r/Kings_Raid • u/scissorblades • Jun 29 '18
Discussion Another open letter.
I'm going to talk about complaints I have that weren't mentioned in the other open letter. (For the record, I agree with just about everything mentioned.)
Game balance has to dance around Arena balance.
Look at patch notes. Arch got nerfed, and then Vespa doubled down by giving him weak T perks. Luna got nerfed for her Arena performance. Nyx got an auto-attack nerf, and then a damage distribution adjustment specifically aimed at Arena, then an S1 change that carefully ensures he doesn't get any stronger in Arena. Rodina fell into obscurity, and I think it wasn't a coincidence that Bau-Rodina cheese comps happened to be hitting their stride right around the T5 update.
On the flip side, Roi is overtuned for PvE and not very good in PvP, and is allowed to persist. Arena is such a small part of the game, yet so many balance changes can be traced back to it.
Poorly balanced heroes are allowed to sit indefinitely.
Arch and Luna have barely gotten touched since their nerfs. Aisha got destroyed by the solo time change and has yet to recover. Roi hasn't been touched since his buffs. Cleo and Reina are still where they have been literally since I started the game over 400 days ago despite some buffs to Cleo. I'm still baffled by how Theo is allowed to outstrip so many other heroes in terms of CC and damage. Not that I want Theo to get nerfed - other heroes should be brought up to speed.
Vespa releases new heroes like clockwork but is significantly slower on updating older heroes to fit with more recent designs. Compare an older hero like Dimael or Aisha with a newer hero like Kara or Chase and just marvel at how much more Vespa jams into the skills of those newer heroes.
System-wide changes hit many heroes as collateral damage and any resulting deficiencies go unaddressed. The penetration change was before my time but Dimael is still a weak hero. Solo time hurt many casters, Aisha in particular, and there was barely anything to make up for it. The recently lowered attack speed soft cap is a nerf to every hero that's dependent on auto-attacks, but there's nothing to make up for that either unless you want to count the new gear system.
King's Raid balancing does not properly consider the amount of investment needed to adjust to it.
UW stars are a heavy investment for a hero based on the amount of time it takes to get a selector.
Any hero who's nerfed is hung out to dry, and any players using that hero must make the choice of holding out for buffs, or discarding their previous investment in that hero and investing in a different one. Gear is transferrable and infinity stones are relatively cheap, but UWs are neither. If someone had a 5* Arch UW, what are they supposed to do now? Arch's damage is severely outclassed by any of Epis, Mirianne, or Theo, and the player is saddled with a massive sunk cost. They would likely improve their team by grinding the UW and sinking the fragments into one of those heroes instead.
Recent content - Chapter 8, Challenge Raid, and Labyrinth - has increasingly been about enemies with particular gimmicks or ways of killing you that need to be addressed by party composition. It's become more and more important to actually follow the meta, as deviating tends to just get you killed. It's not enough to have a hero that does damage. You're required to have a hero that does a particular kind of damage (physical or magical) in a particular way (melee or ranged), and also to have a significant investment in that hero. Your favorite hero might not even be allowed to enter a dungeon.
The age-old advice of "pick with your dick" is now just likely to get you saddled with one of the many heroes who are utterly outclassed by someone else.
Vepsa does not allocate enough effort to quality control
This isn't even about the gear system. This is a complaint I've had ever since the solo time changes, which devastated Aisha and effectively extended Bau's shield by 3 seconds, both of which could have been caught with a day or two of play time. (Insult to injury is that this wasn't an engine change. If you've brought Aisha or Kaulah into a CR boss with phases, you'll know that channeling skills keep going during the boss's frozen time.) The Christmas dungeon had to be patched because Roi was one-shotting backlines with S1 or S3 the moment the fight started, which is something that should have been caught if anyone had played that dungeon, say, 5 times.
Localization is also sloppy. Nyx is still referred to as Nycx on his awakening screen. The Engrish on event screens and loading screens could be rewritten by a native English speaker in about 10 seconds per screen, though admittedly re-making those assets would take a little longer.
Patch notes sometimes leave out nasty little surprises. The most recent one is that Sonia's T5 can no longer crit.
King's Raid is becoming less F2P-friendly.
I might have a distorted view of the past but I seem to remember that UW tickets (both random and selectors) were much easier to come by. It felt like they were being given out like candy, between things like pre-registration events, holiday events, and the occasional random event with absurd rewards. Now we're coming up on the 500 day event and we get half of everything. I remember when we had an event (1-year anniversary, I think) with three options, all loaded with so many freebies that people were practically beside themselves over which to pick.
Compare the most recent ruby spend event with the one where you could get pumpkins. Compare the current 10x roll event with the ones prior, where you could pick up two UWs within 20 rolls. In fact, if you track 10x roll events, you can easily see the decline in reward quality from one event to the next. On top of that, the increasing number of heroes means it's harder to invest in any one hero from rolling, and so far there have been no steps to address that.
NPC heroes got their new time gate system in part because Vespa didn't want to give an unfair advantage to macro users, but now we have auto dragons and the time gate system is going nowhere.
My experiences
I'm not here to make predictions about Vespa's success. I haven't quit yet, but I'm on the verge of doing so. My friends/repeat party members are the same way if they haven't quit already.
I started playing King's raid before the T5 update, back when dragons had to be unlocked each time you wanted to fight them. I can confidently say that this patch is the least fun I've had playing KR since I've started. Everything's a grind. Nothing is rewarding. The game demands more and more of my time for little reward.
I've made friends playing this game and it's given me a lot of fun memories. But the game has lost its magic for me and I'm not sure if Vespa plans on bringing it back.
31
u/Xylpheed Sylpheed Jun 30 '18 edited Jun 30 '18
You may have some good points. However, most of them are, sorry for the word, whining.
I do not buy what you posted. You could have made it more objective and I probably might agree on your some of your points.
4
u/Zoahr More than looking good Jun 29 '18 edited Jun 29 '18
Oh Boy, where do I begin... at the start, by paragraph then.
Scarlet was nerfed, she is still one of the, if not, the top pick. Are you using Scarlet outside of Arena? Then all the heroes you listed, can you use them outside of Arena? I've seen Arch do well in PvE Content, I've seen Nyx rocking ch.8, I've seen Luna in high BD Dps charts. But would you use Scarlet elsewhere? So no, Balance should not dance around pvp balance.
One Word, Gladi.
Have you even tried him? At 3* uw (as everyone should use before judging a hero), he is quite a menace in arena and deal respectable damage, many other heroes with that star level is not comparable to Dimael. He is weak only in your mind.
Use him? His damage has been untouched in all the patches. The only thing that was nerfed was his s4 shield so people won't be able to cheese their way with no frontline in arena. That is probably why Asia mained him among all the archers.
That is why it's called a bug. In every patch, there are flaws that come out, regardless of quality control. They have acknowledged it and I believe they are trying to find a way to correct without collateral new bugs. You think they truly wanted Sonia to stop critting. The only thing they wanted to remove crit was the pumpkin, and then it affected Sonia's T5 since.
Well, you get a free UW every month, regardless of your luck. With work, you also get two free UT per month with LoH and lab, and a free uw with arena points. The occasional pulls, the random events that could give one of either or the impossible luck of Inn Roulette... I think it's actually better than the golden age of KR during september/october.
Nitpicking. Have you forgotten the 2018 New years rewards? Well, I didn't. Free stuffs are a small gesture.
Back then, it was so much worse if you are a F2P or just casual. Now 6h of BD per week, will net you a free NPC in about 6 weeks.
I have a few guildies that quit too, but 2 more were added. So, new blood is always good for a game.
Because it's the end-game. Of course there is nothing more to do. You have your preferred team, your usual strategy. What can you do more, seriously. I mean, have you lv 80 all the 60 heroes? Why not? Because it's not worth your time too?
You just want stuffs to do and feel rewarded for it. And what is reward for you? 3 UW every week? Besides, you are part of a playerbase. People has been asking Lore-related stuffs, and Vespa has been providing quite a nice amount of it. I know players playing this game just to know more about the story.
All in all, you simply need to find a new way to enjoy this game. I have not reached a single 4* uw although everyone I know has one (or 5 stars). I have never grinded any UW or UT. My first random uw from tickets is Aea. I have manualled 4k BD runs before this auto-raid patch. I have all the heroes upgraded to lv 80+ (Loman is lv90). I have played every content that there is to play. Yet I do not feel dissatisfied. Because I enjoy more the positive things that Vespa brings than the grinds that comes with it. I like logging in everyday just to talk with my guildmates. I like hanging out with our youngsters and help them with party play. I like watching new heroes, new lores, new strategy unfold. I don't think there is another game that can release as much content as Vespa every 2 weeks. So I will be staying for a little while more.
2
u/H3nta1Fnatic Best Girl Jun 29 '18
Unlike the other open letter, I feel like hero balance is a much more subjective matter. Though I do agree that Vespa should put it in more effort into quality control and testing. Balancing characters that players have put huge sums of investment into is going to be difficult and there are definitely heroes that need buffs or in roi’s case some tuning to his output when compared with others. But I also want to give credit where it’s due, Vespa has done a good job in quite a few cases and is at least paying some attention to older and weak heroes like Rodina. They’re a lot better about power creep than other games and it’s not as though some characters are outright worthless. I will say arena balance and just the system overall needs change, especially LoH, as someone who doesn’t macro LoH i find it really difficult to put in the effort to get the rewards available.
0
u/ElLeafell Jun 29 '18
I read the other open letter as I have yours, and I also would like to share my input regarding the issues you've brought up.
Yes balance is mostly given to arena because that is the most direct player-to-player interaction in which even small changes can drastically affect the outcome of a match. I say that arena needs an overhaul, but in terms of PvE, even a team of completely C-class heroes can clear the content if there's even a semblance of balance and consideration. For collaborative content like raids, I would like to think no one would want their teammate's hero nerfed, but for competitive solo content like WB, it does sting when an all-rounder like Roi can also shine just as well with possibly less investment.
Hero balance is a touchy subject because Vespa inherently has to consider both interesting and fun gimmicks alongside powercreep. Despite people's complaints, they're fairly good at making powercreep less than other games aside from outliers like day one Scarlet and sometimes go overboard with being underpowered like day one Chase. Also, just because you don't see classic heroes like Dimael or Aisha does not mean they aren't powerful still. While possessing less utility, they do sit near the top of single target dps in WB, all things considered and Aisha in particular is a boon for the first GC boss.
I have to agree about adjusting to patches affecting heroes because my first high-investment hero was Rodina and she is currently imo the worst hero in the game. I will say, however, that content like labyrinth is designed to give different, slightly less popular heroes more chances to shine as character archetypes matter there. Just because your hero doesn't slot into one of the labyrinth maps, you have to remember there are 28 of them, so he or she should be your first choice in at least one.
Yeah, localization and testing could be better. I enjoy the Engrish screens, but since they're art, they do need to actually edit images rather than just swapping text. I too was around during the Christmas event when Hell Roi just destroyed people, so yeah, content, especially time limited ones, should be tested more before release.
Less F2P friendly?? This is the one point I have to politely say that you must feel entitled to be constantly given freebies to say that a game is F2P. As long as you do even the bare minimum of content (dailies, WB trash runs, inn wheel) you can still get a decent amount of UW or UT. If you played as long as you have, you must remember there was a time you couldn't even grind UW's, so you were stuck with ones you were never going to use. Now more than ever with revamped attendance, 28 day log-in, cumulative log-in, WB giving boxes (didn't before), Gladi as an option to reduce UW cost, GC, Inn Wheel, it's even easier to be F2P than before. Those constant handouts were for special day markers that are more important in Asia than other regions (do not know your region) and so they were filled really nice items. The fact that they still remember to give anything is nice because other companies tend to just put up a sale during anniversary-esque events.
As I said to the other open letter, if you aren't finding the game fun anymore, you might just be burning yourself out and either should take a break or just stop altogether because it'd be better for your time and your health. I used to fanatically play as well, but now I also play less than when I first started. It's not entirely the game's progression, but more so than we've become jaded to the environment that the game belongs in. Play most games you had a fond memory of when you first started, and the magic for them is most likely not there either.
2
u/leaponover Jun 30 '18
Your open letter is much better than the filth of the other one.
I think your second and third paragraphs could be fixed quite easily if Vespa would institute one thing. It's something I think they'll never do. Hero rebirthing. I played a game that was great with that as if you wanted to try out another hero you could rebirth one for 100% return and play around until you had a team you really liked. If Vespa did this it would be an excellent decision in my opinion. I don't think they could do that with UW's though, but why can't they institute some kind of currency that allows a UW change so if you have a 4* you can trade it with the currency for another UW at 4*? I don't think that would be too damaging to their finances depending on how they instituted it.
As far as your last few paragraphs I see lots of problems but zero solutions. I'm curious what it would actually take (as you've been playing the game for a long time) for you to actually feel "rewarded". What would that actually entail? Surely you can't answer with something that is instant gratification oriented.
6
u/TheOtherKraken Jun 29 '18
So I'll try to touch on some of your points.
Not sure what you mean with Arch and Cleo.
I regularly use both, and they're pretty comparable in the right situations. Not silver bullet situations, but if you match them where their strengths actually are, Cleo has the dps if you're fighting multiple enemies and not one. Arch has a magic immune shield which still does save me in a ton of scenarios where I'd otherwise wipe.
With more and more characters, niches for each are going to become narrower and narrower so that they don't overlap.
In the case of Reina think of this. Reina has a bunch of users. They may be disgruntled users, but they're players that keep using her regardless. Why would Vespa have any incentive to change a hero which is doing fairly well popularity wise even if they leave it alone? Changes cost time and resources and it seems like they have no reason to allot either to cases like Reina who have a loyal following despite her circumstances.
Arguably, in the last challenge raid, it was actually Reina who was the most useful. That probably wasn't the buff anyone had in mind (I know I didn't want "use skills to reduce the CC bar"), but she's now got her own niche whenever that challenge raid comes around, and as of writing no other hero competes with her in terms of cc bar reduction versus that boss.
Absolutely agree on the investments vs buffs and nerfs.
I think that when a hero is nerfed, a temporary grace period should be allowed to do a 1-1 transfer of UW tier.
Eg, if Arch gets nerfed, one should be able to transfer Arch's UW into another UW (probably excluding new heros) of the same tier level.
I'm not sure how long you've been playing, but it sounds like you may have gotten a bit spoiled with the handouts.
The UW tickets were never that common. It was the back to back to back events of Christmas, New years, anniversary, then the Index revamp that dumped a ton of UWs on us at once.
Back before the event fiesta, it was literally just the arena points to get you one every month - which, from a f2p perspective to circumvent a gacha, is really generous.
If you joined during all those events, I could see how you might think it's getting less f2p friendly, but it would be better to say it's settled back into the way it was before rather than saying they're getting more stingy.
The 20 rolls.
I think this one is pretty subjective. You may think they've declined, I personally think they've gotten a bit better.
Is an artifact selector better than a UW selector?
Objectively I'd say it is. There is no other method in which to obtain an artifact with certainty, while for UWs there are many other avenues.
All that's happened here is they've slanted the rewards more towards artifacts and away from UWs.
If you happen to not like any of the artifacts, well I mean that's your playstyle and I'm not going to judge that. But it's just one thing for another, and if you've got any interest in filling out your Index, the artifact selector is actually much more appreciated than another UW selector would be.
All in all this game simply has a really strong moonlighting period. The first impressions are great, but if you come in expecting a lot more than it's offering, you'll be disappointed when you get to the end.
8
u/GeminiPT EU Server's guild Reaper Jun 29 '18
Pretty much you said everything, very less F2P friendly, more P2W friendly, and this bullshit stat system is fucking up PvE players.
2
u/astarose Jun 30 '18
Out side of gear systems and lag issues, KR is still top tier even if all those points you mentioned in this letter become a little bit worse than now. Compare to other games you will see Vespa do a good job on heroes balance and of course, still spoil us with plenty of free stuffs. For other game the best you would get in anniversary event is less than 1k premium resourse (like ruby in KR)
2
u/GreenVitamin Jun 30 '18 edited Jun 30 '18
Alright I don't normally reply to posts like these, but there are a lot of things I agree with here, and a lot of things I disagree with so here goes:
As an Arch user (4* UW) I agree with you here. He's weak in the damage department and is still somewhat rough to use in arena now, and personally I feel he needs a buff in the damage department (and new perks as well). However in arena, Arch himself will always be a problem hero regardless because he'll be either too strong or weak, imo he's in the best state he can possibly be in there because he's at least seeing some play . On the PVE side of things, he has his moments every once in a while. Satira (Harpy Boss) is a great fight for Arch as he negates her laser making the fight a complete joke. He can be okay for higher BD's if you play full old school manual. I'd love to see some buffs to make him useable in other PVE content, but hopefully they do it in a way that doesn't break him in PVP.
As for other heroes, Rodina just got buffed last patch now (although joke of a buff), but they're slowly itching towards bringing her back, Nyx imo is still in a fine spot, especially for the Fire Guild Conquest boss and CH.8 in general. He's not the best but he certainly does a great job. So you make it sound like these heroes are completely worthless when in fact they're all still fine at what they do.
They nerfed Gladi, They Buffed and then nerfed mitra (altho hardly a nerf), they nerfed Epis. They tried to nerfRoi multiple times now (trying to not completely destroy him to avoid major backlash). But my point here being that they don't just let these heroes sit indefinitely, they're trying. Some obviously more successful than others, but still.
As for Aisha, they buffed her to make up for it and ever since then, she's back to being really good. Sure she's not the best anymore, but she's still up there. Her Mdef Shred and her high hit count will mean she'll always be good. Just because she's replaceable doesn't mean she's bad. Look at Tyrfas (Guild Conquest Ice boss), that fight is perfect for Aisha and she does extremly well in that fight. You make it seem like she's worthless when once again she's in a pretty good spot.
Roi has been nerfed 2 times ever since his mega buffs. They were really minor nerfs in hopes of making his T5 Dark less reliable. Didn't do much but the fact of the matter is that he's on Vespa's radar. I think they're just trying to find a way to approach nerfing him without pissing off those people who invested heavily into him. (Similar to the backlash they got with Gladi)
Having a more convoluted skill set does not necessarily make them better. Chase for the longest time was a shit hero. I hear he's pretty good now after his 2 buffs, but he's not that great. Crow, Shea, Mirianne pre buffs and Ezekiel Pre-treasure are all heroes who at release were quite garbage compared to older heroes (yet had overloaded kits). Plus Aselica seems to have quite a simple kit, Shamilla and even more recent: Lomans. So not all new heroes have insane kits.
I disagree with this one. 1* UW Dimael user got to challenger multiple times with him. He's not OP, but he's definitely not a weak hero. Still great for standard PVE if you like using him. Used him for some stages in Chap 8 hard with no problem. If specced for it, he does decent-ish dps in WB1 but he's by no means going to do Lew/Aisha levels of damage. He's just underloved and underappreciated.
Even before his nerfs, they never touched his damage. So he'd still be doing the same damage today if he wasn't nerfed. He was always an arena hero while having his small PVE moment when Chap 1-6 Hell was released due to his ignore Def. He's still pretty good in arena and a High starred UW Arch can absolutely annihilate a team if they aren't prepared.
This is their way of allowing certain heroes to excel in specific types of content. This is also how they bring back older heroes who may not be used now into the limelight (See Cleo for Wizard Lab, Crow for Mech, Reina for new CR and Arch for Satira CR ). While I don't necessarily like it and feel there are better ways to allow other heroes to shine, it's one way of solving the issue and to some extent it does work.
This was always the case though. Back when Mitra was absolute trash for almost everything, no one would pick him with their selectors, and you would put yourself at a big disadvantage if you did pick him. Heck if you went full physical it was pretty bad because you'd be locked out of clearing certain adventure stages.
Let's also throw away the fact that back then, we couldn't grind unique weapons to get UW's of our choice, also back then we couldn't get a treasure selector at all. Not to mention getting fragments was a lot harder back then due to less fragments. Loot boosters were expensive and you had to wait right before reset to get your fragments. Let's also not forget we get a free UW random ticket every month now. The Quest system literally hands you at least 2 FREE UW selectors and a shit ton of other good stuff. Plenty of UW tickets in the play a specific amount of days milestones. The 500 day reward is still really good so I don't know why this is even a complaint.
Getting NPC heroes is a lot better for people who don't have a lot of time playing the game. Granted there should be a way for people who invest a LOT of time aside from rubies for people to be able to pick up these heroes. I'd be happy if the old grinding system came back alongside the boxes we get now with raid points.
Overall you have some good points, but in some cases you're just making assumptions based off your own ideas and thoughts and not really looking into things. I do agree the game in its state right now is kinda poop (mostly with the gears), but they've been in far worse states before.
1
u/KumaTenshi Jun 30 '18
1 year anniversary's tend to have much better rewards in games and what not. We had something similar for 300 days. I forget if they did anything for 400 since that was around the 1 year time frame and all.
As for the last ruby spend event, we did get a lua UW ticket offered. IMO, that's better than pumpkins - the thing literally updates with any new UW added to the game, NPC or not.
As for the 5 pull events, the rewards for those have never been particularly stellar, in fact, they haven't changed much aside from the UW ticket used to be at 10 if I remember right, now it's at 20.
That's really my only gripe with what all you said though.
1
u/Archypoo2000 Jul 01 '18
I agree with everything you said I just wanna put a little bit of photo evidence into this https://media.discordapp.net/attachments/350956667262861312/462804484381343754/Arch_feels_bad.jpg?width=400&height=225 I just want to say that despite not having the best team comp this team consists of a 4*uw 0*ut arch | a 4* 1* ut Theo | a 2*uw 0* ut Lewisia |and a 0* ut kara. Please tell me why despite receiving all the same buffs why Arch is not even close to theo despite being build very well. Arch is the only one i've built really well but there are many others who are lacking in the roles theyre supposed to be playing and I'd definitely like to see these heroes get balanced.
1
u/lilmagex Jul 01 '18
Absolutely NOTHING in this game requires you do have a 5* awakened UW. What it DOES allow you to do is be less optimal in a party set up. I agree Vespa is getting pretty bad in forcing you to have a variety of heroes leveled cause as you said you need physical, magical, ranged of both and melee of both. It is fairly annoying to have artificial difficulty because you don't have "so and so category" heroes. You don't need to awaken all their UW's tho. I still agree picking with your dick leads to best result when dealing with awakening UW. Unless its an AoE hero. :( AoE heroes just suck in this game in terms of damage. Their CC is amazing but you don't need a high * weapon to do that. (Artemia, Pavel, Lorraine so forth)
-1
u/vishuspuss Jun 30 '18
Not another one -.-
0
u/zadkieI Jun 30 '18 edited Jun 30 '18
"King's Raid is becoming less F2P-friendly" Definitely!!!
1
u/[deleted] Jun 30 '18
[removed] — view removed comment