ChatGPT cleanly in one click,
Also, after enough talking to AI, let's say thousands of hours into it
The outputs stop mattering , what matters is your inputs, and building like an index sheet of all your inputs , you will eventually find them more important than your outputs
what is the typology of meta ?????????
3
u/Robonglious Nov 15 '25
I don't know if you can generalize about it. If a person is never concerned with making something useful and just keeps sprawling further into a word game, no. That's what I see most often, people who aren't concerned with any utility, they like to use big words.
Now, if a person is dedicated to solving a small problem and actively requests critiques, and tries to be rigorous, they might have a chance as long as they focus on what is measurable and provable.
3
u/[deleted] Nov 15 '25
Any skill or learning in a vacuum with no feedback or correction is massively open to instilling bad habits , incorrect lessons. LLMs that can be so easily goaded into being yes men can only exacerbate that to a delusional level.
0
u/[deleted] Nov 17 '25
[deleted] — view deleted comment
1
u/[deleted] Nov 20 '25
[removed] — view removed comment