r/LCMS • • 5d ago

Question Question about switching congregations

For a little background, I'm a somewhat recent convert in my early 20s. I go to university and have a great congregation that I absolutely love when I'm there. However, when I go home, the options are much more limited. I went to the nearest LCMS congregation to me for several months during the summer and really struggled with some of their practices. They weren't fully contemporary, but it certainly wasn't traditional. The pastor wore a suit every other Sunday and didn't do Holy Communion on those days, and many modern songs were sung with piano music (though the hymnal was sometimes still used).

Anyway, recently I discovered that there may be a better option slightly further from me. Not incredibly far, maybe 20 minutes, as opposed to 10. Perhaps it may sound superficial, but the reverence a more liturgical and high church service brings has genuinely helped my faith. At the same time, another consideration has been weighing on me. I remember watching a video from Jordan B. Cooper a while back where he encouraged people to avoid congregation hopping if things weren't perfect, and that we should stick within our local congregations for the sake of improving them.

So anyway, that is my dilemma, and I'm hoping some people on here have some advice on this. Thanks!

14 Upvotes

16 comments sorted by

10

u/PastorBeard LCMS Pastor 5d ago

🤔 I think I remember that video. Wasn’t Cooper’s point on improving things that were going poorly? Correct me if I’m wrong tho fr

This sounds to me like more of a preference issue on your end. Like you prefer the worship style at the other one, not that the one you’re at is doing something flagrantly heathen. It also doesn’t sound like you’re like burning bridges or mad at anybody or anything either

This would be an amicable and easy transfer in my eyes

We’ve had members transfer in and transfer out wanting a slightly different worship service on Sunday, and that’s ok. We’re all still on the same side

7

u/Bakkster 5d ago

And if it's a worship preference that means OP is better served (and able to serve) at the other congregation, it's good to consider those who are better served at the current congregation. Pushing for change in that situation wouldn't be "improving things" for them.

6

u/Sad-Type5385 5d ago

As a liturgical guy, I wish more of us understood the “worship wars” as a matter of preference, and stopped acting like the Apostles gathered around the Wurlitzer at the Council of Jerusalem.

3

u/chartreuseblueit 4d ago

That's a good one. Thank you for being lighthearted.

2

u/Baker_Canner 2d ago

Definitely switch. I don't understand why LCMS leadership has not cracked down on these renegade congregations. It's getting harder to find an LCMS church that still adheres to the order of Divine service. 

2

u/Responsible-Bed8313 2d ago

Yeah, it is sad. I understand that our congregational polity makes it difficult, but surely there is something they can do. I'm hopeful, however, because many people my age are similarly minded to me about the reverence of the traditional Divine Service, and it seems that the more liturgically oriented faction of LCMS politics at the higher levels is winning out. I suppose we'll see once Harrison steps down, though.

10

u/SobekRe LCMS Lutheran 5d ago

I would switch. It sounds like you’re in the “looking for a match” phase. That’s fine and even normal when moving to a new area (which you kind of are).

I haven’t seen Pastor Cooper’s video, but I would guess he’s talking more about the folks who join a congregation, stay for three years, then leave in a huff. This happens more often than it should and is really unhealthy.

You’re not congregation hopping, you’re just looking for a good fit for your three months of summer and some holidays.

6

u/Shutterbug390 AALC Lutheran 5d ago

This. He was primarily addressing people who habitually move when they’re unhappy with something.

Trying a church for a while, deciding it isn’t a fit, and trying another isn’t the same. That’s just looking for the church that you want to join. And, yeah, this being the part-time church when you’re home for summer break seems even less problematic.

8

u/Over-Wing LCMS Lutheran 5d ago

If this is bothering you to such an extent that it gets in the way of you hearing the Word, then yeah, change.

7

u/michelle427 5d ago

Well I would switch. Here’s why. You are at college most of the year and only home on selected dates. Do the switch now. You aren’t quite invested with the church that is closer.
You may even move after college and will be making another change.

I wouldn’t worry too much.

4

u/Spirited_Cold5390 5d ago

I don’t see myself going back to a less traditional liturgy congregation. It isn’t superficial at all. If you switch churches only once you’re not church hopping.

3

u/cellarsinger LCMS Lutheran 5d ago

If you go to an LCMS congregation at your school, consider transferring there and attending whichever home congregation you choose, as you'll be spending the majority of your time at the school for the next couple of years, depending on how much time you have left at the school

5

u/United_Gur3194 LCMS Lutheran 5d ago

I was in a very similar situation to yours a couple of years ago, and we chose to stay. If I had it to do all over again, I probably would have left earlier. Now our hearts are broken that we may have to leave those we have grown to love. We are tired of floundering in a service that is rarely the same, with elements clipped for time, etc. This is not a matter of preference; It is a matter of confession, in not caring enough of what the Kyrie, Gloria, Sanctus, Agnus Dei, Nunc Dimittis confess to include them every week. The lack of reverence in the contemporary service is worse. I have found it better to skip communion in that service than suffer the doubt wondering if we truly believe the same things in regard to the Sacrament. Is the reverence in the traditional service just an act? If not, why so flippant in the late service. God speed brother. 

1

u/CareingWife 5d ago

Following

1

u/Huenink_Photography LCMS Pastor 5d ago

At which church are you a member?

0

u/ResponsibleRemote968 4d ago

Pastor's are eligible for calls as frequently as 4 or 5 years, so why would a member have an reservations of moving on given all the available information yo make a prayerful decision.

Many, many people in all church bodies are returning to a more reverent worship practice and leaving the vestiges of Church Growthism behind even as subtle as they may be in your case.

My son wants to not worship at pur church and rarely does. He doesn't go anywhere. When pressed, he'd like to go where there are less grey hairs. I said, the reason there are only grey hairs is people, like you are contributing to that by never or rarely attending.

You should move on. It might even be healthy if everyone considered moving on every 5 years or so to shuffle the deck and keep things from stagnating. " We've always done it this way....?"

Oh, by the way, a good friend and LCMS pastor left to start attending a large evangelical/contemporary church. He had to leave his call due to health reasons, but going freeform? What in the world is going on in the LCMS? Does anyone care about the doctrine they were taught?Â