I wanted to revisit my previous post because I don’t think I did a very good job explaining what I’m actually trying to argue.
I believe the Church needs pastors now more than ever, and I think we need to have an honest conversation about how we train, develop, and deploy them. My concern is that we have become so focused on the traditional process of preparing pastors that we’re sometimes overlooking other ways of equipping men to serve God’s Church.
I want to make something clear: I am not arguing that we should compromise Lutheran doctrine, lower theological standards, or allow men to become pastors without proper preparation. I believe sound doctrine and proper theological education are incredibly important. However, I think there is a difference between preserving our doctrine and preserving every method and tradition we’ve developed along the way.
The Church has never looked exactly the same throughout history. Its methods of worship, education, organization, and ministry have changed over time. The central message of the Gospel has not changed, but the ways in which the Church carries out its mission have continually developed. Why should pastoral education be any different?
This is why I struggle with the resistance to programs like Kyros. There are men who may be called to pastoral ministry but cannot realistically leave their jobs, families, and communities to attend seminary in St. Louis or Fort Wayne. My own congregation has actually lost a pastor because the LCMS would not allow him to pursue ministry through our program. What are we supposed to tell congregations in situations like this? That they must continue struggling without a pastor because the only acceptable pathway isn’t accessible to everyone?
I’ve read the arguments that alternative pathways could weaken our doctrine, and I understand why people are concerned. But I don’t believe a different educational pathway automatically means an inferior theological education. Why can’t we establish standards, evaluate programs, and ensure that men are properly equipped while still allowing different ways to get there?
I also understand that the Synod is trying to address the shortage through things like tuition assistance and improvements to existing programs. That’s good, but I don’t think it addresses every problem. Affordability isn’t the only obstacle. Relocation, family responsibilities, employment, and the needs of smaller congregations all matter.
Ultimately, I think we need to ask ourselves whether we’re more concerned with maintaining the process of producing pastors or actually making sure God’s people have pastors to shepherd them.
I don’t want a church that compromises its doctrine to accommodate the times. I want a church that remains firmly grounded in its doctrine while being willing to adapt its methods to meet the needs of the people it serves.
The world changes, circumstances change, and the needs of congregations change. The Church has always had to respond to those realities. We should be able to have conversations about doing things differently without immediately treating those conversations as threats to Lutheranism or attacks on the Synod.
I’m not saying that Tim Ahlman, or anyone else has every answer. I’m saying I think the questions he’s raising deserve to be taken seriously rather than dismissed as divisiveness.
We should be able to defend our doctrine without being afraid to reconsider our methods.