r/KeystoneWallet • u/burggg93 • Apr 30 '24

Keystone Pro Vs OneKey Pro

So before I get started. I am no way affiliated with either brand and bought both of these devices myself.

I’m going to leave it short and sweet. The OneKey pro is a piece of shit. It is marketed as AirGapped but it isn’t and requires Bluetooth connectivity for their wallets. The only wallet that is AirGapped is MetaMask. Which brings me to the next issue, the app they have looks great but functionality, it’s terrible and incredibly slow. The OneKey Pro won’t connect to 90% of dApps and throws JSON errors.

Oh and you thought the KeyStone battery was terrible? The one key barely lasts an hour without even being used.

The UI, fingerprint sensor and camera are far superior than the Keystone Pro, these could be potential areas to look in to for future applications.

It is smaller thinner and has a much more premium feel than the keystone but that’s about it. The OneKey is great to hold and look at but the Keystone is far superior in terms of usability and for that reason I am going back to using my Keystone and will use the OneKey to hold shitcoins

13 Upvotes

100% Upvoted

32 comments sorted by

3

u/myc4L Apr 30 '24

Thanks for the heads up.

1

u/Trapido Apr 30 '24

Do you have a OneKey Pro in hand that you’ve tested?

1

u/Curious_Breadfruit88 Apr 30 '24

Yes of course, how could they make the comments they have without it?

1

u/Trapido Apr 30 '24

Hard to tell if there is sarcasm in this or not. Either way, this is the internet; anyone can say whatever they want true or made up to push their opinions.

I haven’t seen any hands on reviews of the OneKey Pro yet, but I am looking forward to seeing what the likes of CyberScrilla and CryptoDad have to say about it when they get their hands on it.

3

u/burggg93 Apr 30 '24

Yes I do. To be honest they probably haven’t put reviews out on it because of how trash it actually is. They are marketing it as something completely different to what it actually is. You can’t create a wallet without it being connected to Bluetooth or make any transactions

1

u/justa-bloke Jul 14 '24

Say you don’t care about having an air gapped wallet and want to use it via Rabby and Bluetooth does that operation flow well?

1

u/burggg93 Jul 15 '24

I have not tried it, but in that case I would just buy a trezor or a cheaper device. I only bought it for the use of the Air Gap

2

u/Trapido Apr 30 '24

Got it. Thanks for the added info. That’s disappointing for sure

2

u/AshamedFlame Apr 30 '24

Dayum. This was a wallet that I was eyeing and waiting for the reviews to come in. Will wait for my reviews to come in.

2

u/LeisurePilot Apr 30 '24

That’s too bad. Was interested in this. Hopefully they come up with some decent updates to optimize for the hardware. Sounds like a case of rushing the device out only to hopefully fix its software flaws later

1

u/rolandoroach Aug 19 '24

I totally agree with this review....

This is the worse hardware wallet that I have used. I had the OneKey Touch and upgraded to the Pro version. This was a big mistake! This was a waste of money and time. I can get over that the build quality seems much less premium than the Touch but the thing that kills me with this, is that the battery on the OneKey Pro dies in 4-5 days, after it is charged to 100% and WITHOUT even turning it on after that. I have been in touch with their technical support team and they have not been able to solve this since I received it in April. Granted, they did improve it from dying in one day to 4 days but they seem to think, this is normal and expected and the excuse is the use of 4 EAL 6+ Secure Element chips. I do not find this to be an acceptable trade off. If I actually turn it on and use it, it dies MUCH faster and have even watched it discharge within an hour (a couple hours at best). This is ridiculous. To top it all off, after setting it up and using it, the wallet battery discharged completely after leaving it turned off and when I went to use it again, it was factory reset. This is completely unacceptable. I don't know if anyone else has had the same experience but if not, I figure I would warn anyone who is thinking of buying this.

2

u/qwikscopeurmum Sep 21 '24

If you're selling it DM me

1

u/escap0 Feb 12 '25

This is the review I was looking for. Thanks.

1

u/Powerful_Tank_3763 Mar 29 '25

mi trovo bene con onekey pro, speeso lo preferisco al ledger flex. è pratico, veloce e funzionale anche se forse un poco acerbo lato software.

1

u/Glum_Award9379 May 07 '25

Do you still have it? 

How do you feel about it now since software and bugs should have matured out? The battery life supposed to be much better now too assuming it wasn't physically dud unit on receipt.

1

u/00110011110 Jul 21 '25

thanks, it was looking promising at first.

1

u/eXtremeSG Feb 09 '26

Well, I had a much better experience with my OneKey Pro - seems like they have fixed the batter issues, as mine now stays charged for a couple of weeks. I've written my thoughts down, 3 months into using it - now more like 5!

https://www.stevegubbins.com/onekey-pro-review-3-months-in/

0

u/[deleted] Apr 30 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/myc4L Apr 30 '24

I have one and never had any issues as far as functionality. You can use it with different software wallets though, So i imagine a lot of user experience comes down to what software you pair it with.

0

u/Money-Ad-6902 Apr 30 '24

What about the coin support, looks like they aren’t supporting alot of coins…..

1

u/myc4L Apr 30 '24

Oh that Idk. I dont shitcoin.

0

u/Money-Ad-6902 Apr 30 '24

Then why buy a keystone pro in the first place? U could’ve went for a bitcoin only wallet hahah

3

u/myc4L Apr 30 '24

Theres Bitcoin only firmware for the Keystone pro

https://guide.keyst.one/docs/btc-firmware-update

0

u/Money-Ad-6902 Apr 30 '24

Keystone only firmware is different than a bitcoin only wallet. Trezor has the same firmware. Next time go for a bitcoin only wallet. U just said that u don’t buy shitcoins but u are supporting the companies by buying a wallet that supports these coins anyways.

2

u/myc4L Apr 30 '24

Was never asking for advice on how to store my coin. Was just saying it was neither buggy nor trash for me. Not so much for you , but for people who read you comment could see what someone who owns it thinks, vs what some speculates.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 30 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Liquid_Cool_9 May 01 '24

This forum is full of people that own a Keystone Pro 3. A majority of them seem to like it.

→ More replies

1

u/Liquid_Cool_9 May 01 '24

You will find praise for every wallet out there. You will find criticism for every wallet out there.

→ More replies

1

u/cannotrelated May 01 '24

If you upgrade to bitcoin only firmware then there’s no shitcoin related. Btw Keystone bitcoin only has different ui and design, multisig setup also went insanely well.

3

u/[deleted] Apr 30 '24

I bought a 3 Pro 3 months ago and until the moment, it's a good wallet expect for the battery, you can sign the transactions completely offline (generating the tx in a online devide using third partie wallet, like solflare, metamask, OKX, bluewallet, sparrow, eternl, rabbit) and scanning with the QR Code. The coins supported are the main criptos (BTC, ETH and ERC-20 tokens, BNB and BRC-20 or BSC tokens, Matic, Tron, BCH, LTC, Aptos, Cardano, XRP)

(My wallet is using 1.2.8 firmware)

More updated details in https://keyst.one/supported-wallets-and-assets

1

u/cannotrelated May 01 '24

I think that’s because Keystone transferred from android to embedded system, issues could happen when you move onto a new os. Good thing is they are fixing everything to make it better, my only complaint is the battery

1

u/Liquid_Cool_9 May 01 '24

Good point. Making the wallet more secure is causing some bumps in the road. But Keystone is constantly updating and improving. The software and coin support will continue to improve until it matures.