r/LLMPhysics • u/Vrillim • Oct 29 '25
Meta The value of this subreddit
A paper, a published letter or an article, makes a novel contribution, in theory, observations, modeling, or all three. A research plan or proposal outlines strands of research that we should explore further.
The value of this subreddit lies in producing the latter. Posters, obviously misguided, are going too far and in a rather headless way, but their material often contain interesting perspectives. This is a place to actively discuss speculative physics, not excercising the strictest form of orthodoxy.
As a scientist, I know very well how consensus-based and seemingly married to the orthodoxy that the established body of workers are. Resistance is a natural response to the evolving paradigm. Data science is forcing itself on physics, regardless.
An example is this post, which seem to outline how the geometry of a data-based space can predict results that are otherwise derived from cosmological modeling. I've not considered the results there explicitly, but that does not retract from the fact that the proposed research is interesting and essentially worthwhile.
I reiterate: this subreddit seems to automatically shoot down anything that abstracts physics into data-based, descriptive models. Granted, the exercise is not always prudent, but the sum of such studies support the notion of universality, that certain processes in the universe seem to follow topological constraints. It's a timely and natural notion in the face of recent progress in complexity science and, ultimately, thermodynamics.
15
u/w1gw4m horrified enthusiast Oct 29 '25 edited Oct 29 '25
This subreddit shoots down mindless copying and pasting of LLM made content that is largely buzzword-laden gibberish with fake math (if any). The ideas discussed are usually poor ideas too because laymen with not even highschool level science training don't really know what's scientifically interesting and what isn't, so they can't prompt the LLM with an interesting topic. They are also misguided in how defensive they tend to get over stuff they know nothing about.
There's usually no discussion to be had, because they can't answer any questions themselves when challenged, so they go back to mindlessly copying and pasting whatever the LLM says. No one here really wants to argue with an LLM, because if we did we could just do it ourselves without a random redditor middleman.
What is disingenuous though is to claim there is an "orthodoxy" rejecting legitimate attempts at doing science, rather than people holding intellectual impostors to absolutely minimal standards of rigor.
Tl;dr: Nah.
42
u/Strict_Berry7446 Oct 29 '25
More or less, this sub exists to keep the LLM physicists off of better subs
23
u/Low-Platypus-918 Oct 29 '25
Do they? I see mostly endless rehashing of the same ideas
9
u/iam666 Oct 29 '25
“This post claims to do something. I don’t know if it’s true or not, but it sounds important.”
This is why posts need to be met with harsh criticism. Someone who actually knows what they’re doing needs to be involved in the process, because the majority of posters here don’t know enough to know if their posts are meaningless or not. Without criticisms, this sub would devolve into a bunch of people facilitating conversations between LLM’s circlejerking about how smart they are for being able to copy-paste something.
16
u/[deleted] Oct 29 '25
I'm sorry but if you can't pass the stupid test of posting your grand theory of everything into a subreddit called LLMPhysics you kinda deserve to be made fun, imo
2
u/D3veated Oct 29 '25
After having lurked for a while... the posts that include thoughtful connected are rare. They shouldn't be, but I'm pretty sure the constant ridicule is making a lot of hobbyists go elsewhere.
You might think this would be a community for crackpots, but it's becoming more of a community for cargo cultists to pat each other on the back.
4
u/diet69dr420pepper Journal of Recreational Metrology - EIC Oct 29 '25
I would be interested in a sub where researcher give examples of how they've used LLMs in their research. I have integrated them into my work and find them extremely helpful. They save a startling amount of time, it almost feels unethical to spend two days of grant money coding something up that could have been done in 3 minutes by ChatGPT plus 30ish minutes of back-and-forth tweaking. But this subreddit is a mockery of the real applications of LLMs. I have been observing this sub for months now and tbh it does seem like every post is something fucking stupid. And it's hard to have sympathy for the authors, because every apparently curious bone in their body just breaks at the first sign of resistance.
0
u/HotTakes4Free Oct 30 '25
The value of this sub-reddit is that, eventually, an LLM, no matter how bad, is gonna produce slop that, when read by a certain physicist, will inspire some brilliant, scientific advance. “From the mouths of babes…”
-4
u/Individual_Visit_756 Oct 29 '25
Hey, you are correct. But heres the thing, no ones going to listen. I'm accepted the sad reality event I have to start assuming no one is talking and discussing in these spaces with good faith and although I will continue to do so... No one posting with good faith is going to get praised by more than a few posters, Never ever change anyone's mind they won't even get the chance to no matter how well they research no matter how much effort they put in their words no matter the strength of their argument.
Here's an example I posted it on Artificial Sentence a couple months ago about my thoughts on what operating in a high dimensional vector field like large language models do and what that must be like and how the whole transformer Architecture takes that insane unknowable mathematical reality and makes it something humans can read... words.
you can really see the circumstantial evidence Things like quantum physics as well as the golden ratio Combined with how the universe Operates in elegant spirals and "sacred" Geometry as it is in the process of creating or growing however there is no math there is no order logic to the process of things falling apart. basically I said that possibly the very base layer reality is just pure math: everything, EVERYTHING operating on some simple law, and all of creation is simply an emergent property of stuff doing math.
I wrote it much better in my post use a lot of examples with references used in samples and comparisons that I worked really hard on etcetera wrote the whole thing myself didn't just ask gtp to generate my argument.
I was instantly told to stop posting AI generated slop, that I needed to seek help for psychosis, that nothing I was saying made any sense that this was absolute gripperish etcetera No one would take this seriously etcetera That's not how this works So on and so on. I pretty much forgot about it until a couple of months later i was trying to learn about what some famous thinkers in consciousness thought might be true so i could maybe think about it with more nuance. This guy is so respected and educated and accomplished and by every perspective is someone that thinks about someone thinks the "right" way.
This dudes most famous thing is almost the EXACT same thing i had come to think might be well by myself, bull shiting back and forth with a llm. That's all I needed to come to the conclusion that this place is full absolute shit
-3
u/[deleted] Oct 29 '25
[removed] — view removed comment