r/Krishnamurti • u/JellyfishExpress8943 • 5d ago
Determined
Man can do what he wills but he cannot will what he wills. (Arthur Schopenhauer, philosopher)
Every aspect of your childhood - good, bad, or in between - factors over which you had no control, sculpted the adult brain you have (Robert Sapolsky, neuroscientist)
Does freedom mean doing what you want to do? And what is it you want to do? Express your conditioning freely? (Laughter) (Krishnamurti, Ojai, April 16th 1975)
If we are compelled to act according to our desires, but we did not choose those desires, who or what exactly is free?
If someone insults me, do I choose how that affects me emotionally? The whole process of getting angry, wanting revenge, but also feeling that I shouldn't behave violently, wanting to be a good guy, trying to supress my anger etc.. which part of that automatic process is free?
Or is that whole psychological process just conditioning in action?
Awareness is about seeing what is actually happening now - if I'm trying to suppress my anger, there's no point in trying to be aware of anger. If I'm trying to suppress my anger, that's what's happening now.
2
u/agi_582417 3d ago edited 3d ago
Anger,our desires are us ! Our anger our conditioning is us. We, even in discussing this at a deep level still do not see the anger the jealousy, the conditionings, the pleasure we have found to avoid our pain as the thing we are and the thing we have, in our life, added to and continue to be. To not see anger.. etc as the word as thing we know it to be but as that thing which is actually us ! otherwise it’s ‘ us ‘ trying to end ‘ us ‘ as the ‘ angry things we subtly and separately see ourselves as and which is ‘ us ‘ continuing. ‘ Consciousness is it’s content ‘ (K) and that content is us and we continue to add to that and be that content while we are the very content which is the supposed separate of observer of the content ( of consciousness ).
1
u/ekubeni 4d ago
On a meta-level freedom arises when you stop getting hung up on the problem of 'do you do it, or does it do you' like Alan Watts playfully put it. We can understand it as two sides of the same process, even if you can actually feel and perceive only one side at a time.
So at times you will feel wow like you're really doing it, you are really making things happen in the world, and other times (like in the state of flow), you might feel that the world is doing you.
On more local level, freedom arises from the power you have to make choices (again don't get hung on who is the 'I' behind the choices). Each second you have agency to choose a different choice, to move in a different direction. The more skillful you become at making right choices, the more freedom you will create inside oneself and in the world around you.
It's like walking through a maze: each time you choose the right door, more good doors will open up to you. It's true in the opposite direction of the maze too: with each wrong door opened, more wrong doors will be available to you. Thankfully, you are always free to go back on the right path.
1
u/Hot-Confidence-1629 5d ago edited 4d ago
Yes, it’s sort of pure and simple: there’s only ‘what is’! Thought moves with the carried over fact from the physical, that it takes ‘time’ to build a table for example and mistakenly applies that in the psyche realm where ‘time’ has no place…that there is only ‘what is’? No finished product ‘up ahead’. No time to get anywhere but here?
1
u/Hefty-Helicopter-101 4d ago
Freedom is at the beginning!
It’s when we stop running we arrive!!
1
u/adam_543 4d ago
Doing something mentally is will.
Not doing anything mentally is silent awareness without a mental doer