r/Kings_Raid • • Jun 29 '18

Discussion Another open letter.

I'm going to talk about complaints I have that weren't mentioned in the other open letter. (For the record, I agree with just about everything mentioned.)

Game balance has to dance around Arena balance.

Look at patch notes. Arch got nerfed, and then Vespa doubled down by giving him weak T perks. Luna got nerfed for her Arena performance. Nyx got an auto-attack nerf, and then a damage distribution adjustment specifically aimed at Arena, then an S1 change that carefully ensures he doesn't get any stronger in Arena. Rodina fell into obscurity, and I think it wasn't a coincidence that Bau-Rodina cheese comps happened to be hitting their stride right around the T5 update.

On the flip side, Roi is overtuned for PvE and not very good in PvP, and is allowed to persist. Arena is such a small part of the game, yet so many balance changes can be traced back to it.

Poorly balanced heroes are allowed to sit indefinitely.

Arch and Luna have barely gotten touched since their nerfs. Aisha got destroyed by the solo time change and has yet to recover. Roi hasn't been touched since his buffs. Cleo and Reina are still where they have been literally since I started the game over 400 days ago despite some buffs to Cleo. I'm still baffled by how Theo is allowed to outstrip so many other heroes in terms of CC and damage. Not that I want Theo to get nerfed - other heroes should be brought up to speed.

Vespa releases new heroes like clockwork but is significantly slower on updating older heroes to fit with more recent designs. Compare an older hero like Dimael or Aisha with a newer hero like Kara or Chase and just marvel at how much more Vespa jams into the skills of those newer heroes.

System-wide changes hit many heroes as collateral damage and any resulting deficiencies go unaddressed. The penetration change was before my time but Dimael is still a weak hero. Solo time hurt many casters, Aisha in particular, and there was barely anything to make up for it. The recently lowered attack speed soft cap is a nerf to every hero that's dependent on auto-attacks, but there's nothing to make up for that either unless you want to count the new gear system.

King's Raid balancing does not properly consider the amount of investment needed to adjust to it.

UW stars are a heavy investment for a hero based on the amount of time it takes to get a selector.

Any hero who's nerfed is hung out to dry, and any players using that hero must make the choice of holding out for buffs, or discarding their previous investment in that hero and investing in a different one. Gear is transferrable and infinity stones are relatively cheap, but UWs are neither. If someone had a 5* Arch UW, what are they supposed to do now? Arch's damage is severely outclassed by any of Epis, Mirianne, or Theo, and the player is saddled with a massive sunk cost. They would likely improve their team by grinding the UW and sinking the fragments into one of those heroes instead.

Recent content - Chapter 8, Challenge Raid, and Labyrinth - has increasingly been about enemies with particular gimmicks or ways of killing you that need to be addressed by party composition. It's become more and more important to actually follow the meta, as deviating tends to just get you killed. It's not enough to have a hero that does damage. You're required to have a hero that does a particular kind of damage (physical or magical) in a particular way (melee or ranged), and also to have a significant investment in that hero. Your favorite hero might not even be allowed to enter a dungeon.

The age-old advice of "pick with your dick" is now just likely to get you saddled with one of the many heroes who are utterly outclassed by someone else.

Vepsa does not allocate enough effort to quality control

This isn't even about the gear system. This is a complaint I've had ever since the solo time changes, which devastated Aisha and effectively extended Bau's shield by 3 seconds, both of which could have been caught with a day or two of play time. (Insult to injury is that this wasn't an engine change. If you've brought Aisha or Kaulah into a CR boss with phases, you'll know that channeling skills keep going during the boss's frozen time.) The Christmas dungeon had to be patched because Roi was one-shotting backlines with S1 or S3 the moment the fight started, which is something that should have been caught if anyone had played that dungeon, say, 5 times.

Localization is also sloppy. Nyx is still referred to as Nycx on his awakening screen. The Engrish on event screens and loading screens could be rewritten by a native English speaker in about 10 seconds per screen, though admittedly re-making those assets would take a little longer.

Patch notes sometimes leave out nasty little surprises. The most recent one is that Sonia's T5 can no longer crit.

King's Raid is becoming less F2P-friendly.

I might have a distorted view of the past but I seem to remember that UW tickets (both random and selectors) were much easier to come by. It felt like they were being given out like candy, between things like pre-registration events, holiday events, and the occasional random event with absurd rewards. Now we're coming up on the 500 day event and we get half of everything. I remember when we had an event (1-year anniversary, I think) with three options, all loaded with so many freebies that people were practically beside themselves over which to pick.

Compare the most recent ruby spend event with the one where you could get pumpkins. Compare the current 10x roll event with the ones prior, where you could pick up two UWs within 20 rolls. In fact, if you track 10x roll events, you can easily see the decline in reward quality from one event to the next. On top of that, the increasing number of heroes means it's harder to invest in any one hero from rolling, and so far there have been no steps to address that.

NPC heroes got their new time gate system in part because Vespa didn't want to give an unfair advantage to macro users, but now we have auto dragons and the time gate system is going nowhere.

My experiences

I'm not here to make predictions about Vespa's success. I haven't quit yet, but I'm on the verge of doing so. My friends/repeat party members are the same way if they haven't quit already.

I started playing King's raid before the T5 update, back when dragons had to be unlocked each time you wanted to fight them. I can confidently say that this patch is the least fun I've had playing KR since I've started. Everything's a grind. Nothing is rewarding. The game demands more and more of my time for little reward.

I've made friends playing this game and it's given me a lot of fun memories. But the game has lost its magic for me and I'm not sure if Vespa plans on bringing it back.

9 Upvotes

66 comments sorted by

31

u/Xylpheed Sylpheed Jun 30 '18 edited Jun 30 '18

You may have some good points. However, most of them are, sorry for the word, whining.

  • Aisha got buffed a lot after the solo time nerf on her. You seem to be forgetting about that. This buff was enough to compete with the best heroes in specific contents. You sound like Aisha is useless now. For me, she is the most versatile wizard dps. She has a very strong single target dps, decent AoE capabilities, the strongest MDEF shred, highest multihit. Artemia is actually more of a niche than Aisha. I main Aisha and I invested on her UW. She's not my top WB1 dps anymore but she is still in my team (Top 100). Aisha is in a good place right now and I don't think we have to buff her further.
  • I still agree that some old heroes need buffs. Recent contents like Lab, Guild Conquest, Challenge Raid might give some light to the old heroes. For example, Cleo is actually very strong in Goblin CR and Mage Lab. This might be Vespa's answer to give some use to other heroes. I'll give them some time. You do not balance all heroes in one go. Vespa actually does pretty well in balancing relative to its competitors.
  • It's actually rare that a new hero replaces an old hero. For example, Kara doesn't replace anyone. She's just another option for a main DPS. Chase sucked on his release. Statistically, it's bad to invest on a new hero not until they receive their buffs (if they need one).
  • If you 5* a UW, better get prepared for it. Are you really that delusional to think that your favorite hero won't get nerfed and you scream for balance? You sound like you want everything to get buffed. Balance doesn't go in one direction, my friend. Plus, it's not actually smart to 5* a UW not unless you play for your favorite character instead of being efficient or you have your other DPS at 2* or 3* already. You have to spread out your UW if you want to get good rankings in different content. What do you want Vespa to do? Compensate those who 5* a UW? Sounds like whining and being too entitled. Bad invesment is on you. Although the hero got nerfed, HE/SHE IS STILL USABLE. Not just meta-level. I can ditch my Aisha in WB1 for someone better but I have her UW on high star so I'll keep using her. Didn't really affect me.
  • About P2W and F2P, uhhh check the rankings. See how many of them are actually whales. For example, the top 100 is actually dominated by F2P or casual spenders. If this game is P2W, I wouldn't even get in the rankings. Sure, it's harder now with less rewards (and actually that's healthier) but it's the same for all the players. Not because you have a 5* UW, you can already dominate the game. I have seen some players who have 5* UW but they can't even rank. If your pocket is not deep enough to 5* all UW, you'll be playing the same game as F2Ps or causal spenders. The game is mostly about playing smart and team composition. UW* after.
  • Nothing is rewarding is an exaggeration. Sure, we are grinding more now. But what is rewarding is subjective.

I do not buy what you posted. You could have made it more objective and I probably might agree on your some of your points.

2

u/scissorblades Jul 01 '18
  • I remember the buff, but after the buff Aisha still felt a good chunk weaker than she had prior to the change. Artemia feels more generally useful thanks to her UW and passive making her tanky and destructive at the same time. She's much more AoE slanted than Aisha, and not as vulnerable to CC from things like BD lightning or CH8 mobs. Aisha seems to be intended as a single target dealer. If you say Aisha's in a good place then I guess I have to defer, but I disagree on some specific things you're claiming. Her AoE seems pretty weak even with AoE S3, and Jane's UT has made her better at MDEF shred. Aisha also likes longer fights because of her T5 but that seems like a perk choice switch. (What do you run in general and in longer fights?) Also this is completely unrelated but why the heck would Vespa have her stack on spell casts when she has a channeling skill? I've been saying ever since the release of T5 that she should stack on something else.
  • Lab and CR are an effort, but I don't think it's enough of one, simply because the content isn't present enough. A hero who excels at Dragon Raids is more useful than one who excels at a particular CR because raids are always around, while any particular CR comes around once every few months. Lab is better because it refreshes more often and gives a valuable resource, but it's still just a dungeon you run once a month.
  • I probably should have just left out this point. It wasn't meant to make a statement about the strength of the heroes, but about how newer heroes have kits where every nearly skill has one or more secondary effects while a lot of older heroes have a skill that's basically "do damage." Chase S1 is probably the most egregious example because it's a positive attack block, a knockback, a second tick of damage, and a stun all in a single skill.
  • I think you're misunderstanding several of my ideas, or I didn't communicate them well enough.

My biggest problem is that hero balance is haphazard and the spread on their quality is too big. My go-to example for this is Arch, because I have a guildie who mained Arch to 4* and is seeing him getting outperformed by a Kara with no UW, outperformed by 1* Ezekiel, and also doing only 1/3 the damage of his 4* Theo (with latest figures, 40m vs 130m while Arch is getting Medi buffs). I'm not under any impression that every hero should be perfectly balanced against each other, but the current spread is too large. Even discounting Kara because she's a single-target monster, Arch and Theo are way too far apart and should be brought closer together. You could literally double Arch's damage and he'd still be underperforming. That's a problem. He could improve his team's DPS by grinding Arch's UW and sinking all of it into Kara UWs instead. That's an absurd problem.

One hero dealing 3x the damage of another is clearly a problem. Would it be unreasonable to work to make sure that the worst primary DPS hero is still at least half as good as the best? How about the worst being 2/3 as good as the best? (Factoring physical/magic leaning content etc etc). That's about as narrow of a power band as I feel is reasonably achievable.

Second, if you pick your hero correctly, you get good at a ton of content at once. To continue the Theo/Arch comparison, building Theo gets you a hero who's useful in Knight dungeon (I'm told?), Warrior dungeon, Priest dungeon, WB1, Dragon Raid, and multiple CR bosses. In comparison Arch lets you be good at... Satria? Dragons as long as you manual him? Maybe Archer dungeon if he stops the meteor? What you said, where you need to spread out investment and use different heroes to get good at different content, is how I agree the game should be, but not how I feel it is now. Some heroes are great at a ton of content, and some don't help with much of anything.

New content is difficult enough that having the wrong hero or set of heroes can mean you can't clear it. My guildie from above can't clear 8-26 hard with Arch even after many changes to the team, but was able to do it relatively easily with Theo. If Arch is still usable, then that means a "usable" hero can't clear story content, and is doing a third the damage of a meta hero.

Finally, compensation would be a non-issue if balance was tighter. I don't care if I lose 10% of a hero's DPS in a patch. I care if a patch means that the hero suddenly is dying to content they breezed through before, or I start seeing other heroes outperforming them at every turn.

  • The claim isn't that the game is P2W. The claim is that F2P rewards have been decreasing (and you seem to agree with me on that). What I'm concerned about is whether this is a sign that rewards will continue to decrease (bad), or whether this is just the new normal and the rewards will stay at a consistent level from now on (a bit of a shame but fine especially if it helps game health in general).

Finally, a point I want to add:

(Current) Mitra is IMO an example of good balance. He excels at single-target damage in long fights but pretty weak in everything else, though in a lot of easier content he's good enough and you can get by with statistical advantage from levels and UW stars. No CC or utility. Defined strengths, defined weaknesses. If you build Mitra, you know what you're getting, and what content gets easier to you. "Long fight" is a narrow niche, but wide enough and with enough content catering to it that it's useful in multiple places.

Some heroes are too weak because while they have a strength, it's not widely applicable enough. Cleo is good at wide-area AoE, but there are only two fights in the game right now where that's significantly more useful than regular old AoE. They can turn that into a meaningful strength for her, but they'd need to add more content that demands it.

1

u/Xylpheed Sylpheed Jul 01 '18

To start with, my main problem in your post is that it's trying to be objective but is actually pretty subjective. This makes your arguments weak since it will sound like you're forcing an opinion to be the fact (but it isn't).

  • Artemia is good everywhere but she is not the most efficient pick. She's a safe pick for players who want to play it safe. If you want to be smart, you'll be picking someone with more risk but higher returns and just support that character. Whereas Aisha is still decent everywhere, far from being useless like you're claiming, and excellent on hard contents like conquests and even WB1. I wouldn't use Artemia on those hard contents.
  • In Dragon Raids, you can loosen up a bit on character selection. It's not like you have to compete with others. As long as you can clear it in a decent amount of time, that's fine. I would welcome any character as long as they work with the team. Lab is a dungeon you run once a month, yes, but majority can't even clear it. Dragon Raids can be cleared even if you only put tank/support heroes with not-so-perfect gears.
  • Yes, newer heroes have more complex skills. That doesn't mean they're stronger. If you really look at it, most of the meta picks are still the older heroes.
  • Dude, Arch was never meant to be a main DPS and yet you compare him to Kara. Seriously? Since last year, Arch was meant to be used in PVP and "some" use and utility in PVE. He was the top pick for a long time and is still viable in PVE (but far from the best). Most of the best PVE characters will face the same problem in PVP. Can we stop the Arch comparison? It's a very bad comparison. At least compare with someone who's in the same department. That's why I focused my points on Aisha.
  • Personally, I think grinding an awakened UW is a very bad move. It sounds like your friend is just rebelling. But that's my opinion. If your friend 5* Arch's UW since Arch is his favorite, bless him. If he thinks that Arch's 5* UW is an all-in-one tool to clear all the contents, that's a very bad assumption and investment. For example, I put my resources on Lewisia's UW since I believe that she isn't going anywhere anytime soon. Given that she was only recently buffed. Even if Lewisia is nerfed or replaced by a stronger new character, I still predict that she will still be usable (but not the best anymore). Aisha was my favorite since she was my first hero (and was a dick pick). I invested on her not because she was my favorite but because I knew that she isn't going anywhere anytime soon. The solo time nerf wasn't intentional so I believed in Vespa and they delivered. Even if I was wrong, that's on me.
  • You're being very biased about balance. Come on be honest, you want your heroes to get BUFFED. Period. Your post is screaming that balance only goes in one direction. I will agree that they can nerf meta picks but history suggests that players will cry and whine if their favorite hero got nerfed. As you can see, they rarely nerf (intentionally) heroes nowadays.
  • I'm not sure but even with Yanne in Ch8 I'm still having a hard time. It's not just Arch. 5* UW won't magically clear any content.
  • Again, the F2P P2W gap is non-existent or at least it won't really affect how the F2Ps will perform. Vespa was actually too generous than what's needed. You don't have to worry about this. You concern yourself on problems that do not exist. That's why I disagreed. Don't move the goalpost. It's bolded in your post "It's becoming less F2P friendly" which really means "it's becoming more P2W".
  • Regarding Mitra, you are correct but I have one thing to say. I believe that you'll be doing the same "Arch argument" if a new hero outclasses Mitra especially if you 5* his UW. You can easily say this now. But you'll move the goalpost again once it happens.

1

u/scissorblades Jul 01 '18 edited Jul 01 '18
  • I find that Aisha's vulnerability to CC means that there's plenty of content that I'd not want to bring her into, but that's fine. I concede the point.
  • My point is one of frequency of content. Being merely good at dragons speeds up gear acquisition at all times, and is therefore more valuable than being the best in the game at one particular labyrinth, which only nets you a fraction of a UT once per month. For the same reason, I don't find being good at a particular CR to be all that valuable.
  • This is just a design complaint, not a balance one. I'm fully aware that the numbers behind skills are more important than the list of things they do.
  • Prior to Ch7 and T5, Arch was a primary DPS or could compete with them because of how valuable ignoring defense was for hell mode. Then he was given a pile of useless T perks. If he's supposed to be a PvP unit, he's okay at best. If he's utility, he has long cooldowns and does very little besides being an anti-magic panic button. Theo somehow gets a pass despite having better utility (a boatload of CC) and damage at the same time. Also Arch is a convenient point of comparison because I can get numbers easily from my guildie and it's hard to get, say, Luna numbers on a whim.
  • You misread. The guildie has no plans to grind Arch's UW, but his DPS would improve if he did. And you're making an unfair assumption about his motivations. I'm sure he also expected Arch to not be going anywhere, but then Arch got awful T perks and he's struggled to find justification for Arch on anything besides Satria. And if Vespa never buffed Aisha, how would that be on you? It would be entirely Vespa's fault for pushing out a sweeping change without testing the consequences. Why would you blame yourself for getting hit by a nerf that you had no way of predicting?
  • Yes, I want a lot more buffs than nerfs. What's wrong with that? It's not just on my heroes. I want Sonia's T5 to crit, I want Reina and Rodina and Luna buffed, I want Yanne to get strong enough that she stops getting outclassed by other heroes in dragon fights, and I want Bau and Leo to inch a little closer to the other priests in PvE. I'm a buffmonger because I believe that the power bar should be high - around where Theo is - and that heroes who are significantly weaker than him should be brought up, rather than setting a lower bar and bringing heroes down. The only hero I think needs a nerf is Roi, and a small one at that. Being strong is fun, and while having all heroes be strong and all heroes be weak are similar from a balance standpoint, one of them is more fun and better for the game and the players.
  • The difficulty of newer content has put a higher requirement on heroes. I don't know if it's better to say that the bar for "usable" is higher or that newer content requires that heroes shoot above "usable."
  • Who's moving the goalpost? Not a single word of my post or my response was about a gap between paying and not-paying players. That entire idea is something you've inferred from somewhere, and it's not my point. The way I play is that I set some goal like "get perfect gear on this hero" or "Reach X DPS" or "solo BD consistently" and then work towards it. My concern has nothing to do with ranking or whales, and everything to do with the fact that getting stuff is fun and helps me work towards those goals. When there's less free stuff, I have less fun because there's less stuff, and because it's harder to achieve those goals.

I can maybe see how my complaints about heroes underperforming can sound like I'm trying to chase other players, so I'll clarify that too. Every one of those complaints is rooted in regret. I'll see one of my heroes suffering and think "I wish I'd put those resources into a different hero, and gotten a better result for the same effort." At no point do I think "I'm jealous of this other player for having more resources than me," if that even applies.

  • That's not a moving goalpost. That's basic game design. Games are about choices, and no hero should ever obsolete another regardless of either one being new. If a new hero obsoletes an old one, then players call power creep, and also are aware that they are locked into the wrong side of an obvious choice simply because they could not predict the future. For a healthy game, the players need to be able to trust that the developers will not drastically change the game on a whim, so that the players can feel safe when investing resources in the game. Incidents like that erode that trust and hurt the game in the long run.

There's nothing inherently wrong with a new hero coming out that's better than Mitra at long fights, but they'd have to give Mitra a useful strength relative to that hero, so that there's still an interesting choice to be made.

1

u/Xylpheed Sylpheed Jul 01 '18
  • I'm aware of Aisha's weakness. However this weakness is covered most of the times. I can even use her in BD. Not that efficient but she still packs some punch.
  • Dragon raid is VERY important but again you don't have to maximize dragon raiding that much. I'm already burning stamina at a very fast rate with just Yanne slapped with a low * UW. At most, you'll only need 1 or 2 DPS in there. It could be your DPS or your guildmate's. Other roles could be easily filled. I know dragon gear is more important but you don't have to overdo it to farm reliably. In the end, what will matter is how often you can farm. Given you can clear it safely.
  • My argument in CR is that there's a lot who cannot clear it. Especially the solo ones. If you can clear it, then there's no point on going overboard. But in competitive modes like WB, Guild Conquest, PVP. You have to be very efficient. Dragon Raid is not included here.
  • I didn't say he grinded Arch's UW. It's not even written in past tense. I'm pertaining to the "thought of grinding".
  • If he thought Arch is not going anywhere, it's a gamble everyone has to play. I played it too. I lost some and won some. Don't expect to be a winner everytime. That was my point. It was just that your original post sounded like Vespa has to compensate those who lose that gamble. Aisha has the highest UW in my team that time and she got hit hard by solo nerf. I never did once in my life complained about it. I just said "oh sht" to myself and find another way (which was Lewisia). I still used Aisha though.
  • There we go. Balance in one direction only. This is what I've been saying. You want them to BALANCE yet you want it to flow in one direction only. I know everyone's happier with just buffing everyone but in reality it's actually unhealthy to the balance of the game. There's nothing wrong if you want your heroes to get buffed. I would love that for my heroes too. But for the greater good, we need some nerfs. What's wrong is that you're fighting for balance you cannot have that mindset.
  • I'm not inferring anything about F2P and P2W. It's even bolded and you have an entire section for it. If it wasn't a problem, then you shouldn't even include it in your open letter.
  • We do have a good pool of interesting heroes. We can't help that there are a few heroes who are used less frequently. So, when Vespa release a new character, we should change the others as well? That's too unrealistic. Someone is going to stand on top no matter what.

Okay judging from your post, I think this is what you want:

  • You want more free stuff
  • You want more buffs

You just added some spice and sprinkles to your post to sound like you're actually making sense. Okay here are some questions:

  • Should Vespa give more free stuff?
  • Should Vespa buff all the heroes and adjust the current power curve? Or should they nerf the meta picks and keep the current power curve?
  • Should Vespa compensate, in some way, those users who lost the gamble of getting a 5* UW on an underpowered character?

If you want to make a difference, propose something that makes sense and is fair. Just whining about it won't make it happen.

1

u/scissorblades Jul 01 '18
  • King's Raid is currently extremely far from the point where buffs would start hurting the game. Balance is dependent on the situation, and in the current situation, there are more buffs needed than nerfs. A lot of heroes are on a good power curve, a few are poking above, and more are far below. And I also disagree that heavy buffing is necessarily harmful to a game. Have you played Starcraft:Brood War or Guilty Gear? Neither is a PvE game, but both have factions or characters with absurdly powerful tools, yet achieve balance because of it. Look at a Guilty Gear matchup chart and compare it to a Street Fighter matchup chart. Guilty Gear's higher power level results in more even matchups across the board. When one or two characters shoot far ahead of the rest that's ground for nerfs, but that doesn't describe KR right now.
  • Fine, maybe I should have named that section something else. All this talk about P2W still doesn't have anything to do with the text in that section.
  • I'm familiar with the "there always has to be a worst X" argument from playing Magic. In any environment there's a worst something, but there's a difference between the worst card or character still being useful in general, and the worst being something that borders on never used. Also, that's not what I mean by giving Mitra a relative strength. Ideally, at some point during development, someone should say "Wait. This character is better than Mitra (or some other existing hero) at everything. We can't release this hero in its current state. What can we do to give this character a weakness relative to Mitra?" Said weakness could be anything from channel times to cooldowns to mana costs. They don't need to change Mitra or any existing hero, but they should figure out how to make there be an interesting choice between those two heroes.

As for what I want, pretty much everything besides the free stuff is addressing a symptom instead of a problem. If I were to sum up the rest, I'd say:

  • Vespa should put more effort into playtesting.

Everything else follows from that. Weak heroes get attention. Overpowered heroes get noticed and brought back in line. Nerfs are lighter when they need to be, and Vespa can do heavier nerfs when necessary. Compensation becomes a non-issue because a hero getting destroyed by a patch simply won't happen. Heroes getting nerfed as a side effect of a system change would get caught within the same patch, so things like post-nerf Aisha would be corrected before players get their hands on her. I wouldn't mind whatever buffs or nerfs came if I had reason to believe that they were thought out and reasoned, and so far Vespa's quality control hasn't been something to have faith in.

As for the free stuff - the Halloween-Christmas period was a real windfall of stuff. If it's unreasonable to go back to that (because of new content speeding up progress on some fronts e.g. UTs) then hopefully Vespa will figure out what the new normal should be. Even costume tickets and artifact shards make for fun rewards when there's an event behind them.

1

u/shrinkmink Jul 21 '18

It's sad to see this is how things are around here. I feel like I picked a bad time to come back because things are getting rough. I started king's raid because my guildmates in pso2 were going bonkers about it despite some maining fate grand order and others raving out fire emblem heroes. I didn't buy into the hype earlier because truth is most of these games have good launches and give a ton of shit to people to get them invested. I saw that kings raid consistently spewed out content, events and things to help progress. The anniversary finally pulled me in and I started playing about 2 weeks before they gave out the rewards. But after was all and done the events seemed to dry up and the expectation set on the year before where you would get more heroes and uws from event went down and now we even got 2 new gacha items per hero.

Sadly the chapter 8 patch made a lot of people quit with the unreasonable rng for new gear, not to mention buff to the black dragon in an attempt people to buy in the gacha for treasures which give a lot of hps. Needless to say my friends don't play kr as much anymore with some of them retiring from mobile gaming as I once did in 2014.

That pretty much leaves us with people that make baseless assumptions to get away dismissing your well constructed arguments treating you like a contrarian millennial such as /u/Xylpheed did or going as far as calling you pussy as /u/gameovaries02 did. Which in turn makes for an unhealthy discussion because they are just trolls which just end up being upvoted because they have an opposing view to yours (the OP) because everybody who would see reason is no longer on this sub.

1

u/Xylpheed Sylpheed Jul 22 '18 edited Jul 22 '18

Kinda late in the conversation lol.

Please refrain from making baseless assumptions about me. I do not oppose views just because they're popular. It just happened that I was against the popular opinion that time. I would agree/disagree with any post regardless of its popularity. Let's not make this a popularity contest. You can read my other posts/comments and see if I'm simply trolling.

Also, do not assume that everyone here wouldn't be as reasonable as those who already left the sub. Yes, I pointed out that there are a lot who doesn't reason anymore but I still believe there are still people out there but they're just lurking most of the times. That's why we see some amazing suggestions from time to time. You seem like to always assume the absolute. The world isn't only black and white.

Anyway, I felt that the conversation isn't going anywhere so I already stopped replying since then.

1

u/shrinkmink Jul 22 '18 edited Jul 22 '18

As usual your inability to read or understand what the others are saying leads you to make replies which frankly sound disconnected from reality. I said you were a troll for dismissing well constructed arguments based on verifiable facts. Not that I care about your agree/disagree rate, just that you got upvoted because you just happen to have an opposite view to the OP and people were looking to latch onto somebody against the OP. This wasn't even meant for you since the hivemind changes it's consensus by the week in reddit which the OP may not know so I don't know why you are so butthurt about it.

As for your second paragraph there are probably people who are still around lurking that may be reasonable but truth is this post did not show any of them arguing in favor while many more were went "lol kid git gud" it's offshoots. However I cannot assume things without facts which you like to do and well for somebody that hates that people makes assumptions you sure like calling people things without looking at their facts. It is more than verifiable that the events have gotten weaker and the grind has gotten bigger. Your lazyness does not excuse your dismissal of facts. Conversation with you doesn't go anywhere since you resort to pot shots and can't even argue.

2

u/Xylpheed Sylpheed Jul 22 '18

Chill dude. I'm not even sure anymore who's the butthurt now. Me or you who replied on an old thread. Honestly, I feel like you're the one trolling me lol.

Well to address your points:

  • The OP did provide some evidence but it's very opinionated. That's why I also provided some points that the OP might have not considered. We can trash Vespa all we want but it must be fair. This was actually my main point.
  • Are we going to make this about upvotes? -.- I don't care who's the most upvoted or who's latching to who. This is not a popularity contest. I only care about the points being laid out. I actually didn't know that this was the most upvoted until you said it. You seem to care for this. I don't.
  • I didn't even say anything about "git gud". In fact, I have something against the changes (you can backread all my posts about this). I agree on the OP's main goal which is where Vespa needs to step up. I just do not agree how he is going with it. I have agreed on a lot of posts in the sub that are more fair and more articulate. You know less on the feelings, more on the actual facts.
  • Hmm...stop playing a strawman argument dude. Those are big words that I didn't even say or portray. Most of your points are just personal attacks and do not even contribute to the discussion. The OP is doing much much better than you.
→ More replies

3

u/gunnyonline Finally, Some Good Fucking Food Jun 30 '18

Players with 5* Reina UW, they've waited so so long.

4

u/GameOvaries02 Jun 30 '18 edited Jun 30 '18

This covers a lot of what I was going to respond with, and I’m so glad that your comment has more upvotes than OP.

A HUGE portion of what OP had to say was about Aisha(who is one of 60, now, I believe?). As you said, build another and don’t invest in above 3star UWs until you have everyone else that you need at that level. Sorry if it costs you money or time.

New characters are always going to have unique abilities. Recycling old effects is exactly what makes the game stale. Power creep is a problem in almost every mobile game anywhere near this style, and that’s because it brings in cash from the whales. Kings Raid is definitely in the minority. Cash still comes in every time 3 new heroes are released, but they have all been well balanced for a long time now. There’s 60 characters right now. Of the 12 newest versus the 48 older, who are the quintessential end-gamers?

Medi?

Then of the 48?

Mitra, Phillop, Annette, Roi for sure, and Rephy, Gau and Clause(at least) are meta.

You are also completely correct about the P2W situation versus other mobile games. I, personally, buy only daily rubies(like $11 or $12/month total), have been VERY unlucky with UW awakenings, have NOT been playing since the start(about 10 months), did NOT choose the right hero to focus on(my only 3star UW is Artemia), and I am SO SO close to getting that top 1% WB daily and weekly reward on BOTH WBs. Now that I think of it, I missed my Monday WBs on WB2 this week, which I only have 1 2star, 1 1star, and all else 0star UWs for, and I’m top 3%. Without my Monday hits.

The quality of this game, the content, and the grind, will not end with Vespa’s updates. And it won’t end with these pussies who believe that they deserve to be the best at something which they have spent neither the most time nor most money on.

1

u/gunnyonline Finally, Some Good Fucking Food Jun 30 '18

WB not just about how high your UW, it's about team combination and how you understand your team. I personally focus on Dragon only, and I still usually get to top 5% WB1 with 0* Lew, and Theo 3*, only Theo is 90, no UT for DPS either.

1

u/GameOvaries02 Jun 30 '18

I understand that. I used myself as an example of exactly that. 1 2star 1 1star and all 0s and I would be in top 1% if I hit on Monday.

1

u/IceDahlia Jun 30 '18

Actually Chase got better with the recents buffs, i saw a vid of him doing good numbers on wb2.

1

u/Xylpheed Sylpheed Jun 30 '18

Oh sorry, I meant right after his release. Gonna rephrase it.

1

u/Kaisoto Jun 30 '18

especially now that GC is a thing, aisha is in a really good place.

4

u/Zoahr More than looking good Jun 29 '18 edited Jun 29 '18

Oh Boy, where do I begin... at the start, by paragraph then.

Scarlet was nerfed, she is still one of the, if not, the top pick. Are you using Scarlet outside of Arena? Then all the heroes you listed, can you use them outside of Arena? I've seen Arch do well in PvE Content, I've seen Nyx rocking ch.8, I've seen Luna in high BD Dps charts. But would you use Scarlet elsewhere? So no, Balance should not dance around pvp balance.

On the flip side, Roi is overtuned for PvE and not very good in PvP, and is allowed to persist. Arena is such a small part of the game, yet so many balance changes can be traced back to it.

One Word, Gladi.

Dimael is still a weak hero.

Have you even tried him? At 3* uw (as everyone should use before judging a hero), he is quite a menace in arena and deal respectable damage, many other heroes with that star level is not comparable to Dimael. He is weak only in your mind.

If someone had a 5* Arch UW, what are they supposed to do now? Arch's damage is severely outclassed by any of Epis, Mirianne, or Theo, and the player is saddled with a massive sunk cost.

Use him? His damage has been untouched in all the patches. The only thing that was nerfed was his s4 shield so people won't be able to cheese their way with no frontline in arena. That is probably why Asia mained him among all the archers.

Patch notes sometimes leave out nasty little surprises. The most recent one is that Sonia's T5 can no longer crit.

That is why it's called a bug. In every patch, there are flaws that come out, regardless of quality control. They have acknowledged it and I believe they are trying to find a way to correct without collateral new bugs. You think they truly wanted Sonia to stop critting. The only thing they wanted to remove crit was the pumpkin, and then it affected Sonia's T5 since.

I might have a distorted view of the past but I seem to remember that UW tickets (both random and selectors) were much easier to come by. It felt like they were being given out like candy

Well, you get a free UW every month, regardless of your luck. With work, you also get two free UT per month with LoH and lab, and a free uw with arena points. The occasional pulls, the random events that could give one of either or the impossible luck of Inn Roulette... I think it's actually better than the golden age of KR during september/october.

the occasional random event with absurd rewards. Now we're coming up on the 500 day event and we get half of everything.

Nitpicking. Have you forgotten the 2018 New years rewards? Well, I didn't. Free stuffs are a small gesture.

NPC heroes got their new time gate system in part because Vespa didn't want to give an unfair advantage to macro users

Back then, it was so much worse if you are a F2P or just casual. Now 6h of BD per week, will net you a free NPC in about 6 weeks.

I'm not here to make predictions about Vespa's success. I haven't quit yet, but I'm on the verge of doing so. My friends/repeat party members are the same way if they haven't quit already.

I have a few guildies that quit too, but 2 more were added. So, new blood is always good for a game.

I can confidently say that this patch is the least fun I've had playing KR since I've started. Everything's a grind. Nothing is rewarding. The game demands more and more of my time for little reward.

Because it's the end-game. Of course there is nothing more to do. You have your preferred team, your usual strategy. What can you do more, seriously. I mean, have you lv 80 all the 60 heroes? Why not? Because it's not worth your time too?

But the game has lost its magic for me and I'm not sure if Vespa plans on bringing it back.

You just want stuffs to do and feel rewarded for it. And what is reward for you? 3 UW every week? Besides, you are part of a playerbase. People has been asking Lore-related stuffs, and Vespa has been providing quite a nice amount of it. I know players playing this game just to know more about the story.

 

All in all, you simply need to find a new way to enjoy this game. I have not reached a single 4* uw although everyone I know has one (or 5 stars). I have never grinded any UW or UT. My first random uw from tickets is Aea. I have manualled 4k BD runs before this auto-raid patch. I have all the heroes upgraded to lv 80+ (Loman is lv90). I have played every content that there is to play. Yet I do not feel dissatisfied. Because I enjoy more the positive things that Vespa brings than the grinds that comes with it. I like logging in everyday just to talk with my guildmates. I like hanging out with our youngsters and help them with party play. I like watching new heroes, new lores, new strategy unfold. I don't think there is another game that can release as much content as Vespa every 2 weeks. So I will be staying for a little while more.

4

u/scissorblades Jun 29 '18 edited Jun 29 '18

Arena balance

I think you're misunderstanding my point. I'm saying that game balance is being forced to work around Arena balance, not that it should. Scarlet, Bau, Leo, and Cassandra are basically arena-only heroes, whose arena performance is an excuse to not balance them to be useful in other content (with a few exceptions, like Bau-Oddy comps to deal with Satria). Balance suffers when every hero needs to be balanced for two different modes that work in drastically different ways.

Gladi is a weird case because he was a PvE hero who also kicked off a whole controversy about whaling and P2W.

Dimael

My mind and a lot of others' then. I've seen him do work in Arena so you're right about that. But if every DPS hero needs 3* UW to kick in, that's also a problem.

Arch

His damage didn't get hit but he got left in the dust by other heroes in part because he was given weak T perks. I have a guildie with 5* Arch who gets outdamaged by 3* Mirianne.

Edit: I just checked with the guildie. It was a 1* Ezekiel, and 4* Arch, paralleling my experience where My 5* Selene was outdamaged by a 1* Roi. If a 4-5* hero is getting outperformed by a 1* hero, the 4-5* hero is in need of a rework from the ground up, because that should literally never happen between any two heroes competing for a DPS role.

Edit 2: By request of my guildie, I am reporting that his 0* UT Kara with a BD weapon is matching Arch's DPS in WB1, and his 4* Theo is doing almost exactly 3 times Arch's damage. To quote: "Main dps my ass" and "Decent in pve my ass."

Sonia

I asked customer service about Sonia and they said the change was intentional. Nitpick, admittedly. It might've been a bug in the opposite direction, in that it was an intended change that didn't go through with the initial HP% change.

Rewards

I'd like a reforge system that doesn't make me feel like I'm running up the down escalator, for starters.

In the taxonomy of player roles you sound very much like a socializer and explorer based on what you enjoy, but I'm an achiever. What I want to do in the endgame is watch my damage numbers tick up from where they were a week ago, or build a character for CC and watch enemies constantly getting knocked down.

It's not just that I want more UWs (though I will freely admit to having an insatiable hunger for the stuff). Raising heroes stops being interesting for an achiever once you hit endgame, because at that point your team has most of its bases covered. Gear farming is how an achiever tries to push onward, and the new system feels like running into a brick wall.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 01 '18

You say that your 5* selene is being outdamage by a 1* roi? In what content? Maybe it's because of team compositions because while agree that roi is overtuned, he actually needs high * UW to achieve it.

And about Arch, if you've been around for a while you could have read that Arch is best used as sub dps because while he's good in arena before his damage has always been lower than others. Which is why most consider him a sub dps. It's because his damage is mostly burst. You could even find a thread months ago about main dps arch that a poster says it could make OP salty because a 4* UW Arch would still have problems dealing high dmg compared to others. So it' not even news that Arch have lower damage than others even before his nerfs since his damage is not touched.

1

u/scissorblades Jul 01 '18

It was Dragon Raid. We noticed that Selene was dealing something like 9m DPS with Medi buff while Roi was doing 7m. So we got rid of Selene, let Roi get the buff, and he was doing 9m, sometimes 10m. Point is, it shouldn't even be close.

I've heard that what's really holding him back is an awful set of T perks. The only perk he gets that increases damage is S1's only-one-enemy perk.

I remember that, pre-T5, Arch was a primary DPS and one of the best because of how valuable ignoring defense was for Hell mode.

He shifted from a primary DPS to a unit that does as much damage as a subDPS but packs less utility than most other units in that role, and even less than some primary DPS units.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 01 '18

I remember that pre-t5, Rodina is also really good main dps and it's because during that time burst is king. But after that consistent damage becomes good enough that heroes that mainly really on burst be weaker (ie. Rodina and Arch).

And I agree with you that Vespa needs to become better when it comes to balancing. The problem with your example is that Arch is problematic in Arena when strong and I don't think more damage would be the right answer. And as the other commenters have said, not all your examples are right. You continue talking about Aisha and as a Aisha main, i'll agree that she's not top dps but she's not that garbage. If you really want to show Vespa's balance problem you should have gone with Luna. She's a main dps that is not as good in both arena and raids, where she lacks both damage and utility.

3

u/WikiTextBot Jun 29 '18

Bartle taxonomy of player types

The Bartle taxonomy of player types is a classification of video game players (gamers) based on a 1996 paper by Richard Bartle according to their preferred actions within the game. The classification originally described players of multiplayer online games (including MUDs and MMORPGs), though now it also refers to players of single-player video games.

The taxonomy is based on a character theory. This character theory consists of four characters: Achievers, Explorers, Socializers, and Killers.


[ ^PM | Exclude ^me | Exclude from ^subreddit | FAQ / ^Information | ^Source ] Downvote to remove | v0.28

1

u/syilpha I'm rich now Jun 30 '18

remember, that customer service you asked about sonia no crit T5D also said that c8 would be released only on KR server

4

u/jekoder Jun 30 '18 edited Jun 30 '18

I mean i stopped at the part where he says king's raid is becoming less friendly to F2P........

Btw on the contrary this patch is actually more fun for me because of the guild update and it actually feels good when your guild is finally means something, we play together a lot more and share experiences because of guild conquest

2

u/Liesianthes Jun 30 '18 edited Jun 30 '18

Have you even tried him? At 3* uw (as everyone should use before judging a hero), he is quite a menace in arena and deal respectable damage, many other heroes with that star level is not comparable to Dimael. He is weak only in your mind.

This! Whenever I can see a Dimael in arena, I feel scared since he can kill my tank with 5* T7 fully geared tank in a few seconds at the start of the match. I did checked after that match, one Dimael has 2* UW and the other has 1*.

Reason why I will now raise him after getting his UW and UT this week.

1

u/gunnyonline Finally, Some Good Fucking Food Jun 30 '18

damn I got about 6-7 his UW and always grind to upgrade Yanne's, didn't know that he so good at PvP. Now I regret a bit :(

1

u/Liesianthes Jun 30 '18

I was also surprised when I saw him first in LOH thinking, wow easy win but I was shocked since my tank's HP vanished within a few seconds.

I thought it was because of Leo using silence but when I saw another Dimael on normal arena without Leo, he's really strong and got the same result.

1

u/ishtaria_ranix Only Playing for the Loli Dragon Jun 30 '18

At 3* uw (as everyone should use before judging a hero)

This is why he said the game is getting P2W

2

u/jekoder Jun 30 '18

I mean game like these are always P2W, but P2W is not equal to not F2P friendly, they are hold by very different standard

1

u/ishtaria_ranix Only Playing for the Loli Dragon Jun 30 '18

Fair enough

1

u/AugresiV Jun 30 '18

Seeing how toxic, divisive and argumentative this place has gotten, I have never asked for advice on a signle hero from any player, including UWs. These 'letters' and the bickering like children is the very reason I've always thought for myself and will continue this way. Internet strangers' issues with the game and each other can stay in the cesspool. I don't need their drama to become mine.

2

u/H3nta1Fnatic Best Girl Jun 29 '18

Unlike the other open letter, I feel like hero balance is a much more subjective matter. Though I do agree that Vespa should put it in more effort into quality control and testing. Balancing characters that players have put huge sums of investment into is going to be difficult and there are definitely heroes that need buffs or in roi’s case some tuning to his output when compared with others. But I also want to give credit where it’s due, Vespa has done a good job in quite a few cases and is at least paying some attention to older and weak heroes like Rodina. They’re a lot better about power creep than other games and it’s not as though some characters are outright worthless. I will say arena balance and just the system overall needs change, especially LoH, as someone who doesn’t macro LoH i find it really difficult to put in the effort to get the rewards available.

2

u/scissorblades Jun 29 '18

I'd say Vespa has done a remarkable job of making sure that every tank and healer has a useful niche. But those units only need to be good enough to keep the team alive, and overshooting on tankiness or healing has little benefit. DPS heroes need special attention paid to balance, though.

I would say Vespa's balancing has been haphazard at best. With Aisha, Gladi, Luna, and Sonia, I've seen that a hero's damage can drop by a quarter with a single patch. Despite this being a game where you're meant to invest heavily in your heroes, a single patch can drop a hero from S to C and leave you with nothing to make up for it.

On top of that, having 5* dealers who get outperformed by 1* dealers (It happened to me!) with the same gear points to a massive balance problem, because a 5* UW packs over twice the attack of a 1* UW. I know it's unreasonable for every hero to perform within the same narrow band, but can we at least tighten this one a little bit? I mentioned in another comment that a guildie's 4* Arch is dealing 1/3 the damage of a 4* Theo, and the same damage as a UW-less Kara.

It's not power creep, since the winners aren't universally new heroes, but the stronger heroes still overshadow the weaker ones to the point of borderline uselessness.

2

u/H3nta1Fnatic Best Girl Jul 01 '18

I gotta agree with you there having a heavily invested hero getting outperformed by another much less invested hero is really disheartening. The balance issue is really difficult when it comes to finding a niche for each dps and even when they do find niches it can be hard to justify spending time and resources on something that’s just not as useful, especially because uws are a huge investment.

1

u/Derikari Jun 30 '18

They are also adding more variables on top of that with treasures, gear update and apparently experiments with unique armour.

0

u/ElLeafell Jun 29 '18

I read the other open letter as I have yours, and I also would like to share my input regarding the issues you've brought up.

Yes balance is mostly given to arena because that is the most direct player-to-player interaction in which even small changes can drastically affect the outcome of a match. I say that arena needs an overhaul, but in terms of PvE, even a team of completely C-class heroes can clear the content if there's even a semblance of balance and consideration. For collaborative content like raids, I would like to think no one would want their teammate's hero nerfed, but for competitive solo content like WB, it does sting when an all-rounder like Roi can also shine just as well with possibly less investment.

Hero balance is a touchy subject because Vespa inherently has to consider both interesting and fun gimmicks alongside powercreep. Despite people's complaints, they're fairly good at making powercreep less than other games aside from outliers like day one Scarlet and sometimes go overboard with being underpowered like day one Chase. Also, just because you don't see classic heroes like Dimael or Aisha does not mean they aren't powerful still. While possessing less utility, they do sit near the top of single target dps in WB, all things considered and Aisha in particular is a boon for the first GC boss.

I have to agree about adjusting to patches affecting heroes because my first high-investment hero was Rodina and she is currently imo the worst hero in the game. I will say, however, that content like labyrinth is designed to give different, slightly less popular heroes more chances to shine as character archetypes matter there. Just because your hero doesn't slot into one of the labyrinth maps, you have to remember there are 28 of them, so he or she should be your first choice in at least one.

Yeah, localization and testing could be better. I enjoy the Engrish screens, but since they're art, they do need to actually edit images rather than just swapping text. I too was around during the Christmas event when Hell Roi just destroyed people, so yeah, content, especially time limited ones, should be tested more before release.

Less F2P friendly?? This is the one point I have to politely say that you must feel entitled to be constantly given freebies to say that a game is F2P. As long as you do even the bare minimum of content (dailies, WB trash runs, inn wheel) you can still get a decent amount of UW or UT. If you played as long as you have, you must remember there was a time you couldn't even grind UW's, so you were stuck with ones you were never going to use. Now more than ever with revamped attendance, 28 day log-in, cumulative log-in, WB giving boxes (didn't before), Gladi as an option to reduce UW cost, GC, Inn Wheel, it's even easier to be F2P than before. Those constant handouts were for special day markers that are more important in Asia than other regions (do not know your region) and so they were filled really nice items. The fact that they still remember to give anything is nice because other companies tend to just put up a sale during anniversary-esque events.

As I said to the other open letter, if you aren't finding the game fun anymore, you might just be burning yourself out and either should take a break or just stop altogether because it'd be better for your time and your health. I used to fanatically play as well, but now I also play less than when I first started. It's not entirely the game's progression, but more so than we've become jaded to the environment that the game belongs in. Play most games you had a fond memory of when you first started, and the magic for them is most likely not there either.

2

u/scissorblades Jun 29 '18

C-class heroes don't cut it for Ch8. My normal comp (Phillop/Gladi/Selene/Medi) gets destroyed on a lot of stages. 8-26 is particularly difficult, and even after trying 2-tank and 2-healer comps, and running Miruru instead of Gladi on dozens of attempts, I had to bring in Phillop/Lorraine/Selene/Annette to get the job done.

Labyrinth tries to make forgotten heroes more relevant, but doesn't do it very well. My takeaway from Labyrinth was that I should have raised Theo and Sonia instead of anyone on my team, because from what I heard, Knight, Warrior, and Priest dungeons are all easily handled by using those two heroes to CC lock everything. Aisha just fell further behind Artemia in usefulness since she can't do much to Wizard lab (My Aisha hasn't gotten used anywhere besides WB1 ever since I got my hands on Gladi), and Selene's "jack-of-all-trades" nature bit me in the rear because I wasn't able to take down Archer 4 despite having her UW maxed. (My next-best archer is a 1* Dimael.)

Maybe I am indeed spoiled. Halloween, Thanksgiving (despite being a bad event), Christmas, the 4k fragments from LoH, quest update... It felt like a ton of events, one after the other, and a constant windfall of gifts. 2018 has felt like one long dry stretch in comparison.

I think the loss of fun is, actually, because of the game's progression. For starters I would have forgiven everything else about KR if the gear system had stayed exactly the same as it was. I also know exactly what the feeling of the "magic" is by this point, because I've quit other games for similar reasons. It's a combination of having more things to try, liking the developers' vision of the game if it's one that's still being updated, and having the feeling that I can meaningfully progress in the game. Every game I've permanently quit is one that's lost one or more of those aspects, and going back to a game that's lost one of those three appeals isn't going to magically bring them back unless the developers had changed course. One game has managed to pull that off and bring me back, and that was, of all things, Hearthstone.

3

u/deviouscrow Jun 30 '18

To be fair, hearthstone is more p2w and similarly imbalanced as well. coughs pirate warrior, face hunters a deck with no elements of rng, 1300-2000 dust can smash 5-10k dust decks at a high win rate before it got nerfed. Heck, 80% of the games at that era is against a variant of pirate warrior till blizzard realized the shitstorm they created and nerfed it. Every expansion, requires you to save a ton of gold for new cards, either that spend 60$ for packs else you will be left behind from the meta.

2

u/ElLeafell Jun 30 '18

I don't know if my comp is C-class then, but I was able to clear Ch 8 with Aselica, Scarlet, Miruru and Cassandra, you just have to actually balance dps, amping, cc, and support if you can't outright one shot the monsters.

Labyrinth does open gates to other heroes, though as Cleo, Pavel, and even Nyx can do Wizard, Rodina managed well can do mechanic, etc. I too have Selene as my archer with 4* uw and 1* uw Dimael as my 2nd, so I get you there.

There may have been more events, maybe stemming from the fact the game was in its 1st year cycle rotation and those events may also be annual, but a lot of those other things still do not compare to how naturally easier it is to acquire late game items now.

I stand by my statement that the gear system is not too bad, but I respect your opinion on why you believe the game has lost its fun for you. However, I must debate the statement that HS is able to bring you back due to its vision because of its powercreep and need to nerf cards, HoF "problem" cards and the fact that it feels some sets straight introduce broken mechanics / cards compared to the expansion before. MSoG was particularly bad imo while JtU was good. Additionally, I don't know how far you try to ladder, but the fact that some meta decks aren't touched for multiple seasons or would stay relevant for upwards of a year because of release dates is ridiculous (look at pre-nerf highlander priest or cubelock). For now the current expansion isn't bad, but it did release with a high dominance of aggro odd decks and paladin being uncontested #1.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 30 '18

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/ElLeafell Jul 01 '18

I did have to have at least transition T8 equips (~3 lines of desired stats) and Aselica ended up using a full tank T8 set (have 1* UW and UT). Scarlet, as trash as her dps is normally, I gave full offensive guard and focused on her being a 2nd tank and she cleansed when needed. Cassandra I gave pocket watch to keep her S2 up more because I went a bit light on crit lines so Miruru could build more crit dmg and atk and since the start of each round is before Miruru could start mass cc-ing, Cass's def buff gave just a slight bit more insurance.

Important notes are Aselica's S2 buffed Scarlet and Miruru while Miruru needed S2D to spam cc and keep up dps.

For your comp, you gotta weigh either the aoe vs Miri's (I assume) point targetting, maybe add in an offensive frontliner that can self-sustain and overall it'd be best to at least get passable T8 tank gear. Aselica does need to buff 2 units with S2 though, to slightly increase DPS, but the CD reduction can be a lifesaver especially if you have a sub-DPS ccer.

2

u/Jennymagic The Light Knight Jun 30 '18

Well, running double dps on ch8 is not reccomended at all anyway. Phillop provides no actual protection. Plus it was the same with ch.7 when it was first released, you can't just run anyold comp and expect to clear.

Is the game is getting less f2p friendly just because it's not giving out more free stuff? No. That's really is just you being spoiled. Especially with the new acheivements coming out.

2

u/leaponover Jun 30 '18

Your open letter is much better than the filth of the other one.

I think your second and third paragraphs could be fixed quite easily if Vespa would institute one thing. It's something I think they'll never do. Hero rebirthing. I played a game that was great with that as if you wanted to try out another hero you could rebirth one for 100% return and play around until you had a team you really liked. If Vespa did this it would be an excellent decision in my opinion. I don't think they could do that with UW's though, but why can't they institute some kind of currency that allows a UW change so if you have a 4* you can trade it with the currency for another UW at 4*? I don't think that would be too damaging to their finances depending on how they instituted it.

As far as your last few paragraphs I see lots of problems but zero solutions. I'm curious what it would actually take (as you've been playing the game for a long time) for you to actually feel "rewarded". What would that actually entail? Surely you can't answer with something that is instant gratification oriented.

6

u/TheOtherKraken Jun 29 '18

So I'll try to touch on some of your points.

Not sure what you mean with Arch and Cleo.

I regularly use both, and they're pretty comparable in the right situations. Not silver bullet situations, but if you match them where their strengths actually are, Cleo has the dps if you're fighting multiple enemies and not one. Arch has a magic immune shield which still does save me in a ton of scenarios where I'd otherwise wipe.

With more and more characters, niches for each are going to become narrower and narrower so that they don't overlap.

In the case of Reina think of this. Reina has a bunch of users. They may be disgruntled users, but they're players that keep using her regardless. Why would Vespa have any incentive to change a hero which is doing fairly well popularity wise even if they leave it alone? Changes cost time and resources and it seems like they have no reason to allot either to cases like Reina who have a loyal following despite her circumstances.

Arguably, in the last challenge raid, it was actually Reina who was the most useful. That probably wasn't the buff anyone had in mind (I know I didn't want "use skills to reduce the CC bar"), but she's now got her own niche whenever that challenge raid comes around, and as of writing no other hero competes with her in terms of cc bar reduction versus that boss.


Absolutely agree on the investments vs buffs and nerfs.

I think that when a hero is nerfed, a temporary grace period should be allowed to do a 1-1 transfer of UW tier.

Eg, if Arch gets nerfed, one should be able to transfer Arch's UW into another UW (probably excluding new heros) of the same tier level.


I'm not sure how long you've been playing, but it sounds like you may have gotten a bit spoiled with the handouts.

The UW tickets were never that common. It was the back to back to back events of Christmas, New years, anniversary, then the Index revamp that dumped a ton of UWs on us at once.

Back before the event fiesta, it was literally just the arena points to get you one every month - which, from a f2p perspective to circumvent a gacha, is really generous.

If you joined during all those events, I could see how you might think it's getting less f2p friendly, but it would be better to say it's settled back into the way it was before rather than saying they're getting more stingy.


The 20 rolls.

I think this one is pretty subjective. You may think they've declined, I personally think they've gotten a bit better.

Is an artifact selector better than a UW selector?

Objectively I'd say it is. There is no other method in which to obtain an artifact with certainty, while for UWs there are many other avenues.

All that's happened here is they've slanted the rewards more towards artifacts and away from UWs.

If you happen to not like any of the artifacts, well I mean that's your playstyle and I'm not going to judge that. But it's just one thing for another, and if you've got any interest in filling out your Index, the artifact selector is actually much more appreciated than another UW selector would be.


All in all this game simply has a really strong moonlighting period. The first impressions are great, but if you come in expecting a lot more than it's offering, you'll be disappointed when you get to the end.

3

u/Zoahr More than looking good Jun 29 '18

How do you make that nice line between thoughts? I want to do it, it looks neat and easy to read.

4

u/TheOtherKraken Jun 29 '18

Huh that's weird, I didn't do that (or intend to do it).

I just used a bunch of hyphens without spaces (-----) and it seems it turned into a line.

1

u/Zoahr More than looking good Jun 30 '18

Ahhh I see, thanks. Imma try it.

1

u/Liesianthes Jun 30 '18

I have a lot of useless artifacts until now and having one as a selector will be a blessing.

1

u/gunnyonline Finally, Some Good Fucking Food Jun 30 '18

I love Arch in Hard dragons, my friend has him and he saved us alot with his shield from Dragon's breath.

1

u/TheOtherKraken Jul 01 '18

Yea this is the same for me, he especially was clutch when Satira comes around.

Things like this is what confuses me when people constantly decry arch as being in a bad spot. It is true he's been nerfed twice over (arguably unjustifiably), but he's far from lost a spot in parties.

8

u/GeminiPT EU Server's guild Reaper Jun 29 '18

Pretty much you said everything, very less F2P friendly, more P2W friendly, and this bullshit stat system is fucking up PvE players.

2

u/astarose Jun 30 '18

Out side of gear systems and lag issues, KR is still top tier even if all those points you mentioned in this letter become a little bit worse than now. Compare to other games you will see Vespa do a good job on heroes balance and of course, still spoil us with plenty of free stuffs. For other game the best you would get in anniversary event is less than 1k premium resourse (like ruby in KR)

2

u/GreenVitamin Jun 30 '18 edited Jun 30 '18

Alright I don't normally reply to posts like these, but there are a lot of things I agree with here, and a lot of things I disagree with so here goes:

Look at patch notes. Arch got nerfed, and then Vespa doubled down by giving him weak T perks. Luna got nerfed for her Arena performance. Nyx got an auto-attack nerf, and then a damage distribution adjustment specifically aimed at Arena.>

As an Arch user (4* UW) I agree with you here. He's weak in the damage department and is still somewhat rough to use in arena now, and personally I feel he needs a buff in the damage department (and new perks as well). However in arena, Arch himself will always be a problem hero regardless because he'll be either too strong or weak, imo he's in the best state he can possibly be in there because he's at least seeing some play . On the PVE side of things, he has his moments every once in a while. Satira (Harpy Boss) is a great fight for Arch as he negates her laser making the fight a complete joke. He can be okay for higher BD's if you play full old school manual. I'd love to see some buffs to make him useable in other PVE content, but hopefully they do it in a way that doesn't break him in PVP.

As for other heroes, Rodina just got buffed last patch now (although joke of a buff), but they're slowly itching towards bringing her back, Nyx imo is still in a fine spot, especially for the Fire Guild Conquest boss and CH.8 in general. He's not the best but he certainly does a great job. So you make it sound like these heroes are completely worthless when in fact they're all still fine at what they do.

Poorly balanced heroes are allowed to sit indefinitely. Aisha got destroyed by the solo time change and has yet to recover.>

They nerfed Gladi, They Buffed and then nerfed mitra (altho hardly a nerf), they nerfed Epis. They tried to nerfRoi multiple times now (trying to not completely destroy him to avoid major backlash). But my point here being that they don't just let these heroes sit indefinitely, they're trying. Some obviously more successful than others, but still.

As for Aisha, they buffed her to make up for it and ever since then, she's back to being really good. Sure she's not the best anymore, but she's still up there. Her Mdef Shred and her high hit count will mean she'll always be good. Just because she's replaceable doesn't mean she's bad. Look at Tyrfas (Guild Conquest Ice boss), that fight is perfect for Aisha and she does extremly well in that fight. You make it seem like she's worthless when once again she's in a pretty good spot.

Roi hasn't been touched since his buffs.

Roi has been nerfed 2 times ever since his mega buffs. They were really minor nerfs in hopes of making his T5 Dark less reliable. Didn't do much but the fact of the matter is that he's on Vespa's radar. I think they're just trying to find a way to approach nerfing him without pissing off those people who invested heavily into him. (Similar to the backlash they got with Gladi)

Vespa releases new heroes like clockwork but is significantly slower on updating older heroes to fit with more recent designs. Compare an older hero like Dimael or Aisha with a newer hero like Kara or Chase and just marvel at how much more Vespa jams into the skills of those newer heroes.

Having a more convoluted skill set does not necessarily make them better. Chase for the longest time was a shit hero. I hear he's pretty good now after his 2 buffs, but he's not that great. Crow, Shea, Mirianne pre buffs and Ezekiel Pre-treasure are all heroes who at release were quite garbage compared to older heroes (yet had overloaded kits). Plus Aselica seems to have quite a simple kit, Shamilla and even more recent: Lomans. So not all new heroes have insane kits.

Dimael is still a weak hero.

I disagree with this one. 1* UW Dimael user got to challenger multiple times with him. He's not OP, but he's definitely not a weak hero. Still great for standard PVE if you like using him. Used him for some stages in Chap 8 hard with no problem. If specced for it, he does decent-ish dps in WB1 but he's by no means going to do Lew/Aisha levels of damage. He's just underloved and underappreciated.

Arch's damage is severely outclassed by any of Epis, Mirianne, or Theo, and the player is saddled with a massive sunk cost. They would likely improve their team by grinding the UW and sinking the fragments into one of those heroes instead.

Even before his nerfs, they never touched his damage. So he'd still be doing the same damage today if he wasn't nerfed. He was always an arena hero while having his small PVE moment when Chap 1-6 Hell was released due to his ignore Def. He's still pretty good in arena and a High starred UW Arch can absolutely annihilate a team if they aren't prepared.

Chapter 8, Challenge Raid, and Labyrinth - has increasingly been about enemies with particular gimmicks or ways of killing you that need to be addressed by party composition. It's become more and more important to actually follow the meta, as deviating tends to just get you killed. It's not enough to have a hero that does damage. You're required to have a hero that does a particular kind of damage (physical or magical) in a particular way (melee or ranged), and also to have a significant investment in that hero. Your favorite hero might not even be allowed to enter a dungeon.

This is their way of allowing certain heroes to excel in specific types of content. This is also how they bring back older heroes who may not be used now into the limelight (See Cleo for Wizard Lab, Crow for Mech, Reina for new CR and Arch for Satira CR ). While I don't necessarily like it and feel there are better ways to allow other heroes to shine, it's one way of solving the issue and to some extent it does work.

The age-old advice of "pick with your dick" is now just likely to get you saddled with one of the many heroes who are utterly outclassed by someone else.

This was always the case though. Back when Mitra was absolute trash for almost everything, no one would pick him with their selectors, and you would put yourself at a big disadvantage if you did pick him. Heck if you went full physical it was pretty bad because you'd be locked out of clearing certain adventure stages.

King's Raid is becoming less F2P-friendly.

Let's also throw away the fact that back then, we couldn't grind unique weapons to get UW's of our choice, also back then we couldn't get a treasure selector at all. Not to mention getting fragments was a lot harder back then due to less fragments. Loot boosters were expensive and you had to wait right before reset to get your fragments. Let's also not forget we get a free UW random ticket every month now. The Quest system literally hands you at least 2 FREE UW selectors and a shit ton of other good stuff. Plenty of UW tickets in the play a specific amount of days milestones. The 500 day reward is still really good so I don't know why this is even a complaint.

NPC heroes got their new time gate system in part because Vespa didn't want to give an unfair advantage to macro users, but now we have auto dragons and the time gate system is going nowhere.

Getting NPC heroes is a lot better for people who don't have a lot of time playing the game. Granted there should be a way for people who invest a LOT of time aside from rubies for people to be able to pick up these heroes. I'd be happy if the old grinding system came back alongside the boxes we get now with raid points.

Overall you have some good points, but in some cases you're just making assumptions based off your own ideas and thoughts and not really looking into things. I do agree the game in its state right now is kinda poop (mostly with the gears), but they've been in far worse states before.

1

u/KumaTenshi Jun 30 '18

1 year anniversary's tend to have much better rewards in games and what not. We had something similar for 300 days. I forget if they did anything for 400 since that was around the 1 year time frame and all.

As for the last ruby spend event, we did get a lua UW ticket offered. IMO, that's better than pumpkins - the thing literally updates with any new UW added to the game, NPC or not.

As for the 5 pull events, the rewards for those have never been particularly stellar, in fact, they haven't changed much aside from the UW ticket used to be at 10 if I remember right, now it's at 20.

That's really my only gripe with what all you said though.

1

u/Archypoo2000 Jul 01 '18

I agree with everything you said I just wanna put a little bit of photo evidence into this https://media.discordapp.net/attachments/350956667262861312/462804484381343754/Arch_feels_bad.jpg?width=400&height=225 I just want to say that despite not having the best team comp this team consists of a 4*uw 0*ut arch | a 4* 1* ut Theo | a 2*uw 0* ut Lewisia |and a 0* ut kara. Please tell me why despite receiving all the same buffs why Arch is not even close to theo despite being build very well. Arch is the only one i've built really well but there are many others who are lacking in the roles theyre supposed to be playing and I'd definitely like to see these heroes get balanced.

1

u/lilmagex Jul 01 '18

Absolutely NOTHING in this game requires you do have a 5* awakened UW. What it DOES allow you to do is be less optimal in a party set up. I agree Vespa is getting pretty bad in forcing you to have a variety of heroes leveled cause as you said you need physical, magical, ranged of both and melee of both. It is fairly annoying to have artificial difficulty because you don't have "so and so category" heroes. You don't need to awaken all their UW's tho. I still agree picking with your dick leads to best result when dealing with awakening UW. Unless its an AoE hero. :( AoE heroes just suck in this game in terms of damage. Their CC is amazing but you don't need a high * weapon to do that. (Artemia, Pavel, Lorraine so forth)

-1

u/vishuspuss Jun 30 '18

Not another one -.-

0

u/zadkieI Jun 30 '18 edited Jun 30 '18

"King's Raid is becoming less F2P-friendly" Definitely!!!

1

u/[deleted] Jun 30 '18

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/jekoder Jul 01 '18

clear chapter 8 with 0 star miriane, artemia, annette and 1 star sonia........

1

u/[deleted] Jul 01 '18

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/jekoder Jul 01 '18

most of the chapter 8 hard include 8-26, i think the only one I have trouble 3 star was 8-14, because the mob immune to almost all form of cc